Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I would swap with her in an instant

560 replies

Cookiecrumblane · 28/07/2024 01:21

I am a sort of clever woman, financially secure, good at what I do. I have lots of friends and family around me, despite being single.
Today I met a woman through a friend, ten years younger than me. She was upset at losing her job last month, she had tried but made a serious of errors and was eventually sacked.
Even as she cried, she looked beautiful. She told me about her various problems, not being able to pay rent, her debt, her self esteem.
And I thought how much I would love to be that pretty. She was distraught, but even with all that was going on, she was served first and efficiently in the bar. Men held doors and beamed at her. They crossed the street to walk closer to her.
I have never had that. And so what good is education, my job, my success. Because ultimately she'll end up ok. She is more likely to get a job and when she does people will praise what she does much more than they praise people who look like me.
Is that mad? That I would swap with her in an instant, even to be jobless and at risk of losing my flat, just to feel visible?
I'm sure men don't feel this way.

OP posts:
DysonSphere · 31/07/2024 08:14

user33992020 · 31/07/2024 05:57

Oh really? I always thought Anne was described as beautiful but maybe you're right- maybe she was just super charming/vivacious hence him being so captivated.

Cleopatra was by all accounts not classically beautiful either but she captivated men by her intelligence, wit and charm too and had men falling all over her

Yes women like Cleopatra and Anne Boleyn used something more than looks. They had great intelligence, wit, charm, allure, mystery and force of personality. Arguably they were fascinating. Anne Boleyn changed the entire course of British history despite not meeting 16th century beauty standards. And Cleopatra influenced the early formation of the Roman Empire.

Not many women in history had that impact but they are worth studying for a true picture of what makes a woman really captivating besides simply looking pretty.

Doubledenim305 · 31/07/2024 06:11

Just been reading about Bridgette Bardot 😔

Deeply scarred and reclusive now and perfect example of how good looks just get you used.

Extreme good looks attract the wrong type of attention I'd say.

user33992020 · 31/07/2024 05:57

DysonSphere · 30/07/2024 19:09

Anne Boleyn was not considered beautiful for the time. Her eyes and demeanour were considered compelling and she dressed fashionably. But she was not considered a great beauty.

Catherine Howard was considered beautiful. She got her head chopped off just like Anne did. The 'plain Jane' Jane Seymour was the wife who did good and Henry requested to be buried next to.
So looks didn't do anyone any favours!

Oh really? I always thought Anne was described as beautiful but maybe you're right- maybe she was just super charming/vivacious hence him being so captivated.

Cleopatra was by all accounts not classically beautiful either but she captivated men by her intelligence, wit and charm too and had men falling all over her

XChrome · 31/07/2024 03:59

SerafinasGoose

I'm so sorry about what you've been through.

Yes, invisibility and freedom from creepery is great, though it's not total invisibility like I had hoped it would be. It's definitely better though.

DysonSphere · 30/07/2024 19:09

user33992020 · 30/07/2024 18:46

Or Anne Boleyn - she was apparently a looker and got her head chopped off. At least Anne of cleves got to live!

Anne Boleyn was not considered beautiful for the time. Her eyes and demeanour were considered compelling and she dressed fashionably. But she was not considered a great beauty.

Catherine Howard was considered beautiful. She got her head chopped off just like Anne did. The 'plain Jane' Jane Seymour was the wife who did good and Henry requested to be buried next to.
So looks didn't do anyone any favours!

user33992020 · 30/07/2024 18:46

Callum13 · 30/07/2024 10:57

Oh dear could be worse ....you could of been anne of cleves

Or Anne Boleyn - she was apparently a looker and got her head chopped off. At least Anne of cleves got to live!

Callum13 · 30/07/2024 10:57

Oh dear could be worse ....you could of been anne of cleves

Colinthecaterpillarstrikesagain · 30/07/2024 10:44

5128gap · 30/07/2024 10:24

We do. But the taste of not admiring slim blonde women seems over represented amongst women from my observations. With lots of women apparantly not 'seeing it' where such women are concerned. I've seen numerous threads along the lines of 'what's all the fuss about blondes?' Where people come on to say they don't admire the look, being rather rude in many cases, in a way you'd never see about brunettes or red haired women. Which is strangely at odds with blonde being such a popular colour to dye hair to, and the other MN stereotype of the beautiful tall blonde DD.

I agree with the poster who said beauty is facial rather than about hair colour, so find it difficult to understand why people say they don't find blonde women attractive as these women can have a range of features from plain to beautiful just like women with other hair colours.

We are making the same point. Neither of us seem to think that simply having blonde hair makes a woman attractive. It isn’t an automatic pass. Features are more important. I didn’t/don’t see the outward beauty woman I referred to as to be honest her facial features are not beautiful (in my eyes).

Aa for hair dye, I follow a number of gtey blending hairdressers on Istagram. Every one recommends dying hair blonde as it’s the easiest way to cover greys apparently while not being too harsh a contrast with white skin.

For younger people, we are brought up with the All American Girl look on teenage soaps.

I don’t dislike blonde hair. Far from it, my own daughter has long blonde hair and blue eyes. I can see with my own eyes that there is a girl with dark hair in her class that is every bit as pretty and has more attractive facial features than my DD.

ginasevern · 30/07/2024 10:36

DysonSphere · 29/07/2024 19:34

Oh they do.

To a degree.

They don't confer life satisfaction, it has no correlation to the quality of a persons life, except in the rarest of situations where you could argue luck also intervened.

It's an advantage only in some contexts and can be undermined and mitigated by any number of life variables.

Money is a far stronger advantage and predictor for success than looks alone are.

Joan Collins said she has known many beautiful women whose quality of life would have been better if they were less beautiful.

I agree about money, which is definitely the most powerful advantage. It can't solve everything but it does solve most things.

5128gap · 30/07/2024 10:24

Colinthecaterpillarstrikesagain · 30/07/2024 08:42

I disagree. Some women with these features are beautiful, not necessarily all of them are just because they fit a certain mould.

I also don’t find blonde men particularly attractive or men who do body building. We all have different tastes thankfully.

We do. But the taste of not admiring slim blonde women seems over represented amongst women from my observations. With lots of women apparantly not 'seeing it' where such women are concerned. I've seen numerous threads along the lines of 'what's all the fuss about blondes?' Where people come on to say they don't admire the look, being rather rude in many cases, in a way you'd never see about brunettes or red haired women. Which is strangely at odds with blonde being such a popular colour to dye hair to, and the other MN stereotype of the beautiful tall blonde DD.

I agree with the poster who said beauty is facial rather than about hair colour, so find it difficult to understand why people say they don't find blonde women attractive as these women can have a range of features from plain to beautiful just like women with other hair colours.

DiduAye · 30/07/2024 10:13

You cannot be serious! Give your head a wobble

FluffyBenji23 · 30/07/2024 09:40

Walkingaroundjardine your comment about your daughter struck a cord with me. I met an old school friend the other week (not seen in nearly ten years) and when I mentioned my daughter (who is a highly skilled professional after studying for years to progress in her career) all this friend could comment on was how beautiful she was! Yes she is attractive, but that is the least important thing about her and she has struggled with many issues despite her looks. I live by Judge Judy's maxim, as I watch wrinkles increasing on my own face "Beauty fades, dumb is for ever!" Men may be attracted to beautiful women, but it's a shallow and self serving attraction. My Mum used to tell me to be proud of all I have achieved, as what I look like will get less and less important as I and all my contemporaries age. This was one of the best bits of advice she ever gave me!

LiterallyOnFire · 30/07/2024 09:37

No it's my fault @SerafinasGoose - I'm off work with a bit of a fever and clearly need to slow down & read more carefully.

SerafinasGoose · 30/07/2024 09:35

LiterallyOnFire · 30/07/2024 09:17

Oh I thought you weee telling me off. Grin

Apologies that this didn't come across as clearly as I meant it to in my post.

LiterallyOnFire · 30/07/2024 09:17

Oh I thought you weee telling me off. Grin

SerafinasGoose · 30/07/2024 09:09

LiterallyOnFire · 30/07/2024 09:08

Why did you direct that rant at me @SerafinasGoose? Confused

I was taking exception to the idea that the woman was "coasting on her look".

Because I was agreeing with you, and saying why.

NonPlayerCharacter · 30/07/2024 09:08

5128gap · 30/07/2024 07:44

There's also a strong undercurrent of anti tall slim and blonde bias at play I think. Women very rarely acknowledge beauty in this look, very frequently citing the opposite as their ownI ideal. It comes up so often that women don't admire these looks that I think there's an element of push back involved. I mean if this woman was 'truly beautiful' with the looks you describe, it's hard to see how you 'couldn't see it' unless you didn't want to. The look gets rammed down women's throats as the ideal so it's a rebellion to not like it. But a bit harsh on tall slim blonde women that their looks can be underrated with impunity by other women.

When the Barbie film came out, there was an epidemic of men online declaring Margot Robbie to be "mid", and an awful lot of posters on here declaring that they couldn't understand why she was considered to be so very beautiful.

I can accept that she might not be everyone's preferred type, but anyone claiming that they literally can't understand why she's considered a conventional beauty is frankly lying.

LiterallyOnFire · 30/07/2024 09:08

Why did you direct that rant at me @SerafinasGoose? Confused

I was taking exception to the idea that the woman was "coasting on her look".

TwigletsAndRadishes · 30/07/2024 09:01

NonPlayerCharacter · 30/07/2024 08:46

Beautiful types sometimes have no personality and can lack the grittiness to cope when things go wrong. Then they really fall apart.

I hear this a lot, but I've known a lot of people who lack resilience and they really haven't all been stunners.

Yes, it's a bit of a cliche. I'm not sure being beautiful makes you any more likely to be born with a shit personality or a weak character or a lack of intelligence any more than an average looking person. Although I suppose if you are told you are beautiful your entire life by everyone, not just your parents, then it will become a huge part of your identity and perhaps shape your character in ways that might not be positive.

You could lack confidence in your ability to do anything other than merely stand there looking lovely. You could question whether you ever got that job on merit or just because you looked nice. Your peers in school and the workplace might make accusations that you get preferential treatment from a teacher or better pay rises or whatever, because of your looks and whether that's true or not, it's hard to defend yourself against. And even if it is true, it's not your fault.

You might find yourself shunned or distrusted by envious women. You might find that the men you like daren't approach, assuming you are out of their league. If you ever dare speak to someone that is in a relationship, even in the most casual or platonic of ways, you will be watched like a hawk but their partner.

You might find you are treated like an object or a trophy and that all anyone wants to talk to you about is your looks, not about who you are or what you think about anything. It might make you arrogant and entitled. It might make you simper and bat your eyelashes to get people to do things for you, because you've learned from an early age that it works. It might make you shallow and insecure because you obsess over staying beautiful and fear ageing. If it's such a huge part of your identity that must be scary, especially if you've earned a living on the back of your looks and your looks alone.

CameltoeParkerBowles · 30/07/2024 08:57

Yalta · 28/07/2024 07:24

I get what you mean and those who don’t I don’t think have experienced what you mean about having the invisibility that not having the features that makes us look attractive brings

Or the fact that attractive people have in the literal and figurative sense have doors
opened for them.

You can love yourself all that you can. You can be proud of your achievements and working hard to achieve those things but once you see someone who without putting any effort in getting the same or better jobs and experiences and being put ahead just because they are beautiful you then you can’t unsee it.

Its a case of, if 2 candidates for a job were equal on all their qualifications, experience and scored equal marks in their interview, Do you honestly think who gets chosen, how attractive the candidate is will not be a factor.

It's funny you should say that, because an ex family member of mine once actively discriminated against a very competent, and also very beautiful, woman whom she interviewed for a job, on the grounds that she would create too much of a distraction for the men in the office! This was about twenty years ago. I was astonished at that revelation, but she (ex family member) was quite matter-of-fact about it.

SerafinasGoose · 30/07/2024 08:47

LiterallyOnFire · 30/07/2024 01:56

Jeez. Poor woman. For all you know she's completely oblivious to her own looks. She can't help it if she lacks ability elsewhere.

Why are a subset plain women always so catty with this "coasts on her looks" nonsense? There's nothing in the OP that suggests that at all.

Because it's permissible to be intelligent and plain, or very attractive and stupid. Even this thread is evidence of the fact that society can't seem to compute a woman who is both at the same time. It's a possibility some posters upthread haven't even considered.

I'm nearly 6 ft tall and was, until recently, quite athletic (until a serious riding accident put paid to that). I'm not a classic 'beauty', whatever that means, but I was fortunate in my genetics. I had a horrible time in the jobs I took on after school, with people calling me a bimbo and assuming I was completely gormless. I am, in fact, extremely good at English and unlike some of the other secretaries could spell and construct a grammatically-accurate sentence. At school, before I blossomed, I had a reputation for being the clever one because I was bookish. I was bullied for being the 'geek' and, because I was a late-developer, for having a flat chest. I also took shit because of my height: to the extent that I never wore anything but flat shoes. The sexism was off the scale.

And when I did fill out and develop? At fifteen I was raped twice, once being a gang rape, the other non-consensual sex (ie also rape, but I didn't realise it at the time) with the boy I thought I loved. I've fallen for plenty of would-be partners who haven't wanted me in return. I've been in relationships with men who treated me extremely badly. I studied from BA to PhD because I was bored witless with the tedious office jobs I'd taken on (to earn a salary as quickly as possible, leave home and escape my abusive father). I then discovered sexism in universities is absolutely rife. I've been the target of sexual harrassment by an older male colleague who continued stalking me after they fired him. I had to involve the police.

Riding on the back of looks? Not a bit of it. Did looks give me an easier ride in life? Did they hell. Did I earn my position and academic status on merit? Every bit of it. And now I'm likely on the cusp of that oft-lamented age of invisibility which apparently affects women but not men.

I can't wait. Bring it the fuck on.

NonPlayerCharacter · 30/07/2024 08:46

Beautiful types sometimes have no personality and can lack the grittiness to cope when things go wrong. Then they really fall apart.

I hear this a lot, but I've known a lot of people who lack resilience and they really haven't all been stunners.

CameltoeParkerBowles · 30/07/2024 08:46

Newnamehiwhodis · 28/07/2024 02:52

You’re not wrong- there’s something known as “pretty privilege,” but it comes at a high cost. Those men served her because they wanted her. The second they made a move and she turned them down, you’d be shocked at how quickly that politeness can turn into something uglier than you can imagine.

I say this from experience.

what you’re imagining her life is like - I can guarantee you, it isn’t.

when someone is seen as pretty, they’re also seen as a thing. A commodity to possess, to buy and sell. And it comes with owing - owing everyone who wants. Either owing explanations, owing a horrible people-pleasing dance to try to get out of a situation without being harmed, owing your time, energy and attention just to try to stay safe.

her life isn’t good. She is crying for a reason. Please don’t wish that hell on yourself.

That is so well expressed! And true, I fear.

TwigletsAndRadishes · 30/07/2024 08:44

CovertPiggery · 30/07/2024 08:23

Wtf? Unless I need new eyes, none of those women are remotely ugly!

Of course they aren't. What these women often have is that unusual, slightly other worldly, quirky beauty about them, like Anya Taylor Joy. Or they are just not exceptionally pretty or exceptionally beautiful, which is what we are accustomed to seeing as 'normal' on TV, especially in America. They are merely 'normal looking' which in Hollywood terms is practically considered 'ugly.'

If they were actually ugly, or even just less attractive than average, they certainly wouldn't be getting lead roles in big TV shows.

Colinthecaterpillarstrikesagain · 30/07/2024 08:42

5128gap · 30/07/2024 07:44

There's also a strong undercurrent of anti tall slim and blonde bias at play I think. Women very rarely acknowledge beauty in this look, very frequently citing the opposite as their ownI ideal. It comes up so often that women don't admire these looks that I think there's an element of push back involved. I mean if this woman was 'truly beautiful' with the looks you describe, it's hard to see how you 'couldn't see it' unless you didn't want to. The look gets rammed down women's throats as the ideal so it's a rebellion to not like it. But a bit harsh on tall slim blonde women that their looks can be underrated with impunity by other women.

I disagree. Some women with these features are beautiful, not necessarily all of them are just because they fit a certain mould.

I also don’t find blonde men particularly attractive or men who do body building. We all have different tastes thankfully.