Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel uncomfortable with groom's speech at his wedding?

270 replies

Dygger · 06/08/2024 13:01

My cousin's son married his girlfriend of 12 years at the weekend and my partner and I were invited. During his speech at the reception the groom made a number of 'jokes' about being forced unwillingly into marriage. They weren't very funny or clearly ironic. There wasn't much tenderness or love emanating from him. The main topic of his speech was how he hadn't wanted to marry but she did and so here he was with his arm twisted behind his back. His friends (he plays football and there were a lot of football friends there) thought it was hilarious. He said something along the lines of 'I know you're all expecting me to tell you how much I love Katie, but we've lived together for 12 years and so neither of us have any illusions about each other.' She seemed a bit subdued. Her speech was very short but she did say she loved him 'despite everything' which got a laugh. It was all rather unsettling and created a strange atmosphere. We left as soon as we politely could.

Has anyone else experienced something like this? Did your own husbands say anything really inappropriate in their wedding speeches? I'm trying to understand why he did it. He's an English teacher, so he's someone who knows words matter.

OP posts:
StrawberryWasp · 06/08/2024 17:12

I went to a wedding where the groom's speech was definitely aimed at his 'mates'. It was all in jokes about them and their history and he 'joked' about how he pretended he liked his new wife coming out 'with the boys' when he didn't really.

Weirdly her fathers speech was then mostly about the groom and his mates too and he hardly mentioned his daughter. The whole thing was like one big Lads Love In.

I really felt for the bride. Weddings and speeches are usually mostly focused on the bride but she seemed like an afterthought after all the groom/ best man/ father of the bride Bants. It was like she was invisible.

She left him a few years later.

Globetrote · 06/08/2024 17:10

My DM gave a speech at my wedding in lieu of NC DF and it’s one of my biggest regrets in my life. She utterly humiliated me in front of our 80 guests, no one laughed, and later several guests came up to me to ask if I was ok. Some of DH’s friends later asked him WTAF was that all about. Became NC with her a few days later due to other reasons but she didn’t give a shit about what she’d done.

In contrast a couple of years ago we went to DH’s friend’s DD’s wedding and his friend gave a wonderful speech, albeit a bit too long. He had managed to get it just right and I said to DH why couldn’t my DM just stand up and give a toast and leave it at that.

Menolady · 06/08/2024 17:09

In my experience, whenever I go to a wedding and you can see the lack of love and excitement, they get divorced.

Every wedding that left me feeling “huh?”, they’ve been divorced within five years.

Twistybranch · 06/08/2024 17:08

Ivehearditbothways · 06/08/2024 17:04

That’s a very very old joke and gets said at almost every occasion where men wear kilts. No one takes that as an insult. It’s met with a laughing groan of “oh, that old joke.”

For sure, it’s a hacky old joke. But people loved it.

Not all speeches have to be declaring undying love for one another

Moveoverdarlin · 06/08/2024 17:07

This is the issue with waiting 12 years. Whilst you still love each other, you go way beyond that ‘loves young dream’ phase once kids and everything else comes along. My husband gave a great speech at our wedding, would he be quite so gushing 20 years later now I’m two stone heavier and constantly knackered? Probs not.

Sounds like she nagged and nagged and he succumbed. Least he was honest I spose.

StrawberryWasp · 06/08/2024 17:06

I can imagine the situation based on the many realtionships threads we get on here:
Living together for many years, no sign of marriage, women waiting, getting upset, man not bothered as already has all he wants, it becomes a source of tension and conflict, he eventually agrees because she's getting so upset and she plans a wedding: you can then imagone at the wedding he may be ambivalent and 'joke' about how he's been pushed into it.
Becuase he kind of has.

It's a posiible consequence of these long live in relationships before marraige which then make weddings feel irrelevant, or soemthing a man 'has to do' to keep the women happy.

These threads are on here daily.

It doesn't make it OK though, it's a shitty way to treat someone you are suposed to love. Keep your 'banter' for private occasions, public events should show respect even if you are not a super lovey type.

BogusHocusPocus · 06/08/2024 17:06

I went to a wedding 15 years ago where the groom spoke repeatedly and at length about the deep bond and depth of his love...

... for his best man.

Bride didn't get much of a mention but smiled in an uncomfortable way - the way a mother would at a little kid. Indulgently.

I felt so sorry for her.

They are still together.

housethatbuiltme · 06/08/2024 17:04

We didn't have speeches as I find them tacky but I would much rather see banter than so fake cringe 'love bomb' gushing, awkwardly read love song lyrics that mean nothing and crying weirdness... its a wedding not a funeral.

I have never seen a wedding speech in real life that wasn't based around jokes like that. The classic cliched 'Mr. right and Mrs. Always right' and 'bride finally tied him down' and 'look at them holding hands, its the last time he'll have the upper hand' etc... its certainly not 'unusual'.

More to the point its probably just true, if you live together 12 years (likely together a few years longer before living together) your clearly pretty solid and settled in your relationship. You are not in the bloody honeymoon phase of sucking face and fawning over each other like horny teens anymore, its disingenuous to pretend and looks stupid.

Ivehearditbothways · 06/08/2024 17:04

Twistybranch · 06/08/2024 17:02

I wasn’t at the wedding, a friend was.

The groom, wearing a kilt, during his speech said everyone keeps asking ‘what’s the tartan?’ He said ‘that’s her in the white’. That wasn’t even the worst one to be honest.

Everyone thought it was hilarious including the bride/brides family. So everyone’s different.

To be honest I’m more uncomfortable with gushing speeches.

That’s a very very old joke and gets said at almost every occasion where men wear kilts. No one takes that as an insult. It’s met with a laughing groan of “oh, that old joke.”

HollyKnight · 06/08/2024 17:02

Whatever. I have very little sympathy for grown women who put their desire to have children above the welfare of those children. She wasn't forced down the aisle. She chose this man to be her husband and father of her future children.

Twistybranch · 06/08/2024 17:02

I wasn’t at the wedding, a friend was.

The groom, wearing a kilt, during his speech said everyone keeps asking ‘what’s the tartan?’ He said ‘that’s her in the white’. That wasn’t even the worst one to be honest.

Everyone thought it was hilarious including the bride/brides family. So everyone’s different.

To be honest I’m more uncomfortable with gushing speeches.

Waterboatlass · 06/08/2024 17:02

TemuSpecialBuy · 06/08/2024 14:51

YANBU… there’s a time and place.

not quite the same but…

I went to a wedding where the grooms oldest brother died in Afghanistan 15 years previously

the best man speech given by the middle brother was basically “X would have loved to be here today and then talked at length about the dead brother for 15 mins.

the groom’s father then gave us a “wedding speech” which was just a 20 minute biography of the dead brother including a run down of the day leading up to his death

then the groom stood up and we thought thank fuck…

he opened with “I love my bride because she is fearless, humble, kind etc…. All qualities she shares with my brother and that’s why I fell in love with her 😵‍💫😵‍💫😵‍💫
and then proceeded to talk about his brother for 15 mins”

the family are clearly deeply affected by his death and stuck in some kind of trauma loop but it was awful to watch at a 100 person plus wedding and I felt so so soooo sorry for the bride
her MIL was just sat openly crying for an hour and her parents looked incredibly uncomfortable

Goodness, how tragic about the brother but also how sad they couldn't find a way to see the joy in the occasion without feeling guilty about him not being there.

I wasn't there myself but it reminds me of a wedding my DP went to before we met of some friends. The bride's sister had sadly died as a child and the father apparently made his speech all about her instead of the bride. Apparently this was a reflection of her entire childhood and their house which was a shrine to the present day. I've never once seen that lady smile or look cheerful (DP told me the above details when I commented on this as I wondered whether I had offended her).

LavenderPup · 06/08/2024 16:55

Groom sounds like a selfish asshole. My SS ruined his own wedding by getting blind drunk and passing out, it was just awful. He was too immature to get married but this groom doesn’t even have that excuse.

EI12 · 06/08/2024 16:53

Naunet · 06/08/2024 16:49

Ha! You could say the same about any man, so I guess you’re suggesting we all become lesbians? I’m not sure how getting married or having children would make any difference to that possibility either, it’s not a magic spell

Edited

You are absolutely right, I will say the same about my father, about my husband, about my brother.

DeathbyDying · 06/08/2024 16:53

Widowed people and betrayed people I did not mean, I don't class this as giggly dating, they are looking for a spouse, it is serious. I meant elderly dating, when they still think they are 'hot', and are a 'catch'. Dating-dating I meant, not looking for a spouse.

@EI12 but isn't all dating "dating -dating" as you put it to start with? In order to find a serious relationship, you need to hunt your way through the "giggly dating" whatever that is.

how old are you classing as elderly?
there probably are older people who are single and think of themselves as a catch but may actually be a catch depending on what you are after. Status and wealth can be as appealing as a hot young body.

Naunet · 06/08/2024 16:49

EI12 · 06/08/2024 16:41

Sorry, but seriously, how do you know he is not a dad? It is not like us, women.

Ha! You could say the same about any man, so I guess you’re suggesting we all become lesbians? I’m not sure how getting married or having children would make any difference to that possibility either, it’s not a magic spell

Cocobeau · 06/08/2024 16:42

Some people are just crap at speeches. You’re thinking about it too much.

EI12 · 06/08/2024 16:41

Naunet · 06/08/2024 16:08

So I should have kids just in case he changes his mind, even if I haven’t changed mine and he so far hasn’t changed his?! What a brilliant idea!

He is 55 this year anyway, with zero interest in being a dad, but I’m sure you know best…🙄

Sorry, but seriously, how do you know he is not a dad? It is not like us, women.

EI12 · 06/08/2024 16:39

DeathbyDying · 06/08/2024 16:05

Nothing more laughable than elderly dating.

@EI12 what do you class as 'elderly dating'? why is it laughable?

what about people who are widowed? or who wanted to stay married for live but their husband left them? does that mean they should stay single until they die or their efforts to find a partner are 'laughable'?

Widowed people and betrayed people I did not mean, I don't class this as giggly dating, they are looking for a spouse, it is serious. I meant elderly dating, when they still think they are 'hot', and are a 'catch'. Dating-dating I meant, not looking for a spouse.

Naunet · 06/08/2024 16:31

Fargo79 · 06/08/2024 16:17

I sure wish everyone would stop justifying themselves to that vile @El12 poster. They are full of shite and deliberately winding you all up. Either a troll or someone who has been strung along and abandoned and for some reason feels better about that if they insist that everyone else's relationships are crap too.

I don’t think they’ve succeed in winding anyone up, we all have eyes, we all know men leave women who have had children too, we all know women leave relationships more often than men, we all know there’s nothing wrong with not getting married a month into a relationship etc, they’re just making themselves look thick.

graffitiwall · 06/08/2024 16:30

jolota · 06/08/2024 14:19

Re a pp, I don't think many abused people feel confident enough to stand up in front of their family & friends and declare/'joke' that they are being forced into doing something.. usually the repercussions (from abuser) and shame keep abused people from talking about or seeking help so it seems unlikely that's the scenario here?

It seems more likely that the person she's marrying is a prick and thought the wedding was his time to make a statement to his friends that he's still a lads lad and being 'tied down' won't change him, he won't miss a match or pub trip etc etc

I went to a wedding with a very similar dynamic, majority of guests were his friends, his speech was almost all about how much fun the stag do was. It was very sobering.

This. He’s an absolute twat and his speech was unforgivable. PP had it bang on the mark when she said he used his speech to play to his mates, not his bride. Absolute twat.

i went to a wedding where the groom was actually booed as he opened his speeech by saying he had only fallen in love at first sight once ( and it wasn’t with his bride). But at least he went on to say he had a deeper connection with his bride, even if the intro was misjudged.

OurFlagMeansAfternoonTea · 06/08/2024 16:30

I went to a wedding where the bride's father spent 40 minutes telling the story of "TheTaming of the Shrew". He was basically calling his daughter a shrew. The speech took extra time, because if had to be translated for the half the guests, who didn't speak his language. I don't know if he thought he was being funny, but no one was laughing.

LlynTegid · 06/08/2024 16:28

Humour has its place at a wedding. Not sick jokes though.

butterbeansauce · 06/08/2024 16:28

HollyKnight · 06/08/2024 14:51

Ugh it's just toxic masculinity shite from pathetic men. But for reasons I'll never understand, women still choose these immature cretins for partners. So don't feel bad for her, she knew what she was getting. Instead be grateful to her for keeping him out of the dating pool.

Nasty.

She had probably been conditioned to expect nothing more during her own childhood. Sad you haven't got any empathy. If you don't understand then it says more about you than about the bride.

Charlottescobweb · 06/08/2024 16:28

Dygger · 06/08/2024 15:06

I've been with my partner for 23 years and because we met later in life and don't have children we haven't bothered to get married. I don't regard myself as merely a fuck buddy, as you put it. What a horrible transactional view of relationships. We've outlasted many friend's marriages and have reached the stage where we'll probably have to get married to avoid Inheritance Tax — but if it wasn't for that we wouldn't bother.

My guess is that the couple I'm talking about have reached the age where decisions need to be made regarding children (they're 33 + 34) and she has said she wants to be married before getting pregnant. Which probably, according to @Findwen consititutes forced marriage and abuse, but to most of Mumsnet would constitute good sense.

Getting married to only have a baby sounds odd to me. I get the whole protection thing but a lot of couples marry have children and don't own anything. How does getting married benefit those couples who have nothing. Your cousin's son could have an accident or a stroke tomorrow and he can't work and she becomes his carer. Marriage is not something you play with to only have children it's deeper than that. She is also becoming his carer and his her carer if they were to become ill.