Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I would swap with her in an instant

560 replies

Cookiecrumblane · 28/07/2024 01:21

I am a sort of clever woman, financially secure, good at what I do. I have lots of friends and family around me, despite being single.
Today I met a woman through a friend, ten years younger than me. She was upset at losing her job last month, she had tried but made a serious of errors and was eventually sacked.
Even as she cried, she looked beautiful. She told me about her various problems, not being able to pay rent, her debt, her self esteem.
And I thought how much I would love to be that pretty. She was distraught, but even with all that was going on, she was served first and efficiently in the bar. Men held doors and beamed at her. They crossed the street to walk closer to her.
I have never had that. And so what good is education, my job, my success. Because ultimately she'll end up ok. She is more likely to get a job and when she does people will praise what she does much more than they praise people who look like me.
Is that mad? That I would swap with her in an instant, even to be jobless and at risk of losing my flat, just to feel visible?
I'm sure men don't feel this way.

OP posts:
shuggles · 04/08/2024 22:07

@IpsyUpsyDaisyDoos You're a man. Of course you think we women are mistaken. You clearly know more about our own lives experiences than we do.

The claims aren't just about your own lies and experiences though. Your claims are about how men talk and act in the workplace. I would also challenge men who made the same claims.

@5128gap I was not mistaken when I had to give evidence in a disciplinary at work when a group of male colleagues were sharing nudes of a young female colleague one had had sex with. I'm happy to offer this anecdote without fear of it being outing as sadly this isn't sufficiently uncommon as to identify me or her.

You're the first person to provide a specific example, but I imagine this scenario is very uncommon. Of all the men I have worked with, I have never seen anything that comes to close to this.

Beezknees · 04/08/2024 21:36

Bellsandthistle · 04/08/2024 21:27

All the posters shocked and appalled by the OP, shaking their heads and telling her to get therapy know darn well many (if not most) women would feel the same. Perhaps we as a society need therapy, but pretending like what OP felt is uncommon and weird, is ridiculous.

You might feel the same as OP, I don't. How would you know what "most" women feel?

Poddledoddle · 04/08/2024 21:34

Cookiecrumblane · 28/07/2024 01:21

I am a sort of clever woman, financially secure, good at what I do. I have lots of friends and family around me, despite being single.
Today I met a woman through a friend, ten years younger than me. She was upset at losing her job last month, she had tried but made a serious of errors and was eventually sacked.
Even as she cried, she looked beautiful. She told me about her various problems, not being able to pay rent, her debt, her self esteem.
And I thought how much I would love to be that pretty. She was distraught, but even with all that was going on, she was served first and efficiently in the bar. Men held doors and beamed at her. They crossed the street to walk closer to her.
I have never had that. And so what good is education, my job, my success. Because ultimately she'll end up ok. She is more likely to get a job and when she does people will praise what she does much more than they praise people who look like me.
Is that mad? That I would swap with her in an instant, even to be jobless and at risk of losing my flat, just to feel visible?
I'm sure men don't feel this way.

Is this a joke?

Bellsandthistle · 04/08/2024 21:27

All the posters shocked and appalled by the OP, shaking their heads and telling her to get therapy know darn well many (if not most) women would feel the same. Perhaps we as a society need therapy, but pretending like what OP felt is uncommon and weird, is ridiculous.

IpsyUpsyDaisyDoos · 04/08/2024 21:21

5128gap · 04/08/2024 21:18

Certainly not. I rarely watch television. I tend to spend my evenings in my local The Rovers. There's an old guy who goes in there, Ken something, always bragging about women.

🤣🤣🤣

Lucky your feeble female mind can tell the difference!

5128gap · 04/08/2024 21:18

IpsyUpsyDaisyDoos · 04/08/2024 21:10

Sure you weren't watching Corrie and confused it with your own life????

Certainly not. I rarely watch television. I tend to spend my evenings in my local The Rovers. There's an old guy who goes in there, Ken something, always bragging about women.

IpsyUpsyDaisyDoos · 04/08/2024 21:10

5128gap · 04/08/2024 21:09

I was not mistaken when I had to give evidence in a disciplinary at work when a group of male colleagues were sharing nudes of a young female colleague one had had sex with. I'm happy to offer this anecdote without fear of it being outing as sadly this isn't sufficiently uncommon as to identify me or her.

If that's not enough, my partner and adult sons looked at me in some surprise when I just asked them if any men spoke like this. The surprise being that that i was naive enough to have to ask. And before I get told the men in my life should keep better company, I assure you, they try to. Unfortunately they have no control over who they work alongside, who attends their gym or the other members of their sports teams.

Sure you weren't watching Corrie and confused it with your own life????

5128gap · 04/08/2024 21:09

I was not mistaken when I had to give evidence in a disciplinary at work when a group of male colleagues were sharing nudes of a young female colleague one had had sex with. I'm happy to offer this anecdote without fear of it being outing as sadly this isn't sufficiently uncommon as to identify me or her.

If that's not enough, my partner and adult sons looked at me in some surprise when I just asked them if any men spoke like this. The surprise being that that i was naive enough to have to ask. And before I get told the men in my life should keep better company, I assure you, they try to. Unfortunately they have no control over who they work alongside, who attends their gym or the other members of their sports teams.

IpsyUpsyDaisyDoos · 04/08/2024 21:02

shuggles · 04/08/2024 20:53

@IpsyUpsyDaisyDoos this is an anonymous forum. We aren't giving you specific examples because we wish to remain anonymous and not being recognised by our friends or colleagues.

Then you omit details that would lead to identification.

We also shouldn't have to give you specific examples for you to believe that we've heard men speaking like this. Or that we've been subjected to men treating us like this.

Well I haven't heard it, and being a man, that means they are less likely to filter their words around me. So if this was true, I should have heard it.

What do we have to gain by lying on an anonymous forum???

I don't think you are lying. I think you are just mistaken.

People spend a lot of time watching TV, and it is easy to conflate what you see on TV with real life. For example, misogyny tends to be massively exaggerated on TV (you know, because men are always the bad guys). People see this stuff on TV and this subconsciously changes their brain so they think this is the way men actually are.

I do not watch TV, so I am largely immune to this.

You're a man. Of course you think we women are mistaken. You clearly know more about our own lives experiences than we do.

I completely apologise for thinking I knew more about what's happened in my own life than any random male stranger.

shuggles · 04/08/2024 20:53

@IpsyUpsyDaisyDoos this is an anonymous forum. We aren't giving you specific examples because we wish to remain anonymous and not being recognised by our friends or colleagues.

Then you omit details that would lead to identification.

We also shouldn't have to give you specific examples for you to believe that we've heard men speaking like this. Or that we've been subjected to men treating us like this.

Well I haven't heard it, and being a man, that means they are less likely to filter their words around me. So if this was true, I should have heard it.

What do we have to gain by lying on an anonymous forum???

I don't think you are lying. I think you are just mistaken.

People spend a lot of time watching TV, and it is easy to conflate what you see on TV with real life. For example, misogyny tends to be massively exaggerated on TV (you know, because men are always the bad guys). People see this stuff on TV and this subconsciously changes their brain so they think this is the way men actually are.

I do not watch TV, so I am largely immune to this.

IpsyUpsyDaisyDoos · 04/08/2024 20:30

@shuggles this is an anonymous forum. We aren't giving you specific examples because we wish to remain anonymous and not being recognised by our friends or colleagues.

We also shouldn't have to give you specific examples for you to believe that we've heard men speaking like this. Or that we've been subjected to men treating us like this. What do we have to gain by lying on an anonymous forum???

It happens. Don't be so naive that you think it doesn't.

shuggles · 04/08/2024 20:23

@VickyPollard25 @IpsyUpsyDaisyDoos Most of us know men like this.

And yet, none of you can ever cite specific examples. It's always vague statements like "men talk about their "conquests" with other men" but you can never recall a time when you actually saw this.

I'll agree it's not all men,

I don't agree that it's not all men. I'm saying it's a very very tiny number, or no men, because I've never seen this nonsense outside of school.

but I've worked in male dominated sectors for long enough to have come across the ones who like to tell everyone about their latest conquest or show people the "hot girl" they just matched with.

I have also worked with lots of men. And keep in mind that men have no reason to filter their words around me.

  • I've never heard men walking around work and talking about their "latest conquest." Keep in mind that the majority of men, from early 20s onwards, are in long-term relationships. Those who aren't tend to keep to themselves. The majority of men don't have "conquests," if that word means what I think it means.
  • I've never seen anyone walking around with a dating app to show everyone a "hot girl" that they just matched with. Again, keep in mind that most men get very few, or no, matches on dating apps.

I'm happy for you that you've never met any of these men. But don't dismiss the experiences of other women as not real because they don't match yours.

But again, when challenged on these points, none of you can ever cite specific memories or examples.

I swear that some of you people live on a different planet to me sometimes.

IpsyUpsyDaisyDoos · 04/08/2024 20:14

shuggles · 04/08/2024 18:48

@VickyPollard25 I have seen it many times. When they proud of what they have “got”, they do it.

When did you see it? Where? Who?

How do you know you didn't just see this in a movie, where men behave nothing like their real life counterparts?

Most of us know men like this. I'll agree it's not all men, but I've worked in male dominated sectors for long enough to have come across the ones who like to tell everyone about their latest conquest or show people the "hot girl" they just matched with.

I'm happy for you that you've never met any of these men. But don't dismiss the experiences of other women as not real because they don't match yours.

VickyPollard25 · 04/08/2024 20:09

shuggles · 04/08/2024 18:48

@VickyPollard25 I have seen it many times. When they proud of what they have “got”, they do it.

When did you see it? Where? Who?

How do you know you didn't just see this in a movie, where men behave nothing like their real life counterparts?

What? Like most people, I can tell the difference between a conversation I have with real life people and when I’m watching a movie 🙄

shuggles · 04/08/2024 18:48

@VickyPollard25 I have seen it many times. When they proud of what they have “got”, they do it.

When did you see it? Where? Who?

How do you know you didn't just see this in a movie, where men behave nothing like their real life counterparts?

CeruleanDive · 04/08/2024 18:47

You sound like you have a rather sheltered life, @shuggles. The way some men talk about women is absolutely disgusting. Like inanimate objects to do as they please with. This does not have to be with close friends at all.

VickyPollard25 · 04/08/2024 18:41

shuggles · 04/08/2024 16:00

@VickyPollard25 The fact that men are so much more interested in beautiful women is because of their beauty. Not anything else (at first anyway). That is objectifying women. Boasting to friends, showing photos of their conquest (not inappropriate photos) and generally using the woman to look good - like they would a nice car or other material objects. This isn’t kind or respectful.

Men don't do this. I understand that women may look through dating apps in groups, or discuss love/sex/relationships, or their partner, with friends, but these group discussions aren't something that men would do. First of all, most men over the age of 30 do not have any close friends. First of all, sexuality and dating tends to be something that men keep to themselves. If a man showed me a picture of his girlfriend just to boast, I would find that extremely strange.

I have seen it many times. When they proud of what they have “got”, they do it. My friend even met her husband because a mutual male friend showed him a photo of her to show him how cute she is.

shuggles · 04/08/2024 16:00

@VickyPollard25 The fact that men are so much more interested in beautiful women is because of their beauty. Not anything else (at first anyway). That is objectifying women. Boasting to friends, showing photos of their conquest (not inappropriate photos) and generally using the woman to look good - like they would a nice car or other material objects. This isn’t kind or respectful.

Men don't do this. I understand that women may look through dating apps in groups, or discuss love/sex/relationships, or their partner, with friends, but these group discussions aren't something that men would do. First of all, most men over the age of 30 do not have any close friends. First of all, sexuality and dating tends to be something that men keep to themselves. If a man showed me a picture of his girlfriend just to boast, I would find that extremely strange.

realityhack · 04/08/2024 15:41

VickyPollard25 · 04/08/2024 12:11

I guess I’m thinking of personal experience. Examples - being prevented by a rail guard from exiting a train station, being taken into his office and being very upset and worried, and then told there was nothing wrong with my ticket, and he just wanted my phone number. I had to politely decline and say I had a boyfriend while raging inside. I was late to work because of this idiot.
Another example, being surrounded by a group of men at 9am one morning in a public place who proceeded to block my way and grope me (yes, I reported it to police and they were charged). Another example, being sexually harassed at work by the very old chairman of the board who took a liking to me, would stare at me if he came to the office (embarrassing for me and noticed by others) and he would bypass my boss on work and go straight to me (which obviously caused issues for me with her). It culminated in some severe sexual harassment in front of other colleagues (I sued and received a payout, but my career there obviously over and the entire experience was traumatic). The list goes on. In another job the IT guy decided he fancied me and it became clear he was reading my emails when he congratulated me on some news on and my partner knew about. Until I got to my 40s, my work life was sheer hell because of unwanted attention from men. It is so much better now. These were not men I was in relationships with. Just arseholes who think these are entitled to women they fancy. So I really do think women who men find attractive have a harder time.

I agree with you and have had similar experiences. Please let's not make the mistake of thinking that men "being nice to you" due to your looks is down to a motivation of kindness or innocent empathy and generosity. Its not. They want to shag you is all- so, use you for sex. Thats it, and when you dont acquiesce, or even turn them down politely, they frequently turn nasty and aggressive- happened to me many times and a few times I was afraid for my life.

There is absolutely nothing to envy about that, unless you enjoy being treated like a sex doll who has no feelings, no brain, and isnt even a person in their own right.

CleanCityBird · 04/08/2024 13:29

Poppycock

VickyPollard25 · 04/08/2024 12:11

5128gap · 04/08/2024 10:21

I don't agree with PPs generalisation as I think attractive women are treated better by random unknown men and acquaintances than less attractive ones for the reasons you say. However once in a relationship the gloves come off as it were, and I think there's little difference in how well a man treats his established partner related to her looks. If anything, women who are considerably more attractive than the man may have thought he'd get can find themselves subject to 'negging' jealousy and control due to his insecurity. So maybe that's where the thinking comes from. Though of course women don't need to be attractive to experience these things, as male poor treatment of women from men that way inclined tends to be an equal opportunity activity, fully inclusive of all!

I guess I’m thinking of personal experience. Examples - being prevented by a rail guard from exiting a train station, being taken into his office and being very upset and worried, and then told there was nothing wrong with my ticket, and he just wanted my phone number. I had to politely decline and say I had a boyfriend while raging inside. I was late to work because of this idiot.
Another example, being surrounded by a group of men at 9am one morning in a public place who proceeded to block my way and grope me (yes, I reported it to police and they were charged). Another example, being sexually harassed at work by the very old chairman of the board who took a liking to me, would stare at me if he came to the office (embarrassing for me and noticed by others) and he would bypass my boss on work and go straight to me (which obviously caused issues for me with her). It culminated in some severe sexual harassment in front of other colleagues (I sued and received a payout, but my career there obviously over and the entire experience was traumatic). The list goes on. In another job the IT guy decided he fancied me and it became clear he was reading my emails when he congratulated me on some news on and my partner knew about. Until I got to my 40s, my work life was sheer hell because of unwanted attention from men. It is so much better now. These were not men I was in relationships with. Just arseholes who think these are entitled to women they fancy. So I really do think women who men find attractive have a harder time.

5128gap · 04/08/2024 10:21

shuggles · 04/08/2024 00:12

Citation needed. I've never seen examples of this. If men are more romantically interested in beautiful women (and we expect that they would be), then why would they treat those women worse and reduce their chances of a relationship?

The only way I imagine this could be true is that beautiful women select the most attractive men, and it's only a small number of attractive men that have more than one woman interested in them, so those men feel they can do whatever they want and get away from it. But that's an issue with those men, not men as a whole.

I don't agree with PPs generalisation as I think attractive women are treated better by random unknown men and acquaintances than less attractive ones for the reasons you say. However once in a relationship the gloves come off as it were, and I think there's little difference in how well a man treats his established partner related to her looks. If anything, women who are considerably more attractive than the man may have thought he'd get can find themselves subject to 'negging' jealousy and control due to his insecurity. So maybe that's where the thinking comes from. Though of course women don't need to be attractive to experience these things, as male poor treatment of women from men that way inclined tends to be an equal opportunity activity, fully inclusive of all!

Dinkydo12 · 04/08/2024 08:51

Beauty is in the eye of the beholder. Why you think looking one way or another is better than you have is sad. Don't let looks define you. Be you and get a make over if you feel stuck. You need to start living yourself not spend your life thinking the grass is greener elsewhere

VickyPollard25 · 04/08/2024 07:37

Newnamehiwhodis · 28/07/2024 02:52

You’re not wrong- there’s something known as “pretty privilege,” but it comes at a high cost. Those men served her because they wanted her. The second they made a move and she turned them down, you’d be shocked at how quickly that politeness can turn into something uglier than you can imagine.

I say this from experience.

what you’re imagining her life is like - I can guarantee you, it isn’t.

when someone is seen as pretty, they’re also seen as a thing. A commodity to possess, to buy and sell. And it comes with owing - owing everyone who wants. Either owing explanations, owing a horrible people-pleasing dance to try to get out of a situation without being harmed, owing your time, energy and attention just to try to stay safe.

her life isn’t good. She is crying for a reason. Please don’t wish that hell on yourself.

This is exactly right.

Some men are vile when rejected. I’d rather not have the attention in the first place than have to deal with that.

VickyPollard25 · 04/08/2024 07:29

Lifebeginsat40theysaid · 03/08/2024 19:10

I applied for a job a few years ago - all online interviews as it was a WFH job. I got down to the last 2 and it went to someone else. No reason given, I asked how I could've improved or what I could've done differently and was told nothing, I did really well and they had no tips they could give me, they just went with the other person. I checked their website after that to see who had got the job and it went to someone younger, blond and very pretty. She had only been qualified in our profession for a year, versus my many years qualified and many many more years of experience. I genuinely felt that the only reason she got it was that I am fat and ugly. Maybe I didn't come across as well, especially since I could see my own face in the corner of the screen during the interviews and I avoid looking at myself as much as I can so found that very offputting!
Pretty privilege is definitely a thing and anyone who doesn't think so is one of the pretty ones!!
And yes, I know you will blame it on my own self-esteem issues and yes, you're probably right but it is what it is!

They may have also been able to pay her a lot less.