Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Parents not wanting to parent/tell their child no

189 replies

HappyWorkingMummy · 25/07/2024 07:54

I truly want to know if I am being unreasonable here.

I have loads of experiences with my primary age children's friends and their parents where their parents don't say no to their children and I then do so.

Examples:

Their primary aged child is breaking my children's toys with intention on a play date, parent says nothing and I have to interject.

Their primary aged child is going through my handbag and my personal belongings (keys, card etc) and their parent just sits there and says nothing so I have to interject and say no and tell the child why.

We are out at a restaurant and their primary aged kid runs about all over causing other customers to look frustrated and also walks round the table we are at and starts eating my dinner from my plate with their hands and parent says nothing. I have to find a way to interject.

In shops/gift shops one primary ages child screams if he can't get what he wants and the parent just buys it for him to stop the screaming. The child now knows that screaming and refusing to leave and throwing things off shelves in shops until he gets what he wants works. When the parents are there too my partner and I just walk away with our children and wait outside after we have for what we want (if we buy anything). If it's just me/my partner without the parents there then I/we tell the child we are looking after (not our own but on a play date) to pick the items up they have thrown on the floor and make clear the child will not be getting any treats if the behaviour continues. It works and the child behaves (for a while at least) but the child's own parents never do this.

At a story time event and children are asked to sit on the rug and listen but primary aged child runs and shouts all round the room spoiling things for the other children and parents say nothing... the person running story time tells them to behave each week and looks frustrated.

I also notice that if I ask a child not to do something and they then ask their parents if they can do it, their parent will say ask X (me!). Well, I've already told them no and the parent heard that but is refusing to reinforce it and simply doesn't want to parent.

I don't want to keep having to say no to their child! I've already said no.

These are just a few small examples but I'm noticing so often. I also notice it falls into two camps in our friendship group. The first are the parents who just want an easy life and don't especially want the 'inconvenience' of their child or dealing with their child's moods and negative feelings etc and the second are the parents who think their children can do no wrong and never say no to them.

Are my partner and I horrid parents for raising our children with boundaries (their own while also respecting other peoples)?

We are surrounded by so many parents who don't say no and their child/rens' behaviour impacts negatively on our kids and us too on days out etc,

These kids are neurotypical and, anyway, it's not about the kids' behaviour here (they are kids!) but rather about the fact we have so many friends who never tell their kids no or stop and so we have to sometimes when impacting on us.

How do you deal with this situation where friends' primary aged kids are misbehaving and it's impacting you directly but their parents don't say a peep?

Also, are we too harsh with our own kids?

Should we let our children run wherever they want, let them go through friends' personal possessions, break friends' toys with intention, leave their own dinner and eat someone else's dinner in a restaurant uninvited because they decided when it arrived they wanted that more?

These are just a few examples.

It's frustrating having to repeatedly put boundaries in place with other people's children while parenting your own simply because their kids have no/few boundaries but, even more so, my partner and I are wondering if we are too strict with our children because we DO have these boundaries in place (we know it's a way not only to respect other people but for our kids to respect themselves and feel healthy and secure. No can be good sometimes!).

Would love to hear thoughts.

OP posts:
Bobbybobbins · 25/07/2024 08:40

I am a secondary school teacher and think this is one if the broadest, biggest issues that causes poor behaviour. You can tell when a child has been brought up with firm boundaries.

itainthalfhot · 25/07/2024 08:39

can i clarity... is this just one parent/child or is this multiple parents and children? i'm getting the vibe that its the same parent/child each time and if thats the case, then i wouldn't be spending so much time with said parent/child if you do not like their behaviour.

what is the parent like with you when you police their child?

every parent, parents differently, just because you do it your way, does not make it wrong!

Meadowfinch · 25/07/2024 08:36

None of my friends' or family's children behave like that, and they'd be told very quickly to behave themselves if they did.

I wouldn't want to go out with families who allow that sort of behaviour because it would ruin every outing. Perhaps you need a different friendship group.

Crystallizedring · 25/07/2024 08:35

It's not just primary school kids. I used to work with nursery age kids and from toddler age you could work out which children were never told no.
All week was spent getting these children to accept meant no. By Friday they got it but our work was unraveled every weekend. Obviously not all the kids but quite a few.

NotAlexa · 25/07/2024 08:34

HappyWorkingMummy · 25/07/2024 08:30

Thanks for this.

We usually think so too but are starting to question ourselves when seeing so much permissiveness and wondering if too harsh.

It's also uncomfortable at times eg our kids sitting eating in restaurant and friend's kids running all over the place.

We do think it's best our kids can sit nicely but also wonder how it feels for our kids when they see their friends doing whatever they want?

We want our kids to be happy and healthy.

Can't speak for all kids, but as a kid i remember feeling totally embarrassed being near other kids who would get tantrums because their parents wouldn't get them something. And then if they got it because their parents wanted them to shut up, I would give my mum a look ( my mum told me) and basically never be friends with them again.

I would assume your kids understand that deep inside. Keep doing what you are doing, and you will be pleasantly surprised with the quality of friendships they will be striking themselves when older.

HappyWorkingMummy · 25/07/2024 08:33

theemmadilemma · 25/07/2024 08:32

What you've described is literally why my young niece has decided against having children. She doesn't want to fight the tide of lack of parenting today.

🤷‍♀️

That's a real shame if that's her main/only reason.

Don't let other people out her off having kids if she wants to!

OP posts:
prescribingmum · 25/07/2024 08:33

HappyWorkingMummy · 25/07/2024 08:15

Yes we do this.

The child who kept trying to break the toys at our home (among other things) has not been invited back since. That hasn't been hard to implement as we were never invited to their home anyway, ever. Again, I think this is part of the problem as their parent wanted an easy life (we made plans and arranged stuff, we cooked, we 'parented' their child - not through choice - when hanging out).

That friendship has drifted through choice because we were making all of the effort and the parents expectations were too high of us while they did nothing!

But there are other friendships that we want to maintain and want to know how to navigate telling other peoples kids no!

If it is the friendship with the parents you want to maintain, I would just socialise without the children until they are older.

I completely see where you are coming from and find it absolutely infuriating when parents allow their children to run riot as my children get caught up in the excitement and I have to be really firm to get them to stop. I have no issues with telling their child no in that moment but just refuse to put myself in a position where I am the default parent for all the next time we meet up

ChimpanzeeThatMonkeyNews · 25/07/2024 08:32

I've been there, so i know it's unpleasant.

theemmadilemma · 25/07/2024 08:32

What you've described is literally why my young niece has decided against having children. She doesn't want to fight the tide of lack of parenting today.

🤷‍♀️

HappyWorkingMummy · 25/07/2024 08:32

aesoplover · 25/07/2024 08:31

I had a coffee morning once where one of the children wanted to go in the garden. We were very obviously having building work done either lots of dangerous items and extremely muddy. Parent still asked if child could go out there. When I said no due to the above, she allowed him to open my cupboards and play with all my crockery - he smashed two items on the floor. No apology or offer to buy new although she did clear it up.

🙄

What's wrong with people?!

OP posts:
HappyWorkingMummy · 25/07/2024 08:31

ChimpanzeeThatMonkeyNews · 25/07/2024 08:28

You're allowed to tell these kids 'no', even if their parents can't be arsed to do it themselves.

When they're breaking your children's toys, and messing around in your handbag, OP.

Give them an age appropriate bollocking - like you would to your own kids.

Thanks

We just wish their parents could be arsed/dared to say no!

OP posts:
aesoplover · 25/07/2024 08:31

I had a coffee morning once where one of the children wanted to go in the garden. We were very obviously having building work done either lots of dangerous items and extremely muddy. Parent still asked if child could go out there. When I said no due to the above, she allowed him to open my cupboards and play with all my crockery - he smashed two items on the floor. No apology or offer to buy new although she did clear it up.

HappyWorkingMummy · 25/07/2024 08:30

NotAlexa · 25/07/2024 08:21

You are the best parents, believe me. I've seen the 'products' of other parenting style you are describing here, and trust me when I say it - they are pathetically dim-witted. I used to work in Admissions Office in Russel group University, and oh my god, the toddlers and teenagers that I've seen vs their parents' parenting styles just explained loads to me.

Children must learn boundaries, feeling of frustration, the word NO, the appropriate behaviour in public and respect for elderly/older. And i believe you and your partner are doing exactly that.

Thanks for this.

We usually think so too but are starting to question ourselves when seeing so much permissiveness and wondering if too harsh.

It's also uncomfortable at times eg our kids sitting eating in restaurant and friend's kids running all over the place.

We do think it's best our kids can sit nicely but also wonder how it feels for our kids when they see their friends doing whatever they want?

We want our kids to be happy and healthy.

OP posts:
ChimpanzeeThatMonkeyNews · 25/07/2024 08:28

You're allowed to tell these kids 'no', even if their parents can't be arsed to do it themselves.

When they're breaking your children's toys, and messing around in your handbag, OP.

Give them an age appropriate bollocking - like you would to your own kids.

HappyWorkingMummy · 25/07/2024 08:27

MiGatoEsBonitoTuGatoEsFeo · 25/07/2024 08:23

Oh come on OP with the wide eyed "Are my partner and I horrid parents for raising our children with boundaries (their own while also respecting other peoples)? 🥺👉👈"

😂

This is a genuine question.

We're surrounded by so much passive and/or permissive parenting In wondering if we are ogres for saying no!

OP posts:
HappyWorkingMummy · 25/07/2024 08:25

Strawberriesandpimms · 25/07/2024 08:24

DB/DSIL parented in a very similar way. They split when the DC were small but then coparented well, but I think neither of them wanted to be the bad guy and tell their DC "no" to anything so the DCs wants and needs ruled the roost in both households. The way he parented split up at least one of his subsequent relationships as the DPs couldn't support his way of parenting. His DCs were academically bright and sporty but didnt understand boundaries and resisted them, and struggled at school because of this. Neither have fully fledged as adults because they don't think boundaries at any job apply to them and everything is everyone elses fault. They think the world revolves around them. It's an odd mixture of passiveness and arrogance.
It's such a shame as I remember them as such funny and happy DCs when younger but do think the lack of enforcement of basic boundaries with them when young has caused them long term difficulties.

This is so sad for the kids.

One of the boys has no friends aside from our children. That's because his parents allow him to get away with anything and everything and so the school children have grown to dislike him.

OP posts:
cupcaske123 · 25/07/2024 08:25

If you want to maintain the friendships then see the parents without their children. Also limit what you do with them, for example go to a park or playground where they can tear around and are occupied. Don't go to a restaurant where they embarrass you and don't invite them to your home if they don't respect it. If they go through your personal belongings tell them off.

Mrsjayy · 25/07/2024 08:25

Well you are just going to have to tell them no yourself but are you really wanting to go out in public into eateries where children are being total pests?

HappyWorkingMummy · 25/07/2024 08:24

mitogoshi · 25/07/2024 08:21

Unfortunately this is common. Local pub has now banned children due to a few families who didn't control their children via the word no, even complaining at bar staff who did say "no you can't go behind the bar!"

This is exhausting!

When parents don't say no AND take issue with others who do for the sake of their kids' safety. Imagine what would happen if the child got bumped behind the bar or tripped and cut themselves on glass or whatever? The parents would likely be the first to complain!

OP posts:
Strawberriesandpimms · 25/07/2024 08:24

DB/DSIL parented in a very similar way. They split when the DC were small but then coparented well, but I think neither of them wanted to be the bad guy and tell their DC "no" to anything so the DCs wants and needs ruled the roost in both households. The way he parented split up at least one of his subsequent relationships as the DPs couldn't support his way of parenting. His DCs were academically bright and sporty but didnt understand boundaries and resisted them, and struggled at school because of this. Neither have fully fledged as adults because they don't think boundaries at any job apply to them and everything is everyone elses fault. They think the world revolves around them. It's an odd mixture of passiveness and arrogance.
It's such a shame as I remember them as such funny and happy DCs when younger but do think the lack of enforcement of basic boundaries with them when young has caused them long term difficulties.

MiGatoEsBonitoTuGatoEsFeo · 25/07/2024 08:23

Oh come on OP with the wide eyed "Are my partner and I horrid parents for raising our children with boundaries (their own while also respecting other peoples)? 🥺👉👈"

😂

HappyWorkingMummy · 25/07/2024 08:22

Desertislandparadise · 25/07/2024 08:12

The type of parents you are describing are, unfortunately, quite common. They are doing their children a real disservice.

If these are family members there's not much you can do about it, but if friends then try to form a different social group with more like-minded parents. Save meeting up with your old friends on child-free occasions.

They are all friends rather than family members. Our kids are in the same classes at school, they are neighbours etc so it's not simply a case of ending all friendships with people who don't tell their kids no.

We want to maintain friendships but find a way to shut down behaviour in a way that doesn't cause issues.

OP posts:
mitogoshi · 25/07/2024 08:21

Unfortunately this is common. Local pub has now banned children due to a few families who didn't control their children via the word no, even complaining at bar staff who did say "no you can't go behind the bar!"

NotAlexa · 25/07/2024 08:21

You are the best parents, believe me. I've seen the 'products' of other parenting style you are describing here, and trust me when I say it - they are pathetically dim-witted. I used to work in Admissions Office in Russel group University, and oh my god, the toddlers and teenagers that I've seen vs their parents' parenting styles just explained loads to me.

Children must learn boundaries, feeling of frustration, the word NO, the appropriate behaviour in public and respect for elderly/older. And i believe you and your partner are doing exactly that.

HappyWorkingMummy · 25/07/2024 08:19

fiskal · 25/07/2024 08:17

Just meet up without kids. I have one set of friends whose parenting I don't enjoy being around (not to do with behaviour management) and so I see them for adult time.

We meet with the kids because our children are friends too. We socialise together as families often.

I'm wondering more about navigating this situation and also how to put boundaries in place with other peoples kids with it causing any upset in friendships (thankfully there has been no upset this far).

OP posts: