Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Genuine question re pensioner fuel payment cut

517 replies

Katypp · 02/08/2024 09:49

Just this: How would the Labour supporters react if three weeks into a new Conservative Government, the chancellor cut the winter fuel payment to any pensioner with an income of more than £11k?
Would you think it was a reasonable thing to do or would it be considered cruel because it was the Tories implementing it, not Labour?
I would imagine Angela Raynor, Yvette Cooper and Wes Streeting would have been very vocal and worried about it.
Would the public finances argument wash if it was a Tory Government? It didn't when Cameron came into power.
What's different?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
9
MrsSkylerWhite · 02/08/2024 13:03

VilanelleTutu · Today 12:57
I’m hoping that we’ll see downsizing from family sized homes and using the equity to pay for their retirement costs instead of sitting on property wealth and requiring state top ups due to low income”

We’re doing exactly this. Not yet pensioners, 65 and 60. Took us a hell of a time to find an appropriate apartment, though. We’re downsizing and releasing funds for our adult kids and our future care costs yes, but we didn’t want to live in a rabbit hutch!
Lack of suitable properties to downsize into is a big problem.

TheNoonBell · 02/08/2024 13:01

For those of you unaware of Starmer's huge pension, he even had a law passed mentioning him by name.

The Pensions Increase (Pension Scheme for Keir Starmer QC) Regulations 2013

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-politics-65037136

From the article:
Labour leader Sir Keir Starmer has been accused of hypocrisy by Conservatives over a tax exempt pension deal he has from a previous job.
Sir Keir criticised measures in the Budget which scrapped the £1m cap on lifetime pensions savings.
The Telegraph reported, external Sir Keir got a special "tax unregistered" pension scheme when he stood down as Director of Public Prosecutions (DPP) in 2013.
Labour says it was standard practice for retiring DPPs to get such a deal.
But senior Conservative MP Sir Iain Duncan Smith told The Telegraph it made a "mockery" of Labour's position on the lifetime pension allowance, and was as "close to hypocrisy as it is possible to get".
Tory MP Andrea Leadsom told the BBC's Politics Live it was an example of "extraordinary hypocrisy".

Labour leader Keir Starmer

Sir Keir Starmer criticised over tax free pension scheme

Labour defends its leader's pension arrangements against Conservative accusations of hypocrisy.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-politics-65037136

S0livagant · 02/08/2024 13:00

Miley1967 · 02/08/2024 12:57

If someone just has state pension, they would get most of their rent paid by housing benefit. There is plenty of help. Get even £1 of pension credit and you get all your rent and council tax paid for you but if are a few pounds above the pension credit threshold you'd still get a fair bit of your rent paid.

Edited

So they are not just on 11k then.

AgnesX · 02/08/2024 12:59

If you hadn't noticed there are plenty of vociferous individuals on the Labour side. With regards to Yvette Cooper et al, they've probably been told to button it and toe the party line.

Apart from that just watch, everything that's not nailed down is going to be means tested to pay for the Tory profligacy (and the bloody war in Ukraine). I reckon this is only the start.

1dayatatime · 02/08/2024 12:58

Typically voters act selfishly and don't care if services or benefits are cut so long as it doesn't impact them. Equally voters are supportive of tax increases so long as it doesn't impact them.

You see it all the time on MN "they should tax the rich more " with rich being defined as anyone on 50% more than the poster.

sausawyee · 02/08/2024 12:57

Full details on previous link

Genuine question re pensioner fuel payment cut
Miley1967 · 02/08/2024 12:57

S0livagant · 02/08/2024 12:54

It would be impossible to pay private rent out of that.

If someone just has state pension, they would get most of their rent paid by housing benefit. There is plenty of help. Get even £1 of pension credit and you get all your rent and council tax paid for you but if are a few pounds above the pension credit threshold you'd still get a fair bit of your rent paid.

VilanelleTutu · 02/08/2024 12:57

I’m hoping that we’ll see downsizing from family sized homes and using the equity to pay for their retirement costs instead of sitting on property wealth and requiring state top ups due to low income.

BeachBae · 02/08/2024 12:56

UpTheMagicFarawayTree · 02/08/2024 09:55

I'd have still agreed with it. I don't begrudge older people anything, however if there isn't enough to go around those with the least should be prioritised.

Is 11k per year minimum wage? Or living wage? A cut off of 11k per year seems very low. The cut off should be at least min/living wage.

I don't agree with taking from pensioners first though, unless its based on a means test. There are other areas where spending should be cut first imo.

And the fuel cap should be brought back in. At a reasonable rate.

I'm not Labour btw.

GettingStuffed · 02/08/2024 12:55

mirrorlife · 02/08/2024 09:51

Let’s hope the triple lock goes soon as well.

We already have the lowest pension in Europe ( EU countries) . Not everyone has a private and go those that do they aren't always that big.

The triple lock is what is supposed to keep pensions in line with the cost of living.

Miley1967 · 02/08/2024 12:55

Boomer55 · 02/08/2024 12:25

Well, they’re also talking about reducing childcare funding, free school meals, and Universal Credit, so I think many groups will be paying a price, sooner or later.

I've not heard of any talk of reducing UC, they've ramped it up a lot in recent years.

ruby1957 · 02/08/2024 12:55

Starlingexpress · 02/08/2024 12:48

My ‘pensioner’ parent is fit, healthy, has assets in excess of 7 figures and has quite happily accepted their winter fuel and free bus pass for years. I have a number of other wealthy pensioner relatives who use their maximum 2 year old cars to drive to the outskirts of town, park up for free and then use their bus passes into town to avoid parking fees.

It’s been a mockery of a system for years and I’m delighted that this generation of wealth is no longer being pandered to.

That is your experience - but can you not get your brain round the fact that not all pensioners are that wealthy and surely they are worth a measly £4 per week per household to keep themselves warm over the winter months.
Frankly I don't care how much your parents have - they are disgraceful for accepting the £200 per year instead of donating it.

.
Can you not envisage that millions of pensioners who worked hard all ttheir lives are not on such riches and NEED this extra help.

S0livagant · 02/08/2024 12:54

Katypp · 02/08/2024 12:51

My understanding is if their income is more than £221 per week, there is no help for rent. I might be wrong though

It would be impossible to pay private rent out of that.

Miley1967 · 02/08/2024 12:53

MojoMoon · 02/08/2024 12:25

I find it even more baffling that in London, the 63 year CEO at my company (personal wealth must be more than £20million) can use the tube for free but our teenage and early 20s apprentices (on London living wage) have to pay full fares.

Yes, cheap/free public transport is very important to low income pensioners and should remain. But it would be equally as important to low income people of any age.

I am a Labour supporter and would back Sadiq in getting rid of universal free travel for older people - harder to administer as it's done by councils not HMRC/Treasury though

Crazy too that every 60 year old gets free prescriptions when most are working. My dh earning 40k a year and now getting free prescriptions. he is on a lot of medications but only pays £10 a month with pre paid certificate.

sausawyee · 02/08/2024 12:53

I'm interested to know when Labour will take away the fuel allowance that MPs have .

pocketaces · 02/08/2024 12:53

It's rampant hypocrisy. The other way round Labour front bench would be screaming evil tory cuts.

Get used to this as more is to come.

S0livagant · 02/08/2024 12:52

MrsSkylerWhite · 02/08/2024 12:43

2dogsandabudgie · Today 12:24
MrsSkylerWhite · Today 12:05
Perfectly sensible. Millions don’t need it. My mum gives hers to a cat charity 🙄
**
Oh dear, all these supposed charities that are going to miss out this “

It’s not “supposed”. It’s a local charity in Somerset. She adopted her latest cat from them (irresponsibly, I think, as she has dementia). Why on earth would anyone make that up?

We wouldn't need so much charity if taxpayers money went to those in need. More pets are given up in a CoL crisis.

guineverehadgreeneyes · 02/08/2024 12:52

https://www.almondfinancial.co.uk/pension-breakeven-index-how-does-the-uk-state-pension-compare-to-the-rest-of-europe/

2024 Pension breakeven index: How does the UK state pension compare to the rest of Europe?

"The UK moved up one place from last year’s report in the top 30, now coming in at number 15..."

“Closer to home, the UK has a system that is just above the breakeven point which means at present, there isn’t much room to manoeuvre for those battling the cost of living crisis. And while it is positive that the UK finds itself among the top half of countries, for how much longer is the question.

“Although the increase in the state pension was well intended, it works out at just £33 more per month compared to last year’s pension. It’s clear that those over 66 need to look at other options rather than just relying on the state pension."

Blueglazzier · 02/08/2024 12:51

The cut off point for pension credit should be a levelling off . Those who claim full state pension or may have a small private pension alongside, yet little savings should be able to apply. £1 over the state pension and they get no help. This is wrong and needs to be looked at . I think a rising scale should be applied . The government need to look at this . How worrying for those with full state pension and little money behind them

Werweisswohin · 02/08/2024 12:51

UpTheMagicFarawayTree · 02/08/2024 09:55

I'd have still agreed with it. I don't begrudge older people anything, however if there isn't enough to go around those with the least should be prioritised.

I agree with this.

Katypp · 02/08/2024 12:51

My understanding is if their income is more than £221 per week, there is no help for rent. I might be wrong though

OP posts:
S0livagant · 02/08/2024 12:50

Katypp · 02/08/2024 10:14

Who are those with the least though? A pensioner on £11k is surely one of those?

Are they paying rent out of 11k or would those renting get housing benefit on top?

Starlingexpress · 02/08/2024 12:48

My ‘pensioner’ parent is fit, healthy, has assets in excess of 7 figures and has quite happily accepted their winter fuel and free bus pass for years. I have a number of other wealthy pensioner relatives who use their maximum 2 year old cars to drive to the outskirts of town, park up for free and then use their bus passes into town to avoid parking fees.

It’s been a mockery of a system for years and I’m delighted that this generation of wealth is no longer being pandered to.

Katypp · 02/08/2024 12:47

2dogsandabudgie · 02/08/2024 11:47

Would you include the £10 Christmas Bonus that people on PIP get? Or is it only one group of vulnerable people who you think should be targeted?

The £10 Christmas bonus can go for everyone imo. It's one of those things that are virtually worthless to the recipient but cost the country millions collectively. Get rid.

OP posts: