Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Family expecting us to pay as we’re ‘high earners’

431 replies

Spotlightdeck · 16/07/2024 16:12

DH and I are in our 30s, child-free, living in the city, earning around 100k each. A while ago, we made the mistake of using a family member (mortgage advisor) to arrange a mortgage, resulting in our salaries being shared around my family.

I’m from a small town with low average earnings and the only one in my immediate family earning this much. Since this info has come out, my family’s behaviour towards us has completely changed. At all family meals/events since, no one puts their hands in their pockets and we are expected to pay the entire bill. Snide remarks are made about how we hid the fact we’re “rolling in it”, and we’ve been guilt tripped about how we should be helping people in the family out who are struggling.

Whilst we do live comfortably, we are far from millionaires. I don’t feel that we are in the position to be supporting family financially, nor should it be expected. It’s getting to the point where spending any time with family is a nightmare as finances are almost always brought up or we’re expected to pay. AIBU in being absolutely sick of this and asking for some advice as to how we handle it?

OP posts:
shuggles · 16/07/2024 23:37

@InterIgnis Mumsnet has hundreds of thousands of users from all walks of life, it isn’t the sole preserve of those that on the breadline.

Do you browse this website at all? It seems to solely belong to people who earn colossal salaries (such as OP) and who think that a typical £30k salary is poverty.

Xmasbaby11 · 16/07/2024 23:28

I mean, you are definitely both high earners, of course you are, but that doesn't mean you should pay. It's really quite awful and bizarre that the family are conspiring to pressurise you to pay. Be very firm about this next time, and if anything kicks off, tell them it's the last time you will join them for that kind of event.

Sparrowball · 16/07/2024 23:23

Spotlightdeck · 16/07/2024 17:17

Thank you everyone. I should add, quite a lot has happened for us to finally get to this breaking point. The last family meal was arranged (not by us!) at a fancy restaurant where family members each ordered 4 courses (when paying for themselves, they’d only have a main) and simply passed the bill over to us when it was brought to our table! Safe to say we’ve had enough

Edited

So you both said nothing but paid the bill? What roles attract a salary of 100k and are suitable for meek pushovers?

🤣

Sparrowball · 16/07/2024 23:18

Haven't read beyond the first couple of posts but is this actually true?

Why did you use a family member as a mortgage advisor if you didn't want anyone in your family to know your salary?

Why didn't you report him/her?

Would your family not have an idea of your income based on your occupation? Very few people earn 100k p/a so you're not in an unskilled or semi-skilled role.

If you both have the wherewithal to earn 100k each surely you both can figure out how to deal with this and how to say no to your family?

It sounds like bullshit to me.

Teenagehorrorbag · 16/07/2024 23:15

Spotlightdeck · 16/07/2024 17:17

Thank you everyone. I should add, quite a lot has happened for us to finally get to this breaking point. The last family meal was arranged (not by us!) at a fancy restaurant where family members each ordered 4 courses (when paying for themselves, they’d only have a main) and simply passed the bill over to us when it was brought to our table! Safe to say we’ve had enough

Edited

God that's shocking! I'd have said 'ha ha you must be joking, have you seen the size of our mortgage...????' - and just paid for our own. Let them stew. I can't believe you just bowed down and paid for them all..........😮

Snugglemonkey · 16/07/2024 23:09

isthesolution · 16/07/2024 16:46

Is the mortgage advisor family member at these gatherings?

If so, I'd ask, so that they can hear ' how on earth do you know my earnings?' And when they reply I'd say 'can't you lose your job for doing that?'

Who is suggesting the meals out and the venue? If it's you then you need to be aware of keeping it cheap and cheerful to suit everyone's income. When the bill comes I'd say 'are we working out what we've had or just splitting it 8 ways (or whatever the number of people).' If they ask you to pay I'd state 'ok. I'll pay this time but then it's someone else's turn next time'

Or say, "Who is paying this time? I have paid the last x times"
And if someone says op, then:
"I don't think so, I have paid the last x number of times. I am not paying more than our share". Have cash, put it on the table, and leave.

StuntNun · 16/07/2024 23:08

Spotlightdeck · 16/07/2024 17:17

Thank you everyone. I should add, quite a lot has happened for us to finally get to this breaking point. The last family meal was arranged (not by us!) at a fancy restaurant where family members each ordered 4 courses (when paying for themselves, they’d only have a main) and simply passed the bill over to us when it was brought to our table! Safe to say we’ve had enough

Edited

Oh god that happened to me once when I was too young to know how to react so I ended up paying and then crying all the way home as it was far more than I could afford. I hope you just paid for your food and drinks or an equal division between all the people there and let the rest of them sort it out.

Snugglemonkey · 16/07/2024 23:05

ACynicalDad · 16/07/2024 16:44

Rather than report the mortgage advisor tell him that this is because of him and you don't plan to report him now but he needs to take the lead in getting everyone to pay for themselves in future. And why you pay just pay for the two of you.

I would be inclined to approach this individual too. Let them sort out their mess.

Femme2804 · 16/07/2024 23:05

I don’t understand with so many comments saying cut them all off. For me ita not easy to cUt my family. Because i love them.

i’m in the same situation as you. I’m the high earner and i always pay. Not because they know how much i make but just because i want to. For me its not a big deal. Its not every week anyway.

Jumpingthruhoops · 16/07/2024 23:05

Moveoverdarlin · 16/07/2024 16:22

Madness to let your family member arrange that mortgage. Madness. Whilst I agree with you that they’re fucking idiots and shouldn’t treat you any different. 200k a year with no kids (especially if you’re not in the SE) will seem loads to some people.

If my siblings knew some of our financial matters, they’d be seething with jealousy. Thats why we play everything down. We underplay everything.

But why should you have to do that? You should be able to shout about your success from the rooftops - safe in the knowledge that those who love you will be pleased for you.

Jumpingthruhoops · 16/07/2024 23:00

HelplessSoul · 16/07/2024 16:13

Easy - cut every fucker off.

And report the family mortgage advisor cunt and hope that they lose their job for breaching GDPR with your income details.

Edited

This! With bells on! 👏👏

Whenwillitgetwarm · 16/07/2024 22:59

InterIgnis · 16/07/2024 22:33

Jesus fucking Christ, this isn’t about you! You’re trying to hijack someone else’s thread to bang on about your own obvious distaste and of those you deem to be rich.

Mumsnet has hundreds of thousands of users from all walks of life, it isn’t the sole preserve of those that on the breadline. Not every thread about money has to revolve around those with less, and not everyone has to want a utilitarian lifestyle where they only have the basics. OP and her partner quite reasonably want to have the comfortable lifestyle their wages afford them. That means they’ll have expenses, whether you personally approve of them or not.

What isn’t reasonable is OP’s family treating her with disdain and expecting her to pay for them. I notice you haven’t even bothered to address what the actual thread is about.

Also agreed.

Whenwillitgetwarm · 16/07/2024 22:59

Kisskiss · 16/07/2024 22:20

Part of it is luck , part of it is choices made and part of it does come down to hard work..
please don’t devalue others’ financial success by saying it’s ‘often’ dependent on nepotism and cronyism,. it’s poisonous too as it’s a hugely defeatist attitude - “what’s the point of trying since you won’t get there without cronies or relatives on high places”

Edited

Agreed.

Farting · 16/07/2024 22:56

Spotlightdeck · 16/07/2024 16:12

DH and I are in our 30s, child-free, living in the city, earning around 100k each. A while ago, we made the mistake of using a family member (mortgage advisor) to arrange a mortgage, resulting in our salaries being shared around my family.

I’m from a small town with low average earnings and the only one in my immediate family earning this much. Since this info has come out, my family’s behaviour towards us has completely changed. At all family meals/events since, no one puts their hands in their pockets and we are expected to pay the entire bill. Snide remarks are made about how we hid the fact we’re “rolling in it”, and we’ve been guilt tripped about how we should be helping people in the family out who are struggling.

Whilst we do live comfortably, we are far from millionaires. I don’t feel that we are in the position to be supporting family financially, nor should it be expected. It’s getting to the point where spending any time with family is a nightmare as finances are almost always brought up or we’re expected to pay. AIBU in being absolutely sick of this and asking for some advice as to how we handle it?

Cut the fucking lot.

I did it with my sister 21 years ago and have never regretted it.

More difficult if you’re from a larger family, but nevertheless, cut them.

ManchesterLu · 16/07/2024 22:55

Definitely report the person who shared your financial details with the rest of the family.

Also make it clear that you're not a walking meal ticket and that you expect to split the bill when you go out.

There's nothing wrong with treating your family from time to time if you're in a position to - but it's 100% up to you, and not for your family to assume/expect.

InterIgnis · 16/07/2024 22:47

Geiyotue · 16/07/2024 22:43

200k is huge by pretty much any ordinary standards! Let's not pretend otherwise.

Who is pretending? OP and her partner have their own frame of reference, their own expenses, any their own goals. it doesn’t matter if someone else considers themselves comfortable on £30k and £200k is huge - that doesn’t mean OP has to.

Daisy12Maisie · 16/07/2024 22:47

Maybe say we can't afford to come out for a meal due to getting a totally s* mortgage deal but you are welcome to come to our house for a cup of tea whenever you want.
In all seriousness just don't go out for meals. Meet them for things that don't cost money or not at all.

Taytocrisps · 16/07/2024 22:43

Call them out on it. Ask them how they know how you're rolling in it (even though you know already). Either they'll own up and name the mortgage advisor or they'll look sheepish and say something cagey like, "Oh a little bird told me". I'd follow that up by saying that your salary is your own business and you've no intention of paying for anyone else's meal.

Treating others is all well and good but that should be optional.

Geiyotue · 16/07/2024 22:43

InterIgnis · 16/07/2024 22:35

‘Huge’ is relative. Why would she want to pay for people that don’t even seem to like her?

200k is huge by pretty much any ordinary standards! Let's not pretend otherwise.

GoFigure235 · 16/07/2024 22:39

Wow, terrible behaviour! What a bunch of chancers.

I'd be tempted to "do a runner" and just pay for what you had on the way out 😂.

DoreenonTill8 · 16/07/2024 22:37

Cloudysky81 · 16/07/2024 16:15

You probably need to start cutting ties with a lot of your family.
I would start by avoiding family meals or any situation where you might have to pay them proceeding from there.

This and reporting the twat.

thaisweetchill · 16/07/2024 22:35

I would send a text to all of them (in a group chat if you can) and outline you will not be paying for family meals or anything else going forward. Your wages are your business not theirs. If you both lost your jobs tomorrow would they help in paying your bills? Doubtful.

Definitely report the mortgage adviser, that is a huge GDPR breach.

InterIgnis · 16/07/2024 22:35

Geiyotue · 16/07/2024 22:23

YANBU at them expecting you to pay but yabu to think you aren't rolling in it, you are! 200k and no kids is a huge amount of money. And to be honest, I'm surprised you don't want to pay if your family are on much lower salaries and likely struggling to pay bills.
But they have been cheeky nonetheless so ESH.

Edited

‘Huge’ is relative. Why would she want to pay for people that don’t even seem to like her?

InterIgnis · 16/07/2024 22:33

shuggles · 16/07/2024 22:06

@TellMeWhoTheVillainsAre People with higher incomes tend to have higher expenses. Bigger house, nice car, nice hobbies, holidays etc.

Those are not "expenses." Those are lifestyle choices. I wish someday, people will stop pretending that lifestyle inflation is an unavoidable consequence of having more money.

Do you begrudge someone who has worked hard to earn a nice salary actually spending their own money on the things they like.

If others want more money and fancy meals out they should improve their employment prospects and earning power. Then they can buy themselves nice things without putting their hand out expecting others to fund them.

You're delusional. Of course I work hard too, as everyone else does. But it's not a simple case of "just go and earn more money." You sound like one of those people who thinks people can just motivate themselves out of being disabled, or just stop being overweight. Being a high earner is often dependent on things outside of our control- such as nepotism/cronyism, or being attractive.

Jesus fucking Christ, this isn’t about you! You’re trying to hijack someone else’s thread to bang on about your own obvious distaste and of those you deem to be rich.

Mumsnet has hundreds of thousands of users from all walks of life, it isn’t the sole preserve of those that on the breadline. Not every thread about money has to revolve around those with less, and not everyone has to want a utilitarian lifestyle where they only have the basics. OP and her partner quite reasonably want to have the comfortable lifestyle their wages afford them. That means they’ll have expenses, whether you personally approve of them or not.

What isn’t reasonable is OP’s family treating her with disdain and expecting her to pay for them. I notice you haven’t even bothered to address what the actual thread is about.

PreesHeath · 16/07/2024 22:29

George Michael said one of the saddest things about his success was that no-one else ever paid for dinner,

Aww poor George. I’d gladly treat him to lunch as long as he accepted my budget stretches to Wetherspoons but not The Ivy.