Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

The "terrifying threat from Labour"

317 replies

BigWordAtlas · 02/07/2024 13:50

I know that Tory HQ staff often come on here and post, and will be doing even more so at the moment.

I also know that Kier Starmer has done a terrible job in gender critical thinking, and members like him, Rayner and Lammy are currently an absolute shitshow when it comes to the rights and protections of women and children. I'm not looking forward to the battle we'll face after the election to reverse the damage that's been done and to protect those rights, and fully bring down all the MRA policies that have formally or informally kicked in over the last few years.

But does anyone else feel like the absolute barrage on here in the last few days about the Holy Bloody Handmaid Terror that will be Labour's government is a bit... overblown? A bit Tory HQ-flavoured? They're absolutely panicking at the moment and will do any kind of astroturfing they can to chip away at votes, particularly in swing constituencies like mine.

No party is perfect, and Labour is currently far from perfect for me and my children. But realistically, I have to vote Labour where I am if I want to keep a Tory candidate out. I hate their gender ID policies, but this nail-bitten tone of total and complete apocalypse (and yes, I've heard posters use that word in this context) feels unhelpful and not really equipping anyone to improve things after the GE. They made me feel extremely anxious until I just hit a wall with the frantic language, and now I'm feeling much more pragmatic and ready to fight with Labour on this stuff, rather than against them and allowing another party to get in.

So AIBU to feel that most of these posts are at least seeded by Tory HQ, rather than actual Labour voters like me?

<hard hat donned>

OP posts:
Sossijiz · 02/07/2024 14:54

Me, I'm petrified by the idea of a government that is not largely corrupt and almost totally incompetent. It's so different from what I'm used to.

BigWordAtlas · 02/07/2024 14:54

hamstersarse · 02/07/2024 14:46

How can you say you want an educated and informed person and equate that with David Lammy saying men can grow a cervix?

I think you are living in a dream world if you think Starmer will shift on the trans issue. He has had PLENTY of time - what do you think is stopping him right now to shift his opinion?

If you say, the far left party members, it's not really a great reason. In fact, shows him up even more to be a man of no integrity at all.

This is a fairly fast-moving thread so there's no reason you would have read all of my posts, but I absolutely don't include David Lammy's current attitudes as those of an educated or informed person. I think he's behaving idiotically at best, horribly misogynistically at worst.

I do think Starmer will change his mind though, because society is changing its mind. The more Cass reports and WPATH files and detransitioners and medical experts come out, the more the public realises this isn't a new civil rights movement, it's a men's rights movement that harms women and children in almost every part of life.

He's a centrist, not a boggle-eyed far lefty, and he's had years in the trenches of actual social-facing work. I think he's been hugely poorly advised the last few years, and he's wanted to take a few stands to make Labour feel a bit sexy and young and different to the Tories, and this was his weak, mistaken path.

But I think he'll quickly learn that it's no longer as popular a campaign as it once was.

OP posts:
Melisha · 02/07/2024 14:53

hamstersarse · 02/07/2024 14:48

Do mean mean done nothing other than close the Tavistock gender clinic and make it illegal for children to have HRT or transition mutiliation surgery?

The conservatives did not do that. The surgery was stopped by a court case.
An independent review criticised the Tavistock Clinic and made serious safeguarding allegations which meant that the NHS trust had no choice but to close it.
Either of these actions would have happened whoever was in government.

Alwaystired94 · 02/07/2024 14:53

hamstersarse · 02/07/2024 14:40

Never spewed Tory hate? You must be a very rare Labour party voter, it's in the DNA

I noticed it when I grew up and moved more to the right. I had never had any viciousness from the right when I was a loud member of the Labour party, yet one slight move to the right, small c conservative, and the vitriol that comes your way from the left is relentless.

And yeah, Farage is very like Hitler, you are totally right

https://x.com/ArchRose90/status/1807445277625794737

Never spewed Tory hate? You must be a very rare Labour party voter, it's in the DNA

I noticed it when I grew up and moved more to the right. I had never had any viciousness from the right when I was a loud member of the Labour party, yet one slight move to the right, small c conservative, and the vitriol that comes your way from the left is relentless.

And yeah, Farage is very like Hitler, you are totally right

I said i never called them Hitler, not that i haven't disagreed with them. I'm friends with Tory voters and friends with someone married to a councilor. So i wouldn't say all Tories are X. But what i can say is the overrall party is corrupt and has done nothing but cause more devastation to women in this latest cycle in power. You're the one claiming that its in Labour voters DNA to be like that - how would you like it if i painted every Tory as hate filled?

I have the opposite personally. I've been verbally abused viciously for being a Labour voter.

Did i say Farage is 'like' Hitler? No i stated Parties that say nice things about Hitler. One of the things that makes me most proud to be British was our part as an Allied country.

JaneV1984Madness · 02/07/2024 14:52

"single issue feminist".

It is the biggest issue: if the definition itself is not correct or corrupted!

EasternStandard · 02/07/2024 14:52

BitOutOfPractice · 02/07/2024 14:49

The hysteria on here about Labour and women’s rights is ridiculously overblown and stops Any meaningful debate on any other issue. In fact all it does is silence women on any other topic because every political thread is immediately deluged by people (bots? Tory plants?) wringing their hands about the incoming Labour apocalypse.

It’s clearly not ‘silencing’ you

Why not pick up the issue you want and someone might respond

Staplerandstappler · 02/07/2024 14:52

You don’t think it’s terrifying now but just you wait until they clear out your pension to fund the construction of a basket weaving therapy centre for LGBTQIA+ refugees and tax you at 95%.

Startingagainandagain · 02/07/2024 14:52

The Tory election campaign has been abysmal.

Once disaster after another and it seems that now all they have left is random and increasingly desperate scaremongering or lies.

Frankly, anyone with a bit of common sense just looks back at the past 14 years and how everything in this country has gone downhill and realises it is time for a change.

Labour, Lib Dem and the Greens make sense depending on where you live and tactical voting.

But suggesting the Tories of the Reform lunatics are good options is pure madness.

museumum · 02/07/2024 14:51

what do you think is stopping him right now to shift his opinion?

I think he’s very sensibly avoiding the complete media pile on that would follow, drowning out every other discussion on important issues like health and the economy. I am GC myself but I do not believe that it should be the single most important issue in this GE.

BitOutOfPractice · 02/07/2024 14:49

The hysteria on here about Labour and women’s rights is ridiculously overblown and stops Any meaningful debate on any other issue. In fact all it does is silence women on any other topic because every political thread is immediately deluged by people (bots? Tory plants?) wringing their hands about the incoming Labour apocalypse.

hamstersarse · 02/07/2024 14:48

Melisha · 02/07/2024 14:46

The Conservative government have had 14 years to change the law on Trans issues. They have done nothing. They proposed Self D and then did a U turn.
The Conservatives do not give a stuff about Transgender people or womens rights. They are playing you.
Judge people by what they do, not what they say. If they cared about these issues they would have done something. They have done nothing.

Do mean mean done nothing other than close the Tavistock gender clinic and make it illegal for children to have HRT or transition mutiliation surgery?

Melisha · 02/07/2024 14:46

The Conservative government have had 14 years to change the law on Trans issues. They have done nothing. They proposed Self D and then did a U turn.
The Conservatives do not give a stuff about Transgender people or womens rights. They are playing you.
Judge people by what they do, not what they say. If they cared about these issues they would have done something. They have done nothing.

hamstersarse · 02/07/2024 14:46

BigWordAtlas · 02/07/2024 14:41

This is a massive issue: I don't want a Prime Minister who I'd like down the pub.

I want an educated, experienced and informed person who is willing to make difficult decisions for the long-term benefit of the UK, regardless of how charismatic they are or how hilarious they appear on HIGNFY.

Do I think Starmer is acting like he's informed and sensible on gender? No.
Do I think there's a chance he'll turn his brain on over it eventually? Yes.

We got our pub-mate leader in Boris Johnson. And that was fucking beyond disastrous.

How can you say you want an educated and informed person and equate that with David Lammy saying men can grow a cervix?

I think you are living in a dream world if you think Starmer will shift on the trans issue. He has had PLENTY of time - what do you think is stopping him right now to shift his opinion?

If you say, the far left party members, it's not really a great reason. In fact, shows him up even more to be a man of no integrity at all.

BigWordAtlas · 02/07/2024 14:45

Spinet · 02/07/2024 14:38

I don't disagree but I also think that having that as your thread title might be an own goal quite frankly!

Oh god, I am part of the clickbait problem

Give Me Five GIF by Brooklyn Nine-Nine
OP posts:
JaneV1984Madness · 02/07/2024 14:44

Op im a swinging voter, I have no tribal allegiance to any party and I've voted Labour more than anyone else else.

I am fairly new to understanding the horror of stonewall etc the deep reach into our schools and councils, and the brain washing of right think into our young.

Rosie Duffield and jk Rowling and many mntter have brought it to my attention and the more one researched and learned about it all the more horrified I am.

I do genuinely feel it's panic stations. However keir did say one clear statement on it. This is really important and something to do hold him too.

I just think of the Rotherham scandal under labour and how everyone around the abused girls struggled to call it out for fear of being called racist.

Im worried the same will happen with trans issues and it will become a hate crime to not want a man fling a smear test because he called himself female.

BigWordAtlas · 02/07/2024 14:43

hairbearbunches · 02/07/2024 14:34

@Alwaystired94 Lammy said live on radio that he understood that transwomen could have a cervix after appropriate hormones and treatment etc.

WTAF?

I think he might be a bit thick, actually.

Agreed. It's a shame people in positions of power are choosing to say these things, or feeling they have to.

OP posts:
hamstersarse · 02/07/2024 14:43

Apolloneuro · 02/07/2024 14:40

I think it shows a man with integrity who isn’t ashamed to believe that families matter.

It shows principles. That’s something that’s been missing from Government for a long time.

Yeah, all sounds lovely. Spend time with your family, prioritise. Fabulous.

But it stinks to me of some bullshit he's read on a motivational post on LinkedIn.

He's going to be the PM FFS

EmmaGrundyForPM · 02/07/2024 14:42

hamstersarse · 02/07/2024 14:29

It is quite terrifying that Starmer refuses to work "pretty much come what may" past 6 o'clock

Sounds totes committed

On a Friday evening. As his wife and children are Jewish, and it's a sacred family time.

I'm sure that he works waaaayy past 6pm most evenings, and over weekends. Which is why he prioritises one evening a week as family time.

BigWordAtlas · 02/07/2024 14:42

Oakskn · 02/07/2024 14:32

i agree with labour wanting to spend major money on health and education. But. I don’t think that their sources of funding will materialise as they have laid it out.

I have no idea why a non dom wouldn’t run away to Monaco, for example. Those kind of people must have teams of tax people. I just don’t see them coughing up 5bn. It just seems so convenient and easy for us to think oh we’re in the shit with lots of stuff, let’s have some unicorn super rich sort it out. Nobody seems to question this money magically appearing.

also, whilst I would be happy to pay a bit more tax, I think a raid on private education (a raid which is illegal under EU law), is very wrong. Most of the people who’ve dreamt this up have no current experience of private school and also, many economists have said it won’t raise money - for various reasons. To be clear, I appreciate state schools need money and I want them to have it. But again, I do not believe money from this source will materialise as estimated by labour and having been inside private schools for the past 15 years, some of the assumptions that labour have made are so far out of touch. Out of another century.

where is the money coming from?????

Yes, I agree with all of this too.

I know this is the tactic of most GEs, but even more so this one feels a bit "Does everyone want a unicorn? We'll get you all unicorns! And whoever you think is a baddie will pay for it!!"

OP posts:
EasternStandard · 02/07/2024 14:42

Maybe / maybe not but I guess we’ll see after the GE

Greenismyfav · 02/07/2024 14:42

The real wealthy in this country don’t earn by going to work. They live off investments. Earning £50k is not at all wealthy. I hope Labour realise that.

Melisha · 02/07/2024 14:42

OP I agree with you. I am not a Labour voter. I am a centrist who has voted both Conservative and Labour.
Starmer is a centrist. His policies are classic middle of the road ones that are good for the economy and good for public services. The extreme left wing hate him as do the extreme right wing. So seeing the scaremongering on here is laughable.
If the posts were being accurate they should be from people on the extreme left wing bemoaning the fact that it would have been a different government under Corbyn. The posts are totally inaccurate and simply painting a vision of a current Labour party that bares zero resemblance to the reality.
I mean look at the facts, Traditional Conservative major donors and businesses are backing Starmers Labour. They understand that what he is proposing will be good for business and good for the economy.

BigWordAtlas · 02/07/2024 14:41

hamstersarse · 02/07/2024 14:31

How can you want to vote this person into power? It is stunningly stupid.

https://x.com/alexharmstrong/status/1806753236302610664

If you met this person down the pub, would you really think "yay what a guy!" ?

I don't get it, it is there in front of your eyes how idiotic they are

This is a massive issue: I don't want a Prime Minister who I'd like down the pub.

I want an educated, experienced and informed person who is willing to make difficult decisions for the long-term benefit of the UK, regardless of how charismatic they are or how hilarious they appear on HIGNFY.

Do I think Starmer is acting like he's informed and sensible on gender? No.
Do I think there's a chance he'll turn his brain on over it eventually? Yes.

We got our pub-mate leader in Boris Johnson. And that was fucking beyond disastrous.

OP posts:
Apolloneuro · 02/07/2024 14:40

hamstersarse · 02/07/2024 14:29

It is quite terrifying that Starmer refuses to work "pretty much come what may" past 6 o'clock

Sounds totes committed

I think it shows a man with integrity who isn’t ashamed to believe that families matter.

It shows principles. That’s something that’s been missing from Government for a long time.

Greenismyfav · 02/07/2024 14:40

labour and the gender issue is terrifying. But anything else under Labour? I’m not scared at all. What is there to be scared of? Maybe I’m missing something.