Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

shocked my best friend voted Reform

734 replies

clearmoon · 31/07/2024 23:42

Long standing close friend came round for dinner and we were nattering away, and she just mentioned off hand in the conversation that she had voted Reform. i am really shocked. We don't discuss politics much. But I would have guessed lib dems or labour. I love her dearly. But I do wonder if I should think about her differently now, or just carry on as before

YANBU - She is not such a good person as I thought all these years
YABU-its all fine

OP posts:
Another2Cats · 01/08/2024 08:04

RosaRoja · 01/08/2024 07:03

This is turning into a general politics discussion. OP was shocked about her best friend. Not a random person at work that she chats about the weather with in the kitchen.

When that happens I think you’re also a bit disappointed with yourself - for guessing wrong, or not having had the powerful arguments to change their mind, or a feeling of helplessness.

Depends on the topic and how important it is for you.

To PP who thought I’d equated Reform with paedo. I didn’t mention Reform. The example I gave was friend who was a Trumpster and a Brexiter, despite doing no damage as she’s American and couldn’t vote. I just grabbed at a revolting extreme and that’s what came to mind because of stuff in the news yesterday.

Well, to be fair, this is a thread about Reform and you only mentioned the "Trumpster" on a much earlier, entirely separate, post.

"The example I gave was friend who was a Trumpster and a Brexiter, despite doing no damage as she’s American and couldn’t vote."

So now you're likening everyone who votes Republican to paedophiles? You sound very nice indeed and not at all close minded.

bozzabollix · 01/08/2024 08:04

I think people are missing the point somewhat. I’ve got people in my friendship group who don’t vote the same as me or have the same ideas, that’s fine. My best friend however is very similar to me in lots of ways, especially her opinions. We always naturally agree. That’s what makes me closer to her than other friends.

I would be astonished and disappointed if my best mate voted Reform because it’d mean literally everything about her values that we share would have changed. If another friend did it wouldn’t matter in the same way. I think it being the OP’s best friend is the issue here, I’m not sure why people aren’t getting that.

Would be the same for a pair of best mates who are Conservative too.

Lopine · 01/08/2024 08:03

Look, we all have a right to draw our own boundaries and choose who we want to spend time with.

Shampoo66 · 01/08/2024 08:00

Give your head a wobble
everyone is entitled to an opinion, and opinions don’t all ‘conform’ otherwise we’d all be robots
BUT consider the billions spent on illegal immigration, the buckling education and nhs system. Women not safe walking down a street alone… a prime minister who is unable to confirm what a woman is, men taking sport away from girls and women, spaces designated for the safety of women at risk.
This isn’t far right or racist…but it’s what reform are talking about. Maybe your tunnel ‘racist’ vision is the problem. We need more critical thought processes when balancing who we vote for.
Id ask my friend why/how did they make that decision and respect, not necessarily agree with but look at her reasoning. Maybe learn another perspective so your opinion is more balanced. How does it feel on that pedestal?

PriOn1 · 01/08/2024 07:58

As someone traditionally left leaning, I found myself unable to vote Labour, Liberal Democrat, SNP or Green this time round because they had certain policies that I disagreed with so strongly, that I couldn’t bring myself to do it. I didn’t vote Reform, because I think Nigel Farage is a populist charlatan, but I understand people who felt as I did, choosing to do so. I couldn’t bring myself to vote Conservative and so I (reluctantly and sadly) spoiled my ballot paper. I would have much preferred not to do so.

I hang out on Twitter probably more than I should. There are lots of posts from people who seem perfectly reasonable, but have very different politics from me. There are also a number of left wingers who seem to spend their lives obsessing about what other people do, which they consider beyond the pale, such as attending the recent nationalist rallies in London.

People are sick of what’s happening and all the anger and instability, so they are jumping on board things that they wouldn’t have considered before, in the hope that something will change, I think. Perhaps your friend knew that Reform wouldn’t win, and thus felt safe in voting for them, hoping that they might have a restraining influence on the Labour Party, which were almost inevitably going to win. Having read the policies they set out in their manifesto, it didn’t sound too bad on paper.

Similarly, people going on nationalist marches. Again, I am sceptical because of the man who is leading the rise of those protests, but I understand that people want to object and don’t see him as a stumbling block, for whatever reason. They will have rationalized it for themselves, just as I have, but came down on the other side. That doesn’t make them bad people. I absolutely understand the frustration that leads people to take paths that I myself can’t bring myself to take, even if we previously agreed.

When so many, formerly reasonable people are taking actions that we don’t understand, maybe we shouldn’t assume they have suddenly become bad people. More likely the situation has changed and that is driving them to act differently from me. The current situation is so unstable, that it’s difficult to see which direction is the right way to go. It may only become clear over time, which decisions were reasonable and which led to things worsening.

1dayatatime · 01/08/2024 07:56

This thread is a really good example of how polarised and entrenched people have become on their political opinions, with an inability to see the argument from the other side.

It really doesn't bode well for the future.

EasternStandard · 01/08/2024 07:56

tuvamoodyson · 01/08/2024 07:54

No she won’t, this is MN, everyone is ‘too shocked at to say anything at the time’ or hates confrontation…

Maybe expecting the friend to look up to Labour poster voter and op is ok to condemn in return

Veryoldandtired · 01/08/2024 07:56

My BIL & all his family voted reform. I’m an immigrant. I know it has nothing to do with their attitude towards me. Each and every reform voter does it for their own reasons, not always to do with racial hatered. I think the problem with reform is actually baseless and empty promises (akin that famous NHS bus).

clearmoon · 01/08/2024 07:55

Stumped7 · 01/08/2024 07:52

I guess you've not actually read their immigration policy then, and are just making assumptions that it must be nonsensical and racist.

They want to reduce migration to tens of thousands, and then maintain it at net levels. Net levels means not increasing year on year.

I understand the policy, I just don't understand the posts referring to net levels. Thats not what the word net means, that is what I am saying. Or if it does, then it suddenly has a whole new meaning that I have never come across before. That is why I am confused by several posts with the same syntax errors in them.

OP posts:
tuvamoodyson · 01/08/2024 07:54

DoreenonTill8 · 01/08/2024 07:42

But of course she'll have to tell her why!

No she won’t, this is MN, everyone is ‘too shocked at to say anything at the time’ or hates confrontation…

Stumped7 · 01/08/2024 07:52

clearmoon · 01/08/2024 07:44

It doesn't have a meaning, does it? It doesn't seem to make any sense in English, that is why I was asking. Doesn't it mean "overall". What "does maintain at overall levels" mean? I can't understand it.

I guess you've not actually read their immigration policy then, and are just making assumptions that it must be nonsensical and racist.

They want to reduce migration to tens of thousands, and then maintain it at net levels. Net levels means not increasing year on year.

dottiehens · 01/08/2024 07:52

Fair enough move on but why you need to come and open a threat about it? Very obvious you are after something else.

PointsSouth · 01/08/2024 07:52

sesquipedalian · 31/07/2024 23:59

People vote many ways for many reasons. The consensus of opinion at the last election from many people I’ve spoken to seemed to be that the Conservatives deserved to lose, but Labour didn’t deserve to win. To vote for more or less any of the small parties could be seen as a protest vote, in that they were never going to form a government. And if your friend voted Reform because she agrees with their policies, that is her prerogative. You don’t need to fall out about it!

Yeah, you do...

DoreenonTill8 · 01/08/2024 07:52

clearmoon · 01/08/2024 07:45

I've read carefully, and the shock has worn off now. Yes I will think of her a bit differently, but 30 years of close friendship, since out eldests were together in nursery, no, she is still my best friend this morning. I don't intend to return to the subject unless she does though

Ah so you'll just continue to silently, righteously judge her @clearmoon ? Holding her in contempt while thinking she's an ignorant racist, but smiling to her face?
Yep, you're the better person...

PinkTonic · 01/08/2024 07:52

zoemum2006 · 01/08/2024 06:05

I couldn't be friends with someone who lacked critical thinking skills and anyone who votes for a Nigel Farage party (who is such a blatant con artist/ grifter) would no longer have my respect. I don't see how you could be friends with someone you didn't respect.

Whilst you yourself lack the capacity to understand and accept that people have a wide range of reasons for voting as they do and arrogantly hold yourself in superior moral judgment. It’s a very rigid and some would say authoritarian position. 🙂

Tumbleweed101 · 01/08/2024 07:51

Quite a few people ì know voted reform. I'm not sure that they studied their manifesto so much as were using it as a protest vote because they are desperate for something that cons and Labour aren't offering the average person.

EasternStandard · 01/08/2024 07:51

Didimum · 01/08/2024 07:50

Life long Lib Dem voter here (though Labour this time), and your friend needs new friends if you’re going to attempt to judge her politically. You are not superior because you are a liberal, left wing or centrist.

Agree maybe the friend should decide given this thread

Didimum · 01/08/2024 07:50

Life long Lib Dem voter here (though Labour this time), and your friend needs new friends if you’re going to attempt to judge her politically. You are not superior because you are a liberal, left wing or centrist.

AmusedMaker · 01/08/2024 07:49

If she just blurted out randomly that she voted reform ( which your op seems to suggest? )
maybe she’s looking for a way out of the friendship. I mean, why would anyone do that? especially knowing your political beliefs.

Another2Cats · 01/08/2024 07:48

swimsong · 01/08/2024 05:13

No, explain what you think is ironic.

One poster asked the other why she was so righteous. The other then replied with "Righteous?" implying something like "Righteous, what me?" and then went on to give a perfect example of somebody being righteous.

Daysnconfuddled · 01/08/2024 07:48

Yabvu to be so judgey and ignorant.

clearmoon · 01/08/2024 07:45

I've read carefully, and the shock has worn off now. Yes I will think of her a bit differently, but 30 years of close friendship, since out eldests were together in nursery, no, she is still my best friend this morning. I don't intend to return to the subject unless she does though

OP posts:
GentlemanJay · 01/08/2024 07:44

I've seen comments like this on Facebook. "Discovered my best man from my wedding was a Reform voter. Don't want anything more to do with him"

Are people not allowed their own view. What gives anyone the right to think their views are the only legitimate ones. My way or the highway.

ElBandito · 01/08/2024 07:44

Maloneyb · 01/08/2024 06:04

No I think I either explained the point wrong or you misunderstood

she gave no interest in understanding the parties until
her bf came along - it was a “I’ll support them because my dad does” not knowing what she was supporting exactly.. but if you wanna take it as manipulation then that’s on you.. because it wasn’t lol

She's basically just voting the way the (currently) most important man in her life tells her to.

clearmoon · 01/08/2024 07:44

Stumped7 · 01/08/2024 07:40

Erm... Because Reform advocate for maintaining migration at net levels ( at the figure of tens of thousands), rather than it increasing indefinitely.

Also, how can "net levels" be a typo?

It doesn't have a meaning, does it? It doesn't seem to make any sense in English, that is why I was asking. Doesn't it mean "overall". What "does maintain at overall levels" mean? I can't understand it.

OP posts: