Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to not understand people who never ask reciprocal questions in a conversation?

263 replies

BlownItJellyHead · 01/07/2024 15:14

It's just so bloody strange. How can they not just do it reflexively? Do they genuinely have that little interest in finding out about other people? I'm not talking about people with ND issues or people with a lot on their mind at a specific time. I mean people who just generally don't ask questions.

I just don't get it at all. It goes without saying that its rude and indicative of some level of self-obsession. But, I just don't understand how they can do it. It's so bloody odd to me. Even if I don't have that much interest in the other person, I reciprocate questions reflexively, and I always find I'm interested in something about them.

Yesterday I was out with a friend for three hours - I asked about her work, her mum, her health, her plans for summer gardening, her partner, her pets, as well as follow-up questions off the back of things we were talking about.

She asked me nothing 😂😂😂

What is it with these people?!

OP posts:
ChestnutGrove · 01/07/2024 16:52

I have to consciously think to ask questions. It doesn't come naturally, but I do do it.
There was a character in "Here we go" called Uncle Boyd who they called Void as talking to him was like talking into a void as he'd never ask question back.
Eg. Ella went to Sweden this Summer
Void : I went to Norway etc

TheYearOfSmallThings · 01/07/2024 16:51

I think it cuts both ways though, they may feel you are very inquisitive but tell them nothing about yourself. I am sometimes surprised at the questions people will ask, because my background would be more to share information about yourself and listen if they reciprocate, but not put them on the spot.

Obviously if they don't let you get a word in or yawn when you are talking, you should drop them. But have you tried just telling them what is going on in your life and volunteering information that hasn't been directly asked for?

Bearbookagainandagain · 01/07/2024 16:51

magentarain · 01/07/2024 16:37

It's actually really awkward to suddenly shift a conversation to be about yourself. If we've been talking about the other person for hours, I don't know how I can suddenly say "so anyway, about me...". You wait for the other person to turn the topic around to include you.

But then you should be able to understand that others find it equally awkward to ask questions about your private life? It's the same opposite of the spectrum really.

There isn't ONE way to lead a conversation.
I manage conversations by volunteering information based on what the other person is telling me, if on top of this they are probing me on details I haven't volunteered then indeed we can easily spend 3h talking about me.
That's not what I want at all! I do get that it comes across as rude, so I try to adapt but it is difficult and I have to make an effort to remind myself to reciprocate the question (but that's usually followed by another series of questions about me!).

ViaBlue · 01/07/2024 16:50

I get you OP.

Have SIL just like that, it's exhausting. I stopped making any effort to see her now as it was always just about her. I would listen to her for hours but she never asked me anything and if I spoke about me she wouldn't even last a few minutes before changing the subject/leaving to do something etc.

hopeishere · 01/07/2024 16:50

My boss is like this. Drones on constantly about herself. Can talk for hours. So boring.

Occasionally she'll remember social norms and will reciprocate.

comingintomyown · 01/07/2024 16:48

I agree OP and over time I filter them out, however justifiable the reason may be doesn’t alter the fact that it’s one sided and can become dull same as people who talk about themselves and won’t spend more than a few word’s talking about your stuff

OnceICaughtACold · 01/07/2024 16:48

I fall under your umbrella of “people who don’t ask questions”. I too had it drummed in to me as a child that asking questions was intrusive and impolite (and being impolite was absolutely the worst thing I could do). I now have to really push and remind myself to ask questions, and often walk away from a conversation and think “oh crap, I totally forgot to reciprocate and ask how her husband is, I hope she doesn’t think I’m totally rude.” I also try to think back and remember something they’ve said before to show active interest - how’s the new job, how’s x getting on with his new piano class, etc. But sometimes I forget. Judging by your posts, maybe people do think I’m totally rude.

Id also counsel against a sweeping statement of “I’m not talking about people who are ND”. I’m pretty sure I’m ND, I’ve never mentioned it to anyone. Would you know if you were my friend? Possibly, possibly not.

Im much more comfortable in a conversation which flows without loads of questions - someone brings up their view on a topic, you give your view, maybe an example from your life, that prompts someone else, and on and on. Whatever we’re talking about, I’m interested in your views and experiences, I just might forget to ask you outright.

BlownItJellyHead · 01/07/2024 16:47

@RamonaRamirez As I clarified, I don't fire question after question, just make polite conversation. I asked about the rota because she was very specifically sounding off about it a couple of days earlier. I don't just randomly start asking people about their work rotas. Obviously.

OP posts:
Ukhotelsareshit · 01/07/2024 16:46

I get where you are coming from op, because I find a lot of people to be like this. I could ask “how was your holiday” for example and I will get a 40 monologue. That’s fine, I’m genuinely interested. But, they know I’ve just come back from holiday and they won’t ask how mine was? I know people that I could genuinely describe in intimate detail their entire lives, but they don’t know a thing about me! And if I do try and say anything about me, they turn it back to them. It is NOT uncommon! I don’t spend much time with these people now, for obvious reasons.

Pocketfullofdogtreats · 01/07/2024 16:43

Kneenightmare · 01/07/2024 15:54

You are not interested in your friends lives? I find that sad.

I find that when they're people I know really well, there's no need to ask about their kids or DHs. It might come up in conversation, and then we move on. We talk about other stuff. So don't be sad on my account.

RamonaRamirez · 01/07/2024 16:42

I also would not want to be asked about my new rota shift 😁

RamonaRamirez · 01/07/2024 16:40

Some people, maybe you are one of them OP 😁🫣, think it is the height of good manners to treat a conversation as an interview, firing question after question

I find these kind of conversations exhausting

I like random conversations about random topics, or for conversation to flow naturally, not a line of questions Grin

TitInATrance · 01/07/2024 16:40

ThoseDarnCrows · 01/07/2024 15:41

Well it seems I am one of 'these people' as you so charmingly put it. As a child , and throughout my life until my fifties I was browbeaten and berated regularly by my parent to 'not be nosy', mind your own business', 'what's it got to do with you' , why do you think they want you to know'....... and on and on and on, until I had no self esteem and was scared stiff of asking anybody anything in case I was judged as that awful nosy person I was constantly told I was.

So no, it is not necessarily the me, me, me scenario, and not because we don't want to know. It's taken me another decade since they have no longer been in my life to believe in myself and actually push myself to ask people those - what are to you - simple questions.

So OP, get off your high horse and actually think about what that non-reciprocal person may actual have gone, or still be going through.

Absolutely this, along with “nobody’s looking at you”, “don’t show off”. Talking in the car or at the dinner table was forbidden.

SummerInSun · 01/07/2024 16:39

My DH has now done so much training at work on sensitivity, unconscious bias, micro-aggressions, etc, that he's terrified of asking anyone anything ever, at least in the workplace or casual acquaintances. Can't ask people whether they have kids - hurtful to people who might be having fertility problems. Can't ask people about where they went / are going on holiday - might be seen as making remarks about their financial standing or, worse, their ethnic background. Can't ask people if they had a good Christmas or Easter break - what if they follow a different religion? Can't ask people what they did on the weekend - invasion of their privacy. He will happily discuss any of these these things, but only if th le other person volunteers the information first.

Ratflaps · 01/07/2024 16:37

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Eeyoreknowsall · 01/07/2024 16:37

SwordToFlamethrower · 01/07/2024 16:36

I've dumped friends that do this, and then actually have the audacity to interrupt me, when I attempt to speak about myself. I say that, my mil is exactly like this

Interrupting is classic ADHD, as is talking about yourself, at speed, to make sure you don't forget the very important thing.

BlownItJellyHead · 01/07/2024 16:37

Just for clarity, I absolutely don't bombard people with questions 😅😅

Yesterday, me and my friend were together for about three hours. Just the two of us. It absolutely wasn't me firing question-after-question at her.

For example, in the OP when I said that I asked about her work I meant that I asked two completely normal, just polite questions: "How's work going?" and then, after she'd talked about work for a while, "How's the rota change panning out?" I wasn't bombarding her with work-related questions. Ditto the other topics we talked about too.

OP posts:
magentarain · 01/07/2024 16:37

TheLightSideOfTheMoon · 01/07/2024 16:35

I find being asked questions exhausting.

I wouldn’t do that to someone else.

If people want to tell me things then they will. I don’t need to interview them.

Some people like to share, some people are private. It’s not up to me to pride information from them.

It's actually really awkward to suddenly shift a conversation to be about yourself. If we've been talking about the other person for hours, I don't know how I can suddenly say "so anyway, about me...". You wait for the other person to turn the topic around to include you.

stopthepigeonstopthepigeon · 01/07/2024 16:36

I was going to say that not everyone is that interested in you (speaking in general) but I guess it is a bit weird if she’s a friend. That said even if she is a friend she’s not necessarily going to ask after your husband if she’s not friends with him too. It depends how often you see her as well.

SwordToFlamethrower · 01/07/2024 16:36

I've dumped friends that do this, and then actually have the audacity to interrupt me, when I attempt to speak about myself. I say that, my mil is exactly like this

TheLightSideOfTheMoon · 01/07/2024 16:35

I find being asked questions exhausting.

I wouldn’t do that to someone else.

If people want to tell me things then they will. I don’t need to interview them.

Some people like to share, some people are private. It’s not up to me to pride information from them.

magentarain · 01/07/2024 16:34

Artists are the worst culprits for this. All my artist friends only talk about themselves and never reciprocate my questions.

DinnaeFashYersel · 01/07/2024 16:31

Some people have better social skills than others.

Some are self absorbed.

Some are shy

Some people don't really want to talk to you or aren't interested in you

Then there are those who are ND or hand things on their mind that you've already excuse.

Bearbookagainandagain · 01/07/2024 16:30

That's sounds like me, but I'm glad my friends aren't as judgemental as you.

Generally, I find it difficult/uncomfortable to quizz people about their private life, so with colleagues for instance if they don't volunteer the information I would rarely ask. Or I would ask very generic questions which aren't good conversation starters apparently.

With some friends I find that I'm bombarded with questions and by the time I have answered them all, there is no time left. I try to reciprocate but it's sometime difficult to find space to speak.

Honestly I generally don't have that issue with people who don't ask about every single detail of my private life. Surely there is a way you can rebound on what your friend is saying to redirect the conversation to you?

BlownItJellyHead · 01/07/2024 16:22

Some posts here are proving my point though - that even if you're not all that interested or not that quick off the mark, most people will still ask questions just to be polite or to find out what makes people tick.

It's just people who let silences hang when there's a clear opening for a reciprocal question that I just don't get. As I said, in cases where there are no ND issues, no childhood trauma, no acute problems going on.

Like yesterday, I asked my friend about her partner and followed-up with questions about particular things she was talking about. So she talked about him for maybe five or ten minutes. Absolutely fine. Then silence. Nothing. We just walked in silence for a good few minutes.

Surely it's just polite to ask "And how's your other half?" even if you're not all that interested. It'd have been really fucking weird - and probably pretty passive aggressive - for me to just jump in with "My Dave's okay" unprompted.

OP posts: