Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To leave baby crying if…

110 replies

Apppron · 13/07/2024 06:52

It’s before 7am and you’ve gone in to settle a few times but they won’t stop? Not needing anything, just wanting to get up. They’re 21 months. I’ve left to cry for ten mins and they did eventually stop but now I’m wondering if that was wrong?

OP posts:
AllIThinkAbourIsKarma · 13/07/2024 07:59

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

thatstakingalongtimetoboil · 13/07/2024 07:58

Most kids start their day at 6.

Gogogo12345 · 13/07/2024 07:57

time2changeCharlieBrown · 13/07/2024 07:45

The title? To leave crying? From 5-7
been in to settle a few times over two hour's”

is pretty ignoring ,I think I would feel I’d ignored my child if I’d only been in few times and left them crying for two hours
sorry but that is my opinion from what I’ve read , if yours is different your entitled to your own opinion, that’s fine of course , but mine won’t be changed and is formed from what I’ve read

Hmm I didn't read that in the OP at all. Please quote where is says that

SallyWD · 13/07/2024 07:54

SallyWD · 13/07/2024 07:52

I did controlled crying when my child needed to sleep (at night time) but there's no way this would work just before 7am. Your child clearly has had enough sleep and is ready to get up! I mean if it was 5am or something it's worth a try, but 6.30am? No way. Just get them up. Bring them to you bed for a cuddle if you want to stay in bed longer.
I don't understand why you'd leave them to cry at them time. Surely you can't relax if they're crying?

Sorry just seen it was 5am! I thought you did it just before 7!
You did the right thing. They needed more sleep (and so did you).

SallyWD · 13/07/2024 07:52

I did controlled crying when my child needed to sleep (at night time) but there's no way this would work just before 7am. Your child clearly has had enough sleep and is ready to get up! I mean if it was 5am or something it's worth a try, but 6.30am? No way. Just get them up. Bring them to you bed for a cuddle if you want to stay in bed longer.
I don't understand why you'd leave them to cry at them time. Surely you can't relax if they're crying?

RedPanda901 · 13/07/2024 07:51

OP, don’t worry. I did this sometimes with mine. If you’re extremely tired and you needed some sleep but still checked on them, it’s fine. You’ll be a much better parent this morning if you’ve rested and recharged too.

Pennyandolive · 13/07/2024 07:51

Maybe you need to read up on developmental stages, attachment and sleep. Babies were left to cry in the past but things have moved on and we now know the damage that it does. Once is probably unlikely to have an impact but if it becomes a regular thing then your baby is going to learn that their needs are being ignored.

time2changeCharlieBrown · 13/07/2024 07:50

Emeraldiisland · 13/07/2024 07:42

She didn't ignore for 2 hours, it was 10 minutes and the toddler went back to sleep.

Now I’m confused people are saying 10 minutes before 7 of course that’s not unreasonable
But then others saying 5am
but 5-7 am is not ten minutes it’s two hours, so now the post is now not making sense

actually edited found the reply from the
op to another comment

** because it was 5am and they usually sleep until 7

Packingcubesqueen · 13/07/2024 07:49

They went back to sleep so I’d say you made the right call. Being left for a few minutes to self settle is completely different from being ignored and left to cry repeatedly for hours. Young children do need to learn to settle themselves sometimes. Some of the comments here are ridiculous.

Didimum · 13/07/2024 07:46

6am perhaps, but I think 7am is quite late for that age.

MammaTo · 13/07/2024 07:46

I’ve been trying to treat anything before 6am as night time. The only suggestions I can make is maybe looking at their daytime sleep, if they even have any now? Making sure bed time is at the right time and they’re not getting over tired.

time2changeCharlieBrown · 13/07/2024 07:46

Emeraldiisland · 13/07/2024 07:42

She didn't ignore for 2 hours, it was 10 minutes and the toddler went back to sleep.

So why is the title
The title? To leave crying? From 5-7
been in to settle a few times over two hour's”

is pretty ignoring ,I think I would feel I’d ignored my child if I’d only been in few times and left them crying for two hours
sorry but that is my opinion from what I’ve read , if yours is different your entitled to your own opinion, that’s fine of course , but mine won’t be changed and is formed from what I’ve read

mewkins · 13/07/2024 07:46

Emeraldiisland · 13/07/2024 07:03

You left them to cry for 10 minutes, not 2 hours and then were clearly tired as they went back to sleep.
Don't beat yourself up, it's honestly not going to affect your baby to be left for a bit. You checked, they were fine and after 10 minutes slept.
I really wouldn't worry about it.

Agreed.

Devilsmommy · 13/07/2024 07:45

BippetyBoppetyBooHoo · 13/07/2024 07:03

Do not wake them now. What time do they go to bed? Most toddlers go through a phased of getting up for the day at 5am.

My 21 month old has got up at 5 since he was tiny. I wish it had have been a phase😂

Thefaceofboe · 13/07/2024 07:45

Why before 7am? They are probably just ready to start the day. Totally normal, what are you hoping they will do? Sit there till you are ready?

time2changeCharlieBrown · 13/07/2024 07:45

Gogogo12345 · 13/07/2024 07:40

Who has been ignoring for 2 hours? Dis you read something different to me?

The title? To leave crying? From 5-7
been in to settle a few times over two hour's”

is pretty ignoring ,I think I would feel I’d ignored my child if I’d only been in few times and left them crying for two hours
sorry but that is my opinion from what I’ve read , if yours is different your entitled to your own opinion, that’s fine of course , but mine won’t be changed and is formed from what I’ve read

Apppron · 13/07/2024 07:42

@johnd2 thank you, I was quite upset about some previous posts x

OP posts:
Emeraldiisland · 13/07/2024 07:42

time2changeCharlieBrown · 13/07/2024 07:28

Ignoring for two hours is cruel and a lot of babies and toddlers can do periods of waking early
some good suggestions above
I used to get up with mine give them a cup of milk downstairs and put tv on low and then snooze on the sofa! We had periods of 5am starts for a while at times around the 19-24 months stage

She didn't ignore for 2 hours, it was 10 minutes and the toddler went back to sleep.

Mere1 · 13/07/2024 07:42

Not ‘maybe’- you should have got them up. It’s not early and they need you. Selfish.

johnd2 · 13/07/2024 07:41

Gosh lots of arsehole posters on at this time of the morning, 50 years ago people used to park the pram at the bottom of the garden and even 20 years ago people advocated cry it out to get your child to sleep.
OP I think only you can judge how to balance your needs and your child's, many random strangers on the internet will loudly tell you all child's needs trump all parents needs but that's not the case.
Having said all that you're child's distress won't damage them but it is telling you something important so use that information and if it starts happening more often then consider solutions. Eg blackout curtain, later bed time, change nap time or length, buy books about sleep and read them together, put an air bed in their room for early mornings for you, etc etc.
Good luck and I'm sure you're doing your best parenting (which is better in the long term than "perfect" parenting

Gogogo12345 · 13/07/2024 07:40

time2changeCharlieBrown · 13/07/2024 07:28

Ignoring for two hours is cruel and a lot of babies and toddlers can do periods of waking early
some good suggestions above
I used to get up with mine give them a cup of milk downstairs and put tv on low and then snooze on the sofa! We had periods of 5am starts for a while at times around the 19-24 months stage

Who has been ignoring for 2 hours? Dis you read something different to me?

DoIWantTo · 13/07/2024 07:39

After 6 you get up surely…. Your baby was crying for you and you just ignored them?

Gogogo12345 · 13/07/2024 07:38

mrssunshinexxx · 13/07/2024 07:03

I mean I'm hungry for breakfast at 7am so I imagine a 1 year old will be

But it was 5 am not 7.

I would've probably just hauled them in with me fro the off rather than spend time settling but it's hardly that terrible they were left to cry to 10 mins. Certainly wouldn't be getting up with a child at that sort of hour. No way would I reward and encourage such early morning waking

InTheRainOnATrain · 13/07/2024 07:37

If it was 5am I absolutely would give resettling a go first. And 10 minutes of crying, then back to sleep shows baby was obviously tired and not ready to start their day yet. Waiting a couple of minutes to see if it’s resettling grumble vs. a proper wide awake scream was always what I did too. More often than not they’d go back to sleep.

mondaytosunday · 13/07/2024 07:35

My first born rarely made it to 6am. Very high energy and an early riser (he still is at 20)!
I never let my babies cry. A couple minutes to see if they self settled, if not I'd go in.