Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be up to here with older generation's attitude to car seats

60 replies

comoatoupeira · 13/07/2024 21:12

It's this time of year again, it's the Summer holidays, and they're at it again about the car seats.
My youngest is only 11 months and they're trying to get us to put her front facing (the legs...). I reminded them we talked about that 4 years ago with the eldest (and they've been front facing since age 2, hardly radical, actually against advice).
Loosening the straps (a lot, you could get a teddy bear between them and the straps) on the 5 year old's because she says it's too tight, then driving for 5 hours on the motorway like that.
When the 5 year old gets cross because she gets tangled up getting out, muttering (not quietly, so I can hear): 'yes I know, these car seats are so stupid and unnecessary, we are living in anxious times'.
I'm just ... why? They know driving a car is the most dangerous thing we do. They've all (my parents and my in-laws) had car crashes at some point in their lives, one still has physio because of it. We know someone who's child's life was changed forever because of a car accident.
Why can't they just take it bloody seriously? What are they actually trying to achieve? What do they get out of endangering the safety of my children?
Please rant with me. Thank you.

OP posts:
Branster · 13/07/2024 21:47

Unfair to generalise like this. When my children were driven around by PIL or my own parents, they always used car seats correctly and would regularly ask us to check everything was still fitted correctly. Both sets of grandparents were super careful about up to date car safety for all their grandchildren. And I don't know any grandparents being careless or not following the correct advice,
Your parents are clearly an exception, they simply do not comprehend the importance of this. Maybe you can find some YouTube videos to show them some car seat safety tests, to make them see sense?

MixedCouple2 · 13/07/2024 21:47

Not just older but younger to.
I the designated driver, was being bullied into taking a family child in my car without a seat as the car was full capacity, the MOTHER said to me "oh it is fine just pop them on the lap of so and so! Uuuuuuuh no! The mother built up hope for the child and tried to guilt trip me when the child cried and I refused.
Trying to push their child on us to have a break and be child free and this journey is 1.5hrs on the Motorway for 60% of the way.

Nn9011 · 13/07/2024 21:47

TBH OP I've seen some horrendous advice on here and other social media with parents millennial and younger choosing to make their life easier by buying an unsafe car seat or refusing to one once they've been educated on the dangers because their child their choice. I think it comes down to either people are too stupid to understand why it's important or they don't care because they don't see children as individuals entitled to their own safety above convenience.

I saw an interview with a father of a young child, I think she was 3/4? Head on collision only going 30mph but she was forward facing and died. Had she been rear facing she'd have survived. Always sticks with me, it's so so sad how avoidable it can be.

HoppityBun · 13/07/2024 21:45

PunchyLunchy · 13/07/2024 21:13

You’re about to be called ageist, get ready…

Well yes, because it is. I’m old enough to remember before seat belts were compulsory and child seats weren’t used. I think the behaviour described is appalling.

bergamotorange · 13/07/2024 21:42

The quick way to deal with it is just to say the kids can't go in their cars. Just tell them you are aware they find the car seats frustrating so you are leaving it until they are tall enough not to need a seat.

godmum56 · 13/07/2024 21:42

comoatoupeira · 13/07/2024 21:26

I think I'm being ageist because I feel so isolated. With four sixty five year olds with very strong characters up against me every single time we see them. About this! I can't believe it's about this.
It feels like a gulf, like a culture war, you know.

if you refuse to put up with their shit what can they actually do? You say strong characters but put your foot down. When they mutter ask them to repeat what they said. When they do it wrong correct them, if they do it wrong again, then their child in their car privileges are revoked. I am presuming as you have In laws that you have a partner? Do they support you? Yes okay have a rant on here but go fix the issue!

MaidOfSteel · 13/07/2024 21:38

Your generalising is very ageist.

Teebles007 · 13/07/2024 21:36

Grandparent here with rear facing isofix car seat in my own car for DGC opportunities. Always strapped my own DC's in with best available car seats in the 1980's 1990's. Please don't insult all older GP's with the incompetency of your own family.

CatStoleMyChocolate · 13/07/2024 21:36

I hear you. My parents are in their seventies and super switched on in most ways. They’re very proud of having adhered to the car seat standards of their days and don’t dispute the need for car seats for a minute - but they seem to struggle to accept those standards have changed, especially around RF/ERF. My youngest was ERF to age 4 and you’d think it was a form of abuse. Especially as DSis chose to FF her 15 month old.

Gamergirl86 · 13/07/2024 21:35

My mother is the same. Need to upgrade my 15month baby car seat and she thinks it's OK to.go front facing. I've offered to buy a seat for her (rear facing) amd she says it won't fit in her car.

Says she only takes them (4 yrs, 15mnth) short distances so its not really a factor.

I get really upset about it.

porridgecake · 13/07/2024 21:34

PunchyLunchy · 13/07/2024 21:13

You’re about to be called ageist, get ready…

Well if the cap fits. Why is ageism ok on MN when other forms of discrimination and generalisation are not?

Ratfinkstinkypink · 13/07/2024 21:31

I am 61, no grandkids but I am a foster carer to an almost 4 year old, out of all of his peer group he is the only one who is in a plus tested car seat and is still rear facing when he does use a car seat (he is usually forward facing in his wheelchair and that makes me very uncomfortable as he is a long way of the minimum weight that the seat belt is tested on). All of his peers have parents much younger than I am and I am seen as being anal about car seat safety. All of my little ones who live with me have always been in a rear facing seat, no coats, straps suitably tightened. Guess us older generation can't win! 😀

Julyshouldbesunny · 13/07/2024 21:30

Send a generic message to all of them saying your dc won't be available for day trips this summer until you can be assured they take their safety seriously.. My ils were never allowed our dc in their car.
Mil wore her glasses to assist fil with the driving.
I once got into the car with mil to drive the mile into our town. She never got past second gear..
I got the bus home.

Lifestooshort71 · 13/07/2024 21:30

I brought my firstborn home from hospital on my lap on the front seat in '78. We drove around with him in an unsecured carrycot on the rear seat. We drove my very poorly gran home from Yorkshire flat out on an eiderdown in the back of our estate car. It didn't feel wrong because we never used seat belts. I can't believe how careless we were with such precious lives 😢

AmusedMaker · 13/07/2024 21:29

Op: I’m so sorry you’re in this situation with your parents & in-laws, it must be so draining.

Bonbon21 · 13/07/2024 21:29

Then use your words... these are your kids.
As a grandmother I am saying.. if they are not respecting your rules, they dont get to see/travel with your kids....

Problem solved.

This is not a battle they should win.

5128gap · 13/07/2024 21:28

I know it's been said OP, but I'll say it again, because your thread title is awful. To state that 'the older generation' risk children's lives through lack of car seat safety is terrible. Honestly, would you say that about any other demographic of society on the basis of knowing a couple of people who did it?

Createausername1970 · 13/07/2024 21:28

I am probably the age you are referring to? 60s? I wouldn't have dreamed of taking my DS in a car without a car seat.

My parents in the other hand ....... But to be fair I don't think car seats were really a thing back then. I am not even sure our car even had seat belts in the back. Certainly never used them. I spent most journeys lying on my back with my feet on the window

I think the problem is your parents. What did they do when you were a child?

Citrusandginger · 13/07/2024 21:27

I find your comments about older people hurtful. I'm only in my fifties and the technology around car seats has changed multiple times since my eldest DC were born.

I survived a car accident as a baby that killed two others and I don't need your foul ageism.

AmusedMaker · 13/07/2024 21:26

I’m 61 and look after my grandchildren occasionally - I’m absolutely meticulous about car seat safety, as I was with my own children who were born in the 1980’s.

Bonbon21 · 13/07/2024 21:26

My grandchild is in the back of my car in the car seat that his parent chose, that his parent fitted and adjusted and that I ask their parent to check on a regular basis.
As PP stated ... you have a parent/ inlaw problem.

Just to be clear.

comoatoupeira · 13/07/2024 21:26

I think I'm being ageist because I feel so isolated. With four sixty five year olds with very strong characters up against me every single time we see them. About this! I can't believe it's about this.
It feels like a gulf, like a culture war, you know.

OP posts:
porridgecake · 13/07/2024 21:26

My dc were born in the 80s and we were extremely careful about car seats. I am nearly 70 and I do resent being lumped in with ignorant people. I have seen young parents speeding on the motorway with children loose in the car. It isn't fair to generalise. As for your parents, op, be grateful you haven't inherited their lack of common sense.

Diversion · 13/07/2024 21:23

I am in my late 50's. As a child my parents had us in harnesses in the car, a bit like the ones worn in racing cars. These were bought and not homemade. My children were all in car seats as required by Law and I respect my children's instructions as to what car seats my grandchildren need to be in and would neither complain or comment negatively on this.

Screamingabdabz · 13/07/2024 21:22

YANBU to be concerned over the attitudes of your parents but YABU to be so ageist. You’ll be old one day, and you’ll be even more furious than you are about the car seats, if somebody presumes to judge you and write you off because of your age.