Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To want advice before bf moves in?

56 replies

Desertislandparadise · 16/07/2024 20:14

I've been on mn for a while and have read so many heartbreaking and/or enraging posts about deadbeat partners. I really don't want to be writing my own some years down the line. Does anyone have any advice for specific red flags or boundaries to pay attention to?

My bf (32) and I (34) have been together 2 years. We have discussed living together soon. I own my own home while he rents so it would be a question of him moving in with me (he suggested finding a new place together, but I don't want to leave my flat). He's a lovely person, very kind, but also e.g. much less confident about cooking than I am (lives off ready meals and take out) and more tolerant to mess.

I absolutely don't want to end up in a dynamic where he is "helping" me to cook and clean in the home we share. Especially not if we end up having kids.

I guess I'm asking if there are things I can do from day one that would help head that off. Since it is originally my home, how can I encourage him to see it as also his responsibility as soon as he's moved in? Financially I'll be responsible for all repairs etc but I mean the general housekeeping work needed everyday?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
pikkumyy77 · 17/07/2024 11:52

Greatmate · 16/07/2024 20:31

The thing is him living with you will be saving him money. Which is lovely but it should also benefit you. Your giving up your space. You're accomodating him. He shouldn't get to save heaps while you pay everything. Where I live renting a room in a house costs £800 PCM minimum. You don't want to be unfair but you shouldn't be subsidising someone either.

I think you really need to think hard about living together without knowing where you are headed. that seems off to say but it sounds like you are thinking about this as a trial for a future marriage or permanent cohabitation. But it may not work out.,—children? Breaking up? Both of these contingencies will cause quite a bit of fallout and stress and should be prepared for.

I think what I mean is for you this sounds like a trial run as well as the next step. Is he of the same mind?

CeruleanDive · 17/07/2024 11:45

much less confident about cooking than I am (lives off ready meals and take out) and more tolerant to mess.

Those are red flags there.

"Less confident about cooking" or just can't be arsed? Do you really need much confidence to cook basic meals? Just follow a YouTube recipe, that would build confidence. But he's chosen to live off take aways instead.

"More tolerant to mess" or just lazy and a bit of a slob?

GKD · 17/07/2024 11:33

IMO you want to ensure that if you were away for a month you should return to the house (inc admin) as you left it.

GKD · 17/07/2024 11:29

Not Read full thread.

DH could cook 2 things when we started living together.

When I finally admitted I was tired of fecking meatballs every time he got some cookbooks and branched out.

When he randomly said ‘oh, you’re not doing a roast this Sunday’, he ended up doing his first the next…

We’ve always shared housework but work to our strengths. I hate hoovering, folding clothes, making the bed so he does those. He hates washing up, cleaning bathroom and kitchen so I tend to do those (but not always).

IMO it’s vital child/housework is seen as shared. We are both equally responsible. We’ve not argued about this shit at all.

I’m currently on mat so doing maybe 75%? Usually while he has DC, he prefers that to me doing housework + childcare.

20 years together 14 married.

Start as you mean to go on. Compromise on standards (don’t do it all cos his are less).
DONT DO MORE.
oh and ensure he isn’t just gardening DIY, he needs to do day to day stuff too.

Eadfrith · 17/07/2024 11:11

Someone suggesting making a rota, don’t do that 😂

you’ll probably have a few teething problems, living together is a different ball game. But make sure you keep it as your house, do not place him on the mortgage or whatever, and make sure he knows that if the relationship doesn’t work out, that he will be the one to move out.

ABirdsEyeView · 17/07/2024 10:59

Best advice I can give you is not to get married - if you have kids, chances are it's you who will be disadvantaged in career terms/financially and so if things do go pear shaped down the line, you don't want him having a claim on your biggest asset.
Dont let him finance home repairs/new kitchen as this gives him a claim.
At the same time, he has no security so I think it's fair that he gets to save some money to protect himself, so I wouldn't be charging him market rent.
It's unromantic but a cohabitation agreement lets everyone know where they stand and makes breaking up less hostile than it might otherwise be.
TLDR - hope for the best but plan for the worst.

rwalker · 17/07/2024 10:25

I think the main thing is accepting people for who and as there are trying to change or “train “ people never works

he isn’t the tidy so has different standards to you and would happily live off ready meals
this is him he isn’t expecting you to cook and tidy for him he’s quite happy with Living like that

Desertislandparadise · 17/07/2024 10:04

0live · 16/07/2024 23:51

I’ll tell you now that dynamic WILL continue .

He won’t clean because he “ doesn’t mind the mess “ or he “ doesn’t see it” or “ he doesn’t know where you keep things / how you like it done “ and he was waiting for you to ask him. Or because you asked him at the wrong time or in the wrong tone of voice.

And it will be the same with the cooking , shopping and laundry.

And of course you will do all the admin, DIY, Gardening, decorating and maintenance because it’s your house.

And you will do all the life admin because he’s not from the UK / he’s busy / you are so good at it / he works shifts / he works 9-5/ he’s not near the shops.

The person with the highest standards always ends up doing everything. And so many jobs are so easy and quick for a woman and so hard / stressful / time consuming for a man, it’s not worth all the aggro and hassle 🙄

You will spend your life asking him to “ help” you and you will grow more and more resentful. The only Way to stop this happening is to

  1. sit down and agree it all now. yeah I know it’s not romantic and sexy and cool and fun but you need to start adulting now
  2. keep a very close eye on things and act as soon as they slip. Don’t give him the benefit of the doubt for one minute.

You are a fool if you don’t get a cohabitation agreement drawn up by a solicitor - would you take a job with no contract or buy a car with no paperwork ? Don’t risk your home for some man - I assume you worked hard for it.

I definitely don't want to end up in the scenario you've described. My parents had what I consider a very equal relationships but I've got a sister who has ended up doing way more than her fair share. She's constantly stressed.

I'm definitely going to talk things over and reach a clear agreement with my bf before he moves in. One reason I posted is to get some idea of what I should be insisting on and where I should relax a little. Yours and other's posts have really helped with this.

Regarding the finance and legalities, that's more clear cut and I will absolutely be getting legal advice. My bf and I are on the same page there.

OP posts:
0live · 16/07/2024 23:51

Desertislandparadise · 16/07/2024 20:54

Would definitely be red flags, I agree! My bf's been living independently for years now so he can do basic household chores. It's more that he cleans less often or a bit less thoroughly. With food he is happy to cook with me but doesn't cook by himself. He buys a lot of ready meals etc but I prefer home cooking.

I'm worried that there's been a dynamic where he is a 'guest' when over at mine while I'm a guest while over at his. Now that we're both going to be moving into my flat, I want to make sure that dynamic doesn't continue.

I’ll tell you now that dynamic WILL continue .

He won’t clean because he “ doesn’t mind the mess “ or he “ doesn’t see it” or “ he doesn’t know where you keep things / how you like it done “ and he was waiting for you to ask him. Or because you asked him at the wrong time or in the wrong tone of voice.

And it will be the same with the cooking , shopping and laundry.

And of course you will do all the admin, DIY, Gardening, decorating and maintenance because it’s your house.

And you will do all the life admin because he’s not from the UK / he’s busy / you are so good at it / he works shifts / he works 9-5/ he’s not near the shops.

The person with the highest standards always ends up doing everything. And so many jobs are so easy and quick for a woman and so hard / stressful / time consuming for a man, it’s not worth all the aggro and hassle 🙄

You will spend your life asking him to “ help” you and you will grow more and more resentful. The only Way to stop this happening is to

  1. sit down and agree it all now. yeah I know it’s not romantic and sexy and cool and fun but you need to start adulting now
  2. keep a very close eye on things and act as soon as they slip. Don’t give him the benefit of the doubt for one minute.

You are a fool if you don’t get a cohabitation agreement drawn up by a solicitor - would you take a job with no contract or buy a car with no paperwork ? Don’t risk your home for some man - I assume you worked hard for it.

Moanranger · 16/07/2024 23:35

I have a similar set up, & it has been established for ten years. My partner can cook, but he is incredibly slow & chooses over-elaborate recipes. We have settled on a system where I mainly cook, he helps & he does most of the washing up. Some days we just do our own thing food wise. My DP actually likes crap like ready meal curries, so this means he gets to still have these, while I can have a big salad, which would not be filling enough for him.
You might want to consider this, as a lot of people are not natural cooks, while I can rustle up an elaborate meal in no time. This approach is less stressful for me, as if I insisted that he cook three times a week, I would get stressed out watching his ineptitude & having dinner at 10pm.
The rest of the chores should absolutely be split 50-50. Just ensure your standards of tidiness are not too different, particularly in common areas, just expect his own spaces ( office, wardrobe) will probably be messy. My DP has an incredibly messy office, I occasionally make remarks, but mostly leave him to it, and close the door. We get on fine with this system.

SeaToSki · 16/07/2024 23:11

I would suggest

sit down and talk about how you have different standards and then agree to come to a meeting of the minds on what the basic standards for your joint house situation are.

write down what you both agree that cleaning the bathroom means..floors mopped, tiles scrubbed, bath mat washed etc etc

then do the same for every job

then divide up the jobs and discuss how frequently they should be done, some are daily, some are weekly, some are monthly.

then allocate jobs

then set up your next household planning meeting in a month to review and adjust

moderndilemma · 16/07/2024 23:01

The mental load is really important, especially if he is moving into your existing set up. He might put the bins out, but do you have to remind him that it's Monday night? He might be willing to clean the toilet but do you have to ask him and check that it has been done?

The main thing in terms of housework is that he has to learn to notice when something needs done. That's his first job every day when he comes home from work - to notice if there are unwashed dishes, to check whether there's any laundry (that need to go in the machine, taken out the machine, dried, or ironed, put away - the whole lot). To look in the fridge and see if there's milk, butter, eggs, cheese, bread - and if not, to add it to a communal (and visible) shopping list. Who actually carries out the chores can be agreed between you but you need him to take his share of the mental responsibility. Now. Or he may never do it.

Also the admin load. He needs to be aware of when bills are paid and how much they are - if they're all on your account and in your name it is a very easy thing for him to simply transfer £Xamount at the start of the month then never have to think about it again - suddenly it is all your responsibility to check there's enough in the budget, or to deal with price increases, or to manage everything to do with utility supply problems, new broadband, etc... And all HIS personal admin is his: his Mum's birthday, arranging family gatherings.

How open are you going to be about your personal finances? Who has savings? Who spends on coffees, gym membership, meals out? How is that financed? Will you be transparent about debts / credit ratings? Do you both have the same amount of pending money?

Cooking? I'm like you, lovel to cook, happy to do it. But dh CAN cook. He has his own version of a 'Jamie 5 ingredient' list, simple dishes that he loves to eat and that he can do quickly (pasta, lemon, basil, pinenuts, parmsan, crispy bacon). He is responsible twice a week

None of that sounds romantic, but having the mental load shared, not building up resentment, being confident that you have a shared approach to money - all of that leaves you able to devote your creative time to being together, being in love.

EveningSpread · 16/07/2024 22:47

Without wanting to be too judgemental, I do agree with a poster upthread that a grown ass man unable to cook and clean is a real turn off, and a real potential problem as a cohabitee. It’s not for us to tell the OP who to date, but I’d be approaching this with extreme caution. She shouldn’t be making compromises on things like being an adult who doesn’t eat crap every night - there’s compromise then there’s pandering to childish behaviour. At the same time it is unreasonable and unrealistic to expect people to change, so I’d worry the OP will end up unhappy/a skivvy. There are just too many women who don’t feel their partner pulls their weight and the relationship becomes full of resentment and a trial - and it seems here the OP has a pretty good idea this man can’t domestically look after himself already! He doesn’t sound like a catch, if I’m honest. I really hope he’s lovely it works out for you OP but do take care! 💐

spriots · 16/07/2024 22:05

We sat down and discussed chores before we moved in together - 20 years on, we still broadly stick to what we agreed back then, obviously children have added to the list!

I really recommend just sitting down with a list of what needs to be done, agreeing who does what and at what frequency and then just getting on with it.

We play to our strengths but although I do more than half of the cooking - I agree with a PP that it's important that he can cook and more than a ready meal. There are lots of really straightforward meals he can start with - the roasting tin cookbooks are good for this, they are largely about cutting stuff up and putting it in the oven

Meadowfinch · 16/07/2024 21:59

OP, be careful.

I agreed 50:50 on bills when ex moved in with me. He quadrupled my electricity bill, tripled my water bill, Christ knows what he was doing with it all.
He ate easily 70% of the food, and insisted on 'upgraded' groceries - salmon, leg of lamb, asparagus, etc.. He preferred the village butcher and farm shop.
After 3 months I had to ask him to leave because I couldn't afford to live his way and he wasn't willing to pay his fair share.

Abigaillovesholidays · 16/07/2024 21:59

Living with someone can be hard- really hard! I think it's made harder when one person moves into another person's home. I would really think carefully about this and consider getting a new place together.

Nocturna · 16/07/2024 21:58

I think you're focusing too much on cooking. Sounds like he isn't a natural cook as such and that's fine, as long as he does the washing up afterwards and pulls his weight equally with other household tasks.

ThePassageOfTime · 16/07/2024 21:56

Get a cleaner.

Desertislandparadise · 16/07/2024 21:53

Overtired345 · 16/07/2024 21:40

For example with cooking, is it fair for me to demand he starts cooking when he would happily continue eating ready meals? He'd be changing for me, should I compromise?

Firstly, is he like 600lbs? How does a grown man only eat ready meals and takeaways?

Secondly, when you decide to live together, you both compromise. I don't think it's too much to ask that he be an adult and cook.

Thirdly, kids don't eat ready meals. So if you want a man to have a family with, that man needs to do the basics.

Fourthly, what exactly is he compromising on? Because so far, I can't see any compromises on his part.

He grew up abroad in a house with a housekeeper. So it's not that he thinks stuff is "women's work" or nonsense like that, but that he really doesn't know how much work it takes to manage a home. He has a tiny flat and lives off take away, as I've said.

All the more reason to have some difficult conversations and also instill some boundaries early.

He's a healthy weight, lol. Guys seem to get away with eating way more crap than women do!

I guess he'd be compromising by cleaning to a higher standard and not eating his favourite ready meal every day? Not loads I admit! But then I'd just be compromising on having a slightly messier home and not eating my favourite home cooked food everyday...

Your point about kids is an excellent one. I hadn't thought of it that way. Definitely makes me more confident in asking him to learn how to cook. Thanks!

OP posts:
Desertislandparadise · 16/07/2024 21:46

EveningSpread · 16/07/2024 21:33

I see your point about the cooking - perhaps that’s a seperate conversation. If he’s happy with ready meals then it’s tricky. Does he eat healthily? Is he ok with money or wasting a lot on ready made foods? And will he be happy to benefit when you’re cooking? All these things would give me pause - you don’t want to fall into the role of mother/carer. Does he have any desire to improve/change? To cook for you if it would make you happy?

On the other hand, it’s a good rule of thumb to assume you’ll never change anyone - and certainly not expect it!

So on that note, it also depends how import food is to you. Food is a pretty big part of my life and my values (ethically and environmentally) so I’d struggle being with someone who had a totally different attitude to it. I also love sharing food, enjoying similar things, etc. But everyone is different and it’s not necessarily a big deal for everyone!

Edited

Well, he's happy with processed food which I personally would consider unhealthy. He's generally good with money, has a budget etc but food is where he splurges. So many restaurant meals!

He's happy to eat food I've prepared, also happy to help me cook it. I think if I asked him to cook several times a week he would do it, but I'd worry it might end up with him feeling resentful further down the line. Take aways are a lot faster!

I guess like you say I'll have to figure out how important the food situation is to me.

OP posts:
Overtired345 · 16/07/2024 21:43

I do agree you can't change anyone. I eventually could not change my exH and I left him. I spent years thinking I was unreasonable and demanding, doing everything at home, while starting a demanding career, thinking "this is how men are".

Then I started dating and it turned out loads of men can cook, clean and be a good partner. I've had none of these problems in my current relationship and I thank my lucky stars I chose to leave exH before having babies with him.

Overtired345 · 16/07/2024 21:40

For example with cooking, is it fair for me to demand he starts cooking when he would happily continue eating ready meals? He'd be changing for me, should I compromise?

Firstly, is he like 600lbs? How does a grown man only eat ready meals and takeaways?

Secondly, when you decide to live together, you both compromise. I don't think it's too much to ask that he be an adult and cook.

Thirdly, kids don't eat ready meals. So if you want a man to have a family with, that man needs to do the basics.

Fourthly, what exactly is he compromising on? Because so far, I can't see any compromises on his part.

He grew up abroad in a house with a housekeeper. So it's not that he thinks stuff is "women's work" or nonsense like that, but that he really doesn't know how much work it takes to manage a home. He has a tiny flat and lives off take away, as I've said.

All the more reason to have some difficult conversations and also instill some boundaries early.

EveningSpread · 16/07/2024 21:33

I see your point about the cooking - perhaps that’s a seperate conversation. If he’s happy with ready meals then it’s tricky. Does he eat healthily? Is he ok with money or wasting a lot on ready made foods? And will he be happy to benefit when you’re cooking? All these things would give me pause - you don’t want to fall into the role of mother/carer. Does he have any desire to improve/change? To cook for you if it would make you happy?

On the other hand, it’s a good rule of thumb to assume you’ll never change anyone - and certainly not expect it!

So on that note, it also depends how import food is to you. Food is a pretty big part of my life and my values (ethically and environmentally) so I’d struggle being with someone who had a totally different attitude to it. I also love sharing food, enjoying similar things, etc. But everyone is different and it’s not necessarily a big deal for everyone!

Desertislandparadise · 16/07/2024 21:32

Thanks for all the advice, everybody, and for sharing your own stories with me. It's definitely giving me food for thought!

OP posts:
Desertislandparadise · 16/07/2024 21:29

CLEO42 · 16/07/2024 21:25

I know you don’t want to give up your flat but I’m especially struck by your comment that your norm is to each be the guest in the others home. This, and the need to be clear from the start about how to live together as equal partners, makes me think you would have a better chance of achieving that equality if you get a place together that’s new to you both.

Can you rent out your flat and rent somewhere together with your boyfriend for a couple of years. It would give your co-habitant relationship the chance of a new start.

(I moved into a boyfriend’s owned flat many moons ago and it was so hard to fit in around his established ways - we were both miserable and split up within a year)

@Overtired345I take your point and you're probably right ... Buuut, I really love my flat! I guess I should at least consider it though.

OP posts: