Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I would swap with her in an instant

560 replies

Cookiecrumblane · 28/07/2024 01:21

I am a sort of clever woman, financially secure, good at what I do. I have lots of friends and family around me, despite being single.
Today I met a woman through a friend, ten years younger than me. She was upset at losing her job last month, she had tried but made a serious of errors and was eventually sacked.
Even as she cried, she looked beautiful. She told me about her various problems, not being able to pay rent, her debt, her self esteem.
And I thought how much I would love to be that pretty. She was distraught, but even with all that was going on, she was served first and efficiently in the bar. Men held doors and beamed at her. They crossed the street to walk closer to her.
I have never had that. And so what good is education, my job, my success. Because ultimately she'll end up ok. She is more likely to get a job and when she does people will praise what she does much more than they praise people who look like me.
Is that mad? That I would swap with her in an instant, even to be jobless and at risk of losing my flat, just to feel visible?
I'm sure men don't feel this way.

OP posts:
IpsyUpsyDaisyDoos · 29/07/2024 18:07

EnjoythemoneyJane · 29/07/2024 18:01

Love how you’ve so neatly unpacked the jobs you think a ‘pretty’ woman might be good for (menial) and that the pinnacle of them all is ‘model’. Guessing the shadowy ‘boss’ isn’t one of them, or even female at all? 😂

Most entry level jobs now will include a requirement of the skills mentioned by the PP, typing is a big part of many jobs nowadays, even manual trades need to do risk assessments, reports etc. Most places have a phone. The aforementioned assessments and reports have to be kept somewhere.

And the model comment I believe was in response to how many women are actually considered "beautiful" enough to meet that criteria.

Pantaloons99 · 29/07/2024 18:04

I used to actually think this way in my 20s. I had quite a traumatic upbringing and clearly had a multitude of issues which years of counselling has helped me understand.

I used to be so jealous of Marilyn Monroe's beauty. Why would someone so beautiful take their life?

Because it means absolutely jack that's why! It is actually so liberating and wonderful to be a little bit invisible. I currently have the most horrific health problems. My quality of life is so poor. I've lost almost everything including the ability to care for my own child now. So I am alone all day in severe pain, unable to move properly and out of treatment options.

Do I now see how ridiculous this way of thinking I had when young really was. Yes. Unfortunately, it sometimes takes an obscene amount of severe suffering to appreciate what really matters.

EnjoythemoneyJane · 29/07/2024 18:01

DreamTheMoors · 28/07/2024 01:45

What in god’s name makes you think pretty girls have it easier than anybody else?
They may get a foot in the door, but when the boss finds out they can’t type or file or answer the phone or add or use the copier?
They’re out.
Only 2% of pretty girls are models. And only 2% of those make it big.
And beauty is only skin deep. And it fades fast. Intelligence lasts a lifetime.
You should be happy that you’re you.
The grass is never ever greener.

Love how you’ve so neatly unpacked the jobs you think a ‘pretty’ woman might be good for (menial) and that the pinnacle of them all is ‘model’. Guessing the shadowy ‘boss’ isn’t one of them, or even female at all? 😂

CatNoBag · 29/07/2024 18:01

I know someone a bit like this. She’s intelligent, but completely lacking in common sense and brings chaos everywhere she goes, which everyone puts up with because that’s how she is and of course she’s very beautiful. She’s had some amazing jobs that she blags her way through doing the bare minimum. I’ve tolerated her because it rarely causes me a huge inconvenience, I’m pretty laid back and she’s an in-law so not really up to me, but there have been a string of events recently where I just can’t get over my annoyance so I’m finally drawing a line in the sand. She’ll probably barely notice (despite the fact I’ve actually made excuses and stood up for her many times to my DH), but I think beauty only gets you so far, eventually people are annoyed/disappointed enough to have had enough (+ age catches up with all of us eventually!)

XChrome · 29/07/2024 18:00

SerafinasGoose · 29/07/2024 09:48

The 'bizarre and backward' arguments you refer to are people merely pointing out that no one has life entirely as they want it, and if our society values superficial looks over all else we don't have to buy into the BS. We can focus on something that actually matters. In the shallow, vapid values of our shallow, vapid culture, beauty only equates with youth in any case. And youth isn't a matter of privilege. We all get the same share of it.

If you're fretting and envious over others' perceived beauty (remember this is mostly in the eye of the beholder), be comforted by the fact that when we hit late middle-age our looks are going to fade. At this point, at least, superficially we are equal.

We grow older if we are lucky. Old age is, indeed, very much a privilege; one not everybody is fortunate enough to experience.

Edited

Yes, and if you buy into those superficial values, aging is much more stressful. For a woman who has traded on her looks all her life and mostly ignored character development, I'm sure it's quite devastating. Hence the popularity of cosmetic surgery, Botox, etcetera.

wasdarknowblond · 29/07/2024 18:00

Someone told me a long time ago that more tears run down a pretty face than a plain one. I can vouch for that as I was young, pretty, naive and got exploited by men up to the hilt. I would love to have had what you have - get a bit of therapy!

cremebrulait · 29/07/2024 17:57

I worked with someone that all the guys swooned at. She was tall and attractive but I didn’t get why even the married guys were paying her too much attention. She had a charming accent. She had help handed to her. She needed to be hand-held but keeps moving up. Married young to a guy with an amazing job. It all looks good on paper. Everyone seems to fall all over themselves. But when I was her line manager I noticed that she wore lots of bracelets to cover a lot of scars on her wrists. I knew she frequently vomited after eating. i also know her family put insane pressure on her.
You never know what goes on behind closed doors. I’m sure it feels like the girl you met has it easy. Have you ever met someone that was beautiful and didn’t age so gracefully or was disfigured? You never know what you’re wishing for OP.

XChrome · 29/07/2024 17:55

Sethera · 29/07/2024 12:37

I'm afraid ugly women get harassed too - only it takes the form of being called 'ugly' in the street by complete strangers, having howling/barking dog noises made at you; being used as banter by men to their mates - 'that one's yours" etc.

I've never, obviously, been on the other side but although neither is ideal, I think I would prefer a man stopping me in the street to tell me I was beautiful, than to tell me how ugly I am.

True. Otoh, if you are average looking you probably still get harassed, just not as much as pretty or ugly women. None of us escape male aggression unfortunately.

urbanbuddha · 29/07/2024 17:54

That's wild! You would rather not have control over your life just to look 'pretty' 🤔 why don't you try to improve you, lots of beauty treatments, that you could afford out there. What is it that you don't like about yourself?

Yeh, under 30 you have the looks you were born with, over 30 you can make use of all kind of support.
Best start with the answer to the question, “Why does it bother you so much?” The kind of men who make these judgments are generally very boring. At best.

fireworkkinder · 29/07/2024 17:54

As someone on the “other side” of this, I find some of the comments on here really unfair. I have always been pretty, not beautiful, stunning or drop dead gorgeous but I have been told I have “pretty privilege”. It’s infuriating to be seen as only getting a decent job, promotions and praise because of my looks. I have been the centre of office gossip for having affairs with my male managers because they see how good I am at my job, driven and hard working I am, yet my counterparts who don’t take as much care with their appearance and receive the same promotions and praise, are never the subject of these rumours/gossip. I am bloody clever!

whittingtonmum · 29/07/2024 17:46

I think the way to look at it is that if you're average looking or on the conventionally slightly unattractive side you know that everything you have achieved is 100% down to your own ability and hard work and you can be proud of that. I always thought that I didn't want to swap places with those friends who clearly got career advantages (bestowed on them by men) because of their above average looks. I personally would hate that. I never felt ugly though - just not stunning - maybe that's the difference. Note to all of us to do our bit wherever we are to try and question this bias because it doesn't do anyone any favours and maybe we can start changing these superficial attitudes.

Piwi1625 · 29/07/2024 17:44

Cookiecrumblane · 28/07/2024 01:21

I am a sort of clever woman, financially secure, good at what I do. I have lots of friends and family around me, despite being single.
Today I met a woman through a friend, ten years younger than me. She was upset at losing her job last month, she had tried but made a serious of errors and was eventually sacked.
Even as she cried, she looked beautiful. She told me about her various problems, not being able to pay rent, her debt, her self esteem.
And I thought how much I would love to be that pretty. She was distraught, but even with all that was going on, she was served first and efficiently in the bar. Men held doors and beamed at her. They crossed the street to walk closer to her.
I have never had that. And so what good is education, my job, my success. Because ultimately she'll end up ok. She is more likely to get a job and when she does people will praise what she does much more than they praise people who look like me.
Is that mad? That I would swap with her in an instant, even to be jobless and at risk of losing my flat, just to feel visible?
I'm sure men don't feel this way.

That's wild! You would rather not have control over your life just to look 'pretty' 🤔 why don't you try to improve you, lots of beauty treatments, that you could afford out there. What is it that you don't like about yourself?

Sethera · 29/07/2024 12:37

I'm afraid ugly women get harassed too - only it takes the form of being called 'ugly' in the street by complete strangers, having howling/barking dog noises made at you; being used as banter by men to their mates - 'that one's yours" etc.

I've never, obviously, been on the other side but although neither is ideal, I think I would prefer a man stopping me in the street to tell me I was beautiful, than to tell me how ugly I am.

DysonSphere · 29/07/2024 10:48

SerafinasGoose · 29/07/2024 09:48

The 'bizarre and backward' arguments you refer to are people merely pointing out that no one has life entirely as they want it, and if our society values superficial looks over all else we don't have to buy into the BS. We can focus on something that actually matters. In the shallow, vapid values of our shallow, vapid culture, beauty only equates with youth in any case. And youth isn't a matter of privilege. We all get the same share of it.

If you're fretting and envious over others' perceived beauty (remember this is mostly in the eye of the beholder), be comforted by the fact that when we hit late middle-age our looks are going to fade. At this point, at least, superficially we are equal.

We grow older if we are lucky. Old age is, indeed, very much a privilege; one not everybody is fortunate enough to experience.

Edited

I almost think people are desperate to convince themselves that beauty always fades in order to feel better that they themselves are not beautiful.

For some women even if it fades slightly, they will still be beautiful in comparison to their peers of the same age or even women a decade or so younger. And some remain beautiful right into their sixties and seventies. I saw a woman like that on Instagram the other day. A grandmother with an absolutely incredible fine boned facial structure. The wrinkles detracted very little and you could see immediately she must have been incredibly beautiful as a youth. Her mid aged daughter was pretty but not so dazzling (as an aside have you noticed the impartiality of nature? Often the children of great beauties aren't particularly stunning in comparison. But two averagely looking people can have beautiful children so the next generation might win in the pretty genes stakes).

Some people are beautiful. They're lucky and they didn't earn it. Such is life. Some of us have all our working parts physically and some are born without some of them. Do we tell ourselves that our lives are perfectly peachy just because we have the fortune to be born physically more or less sound? Or do we acknowledge that we may have a physical advantage but it is tempered by other factors in life?

What the OP is wrongly concluding is that this metric defines above all else a person's life success and emotional wellbeing based on such fluffy and inconsequential rubrics as men paying more attention to her pretty 'friend'

ArcaneSquiggle · 29/07/2024 09:55

FredericC · 29/07/2024 09:20

You met her for the first time today, and in that short span of time you managed to witness her being served first at the bar (more than once to prove it wasn't a fluke), men crossing the street to be nearer to her (somehow you knew their intentions), men holding doors open for her (when people actually hold doors open for one another all the time)?

Sorry OP, smells a bit fishy to me...

And if it's not fishy, if all of this happened repeatedly in such a short space of time it would suggest that unwanted attention and intimidating behaviour from men is relentless in this woman's life. Even when she's so distressed that she's crying to a stranger in public.

Doesn't sound much like a blessing, to be honest. Constantly being objectified to that extent isn't flattering, it's exhausting.

SerafinasGoose · 29/07/2024 09:48

shuggles · 29/07/2024 02:43

@XChrome Why don't you ask them if they meant they are ugly?

Why don't you get a dictionary and look up the word "obtuse"?

My point was that people who are attractive or beautiful are immensely priveleged over those of us who are unattractive. Some people in this thread tried to put together some very bizarre and backwards arguments to try to argue that being attractive is not a good thing. However, the data and statistics show that this is not the case, and that people who are attractive have more career success, are more likely to have friends, and more likely to have relationships than other people.

That's it. Being obtuse or presenting "whatabout" arguments about BAME people doesn't change any of that.

The 'bizarre and backward' arguments you refer to are people merely pointing out that no one has life entirely as they want it, and if our society values superficial looks over all else we don't have to buy into the BS. We can focus on something that actually matters. In the shallow, vapid values of our shallow, vapid culture, beauty only equates with youth in any case. And youth isn't a matter of privilege. We all get the same share of it.

If you're fretting and envious over others' perceived beauty (remember this is mostly in the eye of the beholder), be comforted by the fact that when we hit late middle-age our looks are going to fade. At this point, at least, superficially we are equal.

We grow older if we are lucky. Old age is, indeed, very much a privilege; one not everybody is fortunate enough to experience.

NonPlayerCharacter · 29/07/2024 09:48

5128gap · 29/07/2024 08:35

I think those women are very very rare though @@SallyWD, a tiny minority of women are so beautiful it defines their entire existence. And even then, you don't often hear of the most beautiful high profile women in the world complaining of this in particular. I also find it difficult to believe that there are so many women on this thread that fall into this rare category of 'so beautiful its caused me to be harassed'. For one thing, how can they know what it would have looked like if they looked different but everything else was equal? Would creepy postman have overlooked your friend if she'd been only pretty rather than beautiful? Who knows.
And nothing will convince me that when a group of men in a van shout 'show us your tits' to a woman or grab the arse her arse in a bar it's because she has an exceptionally beautiful face.

And nothing will convince me that when a group of men in a van shout 'show us your tits' to a woman or grab the arse her arse in a bar it's because she has an exceptionally beautiful face.

Quite. I can't even count how many times this kind of thing has happened to me and I am plain as the day is long.

FredericC · 29/07/2024 09:20

You met her for the first time today, and in that short span of time you managed to witness her being served first at the bar (more than once to prove it wasn't a fluke), men crossing the street to be nearer to her (somehow you knew their intentions), men holding doors open for her (when people actually hold doors open for one another all the time)?

Sorry OP, smells a bit fishy to me...

IpsyUpsyDaisyDoos · 29/07/2024 08:58

Cookiecrumblane · 29/07/2024 08:19

@swayingpalmtree thank you! That's what I'm trying to say. No one likes to be harassed but no one wants to be ugly. And in the particular predicament of online dating or trying to meet someone, unfortunately attractiveness is important! It's all very well saying 'oh it's terrible, so glad I'm invisible now' when you have a long term partner who you met when you were young and beautiful!

It's quite telling that you're only responding to a poster who has decided that when someone says "I had a lot of attention and I prefer not getting it" that what they really mean is "it's much better to be ugly".

Think it through, please.

STARCATCHER22 · 29/07/2024 08:53

mansviewpoint · 28/07/2024 21:05

Firstly you have made many many assumptions . Secondly I have never dated anyone younger than me but i will try to explain the situation. I was 18 and she was 24. She chose me first. She asked me out. I like women who are self assertive and so I thought that we might be able to form a life together. She knew before she asked me out that I wasn't into one night stands and just wanted long term relationships. She was a PhD student at the same university. Makeup: To go literally across a road to the corner shop is a 30 second walk, yet it would take her 30 minutes to get ready even though she was fully dresse and already had lippy and a bit of foundation on. Humour... I am unfortunately quite funny as it was the only way for my bullies to stop punching me, chineese burns, stabbing me with compasses for 2 hrs every day. but I know that humour is subjective and that this doesn't suit everyone. However in the 6 ish weeks we dated she didn't laugh at anything. Nothing on the tele, nothing or anyone in real life. I asked her if she found things funny and her answer was 'rarely'. Wanting to go out every single night when you are both students is not sustainable, I completely agree that going to a night club twice a week is fine , which is as much as i could afford and whilst being a student you do actually have to do course work and revision. When we would get to the club at 10 he would spend at least 1 and a half hours redoing her make up and would get a bit of a hump if she didnt get someone try to hit on her. Teenager beaviour:
She was naturally very beautiful but couldn't see it in herself and needed external validation. Every day she would ask my housemates if she looked beautiful at least twice a day. She asked me 'why don't you get jealous when boys hit on me?' I said that I couldn't be jealous because of course they are going to hit on you look at you. "Yeah but don't you worry?" I responded with... if you were taking them into the toilets or started kissing them then I'd be worried. At which point she called me a f ING pussy and threw herself on the floor as a child wood do.
I left my own bedroom and slept downstairs. The breakup and retaliation: She said that if I wasn't getting angry that she went off and danced without me then I wasn't a man. Ten minutes later I broke up with her saying that I don't want to feel like I have to pretend to be angry because you want me to be. I said that isn't right. You shouldn't be seeking that kind of attention. Following day she spread a rumour that I was gay and couslnt get it up for her.. which I couldn't give 2 stuffs about. There were then a few other rumours which she started and then the final straw that I had a rape conviction. I phoned the police... who to begin with being 1995 and me a man just told me to get over it and there was no record. I then had to spend 2 years trying to avoid her because if she saw me she'd start yelling at me. I don't know if that's enough detail or not but I can only tell you how It was for me. Perhaps I made it sound worse than it was, but I really do have a very good memory and I do think the above is an honest account. There will obviously be bits In that relationship where I wasn't the angel, I do remember for example she had asked me to get some lemonade as me and my housemates were going to Tesco, and I completely forgot, but I apologised and she never brought it or anything else.real.up in an argument.. only ever the desire for me to be angry or jealous.

Wow. You hold a lot of anger and feelings about a 6 week relationship that clearly happened over 25 years ago (unless your 24 year old daughter’s mother is this woman).

It is time to let it go mate.

5128gap · 29/07/2024 08:35

I think those women are very very rare though @@SallyWD, a tiny minority of women are so beautiful it defines their entire existence. And even then, you don't often hear of the most beautiful high profile women in the world complaining of this in particular. I also find it difficult to believe that there are so many women on this thread that fall into this rare category of 'so beautiful its caused me to be harassed'. For one thing, how can they know what it would have looked like if they looked different but everything else was equal? Would creepy postman have overlooked your friend if she'd been only pretty rather than beautiful? Who knows.
And nothing will convince me that when a group of men in a van shout 'show us your tits' to a woman or grab the arse her arse in a bar it's because she has an exceptionally beautiful face.

Cookiecrumblane · 29/07/2024 08:19

@swayingpalmtree thank you! That's what I'm trying to say. No one likes to be harassed but no one wants to be ugly. And in the particular predicament of online dating or trying to meet someone, unfortunately attractiveness is important! It's all very well saying 'oh it's terrible, so glad I'm invisible now' when you have a long term partner who you met when you were young and beautiful!

OP posts:
SallyWD · 29/07/2024 08:14

5128gap · 29/07/2024 07:45

Those awful examples of male behaviour don't happen because a woman is beautiful. They happen because the men concerned are mysogynists. Women of all levels of attractiveness experience this type of thing, dependent on the places they have to go and the type of men in those places, and sheer bad luck of encountering them. Any aspect of a woman's appearance makes her fair game for the wrong man's attentions, overweight, ugly, large or small breasts, all can bring this sort of offensive attention. Its far too simplistic to say the groping and cat calling stops because 'I'm old and invisible'. As getting older brings other changes that effect this too. Less likelihood of getting groped if you go less to clubs and bars. Less likely to be cat called on the street when you're less reliant on walking and public transport to get from A to B. Less likely to be seen as a safe easy target if you look like an older woman who might report you rather than an intimidated teen.
The idea that harassment and abuse is linked to attractiveness is a myth and a dangerous one at that. It's far too close to "it's a compliment! What do you expect when you're so gorgeous?" for my liking. It's not about appreciation of some women, it's about distain for all women.

I agree to an extent - much harassment is due to disdain and a sense of power or control. Women of all levels of attractiveness experience it.
However, I do believe that beautiful women have to endure a lot more of this shit than average women, like me.
I've known two truly beautiful women in my life and spent a lot of time with them. The level of attention they got just going to the supermarket blew my mind.
For example - on one 15 minute walk from home to the supermarket with my beautiful friend, I saw two men beeping their horns, one man in the street tell her she was beautiful, one man make a huge display of moving aside so she could pass (there was no need, the pavement was plenty wide enough!) saying "I only step aside for pretty women". When this friend was 16 and living at home the postman became obsessed with her, asking her mum if he could date her. When she moved out and lived alone in a flat, a man who lived in the street kept harassing her, repeatedly asking her out, waiting outside her home after work etc. In the workplace she was constantly being hit on by married men.
So yes, you can say many women experience these things but it was the sheer scale of what my friend endured that was shocking and unusual. I'm reasonably attractive (but nothing special) and have experienced unwanted male attention but this night be several instances a year, not several instances every time I pop to the shop.
It was very similar with my other beautiful friend. Way beyond what I'd ever experienced.

moonplop · 29/07/2024 08:12

The idea that harassment and abuse is linked to attractiveness is a myth and a dangerous one at that. It's far too close to "it's a compliment! What do you expect when you're so gorgeous?" for my liking. It's not about appreciation of some women, it's about distain for all women

I agree, which is why it's so odd that OP seems to want that kind of attention and seems to view it as some kind of validation. It's really not.

urbanbuddha · 29/07/2024 08:09

The idea that harassment and abuse is linked to attractiveness is a myth and a dangerous one at that. It's far too close to "it's a compliment! What do you expect when you're so gorgeous?" for my liking. It's not about appreciation of some women, it's about distain for all women.

Exactly.