Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To Feel Angered by People Taking So Many Photos for the 'Gram...?

294 replies

LilacCatt · 12/07/2024 21:31

I am feeling so nostalgic right now for life pre-social media and pre-smart phones.

I am mid 30s. When I was 17 I had MySpace. When I was 19 I had Facebook. I deleted social media when I was 21 and have been without ever since. I use WhatsApp and occasionally have a peruse of Mumsnet.

Anyway.

Lately (for the past few years), I feel like whenever I visit a remotely interesting place (days out are my favourite thing to do) I am just so distracted from my own enjoyment by people around me posing for photos. Sometimes I see people doing really cringey things such as taking a few steps forward whilst getting their photo taken as if "candid", then quickly checking the result, and then going back to their original spot to take the same few steps forward whilst posing again.

Oh my god. This is all with people around them who are trying to enjoy the moment of the place of interest.

I feel it really repulses me, and actually angers me.

But I can't articulate WHY that is.

I don't want to be a bitter or angry person.

So I just want to explore this emotion a bit more, and open up the floor for a debate here.

Am I being unreasonable to have the inner emotional reaction when I see this sort of thing going on around me?

Should I live and let live?

Is it a symbol of everything wrong in society???

Questioning myself and my thoughts.

Thanks.

OP posts:
Longma · 13/07/2024 11:02

I grew up without social media but still took plenty of photographs, albeit we were limited due to needing film and only getting 24 or 36 photos to a reel at a time.

However, now I have a digital camera and my phone and still take many photographs - way more than with film obviously. I guess it's a big interest/hobby for me.

The majority of my photographs aren't for social media, even when taken with a phone. I like taking photographs. I like preserving memories to photograph. I spend time editing them to ensure the light, etc is okay on them. I have them saved on my computer, they appear in the attached digital display thing we have at home, and print an annual photo book of key ones.

It's annoying if people keep getting in your way taking their photographs but I don't see how someone else taking photographs bothers others so much outside of that.

Not everyone is going it for the 'gram 🙄

MissScarletInTheBallroom · 13/07/2024 10:56

SammyScrounge · 13/07/2024 10:29

For you maybe, not for others. Why so judgemental? I can think of many worse activities taking.plsve near me than people taking photographs.

The problem is that normal people can no longer just go about their lives and enjoy nice views and tourist attractions without these self obsessed idiots getting in the way.

It didn't used to be a thing.

Then it was just the odd narcissist who didn't realise everyone was judging them.

Now it's become normalised.

Death of the west indeed, as a PP said.

JamSandle · 13/07/2024 10:55

SammyScrounge · 13/07/2024 10:29

For you maybe, not for others. Why so judgemental? I can think of many worse activities taking.plsve near me than people taking photographs.

Well of course I'm only speaking for me. When did I say I wasn't?

HumanLeague · 13/07/2024 10:54

SummerTimeIsTheBest · 13/07/2024 10:44

Not too bothered about pictures at a beauty spot. However, what gives me the irrational rage is people filming things like concerts and fireworks shows. Just be in the moment and enjoy it 😡 How many times are they really going to watch back that crappy grainy video??

That's one of the many things I don't get about the social media sharers and particularly the family vloggers. Not only taking a grainy video of the firework display at Euro-Disney from the back of the crowd with dozens of heads in the way or their recent attendance at a Taylor Swift concert where they're in the nosebleeds and can't even see the giant screens properly, let alone the stage - but then posting a 30 minute video of it on YT for their followers?

But then I also don't understand why people post and followers watch a 'shopping haul' from Aldi or B and M so I doubt i'm the target audience 😅

CynicalSunni · 13/07/2024 10:50

I suppose it's the pointlessness of it all too. They are expending all this effort taking hundreds of photos to put a few up online.

It doesn't enrich their lives or have any positive effect on them in any way. They could be doing so much more.

The only thing that they get good at is editing photos.

It's the more to life thing

Cuppapuppa · 13/07/2024 10:48

There's nothing wrong with sharing a real life situation that's related to a topic

How have you missed that I didn’t think it was related, fair enough you do. Agree to disagree.

Most people do, yet you think it means I'm holding on to anger?!

The post I called ironic (which you asked me to explain) & your original post came across as you being quite hurt & a little bitter. That’s just my opinion & again you can disagree.

Cuppapuppa · 13/07/2024 10:44

The OPs 2nd post literally says

“I like photos. I take a few snaps to look back on. As memories. This is totally fine. Memories from places I have particularly enjoyed being.”

Hence why I thought it was weird to compare it to your mum who never photographed you growing up or whatever. Which I’ve already explained.

It's like your pouncing on me and replying to me with a conversation you're having in your own head.

Again I’m baffled by your take, you have responded to my posts & asked me questions. Am I not meant to reply? If you don’t like or agree with my responses that’s fine but the only person I’m conversing with is you. This is surely obvious & presumably you won’t now reply back to me. 😆

SummerTimeIsTheBest · 13/07/2024 10:44

Not too bothered about pictures at a beauty spot. However, what gives me the irrational rage is people filming things like concerts and fireworks shows. Just be in the moment and enjoy it 😡 How many times are they really going to watch back that crappy grainy video??

YellowphantGrey · 13/07/2024 10:36

LilacCatt · 13/07/2024 10:29

I've spent time overnight thinking.

I think it is a control thing.

I think the whole situation has gotten out of control, and it angers and saddens me, because of how much nicer life could be, and then I feel that anger towards the people who are actively participating and contributing to it all

So then the anger could be misplaced. What's allowed them to get to that point? The availability of social media? The improvements in phone technology? Peer pressure? How larger companies have switched how they advertise?

Many of them are raised in this culture so to them it's normal. Everyone outside of this thinks it's ridiculous because we have a before to compare it to

YellowphantGrey · 13/07/2024 10:33

Cuppapuppa · 13/07/2024 10:28

Irony? Why?

I'm not angry, far from it, why do you think that?!

Does it really need explaining?

As I’ve said repeatedly I think it’s a weird take to read the OP and link it back to your own experience with your mum. It sounds like you have some unresolved anger and upset over it. That’s all.

I was sharing an experience related to picture taking and one of the consequences of not taking pictures.

The op had implied she takes no pictures as she shows people Google images of places she has been. After I posted this, she replied to me and it was quickly cleared up.

I'm not sure where you got anger from me in any of this, it's really weird!!!

It's like your pouncing on me and replying to me with a conversation you're having in your own head.

There's nothing wrong with sharing a real life situation that's related to a topic. Most people do, yet you think it means I'm holding on to anger?!

SammyScrounge · 13/07/2024 10:31

SammyScrounge · 13/07/2024 10:29

For you maybe, not for others. Why so judgemental? I can think of many worse activities taking.plsve near me than people taking photographs.

Sorry place, not plsve.

LilacCatt · 13/07/2024 10:31

MavisPennies · 13/07/2024 09:46

https://www.amazon.co.uk/Understanding-Media-Routledge-Marshall-McLuhan/dp/0415253977

https://www.researchgate.net/publication/240798916_Communicative_Capitalism_Circulation_and_the_Foreclosure_of_Politics

These are the McLuhan and Jodie Dean things.

McLuhan is the person who coined the phrase 'the medium is the message'

Dean talks about the value of the message becoming its transmission (e.g. number of re-grams/ likes etc) rather than the information it conveys this divorcing communication from information sharing and making it a kind of capitalistic numbers game.

Both older references but I think both really shed light on all kinds of social media communication.

Thank you! Ive had a little look and will return this weekend to read in a bit more detail..

McLuhan very ahead of his time. How did he have that insight??

OP posts:
SammyScrounge · 13/07/2024 10:29

JamSandle · 12/07/2024 22:08

I think because it just looks so false. It becomes cloying with time.

For you maybe, not for others. Why so judgemental? I can think of many worse activities taking.plsve near me than people taking photographs.

LilacCatt · 13/07/2024 10:29

I've spent time overnight thinking.

I think it is a control thing.

I think the whole situation has gotten out of control, and it angers and saddens me, because of how much nicer life could be, and then I feel that anger towards the people who are actively participating and contributing to it all

OP posts:
Cuppapuppa · 13/07/2024 10:28

Irony? Why?

I'm not angry, far from it, why do you think that?!

Does it really need explaining?

As I’ve said repeatedly I think it’s a weird take to read the OP and link it back to your own experience with your mum. It sounds like you have some unresolved anger and upset over it. That’s all.

Abundantwildstrawberries · 13/07/2024 10:26

I just took a tour of Versailles and loved seeing the instagram preening in the Hall of Mirrors. It reminded me that this is just human nature. But admit to feeling sanctimonious.

RazzleDazzleEm · 13/07/2024 10:25

I know what you mean op, living in moment but at same time it's wish I'd had this when I was younger.

YellowphantGrey · 13/07/2024 10:25

Cuppapuppa · 13/07/2024 10:24

You said your mum didn’t take any photos of anything including family. The OP hasn’t inferred in anyway that she has done this.

She has and she has already addressed this. Keep up!

Cuppapuppa · 13/07/2024 10:24

You said your mum didn’t take any photos of anything including family. The OP hasn’t inferred in anyway that she has done this.

YellowphantGrey · 13/07/2024 10:23

Cuppapuppa · 13/07/2024 10:18

I know what your trying to say but none of your posts have come across well. You've obviously got a lot of anger inside of you and there's probably something in that that needs investigating and you'd probably then find the insta generation mildly annoying like everyone else as opposed to the hatred your holding onto.

The irony 😆

Irony? Why?

I'm not angry, far from it, why do you think that?!

Remember the really descriptive words the op used and her admissions of hatred and anger over this?

Or are you just bored and deciding to come at me for entertainment?!

Weird 😅

YellowphantGrey · 13/07/2024 10:21

Cuppapuppa · 13/07/2024 10:16

@YellowphantGrey where?

I read this I like photos. I take a few snaps to look back on. As memories. This is totally fine. Memories from places I have particularly enjoyed being.

I took that to mean the OP takes photos but maybe I’m wrong 😆.

And sorry for sharing my experience of pictures not being taken. I'm happy to report it if it's not meeting the guidelines of the topic?

I said it was a weird take, which it is but you do you.

She said if people ask for photos of places she has been, she shows them Google image photos as she wouldn't have taken any different ones. I took at that as her taking no pictures because it's already there on Google.

And the reason I mentioned my mom is because she also took no pictures because like the OP, she believed they are already there in your memory, except the day came where she began to lose hers and we had nothing to show or to remind her. More of a way to say that photos are important and have a place. It's also perfectly normal to share an experience when it relates to something your posting about.

I get the whole influencer culture and like everyone else find it irritating but the OPs reaction of hatred is quite a strong one, hence why I said it must be something deeper down that needs working on

User135644 · 13/07/2024 10:21

MissScarletInTheBallroom · 13/07/2024 07:52

It was a different type of photo taking then though. I know what the OP is getting at.

I'm late 30s and when I was growing up we took our holiday snaps on old fashioned cameras and had to get the films developed. I got my first digital camera when I was about 18 and even though I was a prolific user of social media all through university and beyond, in those days people would take a whole bunch of photos (mostly incredibly unflattering ones) and upload them all to Facebook for people to laugh at and untag themselves from.

These days everyone seems to have mistaken themselves for a fashion model and it's all about the highly curated shots, taken in the most flattering poses, with a thousand takes to get the perfect shot. People plan their holidays around the most Instagrammable sites and their outfits around the fashion shoots they plan to do in front of them. It's annoying for the normal people who just want to visit those sites and admire the view like we always have done to have to wait for all the preening and prancing to stop before we can just enjoy the view and take a normal photo.

Even ten years ago there might just be one annoying narcissist doing it and you could laugh at them but now it's every other bugger and their entourage.

It's really nefarious. Instagram has turned young people into narcissists - particularly women and plenty of men as well. Instagram and Love Island are the death of culture.

Then there's Tik Tok which has ruined young people's into attention spans - and any other scrolling junkie who uses this Chinese app that is banned there.

It's all very Idiocracy. The west is done.

Cuppapuppa · 13/07/2024 10:18

I know what your trying to say but none of your posts have come across well. You've obviously got a lot of anger inside of you and there's probably something in that that needs investigating and you'd probably then find the insta generation mildly annoying like everyone else as opposed to the hatred your holding onto.

The irony 😆

Cuppapuppa · 13/07/2024 10:16

@YellowphantGrey where?

I read this I like photos. I take a few snaps to look back on. As memories. This is totally fine. Memories from places I have particularly enjoyed being.

I took that to mean the OP takes photos but maybe I’m wrong 😆.

And sorry for sharing my experience of pictures not being taken. I'm happy to report it if it's not meeting the guidelines of the topic?

I said it was a weird take, which it is but you do you.

YellowphantGrey · 13/07/2024 10:15

KimberleyClark · 13/07/2024 10:14

That is really the height of narcissism isn’t it, paying to see a major international star and then just filming yourself singing along!

Its ridiculous isn't it?! And where does the confidence come from to do that?! How have they been raised?!