Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Saying no to childcare in the holidays

895 replies

Aprilmaymum · 03/08/2024 22:03

I today put my foot down and said no to my DSIL asking me to look after her three DC for two days next week. I have DC of my own and I am a full time mum while my DH works long hours. Last week I looked after my DN’s for two days. I I get my DSIL works and I am always happy to help but this is turning into more than the odd day. Of course my DBIL
has spoke to my DH about this and how disappointed he is etc etc. I don’t want to fall out but I feel enough is enough. I plan my DC activities in the holidays and next week two have swimming and one a drama group. this gives me a chance to catch up on jobs. So when DSIL asked me again and for three days I said no. It took me a lot to say no but now I feel
like a pig in the middle.
anyone else who is a full time mum feel like they are being took advantage of.

OP posts:
pollymere · 05/08/2024 13:01

I think you just have to sit back and laugh at her attempts for free childcare.

  1. You said no, so she cried to her husband.
  2. You said no again so she involved MIL.
  3. You continued to say no, so now she's saying how upset her kids are...

(The third one may be true as she may have said you were going to do loads of expensive activities).

There are lots of holiday clubs - some are free. Her lack of planning is not your fault or your problem. In these scenarios you will always be painted as the bad guy...even if you gave in now. Just go with being the bad guy and enjoy your summer with your kids.

DesparatePragmatist · 05/08/2024 12:50

I'd really like to know how the OPs family challenge gets resolved and hope the derailers haven't put her off coming back to update us on what happens, and how she feels about it. It sounds like you're level-headed and able to rise above the drama, OP, so I hope you're OK and feeling good about your totally justified position.

prescribingmum · 05/08/2024 12:27

Usercyzabc · 05/08/2024 08:10

Careful now, this can be applied to everthing then. That poster didn’t directly attack the OP either if she had I wouldn’t have said a word.

I didn’t disagree with you though, however, my immediate thought was some arsehole had belittled or criticised the PP for her to respond like that, not that she views the OP like tha. The PP never came back so who knows how this upset her. I’m not some great defender either but the childish comments in response were pathetic.

The post you are referring to did attack the OP and was unbelievably rude which is why it was deleted for breaking guidelines.

As many have said, if the term upsets someone to the extent they had to post in the way she did, her feelings of upset are a reflection on her dissatisfaction with her own life and nothing to do with the OP (who apologised immediately for using the wrong terminology and meant no offence).

The person who made the post is long gone. Your repeated comments about posting your last one…then reappearing to continue defending the indefensible are quite entertaining so keep going…!

Shinyandnew1 · 05/08/2024 11:34

@Aprilmaymum what is your SIL/BIL doing with their children the rest of the days of the week that she hasn’t asked you to have them for?

GoFigure235 · 05/08/2024 11:32

Usercyzabc · 05/08/2024 09:53

Even when they’re at school? I’m sorry I couldn’t resist 😂

I'm not a SAHM and have a nursery age child so no skin in the game, but surely if you are able to be a SAHM to school age kids, you would use the time when they're at school to get jobs done, organise stuff and recharge your batteries so that family life runs more smoothly and you can fit more in the rest of the time.

Yes, families with working parents manage without this but I often find myself saying to my kids "sorry, Mummy's too tired to play" or not getting round to organising stuff or not wanting to engage with them constantly because I'm tired out. If I had the luxury of time to myself during the day, I'd use it to be a less stressed and more organised parent to my own children the rest of the time, not to do unpaid childcare for someone else.

Deboragh · 05/08/2024 10:57

Aprilmaymum · 03/08/2024 22:07

I used to work part time and did look at full time but DH for a promotion which did mean more money but longer hours so gave up work to look after my three DC. Since then I have been asked again and again. Last week she said she was desperate and as I had nothing planned said yes but this week I said no. My DBIL has yet again text my DH about families helping out etc.

Why's the dbil texting your husband? Hasn't he got the balls to ask you directly to do his job for him. CF.

Usercyzabc · 05/08/2024 09:53

DavidBeckhamsrightfoot · 05/08/2024 09:36

The OP has left paid employment and has made the life choice to commit her time to raising her children full time.

An idiot could understand that. And yet here you all are in all your glory.

Even when they’re at school? I’m sorry I couldn’t resist 😂

FancyBiscuitsLevel · 05/08/2024 09:41

@Aprilmaymum I think it’s very important now that you say that it’s just too much for you to look after all 6 together and so while you have plans for this week, you really can’t offer childcare anymore at all (and yes, you never offered, they asked but that’s a different issue!).

remove yourself from the options, 6 kids is far too many for you. Well done if someone else can cope, you have tried and can’t. They need to find someone else.

DavidBeckhamsrightfoot · 05/08/2024 09:36

ItsVeryHyacinthBucket · 04/08/2024 21:59

Not commonly used on this site. Always needs to be corrected, it’s not nice for working parents to read that. And no, I didn’t read all 28 pages of the thread before commenting, did you? Or did you just read my last post to make your snarky comment?

The OP has left paid employment and has made the life choice to commit her time to raising her children full time.

An idiot could understand that. And yet here you all are in all your glory.

Shinyandnew1 · 05/08/2024 09:14

You don’t ask family for help with childcare and vice versa? Friends too. Takes a village.

The situation here is a couple who appear to have used up all their annual leave on a month long term-time holiday, have no plan for summer childcare and are repeatedly asking OP (nobody else?) to have their three kids for long days and assumed that will be ok. This is despite them never having OP’s kids as well as meaning she can’t go anywhere in the car and she has booked her own kids into childcare anyway so she could get her own stuff done! When she isn’t bowing down and agreeing, SIL is getting her husband involved to ‘talk to’ his brother about it and then bitching about how much OP has upset her to her dad/FIL. I think this is pretty appalling.

A bit of give and take amongst friends and family is fine. When people start demanding a ‘village’ to help them out, they are just chancers.

UKposter · 05/08/2024 09:10

I have read all the OPs posts but no replies as the thread is so long.
DSIL should not assume that the OP can look after her DC on any day let alone certain days.
Telling her DC they would be seeing their cousins when it wasn’t arranged so that they then cried is all on her. It almost sounds like it’s been done deliberately for emotional manipulation.
Stick to your guns OP. Very occasional help would be nice when it wasn’t expected but it sounds like they wanted you to be their regular childcare without even asking.

edited as didn’t make sense!

Blondeshavemorefun · 05/08/2024 09:07

Sil should have asked you before telling the kids that they were going to yours /seeing cousins

I'm happy to have dd cousins /friends over but on the days I went

Dd7 goes to club 2 days a week so I can sleep as I work nights

No way would I be having other kids if mine wasn't there

IncompleteSenten · 05/08/2024 09:00

Ilikeadrink14 · 04/08/2024 22:52

Why do posters keep picking faultnwith what others have written

You mean like lots of them picking fault with her use of the term full time mum?

Yeah, it's irritating. Particularly since she acknowledged the complaints ages back

WickieRoy · 05/08/2024 08:35

Flossyts · 05/08/2024 07:43

You don’t ask family for help with childcare and vice versa? Friends too. Takes a village. I like having my nieces and nephews, it helps keeping my kids occupied. It would be cheeky to ask and just expect an automatic yes (and complain to the husband!)

Edited

In a general sense, not cheeky to ask family to help with childcare.

In this specific case it was cheeky as hell to ask OP to mind three children for long days when she already has three of her own, when she's already done it several times for them but the favour is never reciprocated, and when you're asking because you just couldn't be bothered to organise childcare over the summer holidays. It's not like this was an emergency or a quid pro quo. They just thought the nearest SAHM was there to be their free childcare. They're chleeky as.

Usercyzabc · 05/08/2024 08:10

ABirdsEyeView · 05/08/2024 08:03

But feeling something doesn't make it true. If someone gets disproportionately upset at an innocent and commonly used phrase, and completely overreacts to the poor OP, I'm not sure that can be defended.

Some posters do need to get a bit of perspective and realise that mostly people are not going through life looking at ways to deliberately insult others.

Careful now, this can be applied to everthing then. That poster didn’t directly attack the OP either if she had I wouldn’t have said a word.

I didn’t disagree with you though, however, my immediate thought was some arsehole had belittled or criticised the PP for her to respond like that, not that she views the OP like tha. The PP never came back so who knows how this upset her. I’m not some great defender either but the childish comments in response were pathetic.

ABirdsEyeView · 05/08/2024 08:06

OP, when they ask you next week to look after their dc, be prepared!
I think this is a good time to say that after their appalling behaviour, you think it best they make other arrangements. Bil in particular would have reallly annoyed me, in your position.

ABirdsEyeView · 05/08/2024 08:03

But feeling something doesn't make it true. If someone gets disproportionately upset at an innocent and commonly used phrase, and completely overreacts to the poor OP, I'm not sure that can be defended.

Some posters do need to get a bit of perspective and realise that mostly people are not going through life looking at ways to deliberately insult others.

Nanasueathome · 05/08/2024 08:03

Aprilmaymum · 04/08/2024 13:52

I have said no as I have plans for the week and it is hard to do things with 6 DC. I don’t want to fall out with anyone as we do as a family have a good respectful relationship. I think my problem was allowing myself to be available at the drop of a hat and not saying anything before. I hope now we can move on as a family and not let this get in the way.

I think they will try to get you to help out for other weeks. There’s still a few weeks of school summer holidays
Im more upset for you about the fact they think they can more or less force you to look after their children and get the in-laws involved. It makes the overall situation unpleasant

Usercyzabc · 05/08/2024 07:50

ABirdsEyeView · 05/08/2024 07:30

Everyone knows 'full time mum' isn't a dig at working outside the home mums and just means physically doing childcare ft. Choosing to take such offence at this, that they aggressively pile into a poster who meant no insult, just makes said poster a chippy dick who needs to examine their own life choices. Feeling that riled isn't normal.
How another person chooses to describe their own life is really their own business and no one has a right to police their language.

Hardly the point but crack on, as I said I don’t give a shit about it, what really is irritating though and why I defended one poster is she was clearly very upset and was basically told to fuck off.

The posters who piled on, then and now failed to understand that what she wrote in response was directly related to how insulting she felt what the OP had written. She obviously was t saying the OP was though things but there are varying levels of comprehension on here.

Why am I even bothering at this point I must ask myself. Off I fuck.

Flossyts · 05/08/2024 07:43

BettyBardMacDonald · 04/08/2024 23:54

It was 100 percent cheeky for them to ask! Come on!!

You don’t ask family for help with childcare and vice versa? Friends too. Takes a village. I like having my nieces and nephews, it helps keeping my kids occupied. It would be cheeky to ask and just expect an automatic yes (and complain to the husband!)

ABirdsEyeView · 05/08/2024 07:30

Everyone knows 'full time mum' isn't a dig at working outside the home mums and just means physically doing childcare ft. Choosing to take such offence at this, that they aggressively pile into a poster who meant no insult, just makes said poster a chippy dick who needs to examine their own life choices. Feeling that riled isn't normal.
How another person chooses to describe their own life is really their own business and no one has a right to police their language.

Usercyzabc · 05/08/2024 07:19

How about full time person? Then everyone is happy. Oh wait, what covers the rest of the part of part time person? Telling people to bore off because they’re affronted is an interesting take too, next time I insult or offend someone, I’ll see where that gets me. The level of disrespect on this thread is the standard I suppose. Yawn.

OP detailed her own thread I’m afraid but pile on, I quite frankly don’t give a shit.

Ilovecleaning · 05/08/2024 06:43

ItsVeryHyacinthBucket · 04/08/2024 21:50

YABU for saying full time mum, those of us who work aren’t part time??! What ignorance.

FFS, bore off.

PivotPivotmakingmargaritas · 05/08/2024 04:52

The problem with saying you have plans is that next week they will try again. I know you don’t want a falling out but I think the damage is already done they have run to your DH and IL’s as if they are your boss/ mummy therefore they don’t respect you, your time so I would be saying no not even one day and they need to organise clubs for the rest of the holidays as you are not their holiday childminder

They are CF who went on holiday for a month without a care as they just assumed they could bully you to take their kids for free during the holidays- no way would I want six kids to care for multiple times a week

Jeannie88 · 05/08/2024 00:16

As a working Mum with family in law who don't work or have young DC we have never or would ask. (Lot to do with trusting supervision and to be dropped off at 7am whenthey sleep into the afternoon etc). Nursery, no other help as my family work. As they get older it's easier when one wfh. Xxx