Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder why our value is defined by money?

107 replies

Abigail47 · 06/08/2024 10:15

I was just wondering why everyone's value is defined by how money they have.

When I went to school, all of the most popular girls were from rich families. If your dad was wealthy , you were popular. The rich girls would only hang around with the othe rich girls.

If you were less rich they wouldn't talk to you. If you were poor or from a single parent family, they definitely wouldn't talk to you.

It made me think from an early age: why is my worth/ or anyone's worth defined by how much money I have. It seems so ridiculous.

There are so many other things that add up a person's worth: such as how kind they are, how good they are at different things etc.

Similarly when I went to college, the rich people would only hang around with each other.

I lived in a small town in England growing up, and again, it was always divided by money. The rich people would only really be friends with each other.

I then moved to London, which is a lot more diverse and multicultural, however you still get wealth snobbery in some of the workplaces. And even though in the workplaces, everyone talks to each other.

After work, and in hobbies, I've seen the same thing: that the really rich people in London will only be friends with other really rich people.

I mean is it not all a bit ridiculous. How is our worth tied to money? There are so many othe things that make a human valuable.

Yet alot of people seem to think of money over everything else

OP posts:
Bastide · 06/08/2024 19:12

Not in my experience. I grew up dirt poor. The popular girls at school were the rebellious, sexy ones with older boyfriends with cars and jail time. I went to Oxford, was the poorest person at my very trad college with a high percentage of Old Etonians, but though I wasn’t hanging out with the OEs, absolutely all of my friends were far richer than me, my mind was blown by being invited home in the vacs, and many of us are still friends 25 years on. DH is from a similar poor WC background, and our friendship groups are very mixed. In some settings we’re by far the richest, in others much the poorest. I choose to be around interesting people, and that’s not class- or income-dependent. I assume our friends who own strings of racehorses, multiple homes, and take us out on their yacht like our company.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 06/08/2024 19:09

People literally say “He/ She is worth £1 million” when describing how much wealth someone has.

So it think it’s pretty ingrained!

Abigail47 · 06/08/2024 19:06

Turophilic · 06/08/2024 19:00

Be fair, you are wandering around with a chip on your shoulder the size of a planet and you dismiss everyone's differing interpretations because only you have an insight into the dark and uncaring hearts of The Rich. (cue dramatic music)

People with things in common get along. It might be work, children of an age, interests, living on the same street, campaigning for the same cause, holidaying at the same place etc

For a lot of those things, geography and income play a significant part. As a result, people of similar affluence come across each other more often. I only know a couple of surgeons but more teachers than you can shake a stick at - that's not because I hate surgeons or they hate me, we just move in different circles.

@Abigail47 , you are ascribing every interaction to a callous, materialistic world filled with rich people who dislike or distain the poor. That's bollocks. There are unfriendly, judgemental people at every economic level - your own view of the well off is pretty unpleasant, for example. We've all known absolute gems and absolute gits across society, it's not a wealth based system.

Maybe the singing grouop people didn't like you because you came across as prickly. Maybe you sat in Mavis's chair, and that's a faux pas. Or maybe they and you would never be friends for a myriad of reasons.

But to you, it must be because they are richer than you.

It was because they were richer than me.

And they didn't do it just to me. They were known to be a snobby and cold group locally.

They were cold to anyone that was poorer than them. I remember someone else that i knew tried to join the choir and they were really nasty to her aswell. She told me "they only seem to want other doctors or psychologists in that choir" . Not anyone else

Indeed I remember one of the older women In the choir refused to go to her own sons wedding because he married a "poor" person.

She didn't approve of his girlfriends upbringing, so she refused to attend the wedding.

I remember we all spoke about it at the time, how crazy and snobby it was.

But that was how the town was.

A lot of the richer people wouldn't speak or have anything that all to do with the poorer people.

It was very class based

OP posts:
Abigail47 · 06/08/2024 19:01

Catza · 06/08/2024 17:50

So because you haven’t seen others shift their opinion, you won’t do it yourself? (And it actually happens quite a lot on here so I don’t know where you’ve been looking)
For someone who talks about her own experience, you definitely use a lot of absolutes “always”, “never”, “only” etc. You didn’t ask “why do I feel like my worth is linked to money” you insisted that everyone felt this way.
And just like you managed to miss all the threads where the OP changed their mind, you also seem to see all your experiences as a confirmation of your biases. You don’t know why women in your singing group were not welcoming to you but you made an assumption based on your biases and, bizarrely, had these biases confirmed by someone who wasn’t even present at the event.

Oh how you seem to know so much about a group that you never attended.

I didn't make "an assumption based on my biases". How rude of you.

My friend also attended the choir with me. They also froze her out. She decided that she wouldn't go back as in her words "they were so snobby and cold".

The choir were known locally for being snobby and cold to "poor" people. They were extremely unwelcoming.

The choir were known locally for being snobby and cruel to "poorer people".

I see another thread just posted today on mumsnet where a woman said that richer people are leaving her out.

Is that an assumption based in her biases?

You are aware that we live in a class based society that is filled with inequality and segregation yes?

That's not opinion. That's fact.

It's been going on for a long time.

If only people could start to see beyond money.

OP posts:
Turophilic · 06/08/2024 19:00

Abigail47 · 06/08/2024 16:31

Really? How immature of you to dismiss other peoples experiences.

Be fair, you are wandering around with a chip on your shoulder the size of a planet and you dismiss everyone's differing interpretations because only you have an insight into the dark and uncaring hearts of The Rich. (cue dramatic music)

People with things in common get along. It might be work, children of an age, interests, living on the same street, campaigning for the same cause, holidaying at the same place etc

For a lot of those things, geography and income play a significant part. As a result, people of similar affluence come across each other more often. I only know a couple of surgeons but more teachers than you can shake a stick at - that's not because I hate surgeons or they hate me, we just move in different circles.

@Abigail47 , you are ascribing every interaction to a callous, materialistic world filled with rich people who dislike or distain the poor. That's bollocks. There are unfriendly, judgemental people at every economic level - your own view of the well off is pretty unpleasant, for example. We've all known absolute gems and absolute gits across society, it's not a wealth based system.

Maybe the singing grouop people didn't like you because you came across as prickly. Maybe you sat in Mavis's chair, and that's a faux pas. Or maybe they and you would never be friends for a myriad of reasons.

But to you, it must be because they are richer than you.

Catza · 06/08/2024 17:50

Abigail47 · 06/08/2024 16:36

I have never seen any OP shift from their viewpoint on here. Ever.

I never said I speak for "all poor people".

I said that I'm speaking about my own experiences.

And I also work in a school, and I see the poorer children constantly being left out.

Which is really infuriating. I've seen the children cry about it.

It's an unfair society.

So because you haven’t seen others shift their opinion, you won’t do it yourself? (And it actually happens quite a lot on here so I don’t know where you’ve been looking)
For someone who talks about her own experience, you definitely use a lot of absolutes “always”, “never”, “only” etc. You didn’t ask “why do I feel like my worth is linked to money” you insisted that everyone felt this way.
And just like you managed to miss all the threads where the OP changed their mind, you also seem to see all your experiences as a confirmation of your biases. You don’t know why women in your singing group were not welcoming to you but you made an assumption based on your biases and, bizarrely, had these biases confirmed by someone who wasn’t even present at the event.

InterIgnis · 06/08/2024 17:08

Abigail47 · 06/08/2024 16:00

I disagree that it is anything to do with having things in common with people.

It is snobbery and class based division.

And it is the poor people who are already suffering in life, who end up suffering even more.

I remember joining a choir in the small town next to the small town in england that I lived in. There was the height of snobbery in that town. I joined the choir, and the older women came over to me and asked what I worked at. And then they said oh "and who are your parents, what do they do". After I answered , one woman looked scornful, and just turned and walked away from me.
They wouldn't speak to me at all. All of the rich people stuck together and simple wouldn't even speak to the 'poorer people. ' poverty is relative as at that time, I had okay money, but they still judged me and looked down on my as my parents didn't have as good jobs as their parents had.

My friend who joined the choir with me told me that she couldn't do it anymore after a couple of weeks, as they were so frosty and cold to us. She wanted to leave.

I remember crying to a man I knew in a different group about this. He had actually been born in an extremely poor family and was then adopted into a very rich family, so he was good to talk to about stuff like this, as he had a lot of insight.

I said to him, "why are they so cold and cruel". It's not all about money. I wanted to sing.

He said " I can tell you exactly why they are like that. I can tell you about their mindset. They won't talk to you because they don't want to 'dilute ' their wealth. They feel that talking to anyone that they see as poor, drags them down, lowers their status, and they don't want to even be seen talking to poorer people. To feel rich they will only talk to rich people."

Edited

That just reads like a group of insular people that are averse to outsiders. Again, this isn’t something exclusive to the wealthy - you can find people like this from all walks of life.

InterIgnis · 06/08/2024 17:00

There are countless threads on here that highlight difficulties that can very easily arise between friends of differing socioeconomic status. Just on that level alone, predominantly mixing with those on a similar level to you is one way to avoid those difficulties.

Also, humans are a species that are both tribal and hierarchical, the latter often being an expression of the former. It isn’t exclusive to capitalism, incidentally, because capitalism too is a way of expressing those behaviors (and arguably superior to, say, feudalism, in the potential for social mobility. Additionally, this same structure is present in socialist/communist societies). In all societies, those that have the most in terms of resources, invariably dominate.

BadNeighbour101 · 06/08/2024 16:52

Abigail47 · 06/08/2024 16:31

Really? How immature of you to dismiss other peoples experiences.

I disagree with you generalising your own, and pretending that "rich people" - I am guessing richER than you all behave and think in a certain manner.

That's not my experience at all.

I am also curious what school has very wealthy and very poor children. Very wealthy families tend to send kids to private school, and state school have catchment areas. it's not that common to have such a massive gap between income, is it?

CanadianJohn · 06/08/2024 16:41

ToothPickk · 06/08/2024 10:22

It's not what I've experienced at all, and no one would know what I'm worth or earn because I don't tell them.

Same here... I can make a guess, I suppose, about a person's wealth, but for all I know he might be living at the poverty level because he's a gambler.

A person's wealth is just not an indicator of value at all.

PensionMention · 06/08/2024 16:38

The young girls that both love art is a good example. Imagine being taken to art galleries around the world? I love art galleries, my family never ever took me overseas or even had the money to travel to a gallery in the UK but now as an adult I have indulged that love and have also had art classes, the love of it unfortunately doesn’t mean I have talent but it’s enjoyable.

It is easier to be friendly with people you have more in common with as there is a familiar link but some people are more chameleon like. I am really good at this as is my DS.

Abigail47 · 06/08/2024 16:36

Catza · 06/08/2024 16:28

@Abigail47 you seem to be weirdly fixated on your own narrative. Why post in AIBU if you are not prepared to shift from your position and consider a different viewpoint?
And why are you being so patronising towards "poor people" who supposedly "suffer" from this terrible injustice. I grew up poor, I have never experienced what you are talking about. I have rich friends and I don't always want/able to join in with things they want to do even when they offer to pay for me. The decision is entirely mine and it's bloody offensive to me that you think I am suffering as a result.

I have never seen any OP shift from their viewpoint on here. Ever.

I never said I speak for "all poor people".

I said that I'm speaking about my own experiences.

And I also work in a school, and I see the poorer children constantly being left out.

Which is really infuriating. I've seen the children cry about it.

It's an unfair society.

OP posts:
5128gap · 06/08/2024 16:34

Only some people think that way and to a great extent you choose to collude or not. The 'popular girls' were popular with each other and other rich people. There was absolutely no need for them to be popular with you, as you were at perfect liberty to make friends with less well off people, who would then be popular with you and you with them. Yes, some of the world prizes wealth more highly than kindness, intelligence, humour, and other positive traits. But I don't and wouldn't entertain those who did, so its nothing to do with my life. Stop letting it be part of yours.

Abigail47 · 06/08/2024 16:31

BadNeighbour101 · 06/08/2024 16:12

that sounds like a bad movie script.

Really? How immature of you to dismiss other peoples experiences.

OP posts:
Catza · 06/08/2024 16:28

@Abigail47 you seem to be weirdly fixated on your own narrative. Why post in AIBU if you are not prepared to shift from your position and consider a different viewpoint?
And why are you being so patronising towards "poor people" who supposedly "suffer" from this terrible injustice. I grew up poor, I have never experienced what you are talking about. I have rich friends and I don't always want/able to join in with things they want to do even when they offer to pay for me. The decision is entirely mine and it's bloody offensive to me that you think I am suffering as a result.

BadNeighbour101 · 06/08/2024 16:12

that sounds like a bad movie script.

Abigail47 · 06/08/2024 16:00

I disagree that it is anything to do with having things in common with people.

It is snobbery and class based division.

And it is the poor people who are already suffering in life, who end up suffering even more.

I remember joining a choir in the small town next to the small town in england that I lived in. There was the height of snobbery in that town. I joined the choir, and the older women came over to me and asked what I worked at. And then they said oh "and who are your parents, what do they do". After I answered , one woman looked scornful, and just turned and walked away from me.
They wouldn't speak to me at all. All of the rich people stuck together and simple wouldn't even speak to the 'poorer people. ' poverty is relative as at that time, I had okay money, but they still judged me and looked down on my as my parents didn't have as good jobs as their parents had.

My friend who joined the choir with me told me that she couldn't do it anymore after a couple of weeks, as they were so frosty and cold to us. She wanted to leave.

I remember crying to a man I knew in a different group about this. He had actually been born in an extremely poor family and was then adopted into a very rich family, so he was good to talk to about stuff like this, as he had a lot of insight.

I said to him, "why are they so cold and cruel". It's not all about money. I wanted to sing.

He said " I can tell you exactly why they are like that. I can tell you about their mindset. They won't talk to you because they don't want to 'dilute ' their wealth. They feel that talking to anyone that they see as poor, drags them down, lowers their status, and they don't want to even be seen talking to poorer people. To feel rich they will only talk to rich people."

OP posts:
Hangingupnow · 06/08/2024 12:52

During Covid, we weren't all standing on the doorstep clapping for millionaires.

No we just spent loads of money online which the likes of Amazon passed onto its shareholders as opposed to increasing wages. And low interest rates boosted assets which is why the richer are now richer post pandemic.

StMarieforme · 06/08/2024 12:41

Abigail47 · 06/08/2024 10:15

I was just wondering why everyone's value is defined by how money they have.

When I went to school, all of the most popular girls were from rich families. If your dad was wealthy , you were popular. The rich girls would only hang around with the othe rich girls.

If you were less rich they wouldn't talk to you. If you were poor or from a single parent family, they definitely wouldn't talk to you.

It made me think from an early age: why is my worth/ or anyone's worth defined by how much money I have. It seems so ridiculous.

There are so many other things that add up a person's worth: such as how kind they are, how good they are at different things etc.

Similarly when I went to college, the rich people would only hang around with each other.

I lived in a small town in England growing up, and again, it was always divided by money. The rich people would only really be friends with each other.

I then moved to London, which is a lot more diverse and multicultural, however you still get wealth snobbery in some of the workplaces. And even though in the workplaces, everyone talks to each other.

After work, and in hobbies, I've seen the same thing: that the really rich people in London will only be friends with other really rich people.

I mean is it not all a bit ridiculous. How is our worth tied to money? There are so many othe things that make a human valuable.

Yet alot of people seem to think of money over everything else

Not in my family it circle it's not. And when people like that have come into our lives, they soon leave again when they realise that their Bs is not wanted.

SouthLondonMum22 · 06/08/2024 12:40

Abigail47 · 06/08/2024 11:04

You said "you also tend to move in circles with people who are at a similar income level to you".

Let me correct that:

It should actually say

"Rich people tend to move in circles with people who are at a similar income level."

I've seen it so many times. Rich people will only talk to other Rich people.

To feel rich. And I think They feel richer and superior, by excluding poor people. How can you feel rich and superior, if you don't exclude poor people

People from other walks of life will hang around with anyone.

Edited

You can’t be friends with everyone. That isn’t excluding people, that’s just life.

You are simply much more likely to be friends with someone you have more in common with. Including similar backgrounds.

and it is absolutely the same with people who aren’t ‘rich’.

RiotsLondon · 06/08/2024 12:23

How are odd, there were families of many high net worth individuals at my school and no one gave a moments thought to it?
People who liked each other, liked it each other.
Why would you get on with someone just because they had a large house?

Sethera · 06/08/2024 12:19

Birds of a feather flock together.

taxguru · 06/08/2024 12:13

ToothPickk · 06/08/2024 10:22

It's not what I've experienced at all, and no one would know what I'm worth or earn because I don't tell them.

Likewise, can't say I've experienced it at all. Back in my school days, I don't remember even thinking about which friends/classmates had more money and which were poorer. We all just muddled in together as far as I remember. I don't recall any particular instances of some pupils showing off more expensive trainers or bags etc. Presumably some had more expensive things than others, but it just wasn't on my radar. I was more concerned about being bullied, and I can categorically state that most of my bullies weren't rich - they were mostly from the council estate and just roamed the school as a gang.

Same in adult life, work-life etc. Yes, some people I've known have shown the image of having more money, i.e. bigger house, new cars, etc., but I've known from an early age that it can be all smoke and mirrors with debts/leases/loans etc., so I've never immediately thought someone was rich just because they were driving a new BMW. Some of the actual genuine "rich" people I've known have actually lived a pretty frugal life (old cars, small house, etc)., and I've only known they're so rich because I've seen their bank statements/pass books etc when doing their tax returns!

Personally, I think there's too much emphasis on image etc - it's no indication of the actual wealth of someone - these days it's easy to "fake it" in many ways.

Catza · 06/08/2024 12:13

Abigail47 · 06/08/2024 10:36

You said "it makes sense to spend time with similar people.

But money is only one very small thing that you have in common with other people.

A rich girl who loves painting and art has that in common with a poor girl who loves painting and art.

It's not about having things in common I think, it's snobbery. And its cruel. You see it everywhere in society these days.

People are defined by money.

And the richer people are usually the cruellest ones. They look down on and leave out the poorer more unfortunate people

Yes but a rich girls who loves painting and art might want to book a weekend or art appreciation in Florence and expect to stay in 5 star hotel and dine in the best restaurants which the poor girl cannot afford to join in. Do you honestly not see how difficult it might make maintaining a friendship with someone?
One of my friends is very wealthy. I vividly remember her telling me "oh, you can JUST get a cab on the way back" when we were discussing a night out in an area without 24h transport links. No, Kate, I can't JUST take a £200 taxi home.

Poppysmom22 · 06/08/2024 12:07

Social programming