Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think of I cut down UPF I will gain weight?

34 replies

healthwoes · 09/07/2024 13:27

Disclaimer: I am reading ultra-processed people BUT I haven't finished it yet.

Like many I've been dieting most of my adult life. Sometimes more extremely, but always basically thinking about food, what I eat and what I avoid.

I understand the science/explanation about how food manufacturers have essentially made things addictive/moreish and can see that it's a good idea to eat proper, whole food for the most part and would happily aim for the suggested 80/20.

I do worry about gaining weight, a lot. It's taken me a long time to get to the healthy weight that I am and stay here. The food I eat, on the whole, is pretty good but there's definitely easy swaps/wins e.g. my flavoured, protein yoghurt for greek yoghurt & a drizzle of honey. I can make bread. I am a good baker. But here lies the problem- I don't currently eat much bread or cake/home baking because of the calories. If I make it myself, I will eat it "because it's allowed" and therefore my daily calories will go up.

Am I missing something obvious/will it become clear later in the book?

OP posts:
SparrowFeet · 09/07/2024 13:49

In the book he very clearly states that too much 'feast food' will make you fat. After all, before UPF people WERE fat as well, just not on the scale as today.

You should find it easier to regulate your appetite if you avoid UPF. However, if you're anything like me, and can override your brain telling you you're full in favour of eating an entire Victoria sponge; then yes, you will put on weight.

kitsuneghost · 09/07/2024 13:45

I find I am snacking less even though snacks I do eat are higher calories.
I feel I am eating more calories but losing weight (guessing my body is working better)
Personally I don't eat any bread. If bread would be a problem perhaps don't eat bread at all or maybe freeze and take what you need.

Excited101 · 09/07/2024 13:42

I totally know what you mean op, and many on the groups I follow are similar. But give it a go, I didn’t suddenly start making loads of home baked stuff and that obviously helped not involve ‘empty calories’ anyway, but sticking to no/low UPF limited the grabbing of stuff so much for me. You might be surprised!

Pinkdogs · 09/07/2024 13:41

This wins weirdest upf thread. It's not that cakes are 'allowed'. It isn't a weight loss 'diet'.

Yes home made cake is obviously better than shop bought cake but eating a shit tonne of butter and sugar isn't the best plan if you want to lose weight.

Maybe finish the book?

It basically says any non upf version is better than the upf version in terms of health.

healthwoes · 09/07/2024 13:39

That's interesting @Excited101 I just can't seem to let go of calories. I do already eat a lot of whole foods/cook from scratch. It's almost like I'm wondering if I cut back the upf I do have, it would make way for having homemade bread/baked stuff... But I can't switch off the "calories!" in my head.

OP posts:
Excited101 · 09/07/2024 13:37

I didn’t, I lose it albeit very very slowly!
And that was with pretty much unlimited cream, butter, cheese etc. I had been snacking so much that filling up on proper whole foods made all the difference!

healthwoes · 09/07/2024 13:37

I know I don't have to eat it, but I would want to if I made it! The bread I do eat is generally sourdough/artisan loaf type stuff now and again.

Same with cakes/biscuits. I only don't eat them because I know it's full of fat/sugar etc. From what I've read in the book so far they're saying those things are less important than originally thought. Homemade stuff tastes far superior, I'm not sure it doesn't still have the addictive qualities (I do have an addictive personality too so sometimes all it nothing).

OP posts:
Peonies12 · 09/07/2024 13:34

you don't suddenly have to eat bread? Just look at what you currently eat and see about good swaps, like your yoghurt example. And try frozen berries rather than honey, in plain yoghurt! Your health will only benefit from reducing UPFs, I'd focus on that rather than your weight. And I think UPFs don't fill you up properly, they're designed to make you crave more of them.

Caspianberg · 09/07/2024 13:30

Well if you don’t currently eat bread, you don’t have to suddenly eat bread even if it’s homemade.

Just try and eat a similar style
food to what you already eat and like. Just with less ultra processed products in

Swipe left for the next trending thread