Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

If employers were mandated to allow employees to WFH unless there was a clear reason to need someone physically in a workplace

233 replies

OptimismvsRealism · 16/07/2024 17:54

All the trains and buses at commuter time would be so much less hideous

Infections would be down

Diets healthier

Work life balance more serene

Why do humans always work against their own interests?

OP posts:
TheBossOfMe · 16/07/2024 22:10

OptimismvsRealism · 16/07/2024 22:06

So everyone suffers because you do?

But you’re not recognising that what you want isn’t what everyone wants. So you’re also asking people to suck it up to convenience you.

DesignerStars · 16/07/2024 22:09

I know I'm a weirdo but I actually prefer being in the office. When I'm in the office, I'm in work mode, I can have face-to-face chats and collaborate without people mysteriously disappearing during the day or dropping out due to constant 'wifi issues'.

I just find it better for worklife balance. My house is for relaxing and chilling out, not for working. I live in a lovely 2 bedroom house I bought before lockdown. I don't want a 'set-up' with 3 screens and chair that looks like it's out of F1 in my house, I want to keep it for relaxing.

I know WFH works best for some people who have roles that are more about putting your head down and getting the work done. But if you have a job that involves managing projects and interacting with a lot stakeholders then it's frustrating.

Hateliars34 · 16/07/2024 22:08

Saltedbutter · 16/07/2024 18:08

How is it a weak argument? If employers could no longer have people on site and it all had to be remote, 90% of most larger companies could probably be staffed from overseas.

For jobs where people don't need to be physically they could already do this. My role was made fully remote after COVID and continues to be for UK employees only. Would be cheaper to hire people in India but they don't have the knowledge of laws/culture/processes in the UK so my employer continues to hire people who live in the UK. Same for all the office roles that people go to a physical office to do, but could just as easily do from home.

That said, I do wish I had the option of occasionally going to an office as it does get lonely WFH, and it does mean we all end up working more from home as it's more difficult to switch off.

Ansion · 16/07/2024 22:07

OptimismvsRealism · 16/07/2024 22:05

And this is what I mean. A lot of us have social lives for this stuff. Work is draining forced contact with people we often completely hate.

It's an opportunity from heaven to WFH. So yes because I and millions of others say so.

Just because you did not get on with your colleagues, does not mean that others don’t.

It is possible to have friends in and out of work.

You are looking at life through a depressed and possibly anxious lens. You might want to get some help with that.

OptimismvsRealism · 16/07/2024 22:06

Betty789 · 16/07/2024 22:03

Someone upthread mentioned a 2 tier society, I see this happening already. Having a job that you physically "go to" seems quite sneered upon now. People working in retail, deliveries, education, emergency services all there to service and facilitate the lives of WFH-ers who are the smart ones with proper jobs.

And bore off with "just find a new job" - when you're a menopausal main earner with a mortgage you don't have the capacity in any sense of the word to slip off and find a new job

So everyone suffers because you do?

OP posts:
HelloSunMyOldFriend · 16/07/2024 22:06

OptimismvsRealism · 16/07/2024 22:00

I'm not. I'm a manager and this is what I tell people who complain that "it's not fair". I suffered an office life for 20 years. Now it's time for a change.

Sounds like you chose the wrong career for 20 years, and now as a manager you are dismissing your staff's genuine feelings and experiences because your way is the only way.

You really don't sound like someone who should be managing people.

Ansion · 16/07/2024 22:06

funderama · 16/07/2024 22:05

I totally agree with this. I honestly think it is a regressive step for women.

It is making women retreat back into the domestic sphere, unquestionably.

I cringe when women extol the virtues of working from home. ‘I can just pop on a load of laundry in between calls!’ How many men say this???

OptimismvsRealism · 16/07/2024 22:05

ElaineMBenes · 16/07/2024 22:03

Now it's time for a change.

Because you say so??!

The best part of my job is meeting and working with people. I don't want that to become fully remote. It's nowhere near as much fun.

And this is what I mean. A lot of us have social lives for this stuff. Work is draining forced contact with people we often completely hate.

It's an opportunity from heaven to WFH. So yes because I and millions of others say so.

OP posts:
funderama · 16/07/2024 22:05

Bruisername · 16/07/2024 21:02

I also worry about the impact on women’s rights as it seems a lot of mums are taking on extra childcare while working to save on nursery. I rarely hear of dads doing it. My colleague is away from her desk 2-4 while she does school pick up and is then online with 6yo fully in her care. Not attending a meeting during your work hours for childcare reasons like that isn’t acceptable.

I totally agree with this. I honestly think it is a regressive step for women.

It is making women retreat back into the domestic sphere, unquestionably.

Ansion · 16/07/2024 22:04

TheKeatingFive · 16/07/2024 22:03

I am glad gen z is so stuck on the internet that gen x will be the last of the office insisters.

I wouldn't be so sure about this. Gen Z kids are the most enthusiastic of anyone about being in the office in my work place.

Yep. They are a breath of fresh air. The OP is jaded and unhappy. We need people in offices who want to be there.

Betty789 · 16/07/2024 22:03

Someone upthread mentioned a 2 tier society, I see this happening already. Having a job that you physically "go to" seems quite sneered upon now. People working in retail, deliveries, education, emergency services all there to service and facilitate the lives of WFH-ers who are the smart ones with proper jobs.

And bore off with "just find a new job" - when you're a menopausal main earner with a mortgage you don't have the capacity in any sense of the word to slip off and find a new job

TheKeatingFive · 16/07/2024 22:03

I am glad gen z is so stuck on the internet that gen x will be the last of the office insisters.

I wouldn't be so sure about this. Gen Z kids are the most enthusiastic of anyone about being in the office in my work place.

ElaineMBenes · 16/07/2024 22:03

Now it's time for a change.

Because you say so??!

The best part of my job is meeting and working with people. I don't want that to become fully remote. It's nowhere near as much fun.

ll09sm · 16/07/2024 22:02

WFH is pisstake for many. As shown in thread after thread on this very forum.

AllProperTeaIsTheft · 16/07/2024 22:02

There should be a workplace bonus for everyone who would find it impossible to WFH!

Excellent! I look forward to that...

OptimismvsRealism · 16/07/2024 22:02

Jeannie88 · 16/07/2024 22:00

I assume most who wfh have got used to no commute, no being around people, time during the day to do house stuff etc so they are very unlikely to want to go back. While I believe there are many who do likely work better from home and are professional, there are also those who take the piss (I know both). I can imagine it becomes boring and it's too easy to get lethargic, being in your home, it all becomes mixed? I've found, always having been in a job that involves human interaction big time, you have no choice but to perform, interact, show your best. Xx

Performance is awful.

OP posts:
middleagedandinarage · 16/07/2024 22:00

Saltedbutter · 16/07/2024 18:01

But it would be yet another hoop for employers to have to jump through?
Id probably give up, lay people off and downsize than going through the bother of having to justify occasionally needing people that get paid to be there, there.

This!! Your employer is paying you to be at work, really annoys me that since covid people think it's their employers responsibility to pay them a wage to sit at f***g home.

spikeandbuffy · 16/07/2024 22:00

I WFH. Makes no difference as I have to log on, do my shift and nothing else so there's no piss taking allowed
If I go into the office I don't speak to anyone all day except hi and bye due to the nature of the job so I may as well be at home

OptimismvsRealism · 16/07/2024 22:00

HelloSunMyOldFriend · 16/07/2024 21:59

Oh fuck off. Now I know your just trolling.

I'm not. I'm a manager and this is what I tell people who complain that "it's not fair". I suffered an office life for 20 years. Now it's time for a change.

OP posts:
Jeannie88 · 16/07/2024 22:00

I assume most who wfh have got used to no commute, no being around people, time during the day to do house stuff etc so they are very unlikely to want to go back. While I believe there are many who do likely work better from home and are professional, there are also those who take the piss (I know both). I can imagine it becomes boring and it's too easy to get lethargic, being in your home, it all becomes mixed? I've found, always having been in a job that involves human interaction big time, you have no choice but to perform, interact, show your best. Xx

Ansion · 16/07/2024 21:59

OptimismvsRealism · 16/07/2024 21:56

She's making excuses and she'll have to adapt.

And she will have to find her own social stuff.

Edited

Don’t be silly now. She is bright and motivated and wants to be involved more in projects. She has plenty of friends from school and university but was hoping to hang out with colleagues.

I think you are right that staying home is the right thing for you.

ElaineMBenes · 16/07/2024 21:59

I'd soon teach them why WFH is better🤣

Except it isn't always the case.
It might suit YOU and YOUR role but that doesn't mean that works as a blanket approach.

There are aspects of my role and working life that are significantly more effective and enjoyable in person. I know others feel the same.

HelloSunMyOldFriend · 16/07/2024 21:59

OptimismvsRealism · 16/07/2024 21:56

She's making excuses and she'll have to adapt.

And she will have to find her own social stuff.

Edited

Oh fuck off. Now I know your just trolling.

HelloSunMyOldFriend · 16/07/2024 21:57

Also during lock down, I lead many staff meetings over zoom and they were just so so much harder and less productive than in person.

In person staff meetings: sitting face-to-face, catching up with colleagues for 5 minutes before the meeting started, getting to know everyone as humans (and I am a TOTAL introvert, but do understand the importance of some social interaction!). Working collaboratively on an objective, running ideas by people you actually know, flowing conversation, laughs.

Zoom staff meeting: meeting leader lecturing to participants, one person piping up all the time to ask questions while the rest are silent, at least one or two with their camera's off ('technical issues' ie. doing something else). Awkward flow in any conversations. Everyone just trying to end the meeting as soon as possible.

OptimismvsRealism · 16/07/2024 21:56

Ansion · 16/07/2024 21:49

My child is doing an internship. She struggles some days as all the meetings are on Teams and she has few people to speak to or learn from. She wants to go in every day and pick up skills. And socialise after work with new ‘colleagues’. Very hard from a laptop.

Being 19 and wfh is very different from being 39.

Shame on seniors hiding at home and refusing to be role models and trainers.

She's making excuses and she'll have to adapt.

And she will have to find her own social stuff.

OP posts: