Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

No holidays - carbon footprint

258 replies

Teacherbee85 · 22/07/2024 21:04

I've noticed recently whenever anyone posts about flying to go on holiday they tend to get jumped on by people saying it's bad for the environment.

I don't think I know any of these people in real life - everyone I know goes on holiday at least twice a year.

But on mumsnet a lot of people seem to have stopped due to environmental reasons.

If this is you, when did you make the decision? How do you deal with family and friends who so still choose to fly regularly?

OP posts:
Teacherbee85 · 24/07/2024 06:57

Most of you on this thread are far better humans than me.

I love travelling and going on holiday abroad by plane several times a year - it's one of the things in my life that brings me the most joy.

I won't ever give it up I don't think.

OP posts:
summer555 · 24/07/2024 06:33

But if they need the employees to fly as part of their job, they will want them to use the fastest way possible so they can be back in the office.

My company (investment sector) has just introduced a train where possible policy for European flights. They're happy to cover the cost of extra hotels and loss of productivity (although we’re all used to remote working so it’s not a huge deal).

They've also introduced two extra days a year for our holiday allowance if employees choose to take the train instead of flying to their holiday destination if they agree to work 80% of the time (but are excused if they have kids to look after).

I like taking the train to Europe but I still fly on holiday at least once a year.

NoBinturongsHereMate · 23/07/2024 23:21

OhBeAFineGuyKissMe · 23/07/2024 21:49

You could always travel by cargo ship. https://cargoholidays.com/australia-cargo-ship-travel

Unfortunately all those shut down because of Covid and very few have restarted. None of the long distance, cross ocean ones.

NoBinturongsHereMate · 23/07/2024 23:20

Kitkat1523 · 23/07/2024 20:29

So how many weeks annual leave do you get ?

In my most recent job 33 days plus bank holidays - but some of those trips were when I had less. Done with a mix of careful date planning to maximise the value of bank holidays, unpaid leave, working during part of the trip, and travelling between jobs.

WishIhadnotcome · 23/07/2024 22:17

ellabella89 · 23/07/2024 17:32

Absolutely cannot relate to this and know nobody in real life who can either. Sure, you can ferry and train to places on your doorstep but there is a whole world out there. What a waste not to see it.

I get that. I want to see the world to. But if seeing it also means wrecking it and people dying, I just can’t justify it.

WishIhadnotcome · 23/07/2024 22:09

KeepinOn · 23/07/2024 08:02

I work in supply chain planning, and sustainability is very much on the agenda for many organisations. It's pretty eye-opening to realise how interconnected and interdependent the world is in creating and selling products of any description. It makes me think of The Good Place, where buying a tomato in 2020 results in minus 1,000 points for someone - we really aren't in control of a lot of the choices we make as an end-user. So I do what I can, where I can - I don't actively choose holidays abroad, we have rich and varied options here in the UK. We grow our own food, and have solar panels (in situ when we moved to this house, but one of the big deciding factors in making an offer), we drive as little as possible and use public transport, etc.

I just used a carbon footprint calculator, but I think it has some flawed logic in it, with assigning fewer points if I had an electric car vs fossil fuel. Electric cars are terrible for the environment during their production phase of existence, and they take something like 6 or 7 years of use before they become 'neutral' - and the batteries only last about 10 years! I really don't feel it's a good enough trade-off for the environment's sake, and would rather own 1 car as long as possible and use it as little as possible.

With EVs, even with the battery issue, over their lifespan they are less carbon heavy than ICE cars. I looked into it in depth. If the battery is made using renewables (Scandinavian batteries) then they outstrip ICE cars quite quickly. If you use renewable energy to power it, it’s better too. But even with Chinese made batteries using coal power, all the production carbon and environmental impact and not powering it with renewables, it’s still better than ICE.

InWithPeaceOutWithStress · 23/07/2024 22:04

Me and my partner don’t go on holidays abroad. A few factors but one of them is for environmental reasons. I don’t tend to shout about with friends and family though so doubt many people in our life know this. I just say I prefer holidays in the U.K. without going into the reasons why. My dad is a prolific traveler. Him and his wife go abroad several times a year, every month possibly.

WishIhadnotcome · 23/07/2024 22:01

Thepeopleversuswork · 23/07/2024 08:02

I know people who refuse to fly unless necessary for environmental reasons.

I very cynically have observed that they are all from very comfortable families for whom it was de rigeur to “summer” in Tuscany or Provence as children and ski in winter so they had their fill of foreign trips when young and can now afford (both financially and emotionally) to be smug about the fact they no longer “feel the need” to fly.

Not quite the same if you are from a family which has never travelled outside the UK.

I do think we need to reduce casual air travel as a society but there is a very self satisfied brand of upper middle class Puritanism around this which I find to be a bit “I’m alright Jack.”

That’s not true of us or our friends that don’t fly. I never travelled - had to work Uni holidays to fund myself so no travel for me. Grew up poor so cheap camping holidays in UK. I am now much better off and could afford to travel and feel a definite sense of loss that I won’t get to go to some of my bucket list places now. It makes me quite sad actually. But, I can’t waste that much carbon on something that I don’t I need, when I know that our decisions collectively are already killing people. I just can’t add to that.

OhBeAFineGuyKissMe · 23/07/2024 21:49

nutbrownhare15 · 23/07/2024 19:59

Haven't flown since 2018. I can't justify it knowing that flying would be making climate change worse. We still holiday though in wonderful UK locations inc northern Ireland, as well as in Europe to France, Switzerland, Italy and the Netherlands and Belgium via train or ferry. My daughter wants to go to Australia and I've said I'll consider it in about 3 years time but I will need to think about it carefully and look into offsetting.

You could always travel by cargo ship. https://cargoholidays.com/australia-cargo-ship-travel

Australia Cargo Ship Travel - CARGOHOLIDAYS CARGO HOLIDAY VESSEL HOLIDAY SHIP HOLIDAY SEA HOLIDAY CRUISE CARGO CRUISE CARGO HOLIDAY SEA TRAVEL CARGO TRAVEL

Australia Cargo Ship Travel LIVE CHAT CONTACT US Freighter travel agency cargoholidays Australia Cargo Ship Travel CARGOHOLIDAYS THE BEST FREIGHT

https://cargoholidays.com/australia-cargo-ship-travel

Kitkat1523 · 23/07/2024 20:29

NoBinturongsHereMate · 23/07/2024 18:01

By train I have seen Japan, Russia, Mongolia, South Korea and China (as well as closer places like France and Austria). Khyber Pass and Golden Temple are tricky overland at the moment, but possible when the political situation has been calmer - I hope they will be again. Egypt and north Africa can be done by train and ferry.

Starting from the UK, there are 3 continents to choose from without flying. And you see the country rather than just one or 2 tourist sites.

Edited

So how many weeks annual leave do you get ?

nutbrownhare15 · 23/07/2024 19:59

Haven't flown since 2018. I can't justify it knowing that flying would be making climate change worse. We still holiday though in wonderful UK locations inc northern Ireland, as well as in Europe to France, Switzerland, Italy and the Netherlands and Belgium via train or ferry. My daughter wants to go to Australia and I've said I'll consider it in about 3 years time but I will need to think about it carefully and look into offsetting.

midgetastic · 23/07/2024 18:27

Millions of people saying I have a small impact is why we are in such a bad place

You can't fix everything but you can play your part or not as you choose

pinkspeakers · 23/07/2024 18:26

JennyBeanR · 22/07/2024 23:00

I'm always surprised in these threads by how little people seem to have thought about the figures.
2% of global emissions are due to Aviation.
1% of global emissions is from the UK.

Not going on holiday due to your carbon footprint is little more than virtue signalling.

If you want to make an impact with regards to climate change you're better off reducing beef consumption and buying from local businesses. Support the Greens so you can lobby the government to influence trade agreements and put pressure on the US and China.

When you book holidays, support green initiatives in the local community you're visiting. Boycott the US and China. Plenty of other lovely places in the world to visit that aren't increasing coal mine production. The world is large and beautiful, and travel broadens the mind.

committees.parliament.uk/publications/42703/documents/212154/default/
In the UK civil aviation emissions account for 7-8% of emissions.

And I have cut out beef, thank you. I'm working on dairy...
Yes, of course, everything that we do is small. But that's in the nature of individual action for most of us.

GBJustina · 23/07/2024 18:25

The last time we flew was about 8 years ago to India. We are going to Australia next year so obviously can’t avoid flying (realistically)

but

we have opted for places we can easily drive/train/ferry to or make the journey a part of the adventure - we went to Greece via train and ferry and the journey took us through Italy and Switzerland. It was incredible

we also have family and France and more often will euro star/train to see them, as well as take the ferry to Ireland or go to somewhere in the uk

this year we are going to Norfolk for a week in August and then Orkney in September (via ferry)

faffadoodledo · 23/07/2024 18:23

We only fly once a year and are strict about it. I know. I know. It's still flying and it's still bad.
We also take lots of train trips tho, and ferries and driving. None of which are carbon neutral if course.
But the point is we've cut back on flights.
I view it like meat eating / veganism. If we all did a little less no one would have to give up altogether.

pinkspeakers · 23/07/2024 18:21

Doodar · 22/07/2024 21:43

its usually because they can't afford it.the only 2 families I knew who did this were't well off, one came into some cash and off they went 😂

Travelling by train is usually more expensive that flying to the same destination in Europe. The people I know who travel by train tend to be better off.

pinkspeakers · 23/07/2024 18:18

A large number of my friends and colleagues seem to be doing summer holidays in europe by train this year. It suddenly seems to have become much more common

pinkspeakers · 23/07/2024 18:17

I've not stopped flying, but I've made a conscious effort to fly less than I would if there were no environmental concerns. Limiting long haul a bit, and trying to do our european holidays by train where it is feasible.

Phoebefail · 23/07/2024 18:07

And we once thought Smug "One upmanship" had died out.
At least no one got 'preachy' about having the better equipped Cortina

WalkingonWheels · 23/07/2024 18:06

ellabella89 · 23/07/2024 17:32

Absolutely cannot relate to this and know nobody in real life who can either. Sure, you can ferry and train to places on your doorstep but there is a whole world out there. What a waste not to see it.

I'd rather see them online from the comfort of my own home. Google maps is excellent now, and photographs/videos too. My right to "see the world" doesn't trump the importance of the future of that world.

NoBinturongsHereMate · 23/07/2024 18:01

By train I have seen Japan, Russia, Mongolia, South Korea and China (as well as closer places like France and Austria). Khyber Pass and Golden Temple are tricky overland at the moment, but possible when the political situation has been calmer - I hope they will be again. Egypt and north Africa can be done by train and ferry.

Starting from the UK, there are 3 continents to choose from without flying. And you see the country rather than just one or 2 tourist sites.

Phoebefail · 23/07/2024 17:47

ellabella89 · 23/07/2024 17:32

Absolutely cannot relate to this and know nobody in real life who can either. Sure, you can ferry and train to places on your doorstep but there is a whole world out there. What a waste not to see it.

Thanks for this @ellabella89 , By flying I have seen the Khyber Pass, Golden Temple, and the Pyramids. And met and spoken with some of the people along the way.
In Europe I could have seen the historic cities of the Hapsburgs and Romanovs by long hours of driving. But I was in a much more relaxed and receptive mood after help from EasyJet.

Ariela · 23/07/2024 17:43

We don't fly for animal reasons - someone needs to stay and look after them so we simply don't do holidays.

ellabella89 · 23/07/2024 17:32

Absolutely cannot relate to this and know nobody in real life who can either. Sure, you can ferry and train to places on your doorstep but there is a whole world out there. What a waste not to see it.

Hobbitfeet32 · 23/07/2024 17:08

It’s great to reduce flying but many people would never see their family again.
The people who seem evangelical about not flying also seem to have loads of annual leave/able to take unpaid leave and don’t seem to be equally as passionate about encouraging people to have less children (1 person I know has 3 children but is saving the world by not flying).

Swipe left for the next trending thread