Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be tired of being squeezed?

146 replies

squeeeezedmiddle · 25/07/2024 20:49

I’m knackered and letting off steam perhaps but here goes: is anyone else tired of being the squeezed middle? I don’t know how other people manage without help from their families or inherited wealth.

DH and I both work in public sector middle income jobs, we don’t get bonuses or profit shares or anything like that. Neither of us comes from wealth and we haven’t had any inheritance nor do we expect anything. We’ve worked and saved and it still feels like we’re just scraping by. We’ve two DCs (5 and 2) and live in a 2 bed rental in London. I’ve worked part time since the DCs were born as childcare is so expensive so my wage will go up somewhat in a couple of years when the youngest is in school but nothing to really change our lives.

With the summer holidays I feel so much pressure and they’re both growing so quickly I’m constantly buying replacement clothes and shoes. Everything for the DCs and myself is secondhand (including clothes, toys, bicycle, etc) and much of DH as well. We haven’t any hobbies, I don’t have a gym membership or go to the hairdressers etc. We don’t eat out much, no takeouts but Nando’s once a month (I get a discount through my work.) I don’t have any more corners to cut.

i know we are relatively privileged, we have two incomes and no debts. But I would love to be in a position where I wasn’t constantly thinking about how much is in our bank account and whether the few quid I spend on a small toy for the DCs is going to impact my retirement. Our outgoings are low but our wages are too.

im sure I’ll get slammed for this but I wonder if there are others feeling the same way. I’m not trying to take attention from those on benefits, I know plenty need more help than we do (and should get it) but it’s just bloody exhausting and im feeling a bit hopeless at the momemnt.

OP posts:
TheThingIsYeah · 29/07/2024 11:19

Telling OP to just "move out of London" is an interesting one. Who takes her place when she sells up? Where are all these people with the means to live in London and where does their money come from? Despite what MÑ would have you believe, the amount of workers on £100k+ is a tiny percentage.

It's very sad when people who have grown up in London for the sole reason it's become so unaffordable. And galling to see people being housed in nice new apartments for free when OP would have 0% chance of getting one if she put herself on the housing list. But there you go.

MidnightPatrol · 29/07/2024 10:53

Comedycook · 28/07/2024 20:27

Exactly...in some areas of London, a two bed terrace with a tiny backyard is for the well off!

Tiny two-bed terrace with a backyard £800k-£1m here.

Even more if the attic has been converted into an extra bedroom.

FrogHoppingFreezer · 29/07/2024 10:07

Sharing another perspective. Especially as you say moving isn't feasible at the moment.

If you moved out, you would probably get a bigger place, but I wonder if you would save much money after commute cost? For example, I live in Cambridgeshire (not Cambridge itself) and I used to live in a standard 3 bed terrace with tiny back garden. This has just been listed for £1500 per month. I don't think the location I live is particularly expensive. People have suggested you move within a commutable distance to your job, but I wonder whether that would really "save" money.

The other thing that happens with many landlords these days is yearly rent increases to keep things in line with the market rate. For example, when I moved into that 3 bed 5 years ago I paid £900 a month. One of the reasons I moved was because he kept increasing the rent every year.

Moving won't necessarily solve all your issues - unless you do move somewhere with massively cheaper rent. Or you decide to find another tiny flat. Or you change your job location too so you don't need to commute (which could mean a pay cut).

Things are genuinely shit for a lot of people moneywise. Do you think you or your partner could change jobs to the private sector and get a boost in pay that way? The civil service is massively underpaid and you would probably get a huge salary bump in a similar role elsewhere.

Comedycook · 28/07/2024 20:27

ReformMyArse · 28/07/2024 19:10

It IS different now. The young people, in many areas, can’t afford to buy that 2 bed terrace with a tiny backyard or anything near it. At all. So they are stuck in rent traps with ever rising bills and no disposable income (like the op) or at home with their parents and buying the lattes and cars but no asset.

Exactly...in some areas of London, a two bed terrace with a tiny backyard is for the well off!

ReformMyArse · 28/07/2024 19:10

IamMoodyBlue · 28/07/2024 13:04

I understand absolutely what you are saying.
We first set ip house many years ago. It was very tight but we both worked, & carefully calculated we could afford the mortgage, & the bills. So we got a small, old 2 bed terraced, with a tiny backyard. We had no washing machine, ( used the bath) no vacuum cleaner, ( dustpan & brush) no TV. No wardrobes. ( cardboard boxes.) Lots of other things people take for granted, ( new clothes, holidays, more than 1 pair of shoes, heating) we didn’t have. But we could save a little and gradually improved our lot. Then interest rates started rising, ( we paid upto 17%) and inflation at stupid %.
We too had no more corners to cut , no credit cards to fall back on.
So what is happening now is nothing new. It was soul destroying then; for anyone going through it now, it's so hard. It was years & years before we could sleep easily without worrying about bills.

It IS different now. The young people, in many areas, can’t afford to buy that 2 bed terrace with a tiny backyard or anything near it. At all. So they are stuck in rent traps with ever rising bills and no disposable income (like the op) or at home with their parents and buying the lattes and cars but no asset.

Despair1 · 28/07/2024 18:20

DoIWantTo · 26/07/2024 09:57

Unless you’ve got an endless pit of money, it’s entirely normal to be worrying about money. Plus the fact you’re working part time hours with young children - assuming you looked at the cost of having children prior to having them and ignored the fact that it’d drastically reduce your income for you to be here moaning about how expensive kids are now.

Unkind and unnecessary

TheYearOfSmallThings · 28/07/2024 13:14

When I think back I've just been quietly downgrading my lifestyle for several years now.

Same! But I don't want to leave London, where we have lots of really solid friends, to take a chance on a more affordable area. If we were renting I don't think staying would be an option though.

IamMoodyBlue · 28/07/2024 13:04

I understand absolutely what you are saying.
We first set ip house many years ago. It was very tight but we both worked, & carefully calculated we could afford the mortgage, & the bills. So we got a small, old 2 bed terraced, with a tiny backyard. We had no washing machine, ( used the bath) no vacuum cleaner, ( dustpan & brush) no TV. No wardrobes. ( cardboard boxes.) Lots of other things people take for granted, ( new clothes, holidays, more than 1 pair of shoes, heating) we didn’t have. But we could save a little and gradually improved our lot. Then interest rates started rising, ( we paid upto 17%) and inflation at stupid %.
We too had no more corners to cut , no credit cards to fall back on.
So what is happening now is nothing new. It was soul destroying then; for anyone going through it now, it's so hard. It was years & years before we could sleep easily without worrying about bills.

Jenkibubble · 28/07/2024 08:40

MidnightPatrol · 25/07/2024 20:52

You have my sympathies.

IMO London is verging on entirely unaffordable now for raising a family. The birth rate has dropped by about 20% there in 10 years - no wonder really.

Between housing and childcare costs, there’s not going to be much left over from even a pretty big household income.

£2-3k on housing plus £2-3k on childcare means you need a dual income household of £100k just to cover the basics with young children and work. Ludicrous.

Edited

Presumably living in London will at some point become a privilege of the rich (with pockets of those who can live with support from the state eg social housing ) This is in no way meant as a slur !
No inbetween I mean !
Move out of London - look at where can be accessed on fast trains (where I live it is 50 mins )

Not a nice area IMO and I’m desperate to leave , but commuter towns do exist and many are nice !
All the best x

DevilsKitchen · 26/07/2024 16:33

The problem is not your income. The problem is that you are living in central London and that you had children before buying a house. These things are both choices but we all make choices and have to live with the side effects of the choices we make.

Our household income is similar. Our mortgage is £537/month on a 3 bed with a garage and garden. We choose to live here - “here” is a small town in Essex with a lot less going on but also where DH grew up so his parents and school friends are here. We chose this for the affordability and support network. The side effects are fewer employment opportunities and less to do.

I work in local govt, my husband at the local university.

honeyfox · 26/07/2024 15:48

A plan needs to be made as that rent is going to be increased at some stage, or the landlord may decide to sell.

Comedycook · 26/07/2024 15:40

If the op lives fairly centrally and her rent is £1800, that's not bad. I just had a look at two bed flats in zone 6 down the road from me and they are going for £2k plus

Hellskitchen24 · 26/07/2024 15:39

You live in one of the most expensive cities in Europe. You know what the answer is.

PregnantWithHorrors · 26/07/2024 15:23

Agree, you just can't afford to be cental in London.

AvrielFinch · 26/07/2024 15:01

Very few families who are not rich can afford to live in Central London. We have an income that is way way less than you and yet have a better lifestyle.

Mischance · 26/07/2024 14:57

London strikes me as a very nice place if you have plenty of money but really grim if you don't. - summed up by a previous poster. Time to start looking a bit further afield, where life and costs are more within the bounds of sanity.

Mischance · 26/07/2024 14:55

You both have CVs full of public sector experience.

You need to get out of London and look for new jobs where house prices and the general cost of living is reasonable. Try a market town in Midlands or S Wales or north of England.

Living in London is a drain on your lives in every possible way. Get out from there. Start making plans/looking for jobs/researching housing costs and schools.

Your current situation is unsustainable if you all want some decent quality of life.

BallaiLuimni · 26/07/2024 14:50

Hang in there and stay on the lookout for ways to make things better - higher paying jobs, an opportunity to move, a side hustle whatever.

You're still in the survival years of child rearing - as they get older it definitely gets easier to think clearly about other steps you can take to improve your situation. My kids are 11 and 13 and my living setup is nothing at all like it was when my kids were 4 and 2 - it's amazing the difference a few years can make if you're open to opportunities.

You're doing fine for now, so don't be too hard on yourself.

AndAnotherThingToo · 26/07/2024 14:42

This has always been how normal life is though, The difference is that now you compare your life with others because of social media. Life was actually much harder in the past for average families.
in the case of the OP though, you are incredibly lucky to be paying 1800 a month and had no increase for 9 years! Thst is the most concerning issue, If your landlord sells (and lots are now because of the new government’s hatred of landlords) you won’t find anywhere central for that!

Greategret · 26/07/2024 14:42

People go on about all the culture and everything London has to offer but if you're scrimping that much I don't imagine you're actually enjoying or able to take advantage of those things. As a foreigner, London strikes me as a very nice place if you have plenty of money but really grim if you don't.

IpsyUpsyDaisyDoos · 26/07/2024 14:29

MidnightMeltdown · 26/07/2024 14:17

But people have made a deliberate choice to go into a career that constrains them in terms of movement, and that has obvious consequences.

I'm sure that many people would like to access the career opportunities available in London, but they don't because they can't afford to live there. Everybody cannot live in London. Business need to branch out to other regions.

It's partly the government's fault because they need to invest more in other regions. Ridiculous that HS2 was scrapped for example.7

Midlands to Manchester was scrapped.

Those between Midlands and London are still very much living with the disruption of it being built for very little benefit.

gardenmusic · 26/07/2024 14:29

OP may I ask how part time?
Is it days per week or hours per day?
Is there any opportunity to top up your part time work, and not affect your child care ?

IpsyUpsyDaisyDoos · 26/07/2024 14:26

MidnightMeltdown · 26/07/2024 14:02

This. Having young children has always been expensive so you should expect that your disposable income will be limited during these early years. However, you've made it harder for yourself by living in London.

I don't think it's fair to blame parents for living where a large chunk of work in the UK is based.

The saturation of businesses being based in one tiny circle of the country is not the fault of the employees.

MidnightMeltdown · 26/07/2024 14:17

TheDisillusionedAnarchist · 26/07/2024 09:56

I think people forget there are jobs that are tied to London, working on the tube for instance and yes you can move out and commute in but London commuter belt especially for extreme shifts such as the tube or healthcare is often difficult (trains that get in by 6 on a Sunday morning?)

We’ve left London with those type of jobs but with a commute, the cost of the season ticket and hotels for those extreme weekend shifts we’re better off in neither money nor time, really only better off in living space. I get a coach at 3am to get to work on time and I get home at 2300. I can’t say my quality of life has improved.

But people have made a deliberate choice to go into a career that constrains them in terms of movement, and that has obvious consequences.

I'm sure that many people would like to access the career opportunities available in London, but they don't because they can't afford to live there. Everybody cannot live in London. Business need to branch out to other regions.

It's partly the government's fault because they need to invest more in other regions. Ridiculous that HS2 was scrapped for example.7

MidnightMeltdown · 26/07/2024 14:02

Hankunamatata · 25/07/2024 22:05

It's living in London or south east. Housing isn't affordable on most average incomes

This. Having young children has always been expensive so you should expect that your disposable income will be limited during these early years. However, you've made it harder for yourself by living in London.