Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To find the Ambani wedding distasteful

414 replies

Soonenough · 14/07/2024 21:06

I know everyone can do what they like , it's their money . But such an extravagant event in a place where a large proportion of the population live in slum conditions is rather unsettling.? Plus the bride is stunning but the groom unfortunately does not come across as an individual with a lot

of intelligence . Before I get flamed , he and his family are encouraging the public to view them and I guess are expecting admiration.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
12
marcopront · 21/07/2024 02:57

VerbenaGirl · 20/07/2024 22:33

At least it is some of the wealth distributed from an obscenely wealthy family to many suppliers. Or am I being hopelessly naive?

No you're not being naive.
A lot of people got money from this.

VerbenaGirl · 20/07/2024 22:33

At least it is some of the wealth distributed from an obscenely wealthy family to many suppliers. Or am I being hopelessly naive?

StaunchMomma · 20/07/2024 22:31

Grammarnut · 20/07/2024 21:48

The coronation was necessary and not the sort of thing you want to look cheapskate. The head of state was crowned and dedicated to God, along with his consort. I didn't complain about it - seemed economically done. How much does it cost for the inauguration of a POTUS? And that happens every 4 years. The coronation was the first in 70 years.

It was in no way 'necessary' to be so indulgent as to blow hundreds of millions of pounds of taxpayer money, especially during a period when so many are struggling. I really don't care if Royal engagements make us look 'cheap' to the World.

Pomp & ceremony is not essential, the same as ridiculously extravagant weddings.

Grammarnut · 20/07/2024 21:52

marcopront · 20/07/2024 13:41

@Walkaround

The roads being closed for the wedding did not worsen the monsoon flooding they worsened the impact of the monsoon flooding.
Do you really not understand the difference?

Your article shows that yes there were some people who complained. The people commenting on the X feed were probably middle class though.
I am not denying some people had a problem but none of the people I have spoken to had a problem.
We don't know what your sample size is.

Closing public roads for a private wedding is a bit thick. What gave them the right to do that?

Grammarnut · 20/07/2024 21:51

socialdilemmawhattodo · 20/07/2024 20:23

Surely you are not expecting Heads of State inviting other Heads of State and opening up the country for a mini tourist boom to fund security privately?

And of course celebrities are private individuals and do pay for their own weddings.

But neither for months on end and across multiple countries.

They mean the British RF and have no understanding of how it works, I think.

Grammarnut · 20/07/2024 21:48

StaunchMomma · 20/07/2024 17:37

250 million's worth?!

Nope.

Not even the bloody coronation cost that much, and yes, many of us complained about how indulgent that was at a time when ,any families were struggling to feed their kids.

Spending that much on a wedding is disgusting in my eyes, no matter where you're from AND regardless of race!!

The bloody cheek on you, honestly.

Edited

The coronation was necessary and not the sort of thing you want to look cheapskate. The head of state was crowned and dedicated to God, along with his consort. I didn't complain about it - seemed economically done. How much does it cost for the inauguration of a POTUS? And that happens every 4 years. The coronation was the first in 70 years.

HucklefinBerry · 20/07/2024 20:36

@Walkaround

People living in the city have complained that road closures have worsened traffic problems caused by monsoon flooding, while others have questioned the ostentatious display of wealth.”
This is not saying the wedding caused monsoon flooding ffs.

It's saying the wedding caused more road closures.

The road closures worsened traffic problems that were already bad due to monsoon flooding.

Not that the wedding caused monsoon flooding.

This inability to differentiate is why people do poorly in comprehension tests.

socialdilemmawhattodo · 20/07/2024 20:23

HucklefinBerry · 19/07/2024 03:43

Private people at least pay for their own wedding and security

Surely you are not expecting Heads of State inviting other Heads of State and opening up the country for a mini tourist boom to fund security privately?

And of course celebrities are private individuals and do pay for their own weddings.

But neither for months on end and across multiple countries.

AnnieMcFanny · 20/07/2024 17:54

Princess Sheikha Mehra of Dubai has divorced her husband after commenting on his "other companions"

The Princess made a point but she hasn’t divorced him. She can’t unless she goes to court and the judges grant her a divorce. The husband is the one who divorces a wife using I divorce thee x3.

The Princess is a class act and she has made millions of women laugh, as well as very happy.

Hawkinsresident · 20/07/2024 17:46

Those who can suspend bias and see why this wedding is case study in soft power and compared to royal wedding and South Korean culture

Watch this 25min video...

Was the Ambani Wedding a Genius strategy or just a Show of Extravagance? : Marketing Case study

PS skip the sponsor msg in the middle.

Was the Ambani Wedding a Genius strategy or just a Show of Extravagance? : Marketing Case studt

👉 Register for Register for India's biggest Tech Business event Odoo Community Day - https://www.odoo.com/r/9jE ⭐️ Think School’s flagship Communication cou...

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jLSWPNPSoFs

StaunchMomma · 20/07/2024 17:37

Gingerdancedbackwards · 15/07/2024 06:27

There's plenty of child poverty in this country yet every day, every Saturday, people have tacky, expensive weddings
The hypocrisy on this thread is breathtaking, as is the barely-disguised racism

250 million's worth?!

Nope.

Not even the bloody coronation cost that much, and yes, many of us complained about how indulgent that was at a time when ,any families were struggling to feed their kids.

Spending that much on a wedding is disgusting in my eyes, no matter where you're from AND regardless of race!!

The bloody cheek on you, honestly.

marcopront · 20/07/2024 13:41

@Walkaround

The roads being closed for the wedding did not worsen the monsoon flooding they worsened the impact of the monsoon flooding.
Do you really not understand the difference?

Your article shows that yes there were some people who complained. The people commenting on the X feed were probably middle class though.
I am not denying some people had a problem but none of the people I have spoken to had a problem.
We don't know what your sample size is.

Grammarnut · 20/07/2024 13:09

Kinshipug · 18/07/2024 12:31

That doesn't actually answer why "particularly India". As you've just pointed out, we all know that there are poor people.
It is overt racism to hold brown and black people to higher standards than white.

They are being held to the same standards as the minority ethnic group on the planet (that's white Caucasians) and were specifically compared to e.g. the British Royal Family, whose weddings, funerals, coronations etc are a matter of public display from a family which is accountable to the people who watch/see in contrast to the private wealth being used (perfectly properly, it's their money) by the Ambani family who, whatever their charitable activities, have no accountability to anyone for the wealth and power they are displaying. I would feel exactly the same at an extravaganza by a powerful CEO of a multi-national, he is exhibiting his power, while he has no accountability to the people filling the coffers of the multi-national for his power or how he exercises it. The British RF are accountable to the people of the UK, and behave in a way that shows they know this.

ThisDaringGoldHedgehog · 20/07/2024 09:35

I think that whilst you probably started this thread after scrolling through social media and feeling a bit uncomfortable at what you saw and nothing more, what many who disagree with you are trying to say is maybe challenge your thoughts and ideas.

Sadly this thread has turned into some of the horrible parts of social media

  1. body shaming (the groom has been ridiculed for the way he looks)
  2. judging of women (she is only marrying him for his money)
  3. racism - only this event has been called out despite many linking to other (white) events that are also over the top displays of wealth
  4. Ignorance - you seem to think that India has a specific obligation to deal with poverty over and above any other country. The poverty in the UK is appalling and getting worse. We are a “developed nation” and yet we have children starving and working people relying on food banks. Yet you won’t hear of any comparisons with the wealthy in the UK and holding them responsible (see point 3!)
ThisDaringGoldHedgehog · 20/07/2024 09:23

Walkaround · 19/07/2024 16:04

@marcopront So are you saying that the BBC, Washington Post and Reuters were lying that residents of Mumbai were particularly angered by key roads being closed specifically for the wedding (quote from BBC, “Key roads in Mumbai are being sealed off for several hours a day until the festivities end on Monday”), or are you claiming that closing key roads in Mumbai for several hours a day is normal for an Indian wedding, even if this means that normal people are unable to avoid monsoon flooding as a result, thus making the effects of the flooding much worse than should be the case?

It is actually more than normal for weddings to cause chaos with traffic! I’ve been to lots of weddings (in India) and parades down main roads to the venues is perfectly normal. Sometimes the roads are closed sometimes they aren’t.

Walkaround · 19/07/2024 21:28

@marcopront I did not say the wedding caused monsoon flooding… I said it worsened it - and if I were forced to go through flooded roads because unflooded ones had been closed off for a wedding, I would most certainly as a result perceive this as the wedding making the flooding worse, because the more people forced into it, the worse the flooding is.

In return, I like the way you said “The news reports say
The wedding happened
Monsoon flooding happened

Please share a link to the one saying they are related.”

And then when given several examples of news outlets that do just that, you failed to acknowledge it and instead said that you had no trouble driving through Mumbai on Thursday.

This is from an Indian source, since you prefer that, which is fair enough:
https://www.hindustantimes.com/trending/mumbai-traffic-restrictions-for-anant-ambani-radhika-merchant-wedding-spark-outrage-101720255902005.html

And this BBC report highlights why many are concerned about the excesses of a tiny global elite, of which the Ambani family are one:
https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/c87repz4yx8o

Mumbai Traffic Police has announced some curbs around the time of Anant Ambani and Radhika Merchant's wedding.

Outrage over Mumbai traffic curbs for Anant Ambani-Radhika Merchant wedding: ‘public inconvenience’

Mumbai Traffic Police has announced traffic curbs in the city's BKC area between July 12 to 15 for Anant Ambani and Radhika Merchant's wedding.

https://www.hindustantimes.com/trending/mumbai-traffic-restrictions-for-anant-ambani-radhika-merchant-wedding-spark-outrage-101720255902005.html

marcopront · 19/07/2024 18:25

@Walkaround

Firstly I like the way you completely ignore the fact you wrongly said the wedding caused monsoon flooding.

Secondly I would have more faith in an article from the Times of India than one from western press.

Of course there are people who have complained but my experience being in Mumbai and talking to Mumbaikers doesn't match your opinions.

Walkaround · 19/07/2024 16:04

marcopront · 19/07/2024 08:19

My apologies for thinking when you said "worsening monsoon flooding" you meant making the flooding worse not compounding the effects of the flooding.

There is always flooding in monsoon, there are always roads closed. Indian weddings often block roads. I travelled in South Mumbai last Thursday traffic was not worse than usual.

@marcopront So are you saying that the BBC, Washington Post and Reuters were lying that residents of Mumbai were particularly angered by key roads being closed specifically for the wedding (quote from BBC, “Key roads in Mumbai are being sealed off for several hours a day until the festivities end on Monday”), or are you claiming that closing key roads in Mumbai for several hours a day is normal for an Indian wedding, even if this means that normal people are unable to avoid monsoon flooding as a result, thus making the effects of the flooding much worse than should be the case?

Soonenough · 19/07/2024 12:26

@Hawkinsresident They could have kept it private then . Mumsnet IS for petty thoughts . Guess your family benefitted from their wealth . Culture has nothing to do with it , didn't know expensive watches, Z celebrities, diamond encrusted Rolls were culturally significant at weddings .
Seems to me that you think the best form of defense is attack . Please don't

OP posts:
deeahgwitch · 19/07/2024 12:13

Bad things happen because good people say/do nothing.

Just sayin.

Hawkinsresident · 19/07/2024 08:39

Soonenough · 18/07/2024 23:26

@Hawkinsresident Why the hostility? You realise the majority of responders also found this distasteful? Nobody is educating me . The only person being embarrassing is you . No need to get personal FFS . And are you on first name terms with the Ambani family.

Lol. You are 4,500 miles away from a celebration of a private business family in a nation where you have no idea about its culture, precedence, history, or economic growth. And you create a thread to gather opinions about your petty thoughts. So, you think I’m getting personal?

The gap between developed and developing nations is closing, so I can understand unease within geopolitics, but why is an average Joe getting worked up?

Looks like you have an agenda. I frankly think this is bigotry and am offended by your thought process.

As far as my connection with Ambanis, they have contributed to the nation-building of my home country and made me and my loved ones money through their awesome stock market performances.

GrouachMacbeth · 19/07/2024 08:33

The issue is the fact the media are giving it such attention. Large groups of the media love to feature the rich, the titled, the highly paid - is it rubbing the noses of the plebs in the dirt? It certainly does not promote freedom, democracy and social improvements.

marcopront · 19/07/2024 08:19

Walkaround · 19/07/2024 07:56

@marcopront Basically, if lots of roads were flooded and unflooded roads were closed for the benefit of one family’s wedding so that I could not avoid flooded roads, I would be pissed off with the wedding. Clearly many residents of Mumbai felt the same way. It’s really not hard to understand if you are not deliberately misinterpreting other people.

My apologies for thinking when you said "worsening monsoon flooding" you meant making the flooding worse not compounding the effects of the flooding.

There is always flooding in monsoon, there are always roads closed. Indian weddings often block roads. I travelled in South Mumbai last Thursday traffic was not worse than usual.

Walkaround · 19/07/2024 07:56

@marcopront Basically, if lots of roads were flooded and unflooded roads were closed for the benefit of one family’s wedding so that I could not avoid flooded roads, I would be pissed off with the wedding. Clearly many residents of Mumbai felt the same way. It’s really not hard to understand if you are not deliberately misinterpreting other people.

Swipe left for the next trending thread