Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Thoughtless gifts AIBU

56 replies

Itsrainingten · 04/07/2024 08:19

Anyone else really hate getting thoughtless gifts and think it's REALLY selfish?
As adults DH and I tell everyone we don't need gifts for birthdays/ Christmas whatever but there are certain people who decide to give us presents regardless. That's very kind and generous IF they've actually taken time to think of something we'd probably like or enjoy. But what I really hate and don't understand is family members who ignore the request for no presents and go out and buy something that there is actually zero reason to think we'd want. And then get offended when we don't gush about it or really use it. WTF is that all about? Some recent examples have been - a cycling jersey for DH who doesn't own a bike or even have any wish to, a knitting bag for me when I don't knit, gifts aimed at 5 year olds for our 11 year old twins.
WHY? it feels like an attempt to control us or maybe people are unloading shite they've been gifted themselves?
If we're honest (but kind) about it because we really don't want all this waste and then effort on our part to have to try and return stuff, we get huffy responses about how it's the thought that counts and we're really hurting there feelings by saying we don't want it. But WHERE IS THE THOUGHT? That's what I don't get. There is no obligation at all to get us anything and we always make that clear. If they must get us something to make themselves feel better then I guess smellies or food would always at least be useful.
Why do people do it? And AIBU to not be grateful?

OP posts:
Needmorelego · 04/07/2024 08:38

They're probably the type of people that buy next years Christmas presents in the January sale - "Ooh look at me...I'm so organised. Christmas is done by January and I've saved money" 🙄
Already there's Christmas "what's good for kids stockings" threads and it's JULY.
It's buying stuff for the sake of buying stuff - not actually something the person will want.
@Itsrainingten perhaps start telling them something specific you would like/use. Nothing expensive so you can't be accused of being "grabby".
Just a paperback book or something.

hopscotcher · 04/07/2024 08:28

I think you're overstating the 'thoughtlessness'/controlling aspect of this a bit (some people just aren't very good at choosing gifts), but would also find it frustrating. I guess the thing is to make it REALLY clear that you don't want presents. If you do still get them, say a polite thanks and then do what you want with the gifts. I'd just give them away.

AFmammaG · 04/07/2024 08:27

It is definitely people off loading stuff they don’t want on you. Why don’t they take it to the charity shop like normal people?

I know I’m incredibly ungrateful but I hate a gift voucher. Thanks for passing on the responsibility for my gift to me. As if I don’t have enough to do. Now I have to add that to the list before the fucker expires.

Bjorkdidit · 04/07/2024 08:24

YANBU.

Some people just really like to shop and buy stuff and see other people's birthdays as another excuse to go shopping.

So if you ask them not to buy something, they're annoyed because you're denying them that. It's all about them. They also see you lack of owning X, Y or Z as a reason for them to go out and buy it for you. It doesn't occur to them that the reason that you don't have X, Y or Z is that you don't fucking want it.

Redshoeblueshoe · 04/07/2024 08:24

The cycling jumper made me laugh, just why ?
I totally agree with you.

DustyLee123 · 04/07/2024 08:24

I agree, it’s a waste of money and terrible for the environment.
If you absolutely must give me something to make YOU feel better, just give me money.

Swipe left for the next trending thread