Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be panicking about DC’s employability post uni?

331 replies

NeedXanaxPlease · 03/08/2024 17:18

DD is going into the final year of an Anthropology degree (might get a first but probably a 2:1) from a top RG uni. Has done a Fine Art foundation year. Always worked part time since finishing A-levels (Maths, English Lit, Art), first as a barista/front of house/waitressing, then as an after-school nanny during uni.
She loves working, is highly responsible, great people skills (and people judgement) and quite numerate/commercially savvy. She is a great kid and would be an asset to any team. But… she hasn’t had a single internship so no “relevant” work experience (didn’t get her act together after first year and a long recovery post an operation for a sporting injury after second year) nor does she really know what she wants to do after graduation. She is definitely not pursuing the classic investment banking, Bain/BCG/McKinsey, accountancy, law routes.
I am now feeling highly anxious and helpless as I don’t know how to support/guide her. I did the classic Tier 1 strategy consulting, MBA, corporate M&A so I am spending hours each week helping my friends’ kids who want to pursue this path (mock case studies, mock interviews, CV reviews) but am at a complete loss re how to help my own. I feel that I am spiralling. This is not helped by my being involved in graduate recruitment at my work – CVs I see are all full of Economics/Management/Sciences degrees, multiple internships/work experiences/summer schools – they are highly structured and tick all the boxes (to an extent where I can’t differentiate between them). My DD wouldn’t stand a chance on paper.
Sage mumsnetters, please reassure me that she can get a job without internships and with a “soft” degree? Does she stand a chance with graduate schemes? Should she even bother applying? What potential career routes she could explore?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
masomenos · 06/08/2024 22:27

DD printed off NICE guidance, went with her to GP, strong armed an urgent pathway referral, the girl is now diagnosed, on treatment and getting PIP. DD is big into social justice.

An employer would kill to have this on their workforce. If she were mine, I’d be advising her to find out what area of social justice she wants to work in, and go for it. She has the ability and real life skills to make the impact she’s seeking to make, and if she chooses something that motivates her, she’ll be amazing.

HOWEVER (and I say this as one of the women you refer to as having been chewed in and spat out by the City), like a PP I too will be advising my DD that (1) she will likely be working for many years, so it’s a marathon and not a sprint (2) life is about more than work, and it’s a fact that it’s women who take maternity leave and bear the brunt of family obligations (3) she has a biological clock (4) she needs to make her own decisions, and be responsible for them (5) she would be very ill-advised to rely on a man/woman (partner) for anything (6) happiness is elusive and not the end goal, it’s an occasional by product of a life lived well. I couldn’t care less what my DD does, as long as it does no harm to her or others. She must do what interests her and whatever she’s good at. I’m willing to support her on a sliding scale while she finds her feet - it’s tough out there. But the tap will be turned off eventually, because she needs to search for fulfilment and satisfaction in the hope of finding it at some point.

NeedXanaxPlease · 06/08/2024 21:43

Educational Psychologist is an idea I floated with her during A levels and didn’t get any traction - don’t remember why. May be something to revisit, it’s something I would have liked to do.

Data science tech is a good shout but would need to be something not purely technical/solitary - something to think about as a concept. It resonates what wan earlier poster said about forensic/cyber computing where hard skills combine with behavioral analysis. Something along those lines could be explored.

OP posts:
EatingTillIDie · 06/08/2024 21:12

I've had multiple career crises. I've never found the thing that makes me tick. Maybe most people never do. I like transformation consulting because I get to nose around in other people's jobs for a few months and then tell them how to do it better. If you get a job with one of the big firms, or specialise, it can be high earning.

I've worked in public sector for a long time and the only way to earn big there is senior management. You can't walk into that, you start at the bottom and move up. You might get an assistant director role on 70 to 90k by the time you are in your 40s if you are good at your job and can play the politics. The benefit of this sector is the massive variety of types of project you can work on. If you're someone who gets bored easily then it's great. Downside - got to get good at surviving restrctures. Continually retrain. Embrace technology.

The only other industry I have experience in is tech, and I would say anyone could go that route if they have an interest. Just do a python bootcamp and get a data science apprenticeship.

I've worked with educational psychologists and it is one of those fields that there is never enough people to fill the positions and will never be replaced by AI. Whether she is interested in children or persuing/funding a psychology masters and EP PhD is another matter!

Countingcactus · 06/08/2024 21:05

NeedXanaxPlease · 04/08/2024 22:11

Look. I do appreciate advice on keeping my beak out. It’s a valuable perspective. But I think there’s a balance between being pushy and living their life for them and being an engaged parent trying to give a leg up. My own anxiety about this is a separate matter that I am trying to address.

But friends and I had multiple existential and career crises through which we supported each other. Endless conversations on what next, how to position oneself, helping with writing business cases for promotions, helping with case studies/providing feedback etc. If I’d do it for my friends and young mentees, why wouldn’t I do the same for DC?

Genuine question - where does healthy support stop and over- involvement begin?

I’m not completely sure where the line is but I think you’re well over it. I kind of hoped your first post was a parody.

EatingTillIDie · 06/08/2024 20:55

NeedXanaxPlease · 03/08/2024 21:41

A rather individual sport (competitively) - too outing to name. Still doing her art and some commissions (not a lot - not much time left), quite an accomplished cook - think about own curry paste from scratch with pestle and mortar. Travel. Camping with uni/school friends. Well, and the part time job. As I said, she like problem solving - her friend from uni had symptoms that are indicative of a disease unlikely in someone so young but becoming increasingly disabling. The girl was fobbed off by GP 20 times. DD printed off NICE guidance, went with her to GP, strong armed an urgent pathway referral, the girl is now diagnosed, on treatment and getting PIP. DD is big into social justice.

Could look into educational psychology. Long path to qualification but rewarding, lucrative and never be without a job. And seriously worth doing. Alternative is social care but that's hard graft for lower pay.

GinForBreakfast · 06/08/2024 18:36

OP your daughter sounds great and facing completely normal post-graduation life.

If she's interested in marketing but has no experience, and likes "doing" and "seeing results" then events/event management is a good entry point. It also segues nicely into project management which is an interesting and growing field.

I'm sorry that the university careers service is poor. To be fair to them, the possibilities are endless so she can help them by narrowing down her interests.

EatingCheeses · 06/08/2024 17:54

@NeedXanaxPlease would you mind sharing details of the career service run by occupational psychologists please? My youngest has no idea what he wants to do for a career and this could be useful to him.

EwwSprouts · 06/08/2024 17:24

You start with a hypothesis on paper and iterate in real life as you go along (and if needed switch jobs/re-evaluate careers etc.). I hate the uncertaintly that comes with it, but it is what it is.
Loving the pragmatism. Uncertainty and change are going to feature prominently in the career paths of our young people, however qualified/skilled/personable they are. My pet theory, which DS refuses to embrace, is that if you want security you go self-employed into an industry where AI can't readily make you redundant eg plumber.

NeedXanaxPlease · 06/08/2024 15:54

@titchy

You've said you don't like the cut throat of your job, the inherent sexism, the long hours etc. But that now you have the expensive lifestyle you can't quit. Wouldn't it have been a happier life if you'd been able to try out and few things when you were younger, before youd got used to the expensive lifestyle and responsibilities?

100%. Intellectually, I am with you 100%. Emotionally, it's tough to internalize this thesis.

But also, thinking back, I might have made better choices if I had some career/life guidance which I didn't (nor did I seek it to be fair - was just chasing the money). That's why I so desperately want to be helpful to DD which I realize might veer into pushy/overinvested/suffocating territory defeating the whole purpose of the exercise. I do have some self-awareness...

OP posts:
NeedXanaxPlease · 06/08/2024 15:40

@Pharos
The ones I’m thinking of are much smaller - they tend to be spin-offs from bigger agencies. I’ll DM you a couple of names if you like.

Please do - I just Googled - would be great to have a datapoint

OP posts:
titchy · 06/08/2024 15:21

I think I am getting my head around the fact that it's all about trade-offs - she needs to figure out what hers might be. And it's an ongoing exercise. You start with a hypothesis on paper and iterate in real life as you go along (and if needed switch jobs/re-evaluate careers etc.). I hate the uncertaintly that comes with it, but it is what it is.

Those are good things though - you need to reframe your thinking. Uncertainty means flexibility, it means not being stuck pigeon holed. It means open to a variety of options.

You've said you don't like the cut throat of your job, the inherent sexism, the long hours etc. But that now you have the expensive lifestyle you can't quit. Wouldn't it have been a happier life if you'd been able to try out and few things when you were younger, before youd got used to the expensive lifestyle and responsibilities?

Pharos · 06/08/2024 15:10

The ones I’m thinking of are much smaller - they tend to be spin-offs from bigger agencies. I’ll DM you a couple of names if you like.

LinkedIn tends to be the main recruitment route for vacancies from what I’ve seen.

NeedXanaxPlease · 06/08/2024 15:09

This thread has been a treasure trove of ideas.

I have calmed down a lot in the last few days. I think I am getting my head around the fact that it's all about trade-offs - she needs to figure out what hers might be. And it's an ongoing exercise. You start with a hypothesis on paper and iterate in real life as you go along (and if needed switch jobs/re-evaluate careers etc.). I hate the uncertaintly that comes with it, but it is what it is.

I actually made a note from years ago where a Mumsnetter recommended a career service run by occupational psychologists that helps you figure out your motivations, values, abilities, etc and what careers might tie with the above. Might give this a go.

But solution space has to have some boundary conditions and some might be mutually exclusive. Impact, hours, pay, type of work, job satisfaction, culture, values, aspired property, etc go into a pot and if she gets a circular reference back, she'll need to decide what gives.

OP posts:
NeedXanaxPlease · 06/08/2024 14:57

the conventional routes might be more challenging for you but it could be the right path for her

I am totally fine with it - just have less personal insight into these.

Are corporate comms same as PR? E.g., would Prosek, Brunswick, Fleishman Hillard qualify as corporate comms/boutiqe?

Corporate comms sounds great, it also made me think of of IR but I don't think IR is graduate level job.

OP posts:
Holluschickie · 06/08/2024 12:22

Lots of the smaller boutique corporate comms firms take graduates with humanities degrees - ds did a short internship with one the other week and the majority of the staff were under 25, a couple had done anthropology.

This is what my DD is doing. She's good at it too and enjoys it.

Pharos · 06/08/2024 12:16

Lots of the smaller boutique corporate comms firms take graduates with humanities degrees - ds did a short internship with one the other week and the majority of the staff were under 25, a couple had done anthropology.

His impression was while not as ‘prestigious’ necessarily, they had far more responsibility than at bigger firms and it gave them a really good trajectory within the industry.

Dd is about to finish an anthropology MA from SOAS after a first degree in MFL, she’s had offers from several companies for research posts but is instead going to follow her absolute passion and move into costume design for film and tv.

As a London-based grad, there are plenty of opportunities for your dd, looking away from
the conventional routes might be more challenging for you but it could be the right path for her.

Barney60 · 06/08/2024 11:56

Got to be honest about my ignorance, i didnt have a clue what an Anthropologist actually was, so i googled it.
According to the Bureau of Labour there has been a 4.2% growth in employment for this skill, the higher they qualify the better chance of work.
Does she have any idea in what area of work she intends to use her degree, healthcare, social work, public relations, archaeology, museums?

AmIEnough · 06/08/2024 07:58

NeedXanaxPlease · 03/08/2024 17:46

What are those paths though? As you might have guessed from my post, my world is quite limited to finance. I am actually happy she is not doing it - I have seen enough women chewed up and spat out in these roles - but I am not familiar with what else is out there (that is not STEM/finance/law) that pays enough to have a semi-decent quality of life in London.

To answer your question re what she enjoys - problem solving, pace, probably projects/variety, rather than routine, degree of creativity, seeing specific outcome/result.

Project management?

Mamasharp97 · 05/08/2024 20:19

My degree is literally in songwriting. I became a music and drama teacher, Head of House at my school, looking into leadership roles. I also work making top lines for electronic artists all over the world. My parents wanted me to do a real degree and biopharmaceuticals but instead of something I hate, I live a life I LOVE sooooo much. She’ll be fine. more than fine. Just gotta let her decide what she wants and support her.

user1477249785 · 05/08/2024 15:49

*how about

user1477249785 · 05/08/2024 15:48

OP how absolutely civil service fast stream? She won't get rich on it but it pays ok and offers fascinating work.

LadeOde · 05/08/2024 14:52

senua · 05/08/2024 09:22

Why it is on MN if a person is doing works in a high earning sector it's never the result of hard work they got there it's all because of privilege!
Except I didn't say that.Hmm
OP said that DD missed out on internships because of "a long recovery post an operation for a sporting injury" and I was pointing out that she is not the only one who has had bumps in the road, there will be many other people with non-perfect CVs.

What i will say is, those sectors you mentioned are just a few. There are loads of places your dc can apply to
This time, it is approximately what I said. I can't see that you added anything to the argument.

i.e. are the CVs of privilege - no caring responsibilities nor disabilities, to name just two barriers.
@senua Heavily implied from this barbed comment so at least be honest, as for the rest of your post, @NeedXanaxPlease wasn't asking for an 'argument', they were asking for opinions/advice which I gave along with everyone else, that's usually how comments flow. Sorry yours weren't as unique as you hoped it to be.

OneCoolPearlOP · 05/08/2024 12:36

NeedXanaxPlease · 04/08/2024 22:05

@Ethylred
Doing a PhD is not the way to go; never do a PhD in subject X unless the thought of pursuing anything except X is unbearable.

completely agree - same stands for art, music, ballet etc. as I mentioned prior, ex is an academic as was a lot of our social circle- they all loved what they did (at least initially) but all the pressure and competition was something out of a dystopian novel. You really do need to be brilliant to do well (and I don’t mean financially) whereas in a lot of corporate careers being good enough is more than enough.

She hasn’t had an entirely soft, easy life if one adds a disabled sibling into the equation but materially it was soft and easy. And you are totally right - that’s exactly what I want her to have - a soft easy life because I didn’t have it. I am not actually sure she does. I think she is ok with adversity but I don’t want her to have the soul destroying adversity of working 90-120hrs a week producing absolutely meaningless pitches or presentations. Zero impact, zero purpose.

@NeedXanaxPlease With all due respect, you seriously need to get a grip.There's a difference between working to afford basic security, Vs luxury.

You chose the latter. Nobody forced you to work 100 hour weeks in a erm 'soul destroying zero impact' job so that you could pay for private school, ski trips and expensive sports.

It's not a race to the bottom but so many others work much harder, in worse conditions yet can't afford any treats. If a 'lack of impact' bothers you so much why don't you become a carer or nurse... Work long hours on your feet, get paid peanuts.

Others like myself worked intensely in our youth then got out. Saved for important things like uni fees and a house deposit instead. If you really wanted your daughter to have a soft easy life, THIS is really what you should have spent your money on.

Anyway, I think the girl will be fine, even if she earns 30K and lives at home for 6 years rent/bills free she'll have close to 60K as a deposit, enough to buy a flat with a reasonable mortgage and bills.

But you need to stop projecting the consequences of your choices onto her. And stop thinking of yourself as hard done by. You've been very privileged, so has she (with that kind of money and time to do competitive sport she's hardly been disadvantaged by her disabled sibling although her life might be slightly harder).

mids2019 · 05/08/2024 09:50

I think what I lacked at your child's. age was a full appreciation of the competitive financial nature of life. Pensions, investments, property prices, mortgages etc. we're absolutely not on my radar in my early twenties and I think there is advice to be passed onto children without being in any way controlling or intrusive.

By floating around careers you are missing out on pernsion starting and getting a first on the housing ladder. While these things seem unimportant as a youth it becomes plain in your early 50s how much of your wealth and future security is tied up in these things. You and your children's lifestyles are impacted by these important career choices in youth.

I am certainly not saying a renumerative career is the be all and end all but it has to be a consideration in weighing up your life or there is an element of niavity about all this.