Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To hope I get pregnant even though my partner withdraws?

344 replies

JambalayaFan · 24/07/2024 22:23

Me and my partner are in a bit of a strange situation. We own our own home, plenty of savings and a very happy stable relationship. He’d like to wait a couple of years to TTC as we are considering emigrating to where his family lives in 2 years, and the emigration process will obviously be more costly with a baby. I on the other hand would like to start trying ASAP as endometriosis/infertility runs in my family on both sides (several aunties never managed to get pregnant, I have loads of lovely adopted cousins). For this reason, I experience great anxiety about any sort of contraception as I so want to become a mother and don’t want to lower the chances when it may already be a struggle.

We have a great relationship and have no trouble discussing things, and we came to a deal. Our deal was that we won’t TTC yet until he is ready but we’ll do the withdrawal method. He accepts the high risk of pregnancy and agrees if it happens we’ll keep the baby. It may seem odd to many but for us it was a fair compromise. He isn’t quite ready to TTC yet but understands I may not have the biological clock that most women do and therefore I don’t want to mess around with my fertility. I know non-hormonal contraception exists, but it’s also about not wanting to miss chances to get pregnant. I haven’t pressured him into anything, he’s welcome to use condoms if he wants but he does know my feelings on the situation and we came to this solution together. I’m sure many reading this are judging but I promise, we have a very healthy relationship. This situation has come from a lot of discussion between me and my partner. It can’t be compared to a situation where woman lies about being on the pill to get pregnant. I was honest with my partner about wanting a baby.

anyway, the reason I am posting is I am curious if anybody has gotten pregnant from the withdrawal method? If so, did he pull out last minute (so he came as soon as he pulled out and didn’t have to touch himself)? Or is he ejaculating with plenty of time to spare? Me and my partner are doing the first one. Feeling a bit disheartened because a few friends and my mother have told me they did pull-out successfully for years, which isn’t good to hear when I’m wanting it to fail!

OP posts:
TooTiredOfThisShit · 25/07/2024 20:50

Tolip · 25/07/2024 20:05

@TooTiredOfThisShit

But maybe you just can't conceive? It doesn't mean the method is working!

I've conceived five times (and three of those times were first month trying)! Fair enough, we are both older now, although I'm not yet menopausal.

For us, pull-out worked perfectly well between pregnancies (when it wouldnt have been a disaster to fall pregnant) which is why we carried on with it after our family was complete. But there are factors (which I listed previously) which mean the chance of pregnancy is different for different couples.

Firefly1987 · 25/07/2024 20:17

Newposter180 · 25/07/2024 10:50

I don’t think anyone is saying that at all; but as a matter of fact it is not statutory rape, it is a different offence.

I know it's not technically rape, I wasn't one of the posters that said it was. Morally and ethically it's still despicable behaviour.

And yes some posters do seem to think it's hilarious or that men just need a "push" into fatherhood, so just get him drunk! Yes someone admitted to doing that and seemed pretty proud of themselves. I mean WTAF. Imagine if the roles were reversed and a woman was unsure if she wanted children but the man does so he should just get her pregnant anyway and she's bound to come round. I don't think we'd be worrying too much about the technical definition of the words we'd call him.

Tolip · 25/07/2024 20:05

@TooTiredOfThisShit

But maybe you just can't conceive? It doesn't mean the method is working!

TooTiredOfThisShit · 25/07/2024 19:26

I've done a lot of research into this. Some men produce a significant number in their pre-cum, whereas for other men it's negligible.

Of course the biggest chance of pregnancy when using pull-out, is not pulling out in time.

The other big chance of pregnancy is having sex twice without the man urinating (and "clearing the pipes"!) in between.

FWIW we've been using pull-out carefully for 8 years, with no pregnancy, but we're both mid forties now.

Tolip · 25/07/2024 19:18

@Blondeshavemorefun Has been around for years so if you're insinuating she's a troll then your barking up the wrong tree.

zzar45 · 25/07/2024 18:40

Neurodiversitydoctor · 25/07/2024 15:29

I agree with this poster this is how it is for me.

Cool bro.

AquaLeader · 25/07/2024 18:38

If he wanted a baby with OP, he would be TTC.

When he showing her who he is, the OP is refusing to believe him. This won't end well.

TwattyMcFuckFace · 25/07/2024 18:33

StormingNorman · 25/07/2024 18:30

Nah…he just wants to go bareback, nothing to do with wanting children.

Yep.

I think the OP is failing to take this onboard and if a 'surprise' pregnancy does happen, she's expecting him to be pleased about it.

StormingNorman · 25/07/2024 18:30

PippyLongTits · 25/07/2024 15:04

His words and his actions don't align. If he isn't using contraception and is having sex then it seems like he does want to have children, but perhaps wants to have that get-out-of-jail-free-card if it all goes wrong "Well, why should I have to give up going to the pub/seeing my friends/working long hours/going away with the lads/playing football all weekend/going to the gym 6 nights a week...? I said I didn't want to have a baby, this is all on you, why do I have to change?"

Nah…he just wants to go bareback, nothing to do with wanting children.

CoffeeNeededorWine · 25/07/2024 16:10

Josette77 · 25/07/2024 12:08

Why is there a high risk she won't conceive?

I'm infertile. My sister isn't. Our birth mom isn't.

No need for my nieces to think they will have issues.

worded poorly on my part. I was trying to imply she thinks she’ll struggle to conceive from the posts she made.

Neurodiversitydoctor · 25/07/2024 15:29

zzar45 · 25/07/2024 12:31

@Blondeshavemorefun that's not just me but my gaggle of girls when we spoke about it a while back

Hmm, sure this sounds exactly like what a real female would say.

I agree with this poster this is how it is for me.

SallyWD · 25/07/2024 15:09

I probably shouldn't say this as I don't want to encourage people to use the withdrawal method. However, the withdrawal method was a very effective form of contraception for us!
We used it for about 15 years and never got pregnant in that time. The only two times I got pregnant were when we were actively trying to conceive.
I think my husband is very skilled at pulling out in time!

PippyLongTits · 25/07/2024 15:04

His words and his actions don't align. If he isn't using contraception and is having sex then it seems like he does want to have children, but perhaps wants to have that get-out-of-jail-free-card if it all goes wrong "Well, why should I have to give up going to the pub/seeing my friends/working long hours/going away with the lads/playing football all weekend/going to the gym 6 nights a week...? I said I didn't want to have a baby, this is all on you, why do I have to change?"

Blondeshavemorefun · 25/07/2024 15:01

Odd posts from me ? Was just a curious question 😂

I've been on mn for about 18yrs

But yes

Op doesn't seem to be coming back

If still reading - you say you have money. So go private and see if you actually have any issues about conceiving. Nothing to do with your aunt cousins etx

sadabouti · 25/07/2024 14:56

@emocourt my understanding of sexual consent is not in the least bit blurred.

While my first comment was said tongue in cheek, I'll accept your argument as valid if you can point me to a single reported case where a jury has convicted a woman of sexual assault on a complaint by her husband or partner in circumstances where he had ejaculated in her during consensual sex, after she had told him she wanted to conceive, and knowing that, and sort of being okay with it if she did conceive, he then engaged in unprotected sex with her (repeatedly).

I'm also not sure there is such a thing as reverse stealthing (ie a woman getting a man to ejaculate in her without his consent) to be honest, which is what I think is the basis of your outrage.

How many eye rolling threads are there on here about men moaning they were tricked into conceiving babies.

Men should take responsibility. If you don't want a kid, wear a condom. And be honest with your wife / partner.

fitzwilliamdarcy · 25/07/2024 14:28

Clocloxx · 25/07/2024 08:39

Just get on top and don't jump off 😂 the urges to be a mother can be extremely strong! If ye are as happy and stable as you say ye are then he will probably be delighted, alot of men are probably just scared to make the jump into fatherhood because it's new

The urge to be a mother doesn't override his consent, and the fact that you not only think it does but find the idea hilarious is abhorrent.

I am the LAST person to say this sort of thing but can you imagine the response if a man said this about a woman?

BouquetGarni224 · 25/07/2024 14:20

Blondeshavemorefun · 25/07/2024 13:35

Thank you @BigPussyEnergy

I can't a quote a quote on the app

I def don't have a fetish

It was just an observation. If the man doesn't ejaculate inside the woman - where does it go

🙄

WTAF.

Some very odd posts indeed from this poster.

Back on the thread, it looks like the op has stropped and left.

Otherstories2002 · 25/07/2024 13:38

Blondeshavemorefun · 25/07/2024 13:35

Thank you @BigPussyEnergy

I can't a quote a quote on the app

I def don't have a fetish

It was just an observation. If the man doesn't ejaculate inside the woman - where does it go

Wherever he wants it to go. Many men love it.

Blondeshavemorefun · 25/07/2024 13:35

Thank you @BigPussyEnergy

I can't a quote a quote on the app

I def don't have a fetish

It was just an observation. If the man doesn't ejaculate inside the woman - where does it go

Blondeshavemorefun · 25/07/2024 13:32

zzar45 · 25/07/2024 12:31

@Blondeshavemorefun that's not just me but my gaggle of girls when we spoke about it a while back

Hmm, sure this sounds exactly like what a real female would say.

I don't get your reply ?

Otherstories2002 · 25/07/2024 13:30

Neurodiversitydoctor · 25/07/2024 07:18

Wow how on earth is that rape ?

If the post was “get her drunk and pull off the condom when she’s not looking” that ok with you? Rape no. But it’s not even the same planet as ok.

EmoCourt · 25/07/2024 13:26

sadabouti · 25/07/2024 09:20

@EmoCourt not sure why it's contemptible. She wants a baby. If he doesn't, he should wear condoms (and I say that as a man who thinks you should take personal responsibility for contraception). OP didn't seem to want people commenting on the fact that her DP has provided ambiguous consent to conception. But he does want unprotected sex. I can assure you (again as a man) that he won't mind or feel abused.

It’s contemptible because the OP and her partner have apparently agreed to have unprotected sex, but that he will withdraw before ,ejaculating. Not to using condoms. It’s a monumentally stupid ‘compromise’, obviously, but that is what they have agreed. The suggestions that the OP ‘get on top and stay there’, thereby rendering her partner unable to withdraw before he ejaculates, violates their agreement. He is having entirely unprotected sex he didn’t consent, to by means of physical coercion.

If you’re a man who can’t grasp this, then I’d suggest your thinking around consent is depressingly blurry.

I don’t disagree that this couple should be using barrier methods. I think they should be using two or three methods of contraception until they grow up enough to stop treating something as important as creating another human being who deserves to have been planned and wanted by both parents, as a matter of Vatican roulette and ‘whoopsies’ (I quote).

Rainwind65 · 25/07/2024 13:25

I think your mental health will suffer during those 2 years that you are hoping for the method to fail... You either try or don't. Why don't you try to conceive now if it is so important to you? I think it will be much better for you to understand what kind of child you will have, and what kind of support you will need before you make that big move. Emigrating with a toddler / baby doesn't add so much to the costs.

Coconutter24 · 25/07/2024 13:08

JambalayaFan · 24/07/2024 23:34

He wants a child and tells me he feels the same urges to have a baby that I do.
though he says logically he’d like to settle in the new country before officially TTC. He knows I’d like one earlier and he’ll enjoy it if it happens so we agreed to swerve contraception and do withdrawal until we either get pregnant or start TTC officially after moving. Part of the reason he wants to wait before doing it officially is because if we struggle with TTC and need to go down the fertility treatment route it will be made awkward by impending emigration plans.

I don’t think he has the same urges as you to have a child, if he did he would not be pulling out and you’d both be trying for a baby not just one half of the couple

Imtheproblemitsmeapparently · 25/07/2024 13:05

JambalayaFan · 24/07/2024 23:42

I do admit I sort of want a spontaneous “whoops” pregnancy because I’m terrified that it won’t happen when we actually do TTC with all the bells and whistles on (cycle tracking, supplements etc) and then I’ll have to face the traumatic infertility path that so many of my close relatives did. If we have a whoopsie I get to swerve that. I confide in my partner about this and he’s been understanding and lovely, he really hears me out.

Fertility treatment or a 'whoops' aren't your only options though, those are the two extremes of a very wide spectrum of TTC journeys.

I have PCOS and endometrial hyperplasia as a result, that has resulted in 15 early miscarriages in 10 years. We started trying for a baby when I was 21, my beautiful son was born when I was 30.

I (obviously) completely understand the drive and desire to have a child, and how it can become all consuming when you're trying and it's not happening.

What irks me as a sufferer of infertility for a number of years about your post is this:

  1. You do not have a diagnosis for endo, you just 'assume' you have it because it's in your family and you had a dodgy biosy result one time. If you do have endo and you think it's going to hurt your chances of conceiving, you'd be doing everything in your power NOW to get a diagnosis officially so that when you TTC, you've got immediate support rather than having to wait 2 years for diagnosis.
  2. You havent even STARTED TTC yet and you've already decided you're going to have a hard time based on nothing but your family history. AND YET you're still not pursuing diagnosis for yourself or investigations of any kind. Madness.
  3. Your partner has TOLD YOU he is not ready for a child yet, and instead of waiting 2 years (which is nothing in TTC world) you've come up with this mad 'compromise'. WTF. That's not a 'healthy' relationship. You're now both just wishing for different things to happen in an unspoken way, there's nothing healthy or communicative about that at all.

I think you're using your family history of infertility as a way to strong arm your partner into taking a risk he's not ready for. You have no evidence at all that you're infertile in anyway, so you're lying to him to get him to take risks while he's thinking you're going to struggle to get pregnant anyway, so his understanding of the risks he's taking is based on falsehoods.

You are not infertile, you are not going through a TTC/ infertility journey of any kind, You're taking the absolute piss out of a man who has been incredibly straight with you on his wishes.

Just wait until you're both ready. If you can't wait 2 years to start trying you're absolutely not ready for the absolute head fuck of early pregnancy etc, it will destroy you.

Swipe left for the next trending thread