Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask for feedback from my date?

58 replies

Iaminthefly · 09/07/2024 18:00

Just recieved a polite "thanks but no thanks" after a date a few days ago. We are both female and I actually thought things were going well!

I'm honestly tempted to message her and ask if there's anything I can do to make myself more appealing. I know people say just be yourself but it's clearly not enough.

The last person I dated ghosted me after six months. I've been single six years since my husband left me. I'm starting to think I'm just unlovable.

OP posts:
JawJaw · 09/07/2024 19:27

Ohwellithappens · 09/07/2024 18:59

I was once asked for feedback. The reason that I didn't want to date the guy was he had greasy hair and dirt under his finger nails. I am pretty sure he knew those points and didn't need me to suggest he washes. I just said I didn't feel we were compatible that's my point it mattered to me but won't to someone else. Honestly when I got a request for feedback I found it annoying.

This is a good example of why people on here are wrong to say that everyone is perfect as they are and they will eventually meet the right person. Some people are great, but they haven’t noticed something about themselves that is off putting but could easily be fixed. The problem is few people are willing to tell someone what that thing is.

But it really isn’t helpful to believe that everyone is perfect.

Iaminthefly · 09/07/2024 19:22

Hopefully I don"t have greasy hair or dirt under my fingernails🤣

OP posts:
Ohwellithappens · 09/07/2024 18:59

I was once asked for feedback. The reason that I didn't want to date the guy was he had greasy hair and dirt under his finger nails. I am pretty sure he knew those points and didn't need me to suggest he washes. I just said I didn't feel we were compatible that's my point it mattered to me but won't to someone else. Honestly when I got a request for feedback I found it annoying.

Iaminthefly · 09/07/2024 18:55

@leopardski It's almost impossible to even get a date when you date women. I think it would take me ten life times to date twenty🤣

OP posts:
leopardski · 09/07/2024 18:51

Oh OP!
Dating is hard. But you either click with someone or you don’t. Don’t let it put you off!
One of my best friends dated 20 people via Tinder back in the day; the 21st she is now married to.

Iaminthefly · 09/07/2024 18:50

@DatingDinosaur I do sometimes wonder if I give off vibes of being that 'strong' that I don't need anyone.

But then whenever I've made myself vulnerable in the past it's worked against me. So I just don't know how to behave anymore...

OP posts:
Pikopikoputput · 09/07/2024 18:49

As long as you’re prepared for a negative response. And negative could be silence, blocking, a snarky response, or genuine feedback..:but keep in mind it’s just that one person’s opinion. You’d have to go on many dates and then turn it into a study whereby you ask for feedback and see what is commonly said. In the process you might find your ‘one’, you might find some serious problem that is fixable, or you might end up with your self esteem in tatters.

DatingDinosaur · 09/07/2024 18:45

Iaminthefly · 09/07/2024 18:25

@DatingDinosaur I've worked on appearing confident as it's vital for my career. Making others feel at ease is part of my job role!

Obviously I'm not that confident underneath or I'd not be here wondering wtf is wrong with me🙈

Ahh, yes, but you're not at work when you're dating so it's okay to be yourself. I'm confident in my job and utilised that in social settings to hide my nerves. Thus attracting the wrong people to me because they think I'm this outgoing, confident, ballsy person when, underneath, I'm actually a lot more introspective and introvert. I'm allowing this side of me out in public more Grin

I know dating seems like interviewing for a job sometimes but if all you're giving off is a Professional Front then it could be offputting in a social/emotional setting... maybe food for thought?

JawJaw · 09/07/2024 18:38

OP I think your question is a good one and it’s really not true that everyone should just be themselves and they will eventually find someone who loves them exactly as they are.

Many people have aspects to themselves which are off putting to others and taking the attitude ‘I am what I am and fuck everyone else!’ is quite immature and anti social. For example, a good friend of mine who is gorgeous, charming and successful nevertheless sniffs loudly and constantly and sometimes wipes her nose on her sleeve apparently without thinking.

I am sure you don’t do that OP and you sound lovely, but I think it’s reasonable to ask if you are doing anything to put men off. The problem is, we don’t know because we haven’t met you,

ginasevern · 09/07/2024 18:34

OP, you sound very self aware so I'm sure you're not doing anything "wrong". I mean, you'd know if you were picking your teeth or saying fuck every other word! Don't ask for feedback, it will creep her out. There are so many women on this forum, and in real life, of all age groups who can't seem to find a partner. It's the way of the world at the moment. Society seems really fucked up to be honest.

Mountainormolehills · 09/07/2024 18:34

I’m definitely ‘too much’ for some people - that’s ok! I’m 💯 myself from the get go as I won’t be changing who I am. I actually don’t think I am too much, but I know my mind, have boundaries and am successful in many ways so that can be intimidating for some people. It’s good to filter out people.
I date men and women, I definitely have women wanting a second date far more than I do, but that’s ok too. They haven’t done anything wrong, I just haven’t felt the attraction.

Rycbar · 09/07/2024 18:34

Iaminthefly · 09/07/2024 18:10

@Sprig1 I am being myself and it is not working!

I don't intend to develop a whole new personality. I'm just starting to wonder if I'm doing something off putting that I'm not even aware of!

But it will for the right person!!!

imagine acting in a way not like yourself on the date. Goes well, start to go out. How do you then go back to being yourself again? Or do you stay as this persona forever?

I used to think like you, I really did. I was almost a pick me girl when I was younger.

when I met my husband i was completely and utterly myself and he loved me for it.

the right person will love you for you. Don’t settle for someone you have to change to impress!

Didimum · 09/07/2024 18:32

No no no. No. Do not ask this. For every one person who thinks you are fantastic there will be another 10 who don’t find you appealing to date. It’s a completely useless exercise as it’s irrelevant – it does not matter what it is about you that does not appeal to these people. You are just you and you will attract some and not attract others.

When I was internet dating, there were heaps of people who clearly didn’t want to date me at all, but my (now) husband thought I was the most amazing person he’d ever met.

Iaminthefly · 09/07/2024 18:28

@Ineedaholidayyyy Not sure that person exists tbh. I"m mid forties and still haven't found them.

OP posts:
Iaminthefly · 09/07/2024 18:27

@Evaka My friends all tell me I'm lovely and there's nothing wrong with me. I guess that's what a friend would say though!

OP posts:
whathasitgottodowiththepriceofoliveoil · 09/07/2024 18:26

It's not a flippin job interview 😂

Iaminthefly · 09/07/2024 18:25

@DatingDinosaur I've worked on appearing confident as it's vital for my career. Making others feel at ease is part of my job role!

Obviously I'm not that confident underneath or I'd not be here wondering wtf is wrong with me🙈

OP posts:
Ineedaholidayyyy · 09/07/2024 18:25

No don't do it .Sometimes you just don't have chemistry with someone, it doesn't mean you have done anything wrong.

Someone will like you for exactly who you are, you just haven't found that person yet!

Summerinspringtime · 09/07/2024 18:24

What one person adores another would find unbearable.
I also think it’s down to subtle nuances which we find attractive.
Your date probably wasn’t feeling it with you.
Nothing you can do Tbh.
Better luck next time.

Evaka · 09/07/2024 18:22

Iaminthefly · 09/07/2024 18:15

@Evaka On the surface I have lots of confidence. I can talk to anyone etc.

I always ensure to ask my date lots of questions. I was making her laugh loads and it all seemed to be going really well.

It's hard not to feel unlovable when you keep getting rejected. It's getting to the point where I wonder if I've got some massive flaw I can't pin point!

That's really frustrating. Could you get the perspective of a friend perhaps? If you're overbearing or whatever they might have a view because they know you well x

Iaminthefly · 09/07/2024 18:22

@Babadook76 Hopefully none of those things🤣🤣

I actually tried to pick up the tab. She said let's go halves and I knew my fate was sealed.

OP posts:
Bodeganights · 09/07/2024 18:20

Iaminthefly · 09/07/2024 18:10

@Sprig1 I am being myself and it is not working!

I don't intend to develop a whole new personality. I'm just starting to wonder if I'm doing something off putting that I'm not even aware of!

It doesnt matter if you are. Eventually someone will come along who loves those things. Thats who you want in your life.
Imagine oh I dont know, you inhale food while snorting loudly.
Your not aware of it. Trying to stop doing it is going to fail at some point.
Wait to meet the person who also inhales food while snorting or is enamoured by it.

I will add I'm full of cold and hungry, and literally shovelling food in whilst trying to breathe. Aka snorting. Partner hasn't left me yet.

DatingDinosaur · 09/07/2024 18:20

"On the surface I have lots of confidence"

Interesting statement. "on the surface"... implies you're trying to be someone you're not. Fake it til you make it sort of thing. Maybe it comes across as TOO confident and people are intimidated by that. Which is fine if under the surface you have lots of confidence too...

Iaminthefly · 09/07/2024 18:19

@DatingDinosaur It's not that I want to change my personality. I'm just honestly wondering if there's something about me that put's people off! Do I have an annoying laugh? Am I overbearing? There must be something cos this keeps happening!

OP posts:
Babadook76 · 09/07/2024 18:18

Op it’s not a job interview. You can’t get feedback to improve your ‘performance’. It was a date, it didn’t work out. Unless you reeked of BO, or was unpleasant and offensive, or ordered the lobster and champagne, refused to split the bill and then vomited in her handbag, I think it’s safe to say the chemistry just isn’t there

Swipe left for the next trending thread