Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I would swap with her in an instant

560 replies

Cookiecrumblane · 28/07/2024 01:21

I am a sort of clever woman, financially secure, good at what I do. I have lots of friends and family around me, despite being single.
Today I met a woman through a friend, ten years younger than me. She was upset at losing her job last month, she had tried but made a serious of errors and was eventually sacked.
Even as she cried, she looked beautiful. She told me about her various problems, not being able to pay rent, her debt, her self esteem.
And I thought how much I would love to be that pretty. She was distraught, but even with all that was going on, she was served first and efficiently in the bar. Men held doors and beamed at her. They crossed the street to walk closer to her.
I have never had that. And so what good is education, my job, my success. Because ultimately she'll end up ok. She is more likely to get a job and when she does people will praise what she does much more than they praise people who look like me.
Is that mad? That I would swap with her in an instant, even to be jobless and at risk of losing my flat, just to feel visible?
I'm sure men don't feel this way.

OP posts:
XChrome · 28/07/2024 21:47

shuggles · 28/07/2024 21:32

@XChrome That's the implication.

It isn't, and wouldn't be even if those people had said they aren't pretty. They merely said they are older, and in one case, bigger. All people who aren't pretty aren't ugly, anyway. You can certainly be average or plain.

NonPlayerCharacter · 28/07/2024 21:44

mansviewpoint · 28/07/2024 21:38

I didn't understand the first time so I am asking again because I genuinely don't get how I insulted all women in my first sentence.is it that you think I'm mansplaining or just that I shouldn't be allowed to explain where I was in a bad relationship with a beautiful woman and it wasn't a good fit. Which is what that wall of text was.
Please explain it because I genuinely want to know what I said wrong in my first sentence. Speak to me as if I'm five. I know I had a rant half way through about the worst relationship I had which I shouldn't have done because as someone else pointed out I painted all beautiful women with the same brush and that's my bad. I can't improve as a person unless I understand what I've said or done wrong.

I know you don't understand why your posts are not an eye-opening revelation to women receiving endless applause as you show us the light. I could explain it a third time and you still wouldn't understand.

I'd say it's not my problem, but sadly it actually is...women have to live with this endless nonsense. But I don't have to humour it.

Sunhatweather · 28/07/2024 21:40

That was me a good few years ago, OP. It happened from when I was 15/16yrs old and I’ve lost count of the times I wanted the ground to swallow me up when I was followed while being loudly catcalled, followed out into carparks, had men refuse to let me past them, grope me, not let me ride a bus or train in peace.
It did nothing for my self esteem - in fact it made me horribly self-conscious for most of my adult life.
I love the freedom of being older 😊

mansviewpoint · 28/07/2024 21:38

NonPlayerCharacter · 28/07/2024 21:25

I could explain again (because I said it the first time), but you wouldn't understand and frankly I'm scared of unleashing another avalanche of whatever the fuck that wall of text you bestowed upon us before this post is.

It may be an incredible revelation to you, but I absolutely assure you that anyone born female who reaches the age of 16 is very well acquainted with self-important men who judge you if you're not beautiful, and then if you are beautiful, but also judge you if you make too much effort to become beautiful, and find you to be the shallow baddie either way. And who then spend the next 20+ years lecturing you about it, and accusing you of being unreasonable and irrational ("shouted at" or whatever it was) before they've even started patronising and insulting you in the name of imparting their wisdom.

I suppose at least you're not comparing us to cars and then telling us off for not liking it like the last guy I saw on one of these threads. He thought he was a visionary too.

Edited

I didn't understand the first time so I am asking again because I genuinely don't get how I insulted all women in my first sentence.is it that you think I'm mansplaining or just that I shouldn't be allowed to explain where I was in a bad relationship with a beautiful woman and it wasn't a good fit. Which is what that wall of text was.
Please explain it because I genuinely want to know what I said wrong in my first sentence. Speak to me as if I'm five. I know I had a rant half way through about the worst relationship I had which I shouldn't have done because as someone else pointed out I painted all beautiful women with the same brush and that's my bad. I can't improve as a person unless I understand what I've said or done wrong.

shuggles · 28/07/2024 21:32

@XChrome That's the implication.

SeismicSalad · 28/07/2024 21:30

Cookiecrumblane · 28/07/2024 01:21

I am a sort of clever woman, financially secure, good at what I do. I have lots of friends and family around me, despite being single.
Today I met a woman through a friend, ten years younger than me. She was upset at losing her job last month, she had tried but made a serious of errors and was eventually sacked.
Even as she cried, she looked beautiful. She told me about her various problems, not being able to pay rent, her debt, her self esteem.
And I thought how much I would love to be that pretty. She was distraught, but even with all that was going on, she was served first and efficiently in the bar. Men held doors and beamed at her. They crossed the street to walk closer to her.
I have never had that. And so what good is education, my job, my success. Because ultimately she'll end up ok. She is more likely to get a job and when she does people will praise what she does much more than they praise people who look like me.
Is that mad? That I would swap with her in an instant, even to be jobless and at risk of losing my flat, just to feel visible?
I'm sure men don't feel this way.

“Men held doors and beamed at her. They crossed the street to walk closer to her” That… sounds awful, no? 🤯😂

NonPlayerCharacter · 28/07/2024 21:25

mansviewpoint · 28/07/2024 21:19

How am I insulting you all when I'm pointing out what goes through an average man's brain when they see a pretty girl. Or are you also male? In which case we've got very different real life experiences of over hearing arseholes at the pub who try to get off with the bar maid whilst there misses are at home.

I could explain again (because I said it the first time), but you wouldn't understand and frankly I'm scared of unleashing another avalanche of whatever the fuck that wall of text you bestowed upon us before this post is.

It may be an incredible revelation to you, but I absolutely assure you that anyone born female who reaches the age of 16 is very well acquainted with self-important men who judge you if you're not beautiful, and then if you are beautiful, but also judge you if you make too much effort to become beautiful, and find you to be the shallow baddie either way. And who then spend the next 20+ years lecturing you about it, and accusing you of being unreasonable and irrational ("shouted at" or whatever it was) before they've even started patronising and insulting you in the name of imparting their wisdom.

I suppose at least you're not comparing us to cars and then telling us off for not liking it like the last guy I saw on one of these threads. He thought he was a visionary too.

mansviewpoint · 28/07/2024 21:19

NonPlayerCharacter · 28/07/2024 08:33

You gave yourself and your sexism away with your very first line, insulting us all even before going on to demonstrate exactly why you do indeed deserve exactly what's coming.

It's just incredible that you could have written this and still think it's women who are shallow. I'd explain why, but what's the point?

Date whomever you like, that's your business. But God save us from "I judged women on looks and grooming habits, it didn't work out, wow aren't women shallow" men who think that will be a revelation to us.

How am I insulting you all when I'm pointing out what goes through an average man's brain when they see a pretty girl. Or are you also male? In which case we've got very different real life experiences of over hearing arseholes at the pub who try to get off with the bar maid whilst there misses are at home.

mansviewpoint · 28/07/2024 21:13

swayingpalmtree · 28/07/2024 08:17

If a woman takes 30 minutes to 'put on makeup' or won't leave the house without war paint. If they can't discuss things without shrieking if we have different views, if they don't laugh, if you can't imagine them putting others first, if they are more interested in dancing than a cosy night in and if they can't admit to making mistakes ever, then it's a no go war zone. I guess I am pleased I went out with one of those types because I know what the warning signs are now

I know women who arent beautiful who do this. I also know women who are beautiful and are highly intelligent, socially skilled, have a great sense of humour and modest.

You are being silly to assume its only "beautiful" women who do this and it comes across as being somewhat bitter by categorising all women who are attractive as "one of those types".

You could well be right. It's just my experience. I didnt mean that all women who are attractive are like it, perhaps I was venting a long suppressed setbof difficult memories

SummerSnowstorm · 28/07/2024 21:09

You can improve looks. Spend some of your hard earned money on yourself. Hire a stylist, hire a make up artist to teach you techniques, book in with a professional salon to get your hair done and product matched.
Start getting your nails done, use face masks, start an exercise plan.
You can't change everything, but effort and money are a large part of physical appearance.

mansviewpoint · 28/07/2024 21:05

STARCATCHER22 · 28/07/2024 08:14

Most of your issues with this beautiful woman (the fact that you’ve called her a teenager is very concerning and says a lot more about you than her…) are nothing to do with her looks. You chose her because of her looks and then complain that she takes care of herself (taking half an hour to get ready is not a long time at all) and if she didn’t laugh… maybe you’re not as funny as you think you are. There’s nothing wrong with wanting to go out dancing (particularly if you were dating a teenager…).

You say that they “acted like a child” but I’d be interested to know how old they were and how much older you were… If you date much younger women to make yourself feel good, they probably won’t be interested in having children and may not be that mature yet.

Firstly you have made many many assumptions . Secondly I have never dated anyone younger than me but i will try to explain the situation. I was 18 and she was 24. She chose me first. She asked me out. I like women who are self assertive and so I thought that we might be able to form a life together. She knew before she asked me out that I wasn't into one night stands and just wanted long term relationships. She was a PhD student at the same university. Makeup: To go literally across a road to the corner shop is a 30 second walk, yet it would take her 30 minutes to get ready even though she was fully dresse and already had lippy and a bit of foundation on. Humour... I am unfortunately quite funny as it was the only way for my bullies to stop punching me, chineese burns, stabbing me with compasses for 2 hrs every day. but I know that humour is subjective and that this doesn't suit everyone. However in the 6 ish weeks we dated she didn't laugh at anything. Nothing on the tele, nothing or anyone in real life. I asked her if she found things funny and her answer was 'rarely'. Wanting to go out every single night when you are both students is not sustainable, I completely agree that going to a night club twice a week is fine , which is as much as i could afford and whilst being a student you do actually have to do course work and revision. When we would get to the club at 10 he would spend at least 1 and a half hours redoing her make up and would get a bit of a hump if she didnt get someone try to hit on her. Teenager beaviour:
She was naturally very beautiful but couldn't see it in herself and needed external validation. Every day she would ask my housemates if she looked beautiful at least twice a day. She asked me 'why don't you get jealous when boys hit on me?' I said that I couldn't be jealous because of course they are going to hit on you look at you. "Yeah but don't you worry?" I responded with... if you were taking them into the toilets or started kissing them then I'd be worried. At which point she called me a f ING pussy and threw herself on the floor as a child wood do.
I left my own bedroom and slept downstairs. The breakup and retaliation: She said that if I wasn't getting angry that she went off and danced without me then I wasn't a man. Ten minutes later I broke up with her saying that I don't want to feel like I have to pretend to be angry because you want me to be. I said that isn't right. You shouldn't be seeking that kind of attention. Following day she spread a rumour that I was gay and couslnt get it up for her.. which I couldn't give 2 stuffs about. There were then a few other rumours which she started and then the final straw that I had a rape conviction. I phoned the police... who to begin with being 1995 and me a man just told me to get over it and there was no record. I then had to spend 2 years trying to avoid her because if she saw me she'd start yelling at me. I don't know if that's enough detail or not but I can only tell you how It was for me. Perhaps I made it sound worse than it was, but I really do have a very good memory and I do think the above is an honest account. There will obviously be bits In that relationship where I wasn't the angel, I do remember for example she had asked me to get some lemonade as me and my housemates were going to Tesco, and I completely forgot, but I apologised and she never brought it or anything else.real.up in an argument.. only ever the desire for me to be angry or jealous.

XChrome · 28/07/2024 20:56

shuggles · 28/07/2024 20:13

@IpsyUpsyDaisyDoos I don't think anyone is saying "it's better to be ugly". For one thing, attractiveness is subjective.

Actually, that is what people have been saying. Which is why it's a good idea to read the thread before making such a blanket statement.

Example 1: "Now I'm much older and larger, I am invisible to those kinds of men. It's glorious. I can walk through the world without them noticing me or hassling me, and thank fuck for that."

Example 2: "I am in my 60s now, and seem to have joined the invisible older woman club. And it is liberating, exhilarating, I love the fact that most men gaze straight past me. I don't miss the objectification or attention in public one bit."

And there are other examples beyond that.

Would I be happier if I were more attractive? Would I be more successful? Who knows.

Statistically, the evidence shows that the answer to both questions would be "yes."

Edited

So you think being in one's sixties and being older and larger are synonomys for "ugly?" 🤔

At any rate, those are people saying how they feel. They aren't statements of belief about what is better in general.

shuggles · 28/07/2024 20:13

@IpsyUpsyDaisyDoos I don't think anyone is saying "it's better to be ugly". For one thing, attractiveness is subjective.

Actually, that is what people have been saying. Which is why it's a good idea to read the thread before making such a blanket statement.

Example 1: "Now I'm much older and larger, I am invisible to those kinds of men. It's glorious. I can walk through the world without them noticing me or hassling me, and thank fuck for that."

Example 2: "I am in my 60s now, and seem to have joined the invisible older woman club. And it is liberating, exhilarating, I love the fact that most men gaze straight past me. I don't miss the objectification or attention in public one bit."

And there are other examples beyond that.

Would I be happier if I were more attractive? Would I be more successful? Who knows.

Statistically, the evidence shows that the answer to both questions would be "yes."

Yourdemonsyourproblem · 28/07/2024 20:02

Not tooting my own horn but I'm pretty, like Kim k pretty and you're right there is such thing as pretty privilege, getting a lot of things free and men helping you ect however I get a lot of hate, I've had so many issues with neighbours or other women and creepy men. So it's not all that great I know if I didn't look the way I do I wouldn't have so much bother from others.

IpsyUpsyDaisyDoos · 28/07/2024 19:18

shuggles · 28/07/2024 18:59

@TwigletsAndRadishes "Whatabout, whatabout, whatabout..."

That's irrelevant to my point, which is that attractive people are immensely advantaged compared to unattractive people. People trying to flip that around to argue that actually, it's better to be ugly, are completely disconnected from the real world.

If it's true that life is better if you're ugly, then why is it the case that the majority of people, both men and women, try to look presentable and the best version of themselves? How many men and women intentionally make themselves appear more ugly?

I don't think anyone is saying "it's better to be ugly". For one thing, attractiveness is subjective.

But what they are saying is to not compare yourself to other people. And if you're going to, it can't be solely on whether or not you or they are attractive and the impact that has/will have on your life.

For example, I have a great job, I own a home in a lovely area, I have a wonderful husband and a beautiful daughter (who I think one day people will say has pretty privilege...). Good friends, great family.

Would I be happier if I were more attractive? Would I be more successful? Who knows. It could be a worse scenario. I work in a very analytical position, where I need to be taken seriously. Would I be? Would my lovely husband have actually been attracted to me if I looked different?

None of it matters if you're happy with your life. And that happiness isn't solely based on how attractive you are.

THAT is what people are saying.

shuggles · 28/07/2024 18:59

@TwigletsAndRadishes "Whatabout, whatabout, whatabout..."

That's irrelevant to my point, which is that attractive people are immensely advantaged compared to unattractive people. People trying to flip that around to argue that actually, it's better to be ugly, are completely disconnected from the real world.

If it's true that life is better if you're ugly, then why is it the case that the majority of people, both men and women, try to look presentable and the best version of themselves? How many men and women intentionally make themselves appear more ugly?

TwigletsAndRadishes · 28/07/2024 18:46

shuggles · 28/07/2024 16:11

@Cookiecrumblane Agreed. Beautiful men and women who pretend that they're the victim in some weird convoluted way are completely unhinged and disconnected from the reality.

The data shows that people who are attractive are more likely to have career success, higher earnings, and have friends and relationships. No one can argue with facts.

Well if that's how you measure Pretty Privilege then let's talk about Intelligence Privilege. Social Capital Privilege. Two Married Parents Privilege. Able Bodied Privilege. Good Speller Privilege. Charm and Personality Privilege. Confidence Privilege. Nice Accent Privilege. The Natural Athletic Privilege that successful sportspeople have that most of us aren't blessed with, meaning that they were always picked first to be on the school team and I never was. So what?

A while ago I read an article about white privilege as seen from a black perspective. Twenty years ago, a young black man might have said 'Can you imagine how it feels, having the same capability and the same qualifications as everyone else on the interview panel but not getting the job and always wondering if it's because I am black?'

Whereas this particular young black man did have the job. And he said 'can you imagine how it feels, having to go into work each day always wondering if I didn't actually get my job on merit, but because the employer needed to fill some BAME quota?'

XChrome · 28/07/2024 18:24

LiterallyOnFire · 28/07/2024 05:22

You don't sound much better than OP TBH.

That women is "a fuck up" because she's lost her job and can't pay her rent? Delightful take.

She lost it because of a series of mistakes. She fucked up repeatedly. People who fuck up repeatedly are known as fuckups.
Now go pound sand.

Yalta · 28/07/2024 18:22

TheYearOfSmallThings · 28/07/2024 10:12

I work extremely hard at my gig type job. I am more than capable of rising through the ranks and probably understand better than most what is needed to be done beyond what is written down on the paperwork

However at 60+ and definitely not someone with good bone structure I know I am never even going to get a supervisor role because as the people they promote are all good looking and young and judging by what I am asked lack a basic understanding of the role

I don't want to be unkind, and I am saying this as a fellow middle aged woman with no discernable bone structure at any age. The gig economy is no place to be working when you are 60. There are jobs that are great when you are 20 (regardless of looks) but you need to plan something different for when you are older, because yes, by the time you are 60 people judge you on where you are rather than your future potential. I would get nowhere in the kind of job you are talking about, but those beautiful young women would not get my job either. Hopefully they have a plan that will take them into a more secure work environment as they get older.

Interested to know what type of job do you think I should do?

Newgreendress · 28/07/2024 17:30

They crossed the street to walk closer to her.

I bet Wayne Couzens crossed the road for plenty of women, too

Sugarsugarahhoneyhoney · 28/07/2024 17:08

Iasonnas · 28/07/2024 12:18

"She was distraught, but even with all that was going on, she was served first and efficiently in the bar. Men held doors and beamed at her. They crossed the street to walk closer to her."

What the fuck did I just read?

Something out a novel lol

IpsyUpsyDaisyDoos · 28/07/2024 16:55

Cookiecrumblane · 28/07/2024 15:53

I think it's very different if you have been beautiful and hated it. How do you know you would have loved being constantly overlooked, passed by, to have feelings for someone just to be told they want you to set them up with your mate, be told by pretty much every guy that you're perfect for them but that they want to find someone 'just like you' but not 'you' obviously. How do you know how you would feel to see yourself in photos, the fat, dumpy friend surrounded by five tall, athletic beauties? How do you know you'd have preferred to leave every single night out alone, with no numbers, no attention, whilst your friends are beating the men off with sticks whilst already having a perfectly lovely husband or boyfriend at home.

Turn that around.

How do you know things would be better? How do you know you wouldn't be miserable about your looks for a different reason (people assuming you're thick, not taking you seriously in your career, not wanting a partnership with you because you're just a trophy).

You can apply all your logic to either scenario. Because no one has it perfect.

shuggles · 28/07/2024 16:11

@Cookiecrumblane Agreed. Beautiful men and women who pretend that they're the victim in some weird convoluted way are completely unhinged and disconnected from the reality.

The data shows that people who are attractive are more likely to have career success, higher earnings, and have friends and relationships. No one can argue with facts.

Wendycoping · 28/07/2024 16:06

Cookiecrumblane · 28/07/2024 16:03

@Wendycoping you sound unhinged. They're my friends, I'm happy they're beautiful.

360!

Cookiecrumblane · 28/07/2024 16:03

@Wendycoping you sound unhinged. They're my friends, I'm happy they're beautiful.

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread