Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

If you have confident children - how did you do it?

131 replies

Tiredsendcoffee · 24/07/2024 23:54

I feel we are in information overload and find myself constantly second guessing everything. My understanding regarding resilience in children is that there are two schools of thought, one is you nurture them and then they feel secure and confident (but on the other hand you might not be pushing them enough). The other is to push them out of their comfort zone so they gain confidence (but that then may leave them feeling anxious and insecure if they are not ready).

My DS has just turned 3 and is becoming more shy and clingy which is starting to concern me. I've tried to introduce changes at a slow pace but wonder if I've been doing the wrong thing.

My AIBU is that there is too much information and it is so confusing, but mostly I'm here for some help with those that have experience. Thank you.

OP posts:
Runsyd · 25/07/2024 09:55

I think the best combination is secure attachment to both parents but not protected from consequences in the outside world. So loving but firm parenting with clear boundaries, along with encouragement to take risks while recognising that they might fail and that's okay. Parental tolerance of negative emotions will go along way to enabling their kids to be able to tolerate them within themselves.

Anxiety, for instance, is normal in certain circumstances, a lack of it in any circumstances is pathological. Teaching your kids that it's normal and okay to feel anxious in new or challenging circumstances, but that it shouldn't dictate your choices ie. you don't duck out of a challenge because you're nervous, you feel the fear and do it anyway.

I think resilience is the most under-rated virtue and on a society-wide levels we're all suffering from the tidal wave of young adults who can't cope with even hearing something they don't like.

Tiredsendcoffee · 25/07/2024 09:55

@TheBirdintheCave Clowns are scary!

OP posts:
Msmumm · 25/07/2024 09:54

Nurture, reassurance and playing competitive sport as the grew up. It's teaches them resilience and to learn to problem solve for themselves. Once they realise that they can do this their confidence comes on in leaps and bounds.

Tiredsendcoffee · 25/07/2024 09:54

@OhBeAFineGuyKissMe yes I am going to make an appointment to see my Dr and see if I can figure out how to get some therapy. I know something isn't quite right with me, ironically I used to think I was super resilient but now the smallest thing sends me in a spin.

OP posts:
WasThatACorner · 25/07/2024 09:53

Tiredsendcoffee · 25/07/2024 00:20

@Aquamarine1029 I just saw something the other day where you shouldn't be reassuring your kids and trying to make them happy as then they don't learn to deal with that emotion and become anxious later as they 'fear' being worried or unhappy. But then it also seems counterintuitive as the first thing you want to do is comfort and reassure your child

I think if you can try to provide an impartial sounding board while they are processing their emotions they can learn more from the experiexperience than being left entirely to navigate it alone. Don't solve problems for them, don't hide problems from them when you are facing them and see what they actually need from you.

DS1 (16) will come to me when he wants to vent or just work through, he asks for opinions and advice and takes this on board. He is very flexible and open to changing his opinion and admitting that he was wrong and will laugh at himself.

DS2 (14) is much more self-contained and prefers to do his thinking alone. He is much more sensitive to criticism and gets very fixed on an idea.

DS3 (8) is ND and will often try to use me to externalise his feelings. However, he will discuss things and reflect after the fact which is when we do a what could we have done differently chat and explore the emotion that has been too much in the moment.

So, regardless of you deciding that your parenting style will be X, I think you will need to trust yourself to be guided by your child(ren) to a certain as extent. I haven't approached each of my boys differently, they have responded differently and I've adapted to that in order to meet their individual needs. Hopefully, they will all turn out OK.

TheBirdintheCave · 25/07/2024 09:51

As a person I became less shy once I became happier being myself so I'm trying to foster a good sense of self esteem in my three year old son.

Seems to be working so far! He's not afraid to talk to people or join in with activities. A far cry from the clingy and shy child I was!

The only things that makes him apprehensive are people in costume 😅

Tiredsendcoffee · 25/07/2024 09:50

The comments about twins are fascinating!

OP posts:
OhBeAFineGuyKissMe · 25/07/2024 09:50

OP you say you hardly recognise yourself since having kids and finding it hard with anxiety. As you said you panicked first and he then picked up on this. Then you tried to act like everything was OK so we’re sending out mixed messages which must have been very confusing for him.

Have you spoken to anyone about this?

Your world and body changes so much with pregnancy and a new baby it is easy to overlook your own needs, some of the anxiety could be unresolved PND.

You can speak to your dr or some areas have self referral to counselling. It can be really helpful.

CutthroatDruTheViolent · 25/07/2024 09:48

I have three boys. 15 yo twins and a 12 yo.

I wouldn't say I've done anything differently with them, but my 12 yo is the most confident child I think I've ever met - my older boys are not. None of them were particularly clingy during toddler-hood. For mine I'm pretty sure it stems from academic achievement - my older two are dyslexic and struggle a lot more than their brother. It's also just personality though - twin 1 is a lot quieter and less confident than twin 2.

TheaBrandt · 25/07/2024 09:41

You need to teach them social skills. Most valuable lesson ever. My mother instilled these in us was utter cringe at the time but gets you far in life. Far more important than violin lessons and further maths. You need to
model this too. Save yourself thousands in private school fees 😀

Didimum · 25/07/2024 09:38

They are what they are. One of my twins is incredibly confident and outgoing. The other is very shy and anxious. They have had the same upbringing, same class at school and same experiences. This didn’t develop over time, it was clear from age 18m up, if not before.

Adviceneeeeded · 25/07/2024 09:38

@decionsdecisions62 that's true. Resilience comes from experience and dealing with situations.

I would say I'm quite Resilient due to dealing with some serious things since young. I would also say I'm confident because I had to trust myself to deal with these situations.

Completely agree with you

Galoop · 25/07/2024 09:36

decionsdecisions62 · 25/07/2024 08:43

Resilience and confidence are two different things. I have confident girls but they are not particularly resilient.

Very true

mamajong · 25/07/2024 09:33

My kids are confident teens, and we have been purposeful about building resilience by giving them regular opportunities to step out of their comfort zone and rewarding their efforts. If they wanted stuff from the gift shop on a day out, they needed to go in the queue and pay for it themselves or not have it, a simple calm choice. They ordered their own food at restaurants from a young age and we also equipped them with life skills such as swimming, making a sandwich, putting on their bedding etc which made them feel capable.

That said, we are a confident, extraverted couple, both DP and I are big personalities who enjoy connecting with people so I don't know how much is nature and how much is nurture tbh. I do think though that anxiety breeds anxiety and, based on my own observations only, the people I know who are 'helicopter' parents who do everything for their kids in my social.group, seem.to have the least confident teens.

Tiredsendcoffee · 25/07/2024 09:33

Immemorialelms · 25/07/2024 09:21

I often find with my children I'm projecting. I know I'm thirsty when I keep shoving drinks in their faces, for example. Could this be YOUR anxiety you are experiencing but feeling it as a problem for him? I'm not being critical of you, more saying that's a natural thing to happen. But you could disentangle your adult feelings of anxiety from his 3 year old reactions. He might cry when his friend isn't there. Big emotions, right?! It's probably the equivalent of being dumped or having a holiday cancelled to a 50 year old. A day of his life is worth about 3 years of mine in terms of the experience it compares with.
But that doesn't mean he is not resilient. Just comfort him and let him be him. The only thing that seems key for humans is having their emotions validated.

You're absolutely right. I myself noticed his friends bag missing and assumed he was sick, then went into a bit of a panic thinking my son would panic. Cue my son then looking confused, the teacher then saying something and reacting, me trying to act all is ok. Ugh, total fail on my part. But yes, you're absolutely right.

OP posts:
dbeuowlxb173939 · 25/07/2024 09:32

I think the most important thing is making sure he's secure. He's too young to be forced to do things he's not comfortable with but give him lots of praise for things he's good at.
I don't think it's as simple as deciding to raise a confident child, all children are different and have different personalities. I was a shy child and still quite shy but i am very resilient and confident in situations I feel comfortable in.
My children are similar I think. At the moment we're working on ordering for themselves in restaurants!

Luxembourgmama · 25/07/2024 09:32

Being in crèche and wraparound care where they had to speak to other adults helped. Also allowing them to talk, listening when we have family dinners etc

SmileLady · 25/07/2024 09:31

And I agree from the poster whi said working. It's important to work. That builds a whole other level.of resilience.

SmileLady · 25/07/2024 09:29

My older 3 children are confident outgoing and are able to adapt themselves to the situation they are in..I truly belive this has come from playing team sports outside of school. They have a group of friends they have to make the effort to maintain contact with. The youngest is not interested at all. She is confident in a completely different way. She is wilfully and stubborn. Whereas the older 3 are what I describe as "casually confident" like they take everything in their stride and maintain a curiosity to their surroundings.

I also make sure to explain the correct definition of something. Even this week one was listening to a central C song and they referred to "Traps being open on Xmas day" and asked what this was. I explained it to them. I am aware that they all have Internet access and may be told the wrong thing on line.

Me and DH have also worked hard to make a life in the UK and be confident adults. Even when we don't feel it. Imposter syndrome.

Icanttakethisanymore · 25/07/2024 09:29

My brother was a very shy child (he's fine as an adult) but I was always very confident. We had very similar upbringings. I think a lot of it comes down to nature, not nurture.

Tiredsendcoffee · 25/07/2024 09:27

StellaLaBella · 25/07/2024 05:55

I think personality, school, parenting style (i.e allowing them to make their own mistakes/trusting their judgement) all play a part, but I saw a TikTok recently referencing a study that found the most self confident, resilient kids generally were ones who worked from a young teen on, and I can see from my own how that has shaped them. Because let's face it, when you have a job as a 14/15yo, you're going to deal with some shit. Learning how to navigate that is a great lesson in finding your worth, and how you can relate to everyone from peers, teachers, bosses and other members in the community you wouldn't normally interact with.

Such a good point! My first job was retail, doesn't that help you form a thick skin!

OP posts:
Adviceneeeeded · 25/07/2024 09:27

Open communication, leading by example, not pandering to every little grumble and upset, teach a bit of reliance, don't have such rigid routines so that change isn't alien

Tiredsendcoffee · 25/07/2024 09:26

WonderingWanda · 25/07/2024 08:30

The situation you describe at nursery is a totally normal thing for a 3yo but it sounds like you are attaching way too much emotion to it. 3yos are pretty self centred. Your ds likes to play with his friend at nursery, he arrived and something was different so he didn't like it, you've then gone into overdrive about him not feeling secure enough to be left. Really, he just met an example of the world not going his way and he needs you to teach him how to move on. So, a breezy "Don't worry I'm sure x will be back tomorrow, how about we check out this digger" then cheerily wave goodbye will show him that it's all ok. Hang around anxiously hugging him and he will think he needs to be more upset. It's the same when kids fall over, they look at you and if you smile and say 'whoopsie daisy' then assuming they aren't actually hurt they get up and run off to play, if you rush over shouting 'oh my god, are you ok baby' they ball their eyes out. Obviously, if really hurt then you roll out the cuddles and the love etc.

You say that you have become very anxious, in my opinion the best thing you can do to help raise confident children is work on that. At this age they just need you to be sure of yourself and frankly as long as you are providing for their needs, being loving and not hurting them then there is no right or wrong way to do it and you won't screw him up.

Yes this is so true, because that's exactly what I did. Stayed and hugged him, to make it worse then the teacher commented on it too so made me feel worse about the situation. I'm good when he falls and he'd fine with that, but haven't nailed anything else yet. I am sure he is picking up on my anxious vibes.

OP posts:
User79853257976 · 25/07/2024 09:26

3 is too young to determine whether they will have a confident personality or not. There are probably extremely shy children who might not change much but I wouldn’t worry too much.

I think it’s a personality trait to some extent and just involving them in everyday tasks will help build confidence of it doesn’t come naturally.

mindutopia · 25/07/2024 09:25

Don’t overthink it. Dd is 11 now. She was quite a clingy, reserved, risk averse toddler. She’s very confident, outgoing and social. I think it’s partly down to personality (she just IS outgoing and sociable which comes across as confidence) and partly down to making her feel secure when she needed it. I didn’t push her to ‘be brave’ or tell her to ‘stop crying’. I let her feel her emotions and was there for her.

As they get older, it’s also about being open and talking to them to help them navigate difficult situations. I’m a very open person. I don’t bury my head in the sand or leave difficult conversations unsaid. When she’s had tough stuff come up with friends (she has a couple friends with difficult home lives and we’ve had to make a safeguarding report, for example), we talked about it, I encouraged her to speak up to her teachers, I modelled that by also speaking to the teachers, praising her for supporting her friend and speaking up. But I don’t think it’s like something you can plan at 3. You just model that and support them through it as situations arise where they build those skills.

Swipe left for the next trending thread