Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to not understand people who never ask reciprocal questions in a conversation?

263 replies

BlownItJellyHead · 01/07/2024 15:14

It's just so bloody strange. How can they not just do it reflexively? Do they genuinely have that little interest in finding out about other people? I'm not talking about people with ND issues or people with a lot on their mind at a specific time. I mean people who just generally don't ask questions.

I just don't get it at all. It goes without saying that its rude and indicative of some level of self-obsession. But, I just don't understand how they can do it. It's so bloody odd to me. Even if I don't have that much interest in the other person, I reciprocate questions reflexively, and I always find I'm interested in something about them.

Yesterday I was out with a friend for three hours - I asked about her work, her mum, her health, her plans for summer gardening, her partner, her pets, as well as follow-up questions off the back of things we were talking about.

She asked me nothing 😂😂😂

What is it with these people?!

OP posts:
EmeraldRoulette · 01/07/2024 18:34

Fieldsofgold1 · 01/07/2024 16:58

Only on MN could 'organic conversations' be a thing.

I’ve known that expression for at least 20 years.

@BlownItJellyHead I think when conversation doesn’t flow, it’s hard. I agree that if people don’t ask any questions, it feels like disinterest. I’m usually the one who keeps conversation flowing and there was a whole thread about what happens if the person relied upon to do that decides to stop.

answer- silence. Some people said they prefer that but then I wonder why they organised a meet-up.

ichundich · 01/07/2024 18:33

IPoopRainblows · 01/07/2024 17:00

I am the same I find it exhausting and boring and feels like I’m being interviewed when bombarded with questions mainly because my life is quite vanilla and so the responses are usually ‘grand’ ‘alls good’, ‘alls fine’ blah blah.
With close friends we usually dive into gossip or plans for a night out, weekend away etc.

If I’m aware they or a loved one has recently been unwell or sat an important exams or they’ve been on a holiday for example, I will enquire after them / that but tend to avoid back and forth how’s such and such conversations.
Thankfully my friends are mostly the same so after the cursory ‘ how’s the gang’ opening question we move swiftly on to more important things to chat about.

Hos do you make friends if all your conversations with new people are so one-sided?

blanketjune · 01/07/2024 18:32

There are a lot of self absorbed people but they are just not aware of it (some of the replies on here provide perfect examples)

TheYearOfSmallThings · 01/07/2024 18:30

LoobyDoop2 · 01/07/2024 17:28

I wouldn’t have thought Jane is particularly interested in discussing Alan’s marathon training with you, though. She’s probably spending more time than she’d like discussing it with Alan. I find it faintly depressing when women spend their entire time together talking about the men and children around them. As a PP said, I’d much rather talk about the rest of the world, more abstract things. I’m not a robot and sometimes it’s good to talk about emotions and relationships, but not all the time, it’s exhausting and it starts to feel intrusive if you aren’t in the mood.

Edited

That was an example based on the OP's own description of their conversation. Clearly she can talk about whatever she wants, my point is she doesn't need to be asked.

bellalula · 01/07/2024 18:29

Yesterday I was out with a friend for three hours - she bombarded me with a thousand questions, some of them quite personal, about my health and my partner. Every time I answered she bowled another question at me. In that whole time she never told me anything about herself, and I never got chance to ask her. In fact, I'd have felt a bit rude asking her some of things she did me.

What is it with these people?
I do hope she's not on MN.

PuntasticUsername · 01/07/2024 18:23

I don't normally bother getting into threads where the OP sounds smug, self-satisfied and judgmental, but what the hell - it's Monday, I'll treat myself.

I am awful at keeping up superficial conversations. I feel huge pressure about it, which makes me go to pieces and forget all the things I know about the other person, and am genuinely interested to ask. I am so grateful for those who are happy to lead the conversation - I'll willingly participate, and hopefully we'll alight on a topic of mutual interest and it will stop being awkward. I feel eternally reproached by Jane Austen's description of "Mrs. Annesley, a genteel, agreeable-looking woman, whose endeavour to introduce some kind of discourse proved her to be more truly well-bred than either of the others", because that's exactly where I fail.

More than anything, I appreciate when people understand that it's not that I don't care; I'm just extremely bad at this stuff. But thanks, OP, for reminding me that the judgy folk, too, walk among us.

LakesideInn · 01/07/2024 18:22

@BlownItJellyHead is it just back and forth questioning your friend doesn’t do, or is it the whole general flow of conversation? I absolutely get where you’re coming from re questions but it’s clear many people commenting approach conversation in other ways. I’ve also become frustrated with some friends (well, in laws) when realising that they never prompt any conversation. So it’s not just not asking a question, it’s never being the first to volunteer an opinion or make a comment or offer an observation that would get the chat going. It’s me asking a question or offering a thought and it’s just met with nothing proactive back.

sometimes conversation is like tennis. You can both take turns at serving and getting the ball back (questions and replies) and sometimes you have great long rallies with unexpected twists or you keep the ball going back and forth nicely between you. If it’s just one person serving or hitting or lobbing the ball over the net and the other person just swipes it back into the net each time it all feels a bit thankless.

OkPedro · 01/07/2024 18:22

ThoseDarnCrows · 01/07/2024 15:41

Well it seems I am one of 'these people' as you so charmingly put it. As a child , and throughout my life until my fifties I was browbeaten and berated regularly by my parent to 'not be nosy', mind your own business', 'what's it got to do with you' , why do you think they want you to know'....... and on and on and on, until I had no self esteem and was scared stiff of asking anybody anything in case I was judged as that awful nosy person I was constantly told I was.

So no, it is not necessarily the me, me, me scenario, and not because we don't want to know. It's taken me another decade since they have no longer been in my life to believe in myself and actually push myself to ask people those - what are to you - simple questions.

So OP, get off your high horse and actually think about what that non-reciprocal person may actual have gone, or still be going through.

Clearly the op wasn't talking about people like you.. but you are actually coming across as someone who makes everything about themselves ironic eh 😂

MoodyMargaret11 · 01/07/2024 18:19

I think some posters are purposefully misunderstanding and twisting the situation here. You are not "bombarding" anyone, friend is obv happy to talk about herself for 3 hours and ask nothing about how you are.. it's very weird and most people in OPs shoes would be dropping this sort of "friend" or at least distancing themselves.
This is what I ended up doing, with a family member no less - they'd never ask a single question about my DP (who I'd been with for years), no question about my work or interests; not even after I'd been through a very difficult time they knew about. It's so weird and I just got fed up, so now speak with them as little as possible.

Godivaheadache · 01/07/2024 18:19

I'm going through a tough time at the moment. Still putting on a brave face so talking to colleagues and asking them about their lives.

They can sense that I prefer not to answer questions so are being kind enough not to ask them.

Phineyj · 01/07/2024 18:15

OK, well for my part, if a friend never asked me a single thing about myself/my life I wouldn't bother to remain friends with them.

It's a bit different with family, I think.

I mean, I think my SIL has only ever asked me one question in the entire 20 years or so I've known her (I remember as I was so surprised!) but she is a nice, kind, generous person so while I would never seek her out as a friend (and find it hard to know how to pass time in company with her as any topic of conversation dies), it's not quite the same.

I'd love to watch her interact with a close friend to see how they communicate.

As some of the described methods of here sound like a Samuel Beckett play 😂.

Violet80 · 01/07/2024 18:13

Buddysbunda · 01/07/2024 16:56

I had a very emotionally abusive childhood and I'm kind of weird as a result. I'm really guarded and don't like people asking me questions so I don't tend to ask others too many questions either. I get that it might make me 'hard work' as mumsnet like to say but childhood abuse can rewire your brain and I'm trying not to be hard on the adult that is formed me into. I'm nearly 40 and am who I am at this stage.

Wow I literally said the same thing to dh the other day about myself, I honestly think I'm a bit weird because of how effed up my head is from emotional abuse (from my dm). I'm sorry you feel this way too, but know you're not alone Flowers I'm early 40's and dm is in her 80's now, hasn't mellowed at all which I always hoped she would Confused

Strawberrycheesecake7 · 01/07/2024 18:11

I do this sometimes when my social anxiety is bad. Sometimes it feels safer to just answer their questions and not ask any of my own in case I ask the wrong thing and they hate me. I know that’s irrational but that’s how my brain works. It’s never my intention to be rude I’m just not very good at talking to people in real life. It is something I’m trying to work on every day. In my case it’s definitely not because I’m self obsessed. Quite the opposite really. I think I’m probably so boring that people couldn’t possibly want to have a lengthy conversation with me, so I don’t try to carry it on so that they can ‘escape’ from me as soon as possible. I agree that some people may not ask any questions about you because they’re self obsessed, but that’s not always the reason.

Crazycatlady79 · 01/07/2024 18:08

@BlownItJellyHead I'm Neurodivergent, have complex trauma and acute issues and am perfectly able to engage in back and forth/reciprocal conversations, so let's not make sweeping generalisations, eh?!

OnceICaughtACold · 01/07/2024 18:08

Phineyj · 01/07/2024 17:55

So....if you never ask questions.

Do you not think there's a risk there could be significant stuff going on for your friend that you don't know about?

Do you expect them to lurch into disclosing that their parent died/their house burned down/their husband ran off, with no promoting, or do you hope to find out anything significant from third parties? Or don't you care?!

A LOT of significant stuff has happened to me over the years (not that extreme) that my self absorbed mum, dad and sister aren't aware of as they don't ask. Or I told them but they didn't remember.

Or don't you care?!

How many people have literally told you on this thread that asking questions is not how they show they care.

My close friend’s mum died recently. How do I know? Because she told me. She didn’t wait to be asked. Honestly from my point of view it’s weirdly self-absorbed to think someone else has to drag information out of you for you to share it.

Or another friend, is getting a dog. How am I meant to know to ask her about getting a dog when she’s never mentioned one before?

Telling people stuff they don’t remember is an entirely different thing.

Disturbia81 · 01/07/2024 18:07

Bunnyhair · 01/07/2024 18:05

We have some family friends we see almost every week as our DC are really close. We’ve known them nearly a decade. They are true friends who would help us in all manner of practical ways if ever we needed it, and I love them dearly, but they are so utterly incurious I’m not sure they even know what I do for a living. 😂 I find it baffling.

It's so rude.. you're literally spending precious life on people who don't know hardly anything about you, you could be anyone to them.

Bunnyhair · 01/07/2024 18:05

We have some family friends we see almost every week as our DC are really close. We’ve known them nearly a decade. They are true friends who would help us in all manner of practical ways if ever we needed it, and I love them dearly, but they are so utterly incurious I’m not sure they even know what I do for a living. 😂 I find it baffling.

MetaphorsBeWithYou · 01/07/2024 18:04

I work with a group of women who don’t talk about themselves. Instead, they talk solely about their (quite grown up) children. Some of them (the children) are at school doing exams, some are away at university, a few are married with kids of their own. Their mothers carry on like new mums at a baby group. These are professional, accomplished women. Occasionally they might chat about the dogs with which they have replaced the children. I think they have lost their sense of themselves. I ask them questions sometimes, but two minutes and the conversation will turn back to the “kids”.

fancystrawberries · 01/07/2024 18:04

Bearbookagainandagain · 01/07/2024 17:02

Me: How's Alan?
Jane: He's alright. He's training for a marathon at the minute so I'm not seeing much of him.
Me: How's the training going?
Jane: It's okay. He's building up the distance every day. The marathon's in November so he's got plenty of time.
[Silence]
Me: My Dave's doing okay. He's away with work next week. That's great for him but must be difficult for you. I am not seeing much of Dave either, he's working a lot and going away for work next week.

[Edit: not saying this is what you should respond, but that's how I would]

Edited

Same here. To keep the conversation flowing naturally.

FoxSwiss · 01/07/2024 18:02

Generally it’s because they just don’t care about anyone else apart from themselves. They don’t ask questions as they don’t care what is going on with you.
I know someone like this and they are just plain hard work as a person.

Phineyj · 01/07/2024 18:00

I think as the OP was talking about a friend, good enough that they spent 3 hours together, that's the relevant context.

If you'd call someone a friend but don't feel you can ask a single question, that's a bit odd and not what I would call a friend, personally.

I also wouldn't bother for long with a friend who had no interest in me.

HowDidJudithSurvive · 01/07/2024 17:59

Ponderingwindow · 01/07/2024 15:45

You may not know the person you are conversing with is ND. Reflexive questions are definitely not instinctual for many of us. We still pass as NT for the most part.

This is me, I had to stick a post it to my phone in work to remind me to ask how people are and not just jump straight into the work conversation I rang them for.

Combattingthemoaners · 01/07/2024 17:57

Or the ones who ask a question but don’t listen to a word you are saying and have only asked so they can tell you all about themselves. It’s draining.

Hazelville · 01/07/2024 17:57

Phineyj · 01/07/2024 17:55

So....if you never ask questions.

Do you not think there's a risk there could be significant stuff going on for your friend that you don't know about?

Do you expect them to lurch into disclosing that their parent died/their house burned down/their husband ran off, with no promoting, or do you hope to find out anything significant from third parties? Or don't you care?!

A LOT of significant stuff has happened to me over the years (not that extreme) that my self absorbed mum, dad and sister aren't aware of as they don't ask. Or I told them but they didn't remember.

I don’t wait to be asked. I tell my friends what is going on with me, same as they do to me but then I come from a large family and if you didn’t speak up then you didn’t get heard.

Phineyj · 01/07/2024 17:56

Prompting! Not promoting.