Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is he lying about his salary

62 replies

Askabouttheweather · 05/07/2024 20:11

I have been seeing a guy for a couple of months, very casual. He told me he is a public law and humans rights solicitor, I've checked SRA and he is on there. He claims he makes 130k a year, now tbh I don't care if he does or doesn't but I do care if he is lying.
It is a London based firm, he is 30, not magic/silver circle.
Does this sound likely?

He still lives with his parents, I didn't ask his salary he just told me it and he doesn't seem to have the lifestyle of someone making that much.

If he is lying what's the more likely figure (like has he added 20k or doubled/tripled it.

AIBU to suspect he is lying as his lifestyle doesn't seem to match the salary?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Cantbelieveit888 · 06/07/2024 02:14

130k for a 30 year old lawyer is definitely plausible.

If he’s living at home presume he’s saving up for a house. Easy to find out by asking why he’s living at home? He openly tells you his salary so this question shouldn’t be a problem.

He doesn’t show an extravagant lifestyle. Well I was at home for years saving up too. I wasn’t earning that much but I definitely had a fair bit of money which I could have spent on nice clothes, restaurants, holidays etc. Instead it all went on a deposit to my first home. I actually went to work with tinned soup. People thought I was on my knees broke.

Namechangedforthis25 · 06/07/2024 01:38

Sidebeforeself · 05/07/2024 23:33

What does magic/silver circle mean?

Magic circle are the top 5 uk (London) city firms eg Clifford chance - they pay their lawyers and partners an absolute mint (millions for partners)

silver circle are the next slice down - so still very top firms who specialise in finance and corporate law etc (amongst other areas)

but there are many other firms - increasingly US law firms which have opened in the UK who pay their newly qualifieds £160k plus but expect blood, sweat and tears

and various other well known national and regional firms - who would pay less

Sidebeforeself · 05/07/2024 23:33

What does magic/silver circle mean?

Marvelo · 05/07/2024 23:17

All the big firms will have a public law practice with lawyers warning that much. Human rights not so much, except pro bono.

Bigcat25 · 05/07/2024 23:10

@BarcardiWithGadaffia I thought it was relevant bc op implied his spending didn't seem in line with his high salary. Of course everyone has different priorities for their money and op shouldn't make judgements over a superficial glance at his spending.

NowYouSee · 05/07/2024 23:00

It is most likely one of two things

  1. he does commercial litigation with the odd bit of public law angle thrown in and is really earning c£130k
  2. he really does public law and human rights full time and is likely lying about his salary

Outgoings are less of an indicator as he may just be frugal and saving hard.

Starseeking · 05/07/2024 22:47

Exactlab · 05/07/2024 20:57

I completely understand why you’re asking this. It’s very important to get prospective partners and to do so via stealth.
But salaries can be misleading.
Something to be mindful of is trust funds. You never know who might have one so you can’t base any assessment on salary alone.

Something that is of massive concern is that he’s still living with his parents at 30.

Massive concern that he lives at home at 30?!? Confused

Clearly you have no idea how expensive London is to live in for young people. Better he stay at home with his parents than pay £1,500 in rent and bills for a room in a houseshare.

BarcardiWithGadaffia · 05/07/2024 21:55

Teddybearpicniccelebration · 05/07/2024 21:36

He's not a big spender.

But the question is whether hes lying about his salary not should he be a spendthrift.

mildlydispeptic · 05/07/2024 21:50

A bit naff to be telling your salary to someone you've only been dating a couple of months, but the size of the salary sounds about right for London.

Teddybearpicniccelebration · 05/07/2024 21:36

BarcardiWithGadaffia · 05/07/2024 21:34

How is being frugal related to his salary though?

He's not a big spender.

BarcardiWithGadaffia · 05/07/2024 21:34

Bigcat25 · 05/07/2024 20:38

Some people are frugal or saving for long term goals, doesn't mean he's lying.

How is being frugal related to his salary though?

Teddybearpicniccelebration · 05/07/2024 21:31

SuncreamAndIceCream · 05/07/2024 21:22

Maybe I'm not au fait with how the law works but how does a lawyer working in human rights and public law earn that much?

Isn't it all legal aid? That's peanuts surely.

Legal aid stopped when Tories was in power. It will hopefully come back to help the poor.

Teddybearpicniccelebration · 05/07/2024 21:30

Working out his salary already op you don't waste time. Poor bloke works hard to get to where he is and your eyes have widened at the possibility it's true. What do you do for a living and what do you earn?

Dibblydoodahdah · 05/07/2024 21:24

DodoTired · 05/07/2024 21:18

YES obviously he is not in magic circle. So I said that he must be in a small firm because magic circle pays more than that to first year lawyers, let alone someone with mid-level experience.

No he must not be in a small firm. There are a lot of firms in between “magic circle” and “small”. As I said in the thread above, the top 50 firm that I used to work for pays its newly qualified solicitors £65k in London. It is not a small firm.

SuncreamAndIceCream · 05/07/2024 21:22

Maybe I'm not au fait with how the law works but how does a lawyer working in human rights and public law earn that much?

Isn't it all legal aid? That's peanuts surely.

DodoTired · 05/07/2024 21:20

TemuSpecialBuy · 05/07/2024 20:53

@DodoTired its NOT magic circle…

my company in house lawyers make about 130k with bonus. (This is 6-8 years exp)

I think it is plausible.
the lawyers I know have salaries between 100k ish up to 550k (that one has NO life and travels to America 4 x per month 😵‍💫) none are
magic circle now bar one (not the high earner) but I don’t know any human rights lawyers….

3 of our lawyer friends lived “impoverished” lives until they put down 3/4/500k deposits on places 😅

i “lived at home” when earning 115k pa if that helps 🤷🏻‍♀️

Edited

Again, he is not in magic circle OBVIOUSLY. Magic circle pays more than that to people with zero experience; so way
more than that to someone with several years experience. MEANING, his salary is entirely plausible and even a little low for his age.

in-house lawyers are paid less than pp with same number of years of experience.

DodoTired · 05/07/2024 21:18

Jc2001 · 05/07/2024 20:55

Well he's not in the magic circle.

YES obviously he is not in magic circle. So I said that he must be in a small firm because magic circle pays more than that to first year lawyers, let alone someone with mid-level experience.

ThisHumanBean · 05/07/2024 21:13

I have a feeling that for you, this is more about what he earns than whether or not he is a liar.

TemuSpecialBuy · 05/07/2024 21:10

Namechangedforthis25 · 05/07/2024 20:55

Yeah I was also going to say this

I’ve had friends on salaries like this at a young age who didn’t go out much or on holidays - then just whacked it on a huge deposit for a really nice house

it’s happened quite a few times in my (London) friendship circle

whilst we couldn’t buy anything for years and years due to renting and not being thrifty

I know….it’s surprisingly common!!!!

One is 33 and owns a 2 bed penthouse in zone 1 outright. 😵‍💫😵‍💫😵‍💫
She bought for 650k now about 8-9 years back….

It’s all about priorities…
she turned up to a wedding last year wearing a dress she used to wear to end of year bops at uni 😅 and driving a brand new Porsche

just nuts… all my Porsche money is being spent on fucking childcare for my beloved cherubs

OdeToBarney · 05/07/2024 21:05

Check out the salaries of newly qualified solicitors at his firm on legal cheek, roll on Friday, lawcareers.net and see if his salary makes sense with his level of experience.

Namechangedforthis25 · 05/07/2024 20:59

Exactlab · 05/07/2024 20:57

I completely understand why you’re asking this. It’s very important to get prospective partners and to do so via stealth.
But salaries can be misleading.
Something to be mindful of is trust funds. You never know who might have one so you can’t base any assessment on salary alone.

Something that is of massive concern is that he’s still living with his parents at 30.

I really don’t think it’s a massive concern at all

why pay £2.5k a month towards someone else’s mortgage when that could go towards his house deposit

GuinnessBird · 05/07/2024 20:58

It's definitely possible, it's also possible that he's saving for a house etc. Not everyone earning megabucks make it obvious.

Whattodo2024 · 05/07/2024 20:58

Salary, bonus, plus shares - very possible. His take home will be much less than you think due to tax

Exactlab · 05/07/2024 20:57

I completely understand why you’re asking this. It’s very important to get prospective partners and to do so via stealth.
But salaries can be misleading.
Something to be mindful of is trust funds. You never know who might have one so you can’t base any assessment on salary alone.

Something that is of massive concern is that he’s still living with his parents at 30.

PoppyCherryDog · 05/07/2024 20:56

Entirely possible. Also you don’t have to live a particular way if you earn that much… I imagine he’s probably living at home saving up a really good deposit for a house and which in the london area he’ll need quite a big one.