Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Are people just less tolerant of disability accessibility now ?

470 replies

Takemeback02 · 10/07/2024 15:46

I have been raising a disabled child 11 years now and the first 5 ish years I never really dealt with many issues regarding to the assistance she received or disability access.
the last 5 years has been a real struggle. Usually transport / theme parks etc

most recently 6 of us went on holiday abroad to a European destination, 2 disabled children who require a lot of extra care with very high medical needs and equipment. We always check the hotels first and we speak to before choosing one that works for us. We picked a hotel that offered reserved disabled Sun beds. We arrived and they offered us 6 ( same as whole party ) but we told them we only needed 3. We chose ones away from the kids sections and to the side of the main pool,
they were reserved everyday. They placed disabled badge stickers on the beds for the duration of our stay. I reckon there
was 3 days out of 10 where we didn’t have an issue with someone taking them. Most would move on once asked but have a little moan as they did it and a few who got obviously very upset.

one of the days was a nightmare, we were at the pool bar and physically saw a women tair off the disabled badge sticker and throw it on the ground. I put it back on before going to get the kids
changed and when I got back lady was on bed and had removed the sticker again and lobbed it on the floor.

I just feel the last few years there is an obvious difference in peopls
Tolerance for accessibility or has it always been this way ?

don’t get me wrong I know from the past actual accessibility had got far better but it just feels like it annoys people now.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
ATenShun · 21/08/2024 22:30

ibelieveshereallyistgedevil · 21/08/2024 21:00

They may be adapted sun beds,

they may be in a position which is safer for disabled people to access,

they may be reservable because some disabled people are unable to get down to the pool by 7 to get a sun bed,

they may be reservable because some disabled people are unable to get down and lie/sit on a towel on the floor

they may be closer to other facilities (eg, the accessible loo)

they may be placed such that wheelchair users can navigate between them

I could go on…

People really really will be happier not being able to reserve a sun bed than with a sun bed and my disability.

Of course they may not have any adaptation. Without knowing the full set-up and basing it purely on what is in the OP. I read it as somebody who is asking for preferential treatment based on want rather than need. I'm willing to bet if those sunbeds were in a less desirable position & further back from the pool nearer the building, they wouldn't be taken by others. That would be my suggestion to the hotel operator.

She also describes being at the bar and watching her unused sunbeds being claimed. I'm willing to bet most of us have been in that position. Sitting silently seething as we sit on a plastic chair or lay on a towel while somebdy has claimed beds that they aren't using.

The party in the OP post sound like they have able bodied among them (4 able bodied adults/children 2 children with disabilities) to do the sunbed dash, which in itself is hilarious to watch and often done by people who only then appear after lunch.

How many of those other holidaymakers would be unable to lie down on a towel. I couldn't due to knee issues.

Obviously cannot speak in this instance any more than you can, but the likelihood is that toilets and other facilities will be less likely to be next to the pool. Likewise access to those beds are more likely than not to be more difficult than beds set further back as example.

ibelieveshereallyistgedevil · 21/08/2024 21:46

CherryBlo · 21/08/2024 21:36

Me too! I'd ask fellow passengers and the driver to assist someone in this situation.
If this was the case I'd do my level best to make sure that both of us were able to use the bus. It's usually possible with a bit of jiggling and cooperation anyway. I'd also offer to hold the child though I realise not everyone is comfortable with that (both ways). I've found interacting with other disabled people in public we usually have enough resourcefulness between us to make it work. If we really couldn't both fit, in reality I'd cede to you if your disability also means you can't stand and wait for longer at the bus stop and you were there first. Although if I was on my way to a medical appointment or work and it was the second bus I couldn't get on (always allow two buses if you're a wheelchair user!), I'd be a bit stuck because wheelchair taxis aren't easy to come by last minute.

Also to note that this exception when it comes to helping other disabled people does not mean that all wheelchair users should cede to people with prams just in case there's an invisible disability that they don't want to declare. Whilst I don't think in general disabled people should be made to disclose their conditions in public, my access needs are obvious and if I'm going to give them up I need to know that the other person also has access needs.

Yep- I’m always happy to be helpful- and I’m actually pretty good at lifting so possibly could do the pram thing myself.

Also, if someone explained the situation and I could give up the wheelchair space (had time/energy/no kids with me etc then I’m not averse to it- I wouldn’t insist on the space for the sake of it…

but I won’t give it up to someone who can’t be arsed to fold their pram/doesn’t know how to fold it/chose a non folding carriage pram/doesn’t fancy holding their baby etc.

NotificationsOff · 21/08/2024 21:41

MyOtherWheelchairIsABroomstick · 12/07/2024 13:31

Yes you're right. I'm a visibly disabled person and most people treat me horribly. Every time I go outside I am mocked in some way by people who feel it's OK to shout things at me. Even just shouting "wheelchair" at the top of your lungs is ableism unless you shout "legs" at every person who walks past. People feel entitled to say something to or about me. I've been hit by people being asked to move luggage on trains. Bus drivers slam the ramp down to hurt my ears when they get fed up of it being me waiting at the same stop every day. They feel entitled to moan about me using the bus during rush hour as though they assume I don't work. I get stopped for "shoplifting" all. the. time. Teenagers throw things at me. They stand in the pavement and refuse to move and say "run me over then" or they push each other in front of me. I have been spat at. Had old neighbours leaving obstacles on my doorstep and dog muck laughing about it. Council workmen do shoddy jobs upstairs as they know I can't check until my carer is home. People who come to my house to help me steal things. I've had druggie neighbours take medication from the pharmacy. Grown men shouting "pop a wheelie" in my ear while their families look on in disgust. The ambulance service would abandon my £9,000 chair in an emergency because they don't have a metal loop to secure it to. Premises don't have ramps or reasonable adjustments and don't care when you point out that's not to legislation. Almost everything I want to do in life is totally inaccessible to me. Apart from changing places toilets... who has actually been inside a fully accessible WC. Nobody cares. Except other disabled people.

This and many other stories have disgusted me.

I am sorry to everyone this has happened to. What the hell is wrong with people???

CherryBlo · 21/08/2024 21:36

ibelieveshereallyistgedevil · 21/08/2024 21:25

That’s an awkward situation. I would have thought the driver would lift the pram for you? Surely that’s less hassle for them than forcing you off the bus?

It isn’t an issue on our local service because we don’t have the storage platform with the railings thingy anymore.

If I was the wheelchair user in question I’d be calling up the bus for someone to come and help so we could both get sorted!

Me too! I'd ask fellow passengers and the driver to assist someone in this situation.
If this was the case I'd do my level best to make sure that both of us were able to use the bus. It's usually possible with a bit of jiggling and cooperation anyway. I'd also offer to hold the child though I realise not everyone is comfortable with that (both ways). I've found interacting with other disabled people in public we usually have enough resourcefulness between us to make it work. If we really couldn't both fit, in reality I'd cede to you if your disability also means you can't stand and wait for longer at the bus stop and you were there first. Although if I was on my way to a medical appointment or work and it was the second bus I couldn't get on (always allow two buses if you're a wheelchair user!), I'd be a bit stuck because wheelchair taxis aren't easy to come by last minute.

Also to note that this exception when it comes to helping other disabled people does not mean that all wheelchair users should cede to people with prams just in case there's an invisible disability that they don't want to declare. Whilst I don't think in general disabled people should be made to disclose their conditions in public, my access needs are obvious and if I'm going to give them up I need to know that the other person also has access needs.

ibelieveshereallyistgedevil · 21/08/2024 21:25

CassandraWebb · 21/08/2024 21:20

I mean , for instance, that my disability prevented me from folding down pushchairs and lifting them onto the storage spaces. If someone was willing to help me at both ends of my journey I could, but you don't always get willing volunteers

That’s an awkward situation. I would have thought the driver would lift the pram for you? Surely that’s less hassle for them than forcing you off the bus?

It isn’t an issue on our local service because we don’t have the storage platform with the railings thingy anymore.

If I was the wheelchair user in question I’d be calling up the bus for someone to come and help so we could both get sorted!

CassandraWebb · 21/08/2024 21:21

ibelieveshereallyistgedevil · 21/08/2024 21:00

They may be adapted sun beds,

they may be in a position which is safer for disabled people to access,

they may be reservable because some disabled people are unable to get down to the pool by 7 to get a sun bed,

they may be reservable because some disabled people are unable to get down and lie/sit on a towel on the floor

they may be closer to other facilities (eg, the accessible loo)

they may be placed such that wheelchair users can navigate between them

I could go on…

People really really will be happier not being able to reserve a sun bed than with a sun bed and my disability.

Quite. I don't go to those kind of pools but I wouldn't be able to walk round and round looking for an available.

I would rather be fit and healthy and battling it out with everyone else for a bed

CassandraWebb · 21/08/2024 21:20

ibelieveshereallyistgedevil · 21/08/2024 20:51

Yes they might be disabled and need a priority seat, but unless they use a wheelchair they don’t need the wheelchair space.

I mean , for instance, that my disability prevented me from folding down pushchairs and lifting them onto the storage spaces. If someone was willing to help me at both ends of my journey I could, but you don't always get willing volunteers

ibelieveshereallyistgedevil · 21/08/2024 21:00

ATenShun · 21/08/2024 20:22

Is anyone seeing Will from the Inbetweeners here? 😀

This may sound callous, but isn't meant that way. Do the sunbeds you reserved have any adaptation on them or are they just regular sunbeds. Also can anyone reserve a sunbed? If not, then you are getting favourable treatement and as such I can understand to a degree other peoples frustration. Especially for childless people who will also choose away from the kid area next to the pool.

They may be adapted sun beds,

they may be in a position which is safer for disabled people to access,

they may be reservable because some disabled people are unable to get down to the pool by 7 to get a sun bed,

they may be reservable because some disabled people are unable to get down and lie/sit on a towel on the floor

they may be closer to other facilities (eg, the accessible loo)

they may be placed such that wheelchair users can navigate between them

I could go on…

People really really will be happier not being able to reserve a sun bed than with a sun bed and my disability.

ibelieveshereallyistgedevil · 21/08/2024 20:51

CassandraWebb · 21/08/2024 20:06

You would have to be mindful though that the pushchair user could also have a disability. It's not a simple binary

Yes they might be disabled and need a priority seat, but unless they use a wheelchair they don’t need the wheelchair space.

CherryBlo · 21/08/2024 20:33

est1980 · 21/08/2024 19:08

It is okay to disagree with people you know. In fact, it makes for a much more interesting conversation than -I thinks this, yeah me too, I think that, yeah. Me too...it's healthy. Don't worry I neither like or dislike you anymore or less now that we have a difference of opinion, than when we were of the same opinion. The 2 are not mutually exclusive lol

I hadn't thought about being liked or disliked by someone I've never met, don't worry

CherryBlo · 21/08/2024 20:31

est1980 · 21/08/2024 19:04

You confusing vacating the space with vacating the vehicle entirely. There is no law that would demand this.

Yes, technically you have to vacate the space. But if you can't vacate the space and stay on the bus, because you can't fold the pram, then you have to get off in order to vacate the space. It says on the stickers that wheelchair users have priority by law.
I'm not some monster. I don't want to make parents and children get off buses, and as it happens it's never yet come to that. I'll even hold the baby if necessary while the pram is folded (which again, I haven't had to do). But the fact remains that it's the law, and if it comes to it I will insist on my rights. Especially if it's in the winter because half an hour longer at the bus stop in the cold could have an impact on my condition such that I can't move the next day. And no I'm not allowed to drive, before someone tries to tell me that if it's that bad I should just not take the bus.
As you asked for the law, here's the supreme court ruling https://www.supremecourt.uk/cases/docs/uksc-2015-0025-judgment.pdf FirstGroup vs Paulley. Paulley won damages to confirm that it would have been a reasonable adjustment for a woman with a pram to have been required to wake her child, fold down the pram, and move it out of the wheelchair space. Further, if that had really not been possible, or more likely, if she simply preferred not to wake the child, it would have been reasonable to require her to leave the bus.
I quite liked the phrase in para 117 "Here the context is the elimination of discrimination against disabled people. That will require, in appropriate circumstances, able-bodied people to accept restrictions that they may find irksome or inconvenient."
The whole thing is worth a read for an interesting discussion of how reasonable adjustments are decided and enforced and balanced against the needs of other protected groups.

https://www.supremecourt.uk/cases/docs/uksc-2015-0025-judgment.pdf

Everlore · 21/08/2024 20:23

I'd like to extend my heartfelt sympathy for the posters on here who are so resentful of all of the 'special treatment' all us disabled people get. However, look on the bright side, if you're really lucky one day you or a loved one may have an accident or contract a serious illness which will leave you with a life-long life-limiting disability. Then you too will be able to experience the five-star VIP treatment we disabled people have come to enjoy. You too can experience the thrill of having people make the bare minimum effort to allow you to access services and facilities that able-bodied people can access without a thought while unpleasant and resentful expletive deleteds look on and tut about all the special treatment you're getting. That's if the most minimal accommodations are made in the first place, which they very often aren't.
Navigating a mostly inaccessible world where people often resent the very minor accommodations which transport and public services might begrudgingly see fit to make for us is so much fun, I do hope some of the able-bodied posters on here get to experience it for themselves one day!

ATenShun · 21/08/2024 20:22

Is anyone seeing Will from the Inbetweeners here? 😀

This may sound callous, but isn't meant that way. Do the sunbeds you reserved have any adaptation on them or are they just regular sunbeds. Also can anyone reserve a sunbed? If not, then you are getting favourable treatement and as such I can understand to a degree other peoples frustration. Especially for childless people who will also choose away from the kid area next to the pool.

est1980 · 21/08/2024 20:10

TomatoSandwiches · 21/08/2024 20:01

I would absolutely expect a pushchair user to leave the wheelchair space for my son and I would remain on the bus until they moved or got off as I used to when we used a pushchair... it's a space dedicated to wheelchair users, it's a protected space.

Yes, the space is protected, not the entire bus. They have to move out the space-if there is nowhere for them to move to however,they do not have to vacate the entire bus.

est1980 · 21/08/2024 20:07

CassandraWebb · 21/08/2024 20:06

You would have to be mindful though that the pushchair user could also have a disability. It's not a simple binary

You took the words out of my mouth.

CassandraWebb · 21/08/2024 20:06

TomatoSandwiches · 21/08/2024 20:01

I would absolutely expect a pushchair user to leave the wheelchair space for my son and I would remain on the bus until they moved or got off as I used to when we used a pushchair... it's a space dedicated to wheelchair users, it's a protected space.

You would have to be mindful though that the pushchair user could also have a disability. It's not a simple binary

est1980 · 21/08/2024 20:06

CassandraWebb · 21/08/2024 19:51

I found it interesting that when I was allowed to "queue jump" because I have difficulty standing for any length of time I could hear the grumbling of other people as I was escorted past. The reality was that I was going past to collect a hired mobility scooter and then wait for my family who queued normally. But all they saw was someone "who looked healthy" jumping the queue

Yet when I went to another attraction a week or so later in my electric wheelchair noone seemed to mind me queue jumping at all (I was escorted past because they only had one wheelchair height desk) even though in that case my family came too.

The reality was in a wheelchair I was far more able to queue than probably many of the people in the queue. Without a mobility aid I really can't stand for any length of time at all without getting very ill. There's a real stigma and ignorance attached to invisible disability. Maybe because some people exploit it but I would say it's more because psychologically people like tangible "evidence"

All of this. It's so frustrating. The only thing I woukd say is that the assumption that invisible disabilities are used to exploit the system, is simply not true, or to a far far lesser degree than people assume. You have to jump through hoops to get things that prove you are disabled, so much evidence and assessments that the liklihood of someone managing to obtain it when there's nothing wrong with them is so very unlikely. You were spot on with you last sentence, absolutely nailed it

TomatoSandwiches · 21/08/2024 20:01

est1980 · 21/08/2024 18:21

Well thats not true on either count. If you have 2 children in a buggy, and you remove the children to fold the buggy, where do you now put the children? And where do you put any bags that were on/in the buggy?
Also, the space, at least on my area is actually labelled an accessible space-not specifically a wheelchair space. And even in scenarios where it is a wheel chair space, it doesn't state that no one else could use it, just that it should be given up if a wheelchair user needs it. Now when you get on a bus, with a buggy, you have no way of knowing whether a person using a wheelchair will need the space during your journey. It is not unreasonable to expect a pram user to make way for the wheelchair user as much as is practical, but it is entirely unreasonable to demand they get off the bus entirely, I don't think most wheelchair users would even expect or want them to do this either.

I would absolutely expect a pushchair user to leave the wheelchair space for my son and I would remain on the bus until they moved or got off as I used to when we used a pushchair... it's a space dedicated to wheelchair users, it's a protected space.

est1980 · 21/08/2024 19:58

CassandraWebb · 21/08/2024 19:41

How do you know they don't have a mobility issue? I look youngish and healthy. I don't walk with any obvious difficulty but the more I walk the more unwell I become and standing up makes me very ill rapidly (bizarre as it may seem it doesn't just make my legs weak it also can make me lose the ability to speak, swallow or see). But you wouldn't know that to look at me. Unless you spotted the little medicalert bracelet I wear everywhere

I was literally about to say exactly this. Unfortunately there is no way of knowing whether a person has mobility needs or not just by looking at them. And its a dangerous route to start questioning a person's 'rights' to use these seats. Of course, this does leave the system open to abuse, but unfortunately, that's just something that's unavoidable. Personally I'm sick of the bombastic side eyes I get day in and day for parking in disabled bays or sitting in accessible seats, being walked past long queues of people to the very front of the line etc and hearing all the under the bteath comments and grumbles. I need the accomodations I am given. That doesn't change because I don't fit people's preconceptions of what a disabled person should 'look like' All we can do in this particular scenario, is trust that the vast majority of people are honest and fair. Even with my mobility issues, if I was using an accessible seat, and someone got on the bus who appeared to need the seat more than me, I would still offer them the seat-only it wouldn't look like a disabled person giving was to another disabled person because their need seemed greater, it would just look like I was an arse who shouldn't have been sitting there in the first place and would attract negative attitudes ...but that's a whole different kettle of fish🫠

CassandraWebb · 21/08/2024 19:51

I found it interesting that when I was allowed to "queue jump" because I have difficulty standing for any length of time I could hear the grumbling of other people as I was escorted past. The reality was that I was going past to collect a hired mobility scooter and then wait for my family who queued normally. But all they saw was someone "who looked healthy" jumping the queue

Yet when I went to another attraction a week or so later in my electric wheelchair noone seemed to mind me queue jumping at all (I was escorted past because they only had one wheelchair height desk) even though in that case my family came too.

The reality was in a wheelchair I was far more able to queue than probably many of the people in the queue. Without a mobility aid I really can't stand for any length of time at all without getting very ill. There's a real stigma and ignorance attached to invisible disability. Maybe because some people exploit it but I would say it's more because psychologically people like tangible "evidence"

ibelieveshereallyistgedevil · 21/08/2024 19:45

est1980 · 21/08/2024 19:42

My DS could never travel on a bus because of severe sensory needs and autism, he'd be fine if we were the only 2 passengers though. Is it reasonable for me to demand everyone vacate the bus because he simply unable to use it if it's full of people?

No, because there are no legal provisions for needing an empty bus.

ibelieveshereallyistgedevil · 21/08/2024 19:44

est1980 · 21/08/2024 19:33

Umm firstly, myself and both of my children are disabled.
Secondly, they are 17 and 19 and o drive so I neither use the bus nor a buggy-my examples were just that examples.

I'm not even going to comment on the ratiobale people with buggies didn't campaign for the space, so they shouldn't be able to use it. Except to repeat my earlier point that a lot of these spaces are 'accessible speces' not specifically wheelchair spaces, which absolutely includes buggy users.

Obviously There's the chance that bus after bus will pass with no space. Why not ask 6 able bodies people to get off so the buggy can move to make space for the wheel chair? It's just not a practical, no fair solution. Which is now leaning towards discriminating against what? Parents? Children who can't walk? Parents who don't drive and rely on public transport? Where does it stop? A bus driver could potential stop people boarding at the point there would ALWAYS be a space for a wheel chair, but aside from that somethings just are never going to a a perfect system that works 100% of the time. We need to remember, disability rights, or any other type of rights for that matter are about making sure things are fair and equal to all, but not at the expense of making things unfair for a different group of people. Making reasonable reasonable adjustments/accomadations -folding the buggy-a reasonable request that whilst it may irk the buggy user, would no be considered an 'unfair' request. This is a reasonably adjustment.

Making a person with a buggy get off a bus -this would definitely be considered and unfair request and therefore is not a reasonable adjustment.

It isn’t a matter of opinion, again, it’s the law.

If a buggy is in the wheelchair space the driver is legally bound to tell them to move.

If they won’t fold their pram, or there isn’t space to move it within the bus, then they move it off the bus- they can not legally occupy a wheelchair space which a wheelchair user needs to use.

If they don’t do that they are banned from the bus/the bus has to wait/the driver can call the police/the selfish dick who doesn’t move can be chased by the bus company for costs.

It’s really simple to understand.

a lot of these spaces are 'accessible speces' not specifically wheelchair spaces,

Every bus has to have at least one designated wheelchair space- they may also have ‘accessible’ spaces, and ‘priority seats’ etc- but if there is only one space with a wheelchair board and anchor in it- legally it is for the use of wheelchairs before anyone else.

est1980 · 21/08/2024 19:42

ibelieveshereallyistgedevil · 21/08/2024 19:34

Can’t travel with another wheelchair user.

Yep, I can’t go out with my mum on public transport because on a bus or in a taxi there is only one W/C space.

If my Ds’s disability means he needs a chair in future the same will apply to us- I won’t be able to take my son out on the bus or in a taxi (at the moment he is just about ok on my knee but at 10 that won’t last more than a few more months).

My DS could never travel on a bus because of severe sensory needs and autism, he'd be fine if we were the only 2 passengers though. Is it reasonable for me to demand everyone vacate the bus because he simply unable to use it if it's full of people?

CassandraWebb · 21/08/2024 19:41

Seymour5 · 12/07/2024 08:46

I’m in my 70s, I have a BB, I also have a senior bus pass. My main disability is mobility, sometimes I use a stick for balance. I don’t always park in marked bays, especially at supermarkets as I can walk pretty well holding a trolley. My beef is about public transport.

On the tram, there are accessible seats for people with mobility issues. There are signs saying the seats are for people with reduced mobility. There are pictures to help those who can’t read, or who don’t read English. So, why do so many people without mobility issues choose those seats, even when there are plenty of others available? Difficulty with walking is a mobility issue. Older age doesn’t necessarily mean disability, but it often brings frailty and poor balance. It’s also pretty obvious. But we’re either ignored or resented by some as boomers due to ‘having it all’!

A big thank you to those people who are aware of need, and react accordingly. It is much appreciated.

Edited

How do you know they don't have a mobility issue? I look youngish and healthy. I don't walk with any obvious difficulty but the more I walk the more unwell I become and standing up makes me very ill rapidly (bizarre as it may seem it doesn't just make my legs weak it also can make me lose the ability to speak, swallow or see). But you wouldn't know that to look at me. Unless you spotted the little medicalert bracelet I wear everywhere

CassandraWebb · 21/08/2024 19:38

Melisha · 10/07/2024 19:01

I think there is a lack of understanding for people with physical disabilities, even amongst people with other disabilities. My DP uses a wheelchair. I have lost count of the amount of times we have went out with people who say they are disabled, use a mobility scooter or power chair, and when DP says they can not dance or walk far they agree they are the same. Then later in the night after a few drinks they are dancing away. They say they will pay for it the next day, but they can do it. My DP physically can not, ad they always seem surprised when they realise that.

I use a power chair sometimes. Other times I don't. Sometimes I overdo it and then I might be desperately ill for days or even end up in hospital. So I can't really do it all all but sometimes I make stupid decisions. I am regularly fully aware how lucky I am to have some mobility. But on the other hand the "disabled " (bed bound , unable to speak or swallow) part of my life is largely invisible to others. For instance I was helping at a charity event and I felt this weight of expectation that I should physically do things but I already felt unwell and knew it would be really dangerous.

Different battles and I am fully appreciative of my good moments and good days and never take those for granted but equally I am always at risk of ending up in ICU on a ventilator if I do too much so it's certainly no trivial medical condition despite outward appearances to a casual observer

Swipe left for the next trending thread