Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Husband secretly messaging friend

89 replies

Lili10 · 15/07/2024 22:50

Please tell me - AIBU

when we got together, almost 7 years ago, my husband was super insecure. He'd come out of a bad relationship and had trust issues so struggled A LOT with my male friends and me going out by myself. I took the approach of I loved him and wanted to help him gain confidence and so reassured him a lot, went out less and was very supportive / open about my male friends (there were not many and not close friends) but gradually these fell away and gradually I stopped going out without him.

My husband recently had a birthday. He showed me a message from a female friend but it was in German (his language) and told me it was just a general catch up message with happy birthday and, because he wanted to be open, there was nothing to worry about.

I thought that was all weird (too much reassurance when it wasn't needed) so a few weeks later I google translated the messages.

He'd messaged her talking about a what if moment about when they'd nearly gone out and imagine what would have happened and did she ever think about it. She messaged back saying stuff would definitely have happened. She asked if he'd be sunbathing nude on holiday etc

For context, they are both married with kids. our marriage is not going well. We have a 4 year old and he's not exactly enjoying family life (he doesn't do a lot with him) and is often complaining my main focus is our DS. Whilst I do try to give DH attention (date nights, sex 3x p/w etc) our DS does need attention and I am pretty much the only person looking after him.

Am I right to feel annoyed with the hypocrisy and like this is the first step to cheating? I am at the moment furious and need some rationalisation I think.

Or am I being insecure and need to focus on him a bit more?

I don't mind him having female friends, but he doesn't mention me in any messages, there's no suggestion of us meeting up all together so we can be couple mates so this all feels secret and like he's a massive hypocrite.

OP posts:
OhMaria2 · 19/07/2024 00:41

MaryMack · 16/07/2024 15:49

Write yourself a to do list and at the top put 'leave husband'. Look into rental accommodation in the UK, ask friends and family for support, and get yourself away from this controlling man.

Except do this mentally and don't write any of it down

XChrome · 19/07/2024 00:31

Vonesk · 19/07/2024 00:23

Forgive me for being cynical. Hes a bloke so dont let him out your sight. If he needs to go somewhere GO WITH HIM. Never let him go out unattended. Family life needs nurturing. All women need to do this. Do like Linda mccartney.

No no no. That's called marriage policing and all it does is create terrible stress. If you feel you can't trust a man it's time to leave him. They figure out a way to cheat no matter what you do anyway. My ex did it on his lunch hour at work.
Family life needs nurturing by both partners. Otherwise it does not work.

Vonesk · 19/07/2024 00:26

Thing is : you cant really leave someone when youve got a kid. The sπ|t continues on a different form. Parental alienation for one.

Vonesk · 19/07/2024 00:23

Forgive me for being cynical. Hes a bloke so dont let him out your sight. If he needs to go somewhere GO WITH HIM. Never let him go out unattended. Family life needs nurturing. All women need to do this. Do like Linda mccartney.

Frankfurterwuerstchen · 19/07/2024 00:12

I speak fluent German. If you want me to translate the messages let me know. Google translate can be a bit odd sometimes.

WiddlinDiddlin · 18/07/2024 16:46

It sounds like he has checked out of your relationship a long time ago. It doesn't take 4 YEARS to 'get on board with being a parent'... it sounds like he has no interest in being a parent and never will.

He may have no intentions of having an affair with this female friend. But the lying to you, the nature of the conversation... all adds up to him being more than willing to have an affair or even jump ship entirely should a suitably better offer come along, her or anyone really.

Sort out your shit, and leave him and live the life you and your child deserve, because pandering to this piss-ferret isn't it!

Maray1967 · 18/07/2024 16:11

The child has lived longer in the UK as he is 4 and they moved to Germany 18 months ago.

Maray1967 · 18/07/2024 16:10

The child was born in the UK and won’t yet be at school in Germany - does that make a difference?

Maray1967 · 18/07/2024 16:05

Lili10 · 15/07/2024 23:34

We are both in our forties.

I have naively just been waiting for him to get on board with being a dad and covering everything whilst he does.

So the follow up question has to be how long are you prepared to wait?

He doesn’t bother much with your child and he’s flirting with someone else. When you raise your concern he tries to turn it back on you.

You’re right to be angry.

MrsTerryPratchett · 18/07/2024 15:19

OP, please please get legal advice before doing anything. I know someone who just 'left' a Hague Convention country with her child and she suffered bad consequences. You are far better playing a longer game and getting him to agree to it. But find a good immigration lawyer and get decent advice.

PrincessofWells · 18/07/2024 15:06

AcrossthePond55 · 18/07/2024 15:01

@Lili10

If I was giving me advice I think, which is why I asked, this is big red flag beating me on the head (I've ignored or missed the other ones) and I think I need to prepare to leave. It's not the messages, I think it's the lie and that he's demanding different things of me

So, I believe in listening to yourself. It seems to me that you're pretty dissatisfied with your marriage 'status quo' as it is. This incident is just adding fuel to an already slow burning fire.

You aren't happy that he's sent an inappropriate message to a female friend. You aren't happy that he isn't 'into' family life. You aren't happy that he's plunked you down in a country where you don't speak the language. You aren't happy that you've been isolated from your own friends and family. I'd say that's quite enough 'not happy' to be going on with.

The most important thing to remember is that a person is entitled to leave a marriage for any reason, at any time. So if you are not happy, leave. It's OK. You need no more reasons than the ones you already have.

Yes, I understand that when there is a child involved it complicates things. But the simple fact of having a child doesn't mean you need to sacrifice your happiness. He's not an interested father, staying around isn't going to change that. And eventually your child will realize that they aren't important to their father and that is damaging in and of itself. If or when the time comes that he does want to be an interested father, that can be managed. But cross that bridge when (if) you come to it.

Listen, you don't need to pack a bag and leave tomorrow. You need a careful, well thought out plan. Friends and family spread out? Think about your relationship with them, how much help they may be able to give you (a place to stay, emotional support, etc) and the job market and housing in their area. Make a practical decision based on practical things, rather than trying to focus on 'the area I like best'. If the job market & housing costs are better in a certain place, go there. The point is to get home, you can always move again later.

And if you feel he's isolated you from friends and family, reach out to them. They've probably been hoping you'll call. You may have to hear "I told you so" a few times but it will be well worth it.

Above all SAY NOTHING TO HIM. Continue on as you have been doing, raise no suspicions, drop the issue of the message. If you are leaving (totally your decision) then that message and everything about him is now irrelevant. The point is to leave, not to give him a jolt and hope he changes (he won't). Make your plans quietly, then execute them. Inform him only when you're ready to walk out the door.

It is imperative that you get a solicitor as soon as you leave, if not before. I'm assuming your child was born in the UK so is a UK citizen. Your situation could be complicated by the Hague Convention if he decides (or is pressured by his family) that he needs to be (or fake being) 'Father of the Year'.

This is good advice except I wouldn't tell him you're leaving. He may try to stop you, and you need to get your child into the UK.

AcrossthePond55 · 18/07/2024 15:01

@Lili10

If I was giving me advice I think, which is why I asked, this is big red flag beating me on the head (I've ignored or missed the other ones) and I think I need to prepare to leave. It's not the messages, I think it's the lie and that he's demanding different things of me

So, I believe in listening to yourself. It seems to me that you're pretty dissatisfied with your marriage 'status quo' as it is. This incident is just adding fuel to an already slow burning fire.

You aren't happy that he's sent an inappropriate message to a female friend. You aren't happy that he isn't 'into' family life. You aren't happy that he's plunked you down in a country where you don't speak the language. You aren't happy that you've been isolated from your own friends and family. I'd say that's quite enough 'not happy' to be going on with.

The most important thing to remember is that a person is entitled to leave a marriage for any reason, at any time. So if you are not happy, leave. It's OK. You need no more reasons than the ones you already have.

Yes, I understand that when there is a child involved it complicates things. But the simple fact of having a child doesn't mean you need to sacrifice your happiness. He's not an interested father, staying around isn't going to change that. And eventually your child will realize that they aren't important to their father and that is damaging in and of itself. If or when the time comes that he does want to be an interested father, that can be managed. But cross that bridge when (if) you come to it.

Listen, you don't need to pack a bag and leave tomorrow. You need a careful, well thought out plan. Friends and family spread out? Think about your relationship with them, how much help they may be able to give you (a place to stay, emotional support, etc) and the job market and housing in their area. Make a practical decision based on practical things, rather than trying to focus on 'the area I like best'. If the job market & housing costs are better in a certain place, go there. The point is to get home, you can always move again later.

And if you feel he's isolated you from friends and family, reach out to them. They've probably been hoping you'll call. You may have to hear "I told you so" a few times but it will be well worth it.

Above all SAY NOTHING TO HIM. Continue on as you have been doing, raise no suspicions, drop the issue of the message. If you are leaving (totally your decision) then that message and everything about him is now irrelevant. The point is to leave, not to give him a jolt and hope he changes (he won't). Make your plans quietly, then execute them. Inform him only when you're ready to walk out the door.

It is imperative that you get a solicitor as soon as you leave, if not before. I'm assuming your child was born in the UK so is a UK citizen. Your situation could be complicated by the Hague Convention if he decides (or is pressured by his family) that he needs to be (or fake being) 'Father of the Year'.

Mum5net · 18/07/2024 13:13

Hi, OP, hope you are coping as best you can. I think you need some suggestions from @AcrossthePond55 and @TheShellBeach who always give sound advice.

Newnamehiwhodis · 17/07/2024 03:49

Yeah the lying is a dealbreaker for me. As is the flipping it around on you, calling you mad, etc, then bringing up your male friends to take the attention off his (genuinely) shady behavior.

he’ll only get worse- once they show this tactic, they’re showing you how low they will go.

I hope you escape.

Lili10 · 17/07/2024 03:43

I would be careful with Google translate.
My husband is German too, and sometimes translation in Google is way off/misleading.

I know what you mean, but I don't think it's the case in this instance. They're talking about "what if" we'd gone for dinner and do you think we'd have had sex, along with asking if he'll be going to nudist beaches on our holiday.

It's also not really what they're messaging about - though I do feel it's flirtatious (even in German). It's how he's behaving. He's hidden the messages from me in his archived chats. And if I was secretly messaging a boy, even in total innocence, he'd be very upset.

OP posts:
Itstime2023 · 16/07/2024 17:57

Lili10 · 15/07/2024 22:50

Please tell me - AIBU

when we got together, almost 7 years ago, my husband was super insecure. He'd come out of a bad relationship and had trust issues so struggled A LOT with my male friends and me going out by myself. I took the approach of I loved him and wanted to help him gain confidence and so reassured him a lot, went out less and was very supportive / open about my male friends (there were not many and not close friends) but gradually these fell away and gradually I stopped going out without him.

My husband recently had a birthday. He showed me a message from a female friend but it was in German (his language) and told me it was just a general catch up message with happy birthday and, because he wanted to be open, there was nothing to worry about.

I thought that was all weird (too much reassurance when it wasn't needed) so a few weeks later I google translated the messages.

He'd messaged her talking about a what if moment about when they'd nearly gone out and imagine what would have happened and did she ever think about it. She messaged back saying stuff would definitely have happened. She asked if he'd be sunbathing nude on holiday etc

For context, they are both married with kids. our marriage is not going well. We have a 4 year old and he's not exactly enjoying family life (he doesn't do a lot with him) and is often complaining my main focus is our DS. Whilst I do try to give DH attention (date nights, sex 3x p/w etc) our DS does need attention and I am pretty much the only person looking after him.

Am I right to feel annoyed with the hypocrisy and like this is the first step to cheating? I am at the moment furious and need some rationalisation I think.

Or am I being insecure and need to focus on him a bit more?

I don't mind him having female friends, but he doesn't mention me in any messages, there's no suggestion of us meeting up all together so we can be couple mates so this all feels secret and like he's a massive hypocrite.

I would be careful with Google translate.
My husband is German too, and sometimes translation in Google is way off/misleading.

MaryMack · 16/07/2024 15:49

Write yourself a to do list and at the top put 'leave husband'. Look into rental accommodation in the UK, ask friends and family for support, and get yourself away from this controlling man.

Lili10 · 16/07/2024 14:48

Thanks everyone. Feels helpful to know that I'm not being paranoid or hyper insecure.
Just not sure what to do next.
Don't really know where to go. I have friends / family in the UK but they are all very spread out, so there isn't an obvious return point.
I don't think he'll object (strongly) to me going back but I would like my DC to be able to see him and have some sort of relationship.
I guess it'll work it out once I have my ducks more lined up.
Currently on holiday trying to pretend I'm breezy. I am not breezy.

OP posts:
Mum5net · 16/07/2024 13:48

@Lili10 Been thinking about you. These are dark days but there will be a time in the future when things eventually resolve and become considerably better. This week, seeing things with fresh eyes and a different perspective, you might find some allies and support from people in unexpected places.

FranceIsWhereItsAt · 15/07/2024 23:51

It sounds like you know what you have to do OP.

Did you move to Germany from the UK? If so, how difficult would it be for you to get back here, and get yourself set up again, ie, do you have family and friends that would support you? Have you previously worked in a sector that it would be easy to get back into? Do you think your 'H' would fight you for your child?

Sisiwawa · 15/07/2024 23:49

Start making plans to leave, maybe you could star applying for jobs in the UK? Many do online interviews, then as someone said earlier, visit the UK on holiday and don't return. He's not gonna get any better from here.

DanielGault · 15/07/2024 23:44

Lili10 · 15/07/2024 23:25

*I thought so. Control is insidious and doesn't have to be obvious. It creeps up on you.

What do you want to do? How do you think he'd react if you started pushing back? After all he's got you right where he wants you.*

Yes, we moved to Germany 18 months ago and I'm finding it hard to find work (learning German but it's hard), so yes - we are fully reliant on him.

I asked him if I needed to worry about her, because I'd never met her and he got super defensive and told me I was mad and then listed "all the male friends" he'd had to deal with which I'd never provided suitable reassurances about.

If I was giving me advice I think, which is why I asked, this is big red flag beating me on the head (I've ignored or missed the other ones) and I think I need to prepare to leave. It's not the messages, I think it's the lie and that he's demanding different things of me.

It's pathetic, but I love him and I just want him to be better but that's not in the cards I've got.

You sound very switched on. He's totally trying to mess with you. It's very calculated on his part.

SensualDecay · 15/07/2024 23:38

He sounds controlling and diminishing of you. The way you talk about sex makes me feel uncomfortable for you, like you're feeding a hungry lion rather than enjoying a mutually pleasurable and loving act. I hope I misunderstood.

Lili10 · 15/07/2024 23:34

Takenoprisoner · 15/07/2024 23:30

This is so hard. I'm sorry you find yourself in this situation.

Can you back to visit family and not return? As he's not interested in your dc, so may not fight for custody. I think you need to extricate yourself with care here. He's a very clever and controlling man.

How old are you both?

We are both in our forties.

I have naively just been waiting for him to get on board with being a dad and covering everything whilst he does.

OP posts:
Mum5net · 15/07/2024 23:32

OP, put your phone away for the night. I know your mind will be racing but you need the benefit of sleep.

Tomorrow really is a fresh start.