Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to be a SAHM

117 replies

Bluepinkgreenyellow · 30/07/2024 13:55

Would you be a SAHM in my position?

I appreciate I am in an extremely fortunate position to be considering this. I'm late 30s and have 2 children under 4, currently on maternity leave. Need to make the decision soon if I don't return to my job. I've been part time after my first child. It was incredibly stressful juggling my LO and job, with a lot of responsibility - there's always more work to be done and it's hard to switch off. I want my kids to be my complete priority, and at the end of my life, I know I would regret not spending time with them, rather than not doing more work. I wouldn't say I enjoy my work - it's just something that needs to be done. I can't think of how adapting what I do would make me enjoy it more.

As for relying on my partner financially, we've spoken about how finances would work if I gave up work and we would pay into a private pension for me etc. If we were to split, I think would be tighter financially but would still be ok.

I want to be a SAHM but I'm also worried about judgement from others. I have achieved a lot in my professional qualifications and career to date, and wonder whether others I meet in the future would look down on me (eg other parents etc).

Is there anything else I'm missing or need to consider? How much do children still need you once they're in primary/secondary school?

You are being unreasonable - you would NOT be a SAHM in my position
You are not being unreasonable - you would be a SAHM in my position

OP posts:
Vettrianofan · 30/07/2024 15:35

I study part time with the OU whilst all four are in school Monday to Friday. So I do have something just for me that fits well within school hours term time.

For those who think SAHMs brains turn to mush🤪

MapleTreeValley · 30/07/2024 15:29

I was a SAHM while my DC were pre schoolers, then went back to work when my youngest started school. I enjoyed being a SAHM, but I have to say that going back (part time) has been really good and I do feel happier and more fulfilled now. @Bluepinkgreenyellow you may find that you underestimate how much you miss work!

VivaLaSpag · 30/07/2024 15:27

ll09sm · 30/07/2024 15:17

If there is one life lesson to be taken from people’s experiences on MN, it is never to give up your career and financial independence to rely on a husband, partner or anyone else. Take after take of women on here who have suffered directly or indirectly by doing this.

It is bad move, OP.

This in spades.

CutthroatDruTheViolent · 30/07/2024 15:18

I know I would regret not spending time with them, rather than not doing more work

See, the way I see this is that if I get to 70 and I've only got the public pension - and maybe I'm missing years from that - like my mum has, I'll be fucked. I don't want to spend my sundown years scrabbling around, not being able to spend the way I want and go where I want because I've got no money. Just a couple of years out can have enormous implications for that.

I mean it's obviously entirely up to you, but as someone who now has teenage children, two of whom were in nursery and one who never went to any childcare setting until school - they don't remember and it really makes no difference so long as they're loved and well looked after. The early years are hard, but I'm now in a senior enough position that I can WFH the whole summer and arrange my work around doing stuff with them (well, within reason!).

ll09sm · 30/07/2024 15:17

If there is one life lesson to be taken from people’s experiences on MN, it is never to give up your career and financial independence to rely on a husband, partner or anyone else. Take after take of women on here who have suffered directly or indirectly by doing this.

It is bad move, OP.

savethatkitty · 30/07/2024 15:11

Bluepinkgreenyellow · 30/07/2024 14:08

It'd be hard but not impossible. Would require a period of working for free to get recent relevant experience.

Why did you decide to go back to work?

Edited

The kids were in school, so it seemed like the right "time". I felt i had too much idle time & a bit lazy. My retired dad also offered to collect the kids from school & bring them home until either I or DH got home, so that made it easier to go back.

It's funny, as after working full-time for several years, I'm now back to being a 'SAHM' (temporarily living overseas, work visa not permitted) & the children are even older, almost finished school, so it's odd. It's taken time to get used to.

At the end of the day, do what is right for your family.

Bluepinkgreenyellow · 30/07/2024 15:08

BagJennyUp · 30/07/2024 15:03

@Bluepinkgreenyellow look I will be completely honest, when people both work full time they make it work but you only have to look on here to see how many people are tired, stressed, juggling everything. As a sahm Dh and I felt like we didn't have that. I did work after Ds1 was born so I have juggled work and nursery drop off and pick ups, illness, asking to leave work and then oh it's chicken pox so Dh and I juggled our working days round it.

As a sahm - primary, no rushing from work to get to them, school runs are easy. You have time between picking them up and before dinner to help them learn to read and do their spellings. I did all housework in school hours so I was completely available for the children after school. I batch cooked, used a slow cooker, menu planned and was very organised. No juggling the inevitable half term week or the total 13 weeks of holiday that they have from school. Plus Dh could work slightly late if a meeting ran over, no dashing off to collect children, no having to leave half way through the morning for sick cover.

Secondary, they still need you just in a different way. I was able to oversee homework, guide them to good resources etc. Yes, I know working parents will say the same and Dh was the person to turn to for some subjects and he worked. My youngest is now 18 and academically they both excelled. Dh still says it is the best thing we ever did I think partly because he has never really had to do housework and to be honest who blames him? Grin

Thanks for this. These are the benefits that I imagined we would have. My mum also stayed at home with us, and spent so much time helping with school work/extracurriculars etc.

My limited experience with juggling just one child and work was extremely stressful, especially with a boss who cannot understand what it is like to have a child.

OP posts:
Peonies12 · 30/07/2024 15:06

Who cares if others judge you. But I wondered, is there any middle ground like you and your partner both go part time? I don't think it's fair it tends to be mums who sacrifice their careers. I personally wouldn't want to put all that pressure on my DH in being the sole earner, so I'd make sure you get necessary income protection in case he couldn't work. And consider if you buy a property or move property, it will limit your borrowing power, as you'll be a dependent. And keep checking in with each other about it - you don't want your partner to resent being the sole earner, equally, you have every right to try it and dislike it, and want another set up. I've seen friends relationships fail when they haven't done this, and resentment has grown.

Vettrianofan · 30/07/2024 15:05

Been one for 17 years, and do not regret it one moment. Got 4 DC and each one has needed me in different ways. Two have disabilities which come before a job. Their needs are paramount.

Crack on OP. Don't worry about the rest of society and what they think. It's your life, make the best of it with your family.

BagJennyUp · 30/07/2024 15:03

@Bluepinkgreenyellow look I will be completely honest, when people both work full time they make it work but you only have to look on here to see how many people are tired, stressed, juggling everything. As a sahm Dh and I felt like we didn't have that. I did work after Ds1 was born so I have juggled work and nursery drop off and pick ups, illness, asking to leave work and then oh it's chicken pox so Dh and I juggled our working days round it.

As a sahm - primary, no rushing from work to get to them, school runs are easy. You have time between picking them up and before dinner to help them learn to read and do their spellings. I did all housework in school hours so I was completely available for the children after school. I batch cooked, used a slow cooker, menu planned and was very organised. No juggling the inevitable half term week or the total 13 weeks of holiday that they have from school. Plus Dh could work slightly late if a meeting ran over, no dashing off to collect children, no having to leave half way through the morning for sick cover.

Secondary, they still need you just in a different way. I was able to oversee homework, guide them to good resources etc. Yes, I know working parents will say the same and Dh was the person to turn to for some subjects and he worked. My youngest is now 18 and academically they both excelled. Dh still says it is the best thing we ever did I think partly because he has never really had to do housework and to be honest who blames him? Grin

KintheCottage · 30/07/2024 15:01

Do what you want, it is your life and nobody else’s. I’m a SAHM, I have a degree and a good career but I always knew as soon as I had DC I’d give that up until they started school. I don’t regret it for a second and I will definitely be able to get back into my career in a few years when I want to go back. As long as you’ve thought through the logistics and know the pros and cons then go for what makes you happy.

MoosakaWithFries · 30/07/2024 15:01

What are your part time hours OP?

Is your DHs job well paid and safe?

Due to circumstances I was a SAHM. Financially it just gets tighter as the DC get older. My EXDH also felt the responsibility of financially supporting us quite a strain at times.

If I was you I'd speak with work and see what flexibility there is for you. Climbing back on the ladder post 40 is hard work. I had a divorce in the mix too which added more financial difficulties. Taking that time out has set me back probably 10 years in my career development and earning potential...I could have really done with that at times.

I think it's also what you want to provide for your DC as they grow older, for example a family holiday/driving lessons/university support because that's where I am now and it's bloody expensive.

As for the time you will miss when you're at work - they will be busy elsewhere and will love you no less.

Also, if I think about my DCs peers - there seems no difference between those who has a DM around full time and those that didn't...apart from those who had a DM that worked appear to be more financially stable.

samunthesea · 30/07/2024 15:00

I am a sahm and I'm very happy. No plans to return to work and I'm financially independent to not ever need to.

People do judge you and not everyone copes well with that, they like to have a status and their tribe. Being a sahm is quite rare these days and if you live somewhere without a larger number you have to be comfortable in your own company and choices.

I've protected myself well as I have my own unearned income and built up assets though investing so a marriage split wouldn't financially impact me. That was partly though luck and partly having a high risk profile.

blackcherryconserve · 30/07/2024 14:58

Panicmode1 · 30/07/2024 14:10

I gave up my professional career and became a SAHM when I had my fourth child. I returned to work when they were all in primary school, albeit very part time in poorly paid local roles - DH by then was earning significantly into 6 figures so we could afford for me to work 9-2 in much lower paid jobs than I was used to.

I absolutely loved being at home and haven't regretted it for a second - until recently, when DH has been effectively made redundant in a sector where there are very limited opportunities for someone of his seniority and age....so I am now going back into a full time job, earning about a third of what I was earning when I left my professional career 14 years ago, and praying that he finds something else.

If you do become a SAHM (and only you know whether this works for you and your family - ignore the judgement and noise that will come), then ensure you have a good pension, that you keep your skills up to date and ensure you have a good financial cushion if things don't go quite according to plan...!

Having 4 children I would have opted to be a sham. Luckily I only had 2 and returned to my career.

Whenwillitgetwarm · 30/07/2024 14:57

OP, what anyone else thinks is of no consequence. It’s your life.

I don’t think most people do judge SAHM negatively on the whole.

Nevertheless, I personally roll my eyes at SAHM whose idea it was to stay at home, partly because they hated their admin job, knowing their DH wasn’t massively keen but went along with it to keep her happy. Years later when either partner is no longer happy with the situation, history is rewritten as ‘we agreed together/he wanted me to stay at home/I gave up my big career to facilitate his’ etc etc.

I know a couple of women like this and they forget some people remember how it all started off.

Bluepinkgreenyellow · 30/07/2024 14:52

Grumpy12345 · 30/07/2024 14:48

Could you and your DH both both go part-time so you share the childcare and paid work between you? That way you share the “risk” so to speak of one of you struggling to go back to work when the kids go to school or if you split up

That's a good idea, but his earnings now and in the future are much higher.

OP posts:
GingerPirate · 30/07/2024 14:50

You have to consider the practical points very carefully and yours and your children's financial safety.
I have been a stay at home wife for 20+ years, very fortunate, my husband pays into my pension etc.
No kids.
Think about it and if satisfactory, go for it.

Bluepinkgreenyellow · 30/07/2024 14:49

BagJennyUp · 30/07/2024 14:41

@Bluepinkgreenyellow I think the best advice I can give is a whole relationship one, for us we are the priority, mine and Dh's relationship. We are a team, if one of us is tired we tap out, the other one takes over. We treat each other like we have only been dating 6 months instead of almost 30 years. Phones down, look at each other, talk and not just about the children.

I think checking in and asking each other is there anything I can do that would make your life easier? Finances were fine for us as we know each other's spending habits so could trust each other.

For everyone who says you could split up well that also happens to people who work full time or part time too. I am sure if you were to split then you could find another job. I am friends with one other long term sahm, everyone else went back to work at some point. It can be lonely, it is certainly repetitive days but it depends how well you can deal with that over and over and over again.

Thank you - that's also really helpful re the relationship, which has taken a backseat these last few years.

I'm really happy that it's worked so well for you - gives me a lot of hope!

Can I ask you about the school years - how much did they need you in primary and secondary school?

OP posts:
Grumpy12345 · 30/07/2024 14:48

Could you and your DH both both go part-time so you share the childcare and paid work between you? That way you share the “risk” so to speak of one of you struggling to go back to work when the kids go to school or if you split up

Appleblum · 30/07/2024 14:48

BagJennyUp · 30/07/2024 14:24

As a very long term sahm this comes down to a few things and the main one being the expectation and attitude of your Dh and trust me I have seen other husbands go completely hands off re housework and child rearing leaving everything to the wife.

To protect yourself, keep any skills up to date if you can.
Pay into a separate pension pot for yourself.
Make sure you have full access to finances
Joint decision making about spending "family" money
Housework and expectations surrounding that.
Don't put yourself last, if you need clothes, hair cut, shoes, you should be able to buy them.

Dh had a lie in every Saturday, I had one every Sunday. He spent time on his own with both children to build an incredible relationship with them. We also did one on one time with each child, so if he had to go to the shops he would take a child with him.

Finances are the big one and this puts a lot of pressure on your Dh to be the sole earner so my advice is to check in to make sure everyone is happy. As to what anyone else thinks, fuck them, they are not living your life. It is the best decision we ever made, very low stress levels for us over the past 20 years.

This.

It doesn't matter what anyone else thinks. What really matters is what you and your husband think. If your husband really values the role of a sahm then you'll find that your family life is generally happy and low stress and everyone feels fulfilled.

My kids are primary school aged now and in some ways I feel like they need me more. Of course you no longer have to feed them, bring them toileting, etc, but you need to help them with homework and navigating friendships, and bringing them to all their extra curriculars, etc. I know you can still do these things as a working mom but for me I look forward to picking them up after school, and they still run towards me and are bursting to tell me about their day. No job is going to make me give that up just yet.

Newmumatlast · 30/07/2024 14:48

Don't worry about others, do what is right for you. Fwiw I seem to get more judgement than my sahm friends do for being a working parent who has a high level job so at times work away. It depends on circumstances and the circles you're in I think

aCatCalledFawkes · 30/07/2024 14:46

As everyone else says its up to you.
Although I do think though there is a lot to be said for decent well paid part time jobs which can be like gold dust to find so I would definitely consider that and what coming back to work would look like if you wanted to or needed too.

I was made redundant from my part time role in 2020 and had to go back to full time again in a new role. Thankfully it was covid times, wfh full time was a thing and my youngest was on the cusp of finishing primary school so it was manageable. I'm not sure what it would of have done if I had had to of gone full time earlier and now I'm really glad I stuck at the part time roles as they have all got me in to a job I love and pays enough I can support myself and my children (single parent).

Whenwillitgetwarm · 30/07/2024 14:42

Potatosaladisnice · 30/07/2024 14:26

You do what's right for you. It doesn't matter what others think.

I know one SAHM and don't think any less of her, she did what she felt was right for her family. On the other hand, she feels that working parents are inferior to her or at least it comes across like that.

By feeling superior to ‘working parents’ she means ‘mothers’ doesn’t she? I’m sure she sees no problem with her DH working.

BagJennyUp · 30/07/2024 14:41

@Bluepinkgreenyellow I think the best advice I can give is a whole relationship one, for us we are the priority, mine and Dh's relationship. We are a team, if one of us is tired we tap out, the other one takes over. We treat each other like we have only been dating 6 months instead of almost 30 years. Phones down, look at each other, talk and not just about the children.

I think checking in and asking each other is there anything I can do that would make your life easier? Finances were fine for us as we know each other's spending habits so could trust each other.

For everyone who says you could split up well that also happens to people who work full time or part time too. I am sure if you were to split then you could find another job. I am friends with one other long term sahm, everyone else went back to work at some point. It can be lonely, it is certainly repetitive days but it depends how well you can deal with that over and over and over again.

Bluepinkgreenyellow · 30/07/2024 14:35

IceCream889 · 30/07/2024 14:24

It's not about what other people think but about what is sensible. It's actually harder to juggle work when they're at primary school. And it will be harder and harder for you to juggle everything and find a job, you won't have any flexibility because you'll have to prove yourself all over again at a time when kids are very demanding, so you'll postpone etc. Many women find themselves in that position and regretting it.

You work.part time already which already gives you a lot of balance. I'd stick to that.

Thanks - could you expand on why it's harder to juggle work when they're at primary school? Is it because of school holidays and pick ups at 3pm (as opposed to later nursery pick ups)?
The balance at the moment is not great, and I'm not sure how I'd be able to continue with a second child in the mix. And while the extra money is great, we can cope without...

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread