Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think 'chav' is not an okay thing to call people?

455 replies

enternow99 · 19/07/2024 15:11

I find the use of chav on Mumsnet shocking. Is this name chavvy? Is this holiday destination chavvy? Is this outfit chavvy? Chavs moved in next door (I'm a leaseholder, they rent!!!!)

I understand its snobbiness but isn't it a bit horrible?

OP posts:
Grandmasswagbag · 20/07/2024 18:39

gardenmusic · 20/07/2024 17:15

Dordi!
I have never heard Charva used as a horseman - sometimes as a mispronunciation of Chavva - children.
Horse is a grai (not a written language, so spellings vary)
Grai mush - horse man.
I'm not fluent, I am a generation away. Gorgios take the language and mispronounce/misuse it.

Mush is very common colloquial where I grew up. I had never heard of anyone refer to someone as 'mate' until I moved to a different part of the country. Many Roma words have made it into everyday language. There has been a population here for 500 + years after all. I've never known the word Chav in its modern useage to be used to describe people of Roma origin, even if that's the language the word originated from. As I said previously, how do we know it wasn't first circulated by Romani in it's current meaning?

gardenmusic · 20/07/2024 17:34

Bushmills - such ignorance in every line.
Do you think a Gypsy/Romany can or would want to change who they are?
Do you think we do not suffer discrimination?
I am not saying that the people you call Chavs are racially discriminated against, that would be idiotic - they are not likely to be Romany or Gypsy. You really cannot be that thick?
I am objecting to the name you ascribe to them - Chavvy, which means Romany child. That is the origin, there is no other.
Will you please get it through your head that the Romanies and Gypsies are an ethnic minority - it took until 2010 for this to become law. You cannot discriminate against us any more than you could an Indian, Dane or Nigerian. Using our word for child to describe something you consider laughable or disgusting is racist.

Bushmillsbabe · 20/07/2024 17:19

This thread is hilarious. Chav is a word to describe a person who displays a certain set of behaviours which are perceived by someto be negative, and apparently that's a terrible word to use
But those same people are happy to call people snobs, also a word to describe a set of attitudes and behaviours which they perceive to be negative. Madness!

Is not discrimination in the legal sense, as discrimination applies to something which a person cannot change - skin colour, gender, disability etc. It does not apply to the choices someone is making about their behaviour, clothing, actions etc. Which are absolutely their choice to make. But calling it discrimination undermines true discrimination people experience every day, about things they have no choice over, cannot change.

gardenmusic · 20/07/2024 17:15

Dordi!
I have never heard Charva used as a horseman - sometimes as a mispronunciation of Chavva - children.
Horse is a grai (not a written language, so spellings vary)
Grai mush - horse man.
I'm not fluent, I am a generation away. Gorgios take the language and mispronounce/misuse it.

Calliopespa · 20/07/2024 16:56

enternow99 · 20/07/2024 16:37

I think judging someone you dont know for having very blonde hair or judging women as being 'up for it' for the tightness of her trousers is mind-blowing.

Some women hide behind their 'tasteful' hair and safe clothing putting out what they think is an image of goodliness. When on the inside they're filled with hate of women who they dont even know. I feel so so so sad for the children (and partners) of these women.

You're right it's not about money, clothes, or cosmetic procedures. It's about what you are like on anonymous forums.

Edited

No one is hating anyone.

SinnerBoy · 20/07/2024 16:51

Teentaxidriver · Yesterday 15:20

Chav, or Cheltenham Average. Coined by the ladies of Cheltenham Ladies College to denote a particular type of local.

Or Council House and Violent, another retro fitting. It's from Romany, charva, meaning a horseman. It's still charva in Newcastle, which has a fair bit of Romany slang / dialect.

Doilem: idiot
Gadgie: man

... for example.

Calliopespa · 20/07/2024 16:41

ABirdsEyeView · 20/07/2024 15:38

Everyone judges. Anyone who claims not to is a liar!
And all these people so determined to defend the poor put upon traveller community Hmm, would be total nimbys if said group wanted to camp in a field outside their houses.

It’s a total irrelevance anyway. No one envisages Romany people when you say Chav. There are lots of other eirdz gif that and I’d agree they are pejorative and unpleasant. But that simply isn’t how Chav is used.

enternow99 · 20/07/2024 16:37

Calliopespa · 20/07/2024 12:20

I’m afraid I also think too much make-up, obviously dyed hair ( esp bleached look), trout pout, and dressing too obviously “up for it” ( so high leg slit PLUS low cut top, or slap-me tight leather pants etc) looks chavvy. Some Hollywood celebrities look chavvy so it isn’t just about money. And I disagree the race thing; whatever the origins of the word, in application it has nothing to do with race.

I think judging someone you dont know for having very blonde hair or judging women as being 'up for it' for the tightness of her trousers is mind-blowing.

Some women hide behind their 'tasteful' hair and safe clothing putting out what they think is an image of goodliness. When on the inside they're filled with hate of women who they dont even know. I feel so so so sad for the children (and partners) of these women.

You're right it's not about money, clothes, or cosmetic procedures. It's about what you are like on anonymous forums.

OP posts:
enternow99 · 20/07/2024 16:27

WatermelonMickeys · 20/07/2024 14:10

What a load of nonsense.

People need to stop trying to blame others for the way their lives turned out and start taking some personal responsibility.

These “struggling adults” are in fact adults that are perfectly capable of sorting out their own lives if they can be bothered to do so.

Wallowing and pandering to them with the “poor you, it’s not your fault” attitude helps nobody.

I'm curious- would you share these thoughts in your workplace?

OP posts:
enternow99 · 20/07/2024 16:26

MyOtherWheelchairIsABroomstick · 20/07/2024 13:58

Just seen this while having a scroll. If I hear the word chav, I think anti-social. Which would explain memes like this.

What's interesting to me is that my ex husband was from a nice area of the country and his idea of a chav was as some posters describe. Trying to buy class - but the people he described had money to fritter away. He was in for a shock when he moved because he had assumed that was the most vulgar kind of person one could encounter. My family referred to exH as "Posh Knobs". Instead, he would call the kids round our way "urchins", which for me conjured up images of raggedy dressed children with dirty faces.

After reading a few comments I think that if the likes of the OED update their meaning of the word chav to be a racist slur, I would be inclined to stop using it. Otherwise, I think it's a commonly accepted name. Tbh I think it's only a word I've ever used in writing, and to people who wouldn't understand what a docker-picking scrote is.

" The Fabian Society considers the term to be offensive and regards it as "sneering and patronising" to a largely voiceless group. This is middle-class hatred of the white working class, pure and simple."

OP posts:
AllProperTeaIsTheft · 20/07/2024 16:22

I don't think enfant terrible is the same at all, to me it's a (possibly) middle class child who is playing up, going through a phase. Nothing like describing an entire group of people.

It's not used about children at all in English, I don't think. It is usually used to describe an extravagantly dissolute or shockingly-behaved adult, often one who is well-known in some particular cultural circle - 'The enfant terrible of classical music' etc. But no, it's not remotely like using a romany word to describe a whole group of people.

enternow99 · 20/07/2024 16:21

Calliopespa · 20/07/2024 12:06

On the contrary, the underlying skill in most IQ tests is a capacity for pattern recognition. The ability to link concepts or identify similarities is a sign of healthy cognitive function.

Orangutans can identify patterns. Healthy cognitive function would involve the ability to see your prejudices and frankly hate towards people and identify them as internalised socio-economical discrimination. Especially after two days of you lurking on this post

OP posts:
enternow99 · 20/07/2024 16:18

JudgeJ · 20/07/2024 11:49

The Burberry tartan was popular with the "chav" style - but fake Burberry was what was usually worn

That's what I detested the whole chav thing for, I couldn't wear my genuine Burberry!
Regarding the origins of the word, I only became aware of it when things like Only Way programmes started to pollute the TV, originally the Essex one, and the word was everywhere.

Why couldnt you wear your Burberry?

OP posts:
Needmorelego · 20/07/2024 16:14

@Arraminta so if you look at a group of people and say "urrgh what a bunch of chavs" do you mean -
1 - "look at those people who could possibly be of Romany descent"
2 - "look at those people who are probably from a council estate and are likely to have asbos"
3 - "look at those people in fake designer clothes trying to look like they have more money than they have"
Which is it?
Because despite the many posts of "of course people know what it means" this thread has clearly shown people use it to mean different things.
(none of which are acceptable or nice)

Iwantmyoldnameback · 20/07/2024 15:47

I don't think enfant terrible is the same at all, to me it's a (possibly) middle class child who is playing up, going through a phase. Nothing like describing an entire group of people.

Arraminta · 20/07/2024 15:45

As I understand it, we have evolved by making hundreds of, surprisingly accurate, judgements every day. We're actually extremely good at it, even when we just rely on a quick visual appraisal. Yes, we might sometimes get it wrong but we actually get it absolutely right most of the time.

ABirdsEyeView · 20/07/2024 15:38

Everyone judges. Anyone who claims not to is a liar!
And all these people so determined to defend the poor put upon traveller community Hmm, would be total nimbys if said group wanted to camp in a field outside their houses.

Arraminta · 20/07/2024 15:35

I don't have a problem with it at all. It's a handy moniker to accurately describe a certain sub culture. Everyone immediately knows who you mean. At university we had lots of descriptive monikers to describe distinct groups. Goths, Rugger Buggers, Townies etc. Conversely, I don't have any problem being labelled a snob or judgemental because I absolutely am.

gardenmusic · 20/07/2024 15:30

Calliopespa

Just keep scraping the barrel for excuses.
You are never going to have the grace to admit that you have made an insulting comment.
I'm done trying to educate you.

Calliopespa · 20/07/2024 15:17

gardenmusic · 20/07/2024 14:37

I assume you don’t know the phrase enfant terrible then? A phrase used in English with the French word for child to describe someone whose behaviour is shocking and/or embarrassing

I don't think enfant terrible is the word for 'child' in French, you are just describing a naughty child in French for some obscure reason.
Keep scraping the bottom of the barrel to excuse the racism, though.

I think her point was that you don’t need to be French to fit the description enfant terrible.

None of these concepts are racial because with race you are born something. Being an enfant terrible ( or a chav) is based on behaviours and attitudes that are acquired not innate. It may be a Romany word ( though I think it’s far from clear it is the source of the term) just as enfant terrible is a French term that doesn’t make a statement about being French per se.

Calliopespa · 20/07/2024 15:14

Tomatina · 20/07/2024 12:24

Searching for patterns is a basic feature of human brains, yes. And of course it is central to any kind of scientific effort. But human beings are not 'concepts' or data points and sticking random labels on big groups of people allows the labeller to avoid awkward questions and stop thinking about those people as individuals. It then becomes easy to dehumanise them.

I agree to the extent that you can’t label a whole “ group” - for instance just because your sister is a chat or you live in a particular area etc doesn’t make you fit the bill. Every person is an individual and I don’t think you are born a chav, it’s a decision you take in adopting certain values and behaviours. But I think you can generalise about the aspects that make people generally feel an individual fits the description.

gardenmusic · 20/07/2024 14:37

I assume you don’t know the phrase enfant terrible then? A phrase used in English with the French word for child to describe someone whose behaviour is shocking and/or embarrassing

I don't think enfant terrible is the word for 'child' in French, you are just describing a naughty child in French for some obscure reason.
Keep scraping the bottom of the barrel to excuse the racism, though.

PattyPan · 20/07/2024 14:30

gardenmusic · 20/07/2024 08:15

Some people are chavs. So should be called it. Without the pearl clutching from the ‘be kind’ brigade.

And once more for the ignorant and hard of thinking:

The word Chav come from Chavvy, the Romany word for child. Like kid, or kiddie. Chav was used as an insult, to compare bad behaviour to that of a Romany child.
The fact that perhaps you are too young to know that is irrelevant. It may have dropped into common parlance for some of you, but it still means the same thing.
It does not mean anything else. I can guarantee the people you are calling Chavs are not.

I do not know the french word for child, nor the swahili, nor the urdu, but I can guarantee that if I started saying you are such a 'swahili word for child' to denegrate someone's clothing or actions I would be banned, and quite rightly so.
Would you consider those that banned me as pearl clutching? Would you consider them kind and rational, or part of the 'be kind brigade?'

If I used the urdu word for child and applied it to to drunken loud and aggressive behaviour what do you think would happen?
Why do the posters on here think they can use the children of an ethnic minority as an insult?

I will call out bad behaviour, I will probably swear, what I will not do is attribute their behaviour to their genetic origins.

I assume you don’t know the phrase enfant terrible then? A phrase used in English with the French word for child to describe someone whose behaviour is shocking and/or embarrassing

WatermelonMickeys · 20/07/2024 14:10

enternow99 · 19/07/2024 19:51

Being born without the genetic predisposition to obesity and in a household where you developed healthy food behaviours is a privilege.

Understanding privilege is important, it highlights how often children suffer from the lack of it. These children grow into struggling adults. It's not funny or a buzzword, it's a real issue. Often people who have it struggle to comprehend how others without it suffer. Empathy is needed.

Why you struggle to think of privilege as something beyond a buzzword is probably down to your education, upbringing, and your genetic disposition towards intellectual thinking.

What a load of nonsense.

People need to stop trying to blame others for the way their lives turned out and start taking some personal responsibility.

These “struggling adults” are in fact adults that are perfectly capable of sorting out their own lives if they can be bothered to do so.

Wallowing and pandering to them with the “poor you, it’s not your fault” attitude helps nobody.

MyOtherWheelchairIsABroomstick · 20/07/2024 13:58

Just seen this while having a scroll. If I hear the word chav, I think anti-social. Which would explain memes like this.

What's interesting to me is that my ex husband was from a nice area of the country and his idea of a chav was as some posters describe. Trying to buy class - but the people he described had money to fritter away. He was in for a shock when he moved because he had assumed that was the most vulgar kind of person one could encounter. My family referred to exH as "Posh Knobs". Instead, he would call the kids round our way "urchins", which for me conjured up images of raggedy dressed children with dirty faces.

After reading a few comments I think that if the likes of the OED update their meaning of the word chav to be a racist slur, I would be inclined to stop using it. Otherwise, I think it's a commonly accepted name. Tbh I think it's only a word I've ever used in writing, and to people who wouldn't understand what a docker-picking scrote is.

To think 'chav' is not an okay thing to call people?