Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Choosing Between Egypt in August or India in November—Need Advice for Our Family Trip!

85 replies

flawless29 · 29/07/2024 20:56

We are planning a holiday—my partner, our 18-month-old son, and I. It will be our first trip since I was pregnant. I’ve gone through numerous brochures and read lots of online reviews. We’ve stumbled upon a fantastic deal in Sharm El-Sheikh, Egypt that looks incredible and has good reviews, all at a reasonable price. However, I’m a bit worried about the heat in August being too intense for my son. Additionally, I’ve read a few posts online about harassment towards women, which adds to my concerns. We’re torn between visiting Egypt in August or perhaps waiting to travel to India in November. Is India a far better for young family ? Could anyone share their experiences or advice on which might be a better option? Thanks in advance!

OP posts:
Menopausalcraziness · 30/07/2024 09:20

flawless29 · 29/07/2024 22:38

I know it might seem like an odd choice, but we’ve visited several destinations like the Canary Islands and various places in Europe. This time, however, we want something a bit more exotic, so we’re considering a holiday in Asia or perhaps Egypt.

There are so many other places to visit in the world. Doing anything cultural with a toddler will be challenging - whilst you would like it, a toddler wants to play and explore, which isn’t feasible in places such as temples, deserts or jungles.
Have you considered the Caribbean? The weather is perfect in November (start of dry season), places such as Barbados offer all meal boards, not just all inclusive. So much to do and see that won’t restrict you with your son but also enable him to be a bit more involved.

Lmnop22 · 30/07/2024 09:12

flawless29 · 29/07/2024 22:38

I know it might seem like an odd choice, but we’ve visited several destinations like the Canary Islands and various places in Europe. This time, however, we want something a bit more exotic, so we’re considering a holiday in Asia or perhaps Egypt.

Have you considered Japan? It’s a bit easier to get around with road safety/public transport and less hot if you go near the coast but still exotic and in Asia. Its also a little less chaotic than Egypt/India

backinthebox · 30/07/2024 06:21

We didn’t get D&V in India. I work there 2-3 times a year and have a pretty robust digestive system. But we did have to call an emergency doctor in Delhi for DH when we travelled round Rajasthan for a lung infection so severe he needed antibiotics and we came home early. This was in the November (it was also consistently above 30C then too.) Indian cities are famous for their low air quality. We are often advised at work not to leave the hotel and to keep windows closed and aircon on.

We’d arrived in Delhi on a late evening flight and used an official airport taxi to take us to our pre booked hotel, but the driver took us to ‘a better hotel’ he knew and then argued with us when we wouldn’t go in. We eventually got to our booked hotel, but it was our first taste of being treated like idiot tourists, a theme which continued through the trip. We’d used a phone shop (this was about 20 years ago) to call to change our flights when it became clear we would have to go home early because DH was getting quite ill, and were charged over £100 to make the call from Agra to Delhi. The boy working in the phone shop was quite shameless in admitting he had placed a couple of zeros on the end of the price because European tourists are rich and normally pay whatever he tells them it is.

My other memory of travelling round the Golden Triangle is just how long it took to drive between stops. Eg it’s about 6 hours drive from Jaipur to Jodhpur. Endless driving to get from place to place. I remember it as a trip of fascinating places, but also one which was quite hard work. We went with a reputable tour company and had a driver and guide for the duration, but even a great guide cannot mitigate the pollution, the traffic jams, the kids who follow you everywhere and shout insults at you when you won’t give them cash, the rubbish in the street. The time I spend in India now is just quick dashes in and out, only 1-2 nights at a time, but there’s nothing I see which makes me think it’s a better place now than 20 years ago. I stay in good quality hotels but it’s still dirty, noisy and busier than you can imagine outside the gates, and I’ve been taken back to the wrong hotel again since, and had more than a few tuk tuk rides that feel like being in my own stunt sequence!

It’s definitely a place that will make you sit up and take notice, and the history is fascinating (but be prepared to feel distinctly uncomfortable at some of the descriptions of the British in some places,) but would I go with a baby? Not a cat in hell’s chance. But if the OP is one of those people who really want to push the boat out in terms of exotic, fill your boots, I don’t think you are listening to anyone here anyway.

And Sharm in August? What the heck for? Its main charm (if you could describe anything at all about the place as charming) is the excellent scuba diving. Which is fun when you are 18 months old. Otherwise it’s just a very very very hot dry place.

LiquoriceAllsorts2 · 30/07/2024 06:11

How about Egypt in November? That will be a better temperature.

MissScarletInTheBallroom · 30/07/2024 06:09

Pomegranatemum · 29/07/2024 21:12

I went to India 3 times between 2007-2015. Granted that’s a while ago now, but on the basis of my experiences there I definitely would not take my young DC there.
If you’re after South Asia though, have you considered Sri Lanka?

This. Sri Lanka is much more toddler friendly.

Howtoeatanelephant · 30/07/2024 06:03

What is it with non-aibu topics in the aibu thread at the moment?
But as you are here, why take an 18 month old on a long-haul holiday anyway? It won't remember, and it will be hard work for you

knitnerd90 · 30/07/2024 02:43

Definitely not Sharm, it's not the greatest in general, and in August you couldn't pay me enough. I can handle Israeli summer in general but I wouldn't be taking a trip to Eilat (as a point of comparison with similar weather)

India: I think the amount of internal travel would be an issue for a toddler, and I believe November is when they burn the fields in Punjab and UP to get rid of stubble and prepare them for the winter crops. It turns air quality in north India (never amazing) to absolute shite.

Sri Lanka would have loads to see and be easier on a small child.

samedifferent · 30/07/2024 02:27

The Golden Triangle is fantastic.

It's a lot of distance to travel.
We were advised to take Malaria tablets that couldn't be taken under 8 years old.
The attractions won't be of any interest to your dc.
Goa maybe or Sri Lanka?

Safi7 · 30/07/2024 01:53

Sorry, just saw your post - if you want to do a Golden Triangle Tour in Northern India - great, but I don’t know why you’d bother at this time with an 18 month old. It will be a lot of time in crowds at the sites, a lot if time in coaches and transferring between hotels - your toddler would not get much out if it. Honestly, kids that age only notice a swimming pool and a mini playground or stuff like that. The history and sights of Jaipur - incredible though they are - are best left until your child is a bit older. My DH is British Indian and we didn’t take our kids over there as babies / toddlers. Just the thought of it is exhausting. Any city tours anywhere would be.

WhatADifferenceACatMakes · 30/07/2024 01:39

This reply has been withdrawn

Withdrawn at OP's request.

Safi7 · 30/07/2024 01:14

OP, why do you think Sharm is going to be cheap in August? Because the heat will be unbearable. Also, it’s not far from Gaza - would you really feel comfortable sunbathing and helping yourself from the buffet, given what’s going on over the border? Nobody is going anywhere near there - that’s why it’s cheap!

You won’t get hassle from men in the hotels, but you won’t be going out of the hotel anyway unless it’s an organised tour because a) it will be about 40 degrees and b) it is desert and there’s nothing there except for all inclusive hotels. Hotels will have security scanners on entry.

The main trip people do there is in the evening when they go into the desert for star gazing, baking bread under the sand, camel riding. That’s about it, Not ideal with a baby,

When you say India - where in India?

BlueBellsArePretty · 30/07/2024 00:47

Goa or Kerala would be nice places for a family holiday. Agree with others about the stereotyping, never got any d&v when I was there. Food was great and there was different cuisines available, Italian appeared to be very popular amongst Indians. Worst case you eat dhal and chappatis.

BikesIHaveLost · 30/07/2024 00:39

I adore virtually every part of India I’ve ever been to, but have never taken my fussy-about-food child there. It just would have been an endless trial feeding him. I always take time to acclimatise, even in the days when I was coming from somewhere else hot and crowded. Friends who moved to Delhi for work say their two year old lived on almost nothing but naan and plain yoghurt for months.

I’m also puzzled as to why you’re contemplating two holidays at pretty much opposite poles of holidaying? Do you have any idea what either is like?

onesmallstepforman · 30/07/2024 00:22

Definitely not Egypt in August. Way too hot. Are you planning to go to Sinai or more in land to visit cities and archeological sites? But even on the beach in August is totally unbearable.

RM2013 · 30/07/2024 00:13

Personally I wouldn’t do either with an 18 month old. Egypt will be unbearably hot with India not far behind. I haven’t visited personally but my parents visit Goa every year and keep going back to the same place as they love it

wasthesummerof69 · 30/07/2024 00:04

Go to the far east in November - maybe a Malaysian Island like Penang or Langkawi. Very child friendly and a more pleasant temperature than Egypt in August and easier to travel with a toddler than India. Or the Caribbean, Mexico?

salcombebabe · 29/07/2024 23:40

I’ve been to Egypt in August and it was 50degs! I wouldn’t recommend taking such a young child there at that time of the year. How about Cyprus?

Onelifeonly22 · 29/07/2024 23:17

The main cities in India are really, really polluted in Nov/Dec due to Diwali (I think mid Nov). I wouldn’t go at that time of year. Also don’t think it is a relaxing choice with a baby.

Etoile12345 · 29/07/2024 23:12

Casual observation but there seems to be a bit of stereotyping here with some uncomfortable undertones. Been to India twice, not had any stomach upsets or found anything dubious about the food hygiene. This was travelling around too . . . . I was there with a two year old and I would say it was child friendly. That said doing anything cultural with a toddler is probably more hassle than it's worth so I would wait until they are a bit older and they might appreciate it more - I mean that for anywhere, not being specific about India. If you wanted somewhere with some culture and nice beaches/ancient towns or ruins etc, maybe look at some of the Greek Islands (Crete/Rhodes etc) or Italy. Puglia has some lovely beaches and old towns too. That said, South Goa is gorgeous! Happy holidays OP and good luck with the research.

Ponoka7 · 29/07/2024 23:10

I agree with everything that's being said. Morocco would be better than Eygpt. Both means constant harrasment, unless you are linking your partner. Do your research before you go so you both know how to handle things. November would be a good month. Goa would be fine, anywhere else not with an eighteen month old who would go down hill fast if struck down with gastroenteritis etc.

Puppyyikes · 29/07/2024 23:05

How about somewhere like Goa or Kerala? You could do cultural stuff but also find a nice hotel with a big pool for the toddler? Theres not a great deal to see in Delhi tbh, and the Taj Mahal will probably bore the life out of your toddler. Or, Sri Lanka? Again, there’s culture + beach/ hotel with pool. Google if these places have malaria though- I’m not sure.

PurpleMat · 29/07/2024 23:01

Any holiday with an 18month old will be awful. Same shit different location. Just accept it and go somewhere close and easy. Our holidays were to the grandparents houses at that age, then you can hand over the DC and get a break!

Scirocco · 29/07/2024 23:00

Neither with a toddler!

August heat in Egypt will be way too hot for him to be comfortable, so you'll be limited to air conditioned places and he'll be bored and cranky. Egypt is beautiful, but maybe best when he's older and not in August.

I haven't much experience of India, but people I know who have been there have often reported GI upsets, and those were adults with decent hand hygiene. Toddler D+V can ruin a holiday for everyone, especially if they get dehydrated, which can happen easily anyway in hot countries.

Both would be amazing experiences when he's older.

Puravida23 · 29/07/2024 22:59

Agree with all the comments . Both have obvious negatives . Egypt I have been in August and it was insanely hot . The only place I have got sunstroke . Really would not take an 18month old or myself there again
India is another hard work choice. Only been to Kerala , incredible poverty and dubious food hygiene. I felt like I was playing food roulette with each meal. In saying that I would go back to India and we are planning to but keep putting it off partly I think because of the risk of getting sick but I think it looks an amazing country. Just maybe not with a 18 month old who will be putting everything in its mouth
i would look at somewhere like Thailand, Vietnam, Cambodia if you want an exotic but family friendly holiday

Femme2804 · 29/07/2024 22:59

Go to indonesia. Its very child friendly there. India its not good. I’m sorry but i cant stand the smell and its not very kids friendly. Egypt in august its too hot.

Swipe left for the next trending thread