Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to not understand people who never ask reciprocal questions in a conversation?

263 replies

BlownItJellyHead · 01/07/2024 15:14

It's just so bloody strange. How can they not just do it reflexively? Do they genuinely have that little interest in finding out about other people? I'm not talking about people with ND issues or people with a lot on their mind at a specific time. I mean people who just generally don't ask questions.

I just don't get it at all. It goes without saying that its rude and indicative of some level of self-obsession. But, I just don't understand how they can do it. It's so bloody odd to me. Even if I don't have that much interest in the other person, I reciprocate questions reflexively, and I always find I'm interested in something about them.

Yesterday I was out with a friend for three hours - I asked about her work, her mum, her health, her plans for summer gardening, her partner, her pets, as well as follow-up questions off the back of things we were talking about.

She asked me nothing 😂😂😂

What is it with these people?!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
ByCupidStunt · 04/07/2024 13:55

IAmTheQuarry · 04/07/2024 13:30

For those who think it's nosey to ask questions, I think you're getting muddled. It's never ok to ask overly intrusive questions - finances, status, political stance etc ( unless, you know the person really well and have that type of relationship). Asking general questions - is how you get to know someone and actually show you're interested and care. I can't understand why that is difficult to grasp!

It's not difficult to grasp . They understand it perfectly well. Fact is, they just wanna talk about themselves CONSTANTLY and use this as an excuse. You can tell who they are just from this thread!

IAmTheQuarry · 04/07/2024 13:30

For those who think it's nosey to ask questions, I think you're getting muddled. It's never ok to ask overly intrusive questions - finances, status, political stance etc ( unless, you know the person really well and have that type of relationship). Asking general questions - is how you get to know someone and actually show you're interested and care. I can't understand why that is difficult to grasp!

sandyhappypeople · 04/07/2024 12:52

Itwillbeallwhiteintheend · 04/07/2024 12:47

I'm one of these people! It's not necessarily rude. I just find that often the people who I'd don't ask these questions of, are the people that bombard me with questions, and don't give me time to think...they're also the ones that don't tend to listen to your answers anyway and prefer to add a question to fill a silence!

It can often be rude to ask so many questions!!!

If they gave you time to think, do you think you'd ask them questions though?

I think there is definitely a different between not asking reciprocal questions and not being able to get a word in edgeways, OP seems to be talking about someone who is just happy to talk about herself and doesn't ask anything back, ever.

Noseybookworm · 04/07/2024 12:50

You sound quite exhausting actually! 😂 some people are maybe a bit anxious and over think so that they worry about what to ask and how it comes across. Some people are just quieter than others and don't really learn the art of moving the conversation along? If she is your friend, just accept her for who she is. And allow a few silences - it might give her time to process and she might venture a question!

Itwillbeallwhiteintheend · 04/07/2024 12:47

I'm one of these people! It's not necessarily rude. I just find that often the people who I'd don't ask these questions of, are the people that bombard me with questions, and don't give me time to think...they're also the ones that don't tend to listen to your answers anyway and prefer to add a question to fill a silence!

It can often be rude to ask so many questions!!!

Sjh15 · 04/07/2024 12:36

ThoseDarnCrows · 01/07/2024 15:41

Well it seems I am one of 'these people' as you so charmingly put it. As a child , and throughout my life until my fifties I was browbeaten and berated regularly by my parent to 'not be nosy', mind your own business', 'what's it got to do with you' , why do you think they want you to know'....... and on and on and on, until I had no self esteem and was scared stiff of asking anybody anything in case I was judged as that awful nosy person I was constantly told I was.

So no, it is not necessarily the me, me, me scenario, and not because we don't want to know. It's taken me another decade since they have no longer been in my life to believe in myself and actually push myself to ask people those - what are to you - simple questions.

So OP, get off your high horse and actually think about what that non-reciprocal person may actual have gone, or still be going through.

I agree with this. I don’t ask too much about people becuase I was brought up that things just ‘aren’t your business’, so now when I’m asked too much I hate it and give a simple answer and no more!

DottyLottieLou · 04/07/2024 12:23

There's plenty of these people around. They are best avoided. They talk at you and don't listen.

Chipsahoy · 04/07/2024 12:02

BlownItJellyHead · 01/07/2024 17:00

Exactly. I feel terrible that people don't find conversation easy because of dysfunctional childhoods and being told not to be nosy but surely asking "How are you?" or "How was your holiday?" doesn't fall under this umbrella.

My parents never ask how are you even to me?! Well at least when we were still in touch.
It was seen as prying. “What if they are struggling and you upset them” my family are totally incapable of dealing with emotion or feeling.
I always ask people how they are now and I genuinely want to know.

Chipsahoy · 04/07/2024 11:55

My family are that way and I was raised that way. They don’t believe in prying. We are estranged for other reasons but i had to learn to have conversation as well as many other things they didn’t teach me.
I probably go the other way now and ask plenty to deflect attention from me.

Northernladdette · 04/07/2024 11:52

Agree, we recently, along with another couple, met up with some mutual friends. We heard all about their children’s news, including the couple we were with . No one asked about ours 🙄

dudsville · 03/07/2024 09:10

Fairyliz · 03/07/2024 08:23

But how do you show an interest in others by never asking them a question and only talking about your life?
Surely ‘how are you’ is a question?

I also don't start conversations about me. It honestly bores me to have these kinds of conversations. I get that it'snecessary as a sort of social glue. I start conversations by asking others what they think about a topic.

TheaBrandt · 03/07/2024 08:41

“How did xs exams go?” They answer / you answer then general chat about exams which could then go anywhere. That’s how normal friend interactions seem to go.

The non questioners would presumably give a monologue about their own child’s exams and leave it there. Isn’t that terribly rude?!

Fairyliz · 03/07/2024 08:23

dudsville · 01/07/2024 17:30

I've certainly learned that it's important to some people for me to ask about holidays, pets, family, but really I do it because it's expected. I also find it extremely biting to be asked these things. This isn't the only way to show an interest in others, and it isn't how I take an interest in others.

But how do you show an interest in others by never asking them a question and only talking about your life?
Surely ‘how are you’ is a question?

Fairyliz · 02/07/2024 23:57

TheLightSideOfTheMoon · 01/07/2024 16:35

I find being asked questions exhausting.

I wouldn’t do that to someone else.

If people want to tell me things then they will. I don’t need to interview them.

Some people like to share, some people are private. It’s not up to me to pride information from them.

Well if you don’t ask them questions and you don’t like them asking you questions do you just walk along in complete silence?

sandyhappypeople · 02/07/2024 23:48

MasterBeth · 02/07/2024 22:53

The trouble with the questions you're asking is that they're fucking boring and, no, I wouldn't be interested in knowing about the reciprocal answers. I really couldn't care less about your work rotas. Or how your Dave is doing.

But...

I'm much more interested in your views on conversation and turn-taking which you are sharing in this thread. Genuinely. The things you are saying here - your opinions and assumptions on a social situation - are much more what I would want to talk to you about than your "reporting" on some boring shit that's happened at your work.

So unless you've got some scandalous or hilarious story to tell me, I'd rather hear what you think than what you'd done.

I wouldn't be interested in knowing about the reciprocal answers.

I'm not sure that's what OP means, (she asks about work, so friend should ask about work etc). It's more that her friend doesn't ask anything, so it doesn't matter what OP thinks about things, she is never getting the opportunity to open up about anything unless she starts randomly babbling broken biscuits about her thoughts and feelings on things without ever being prompted.

I would say most conversations start with a basic question, if you don't ask anything at all you aren't ever prompting a conversation, you are literally just answering questions that someone asks you and then waiting for them to ask you another one when the conversation naturally lulls.. in a reciprocal conversation you would normally take it in turns to prompt each other, with a question, a thought, an observation etc.. some people just don't do that.

So when OP asks about something (work in this instance), and when that conversation naturally reaches it's end, the friend could then lead the conversation to a more interesting topic of her choice, "have you seen that new show on netflix" "have you seen about this current event", or god forbid, ask the OP if her and her family are okay and at least pretend to care about the answer like a good friend should.

sandyhappypeople · 02/07/2024 23:32

Phineyj · 02/07/2024 07:34

@sandyhappypeople I enjoyed your post. It was very well described. I suffer the same with SIL. When I see her, we've driven hundreds of miles to be there and won't have seen each other for several months. She doesn't even say hello, generally!

What do you think would happen if you said to your sister, "You asked to come round but you don't seem to have anything to say. What's up with that?"

Asking closed rather than open questions can be a habit I think, and I'm not sure everyone knows the difference. I don't think it's easy to do much about that, but it's lazy to leave all the conversational heavy lifting to the other person every time.

I have asked her before when it has got too excruciating, and said something like, "you're a bit quiet, is everything okay?" .. "Yes, fine"..

I feel a bit awkward saying anything more, as it is just her way I suppose, and I feel if I question it I'm questioning her personality if you see what I mean? But I do get tired of the one way conversations that we have, especially when it such hard work to even get that out of her, but she seems to get something out of it and I love her so it continues, she will tell me everything she's been doing and problems at work and home etc but she continues to never asks a single thing or reciprocate the conversation in any way.

The funny thing is, if I'm ever down or unhappy or somethings happened, she would be there with flowers or something thoughtful to cheer me up, she's always done that since we were kids, and I do the same for her, but when things are going good or just a level playing field, it's like she just loses all interest.

MasterBeth · 02/07/2024 22:53

BlownItJellyHead · 01/07/2024 16:37

Just for clarity, I absolutely don't bombard people with questions 😅😅

Yesterday, me and my friend were together for about three hours. Just the two of us. It absolutely wasn't me firing question-after-question at her.

For example, in the OP when I said that I asked about her work I meant that I asked two completely normal, just polite questions: "How's work going?" and then, after she'd talked about work for a while, "How's the rota change panning out?" I wasn't bombarding her with work-related questions. Ditto the other topics we talked about too.

The trouble with the questions you're asking is that they're fucking boring and, no, I wouldn't be interested in knowing about the reciprocal answers. I really couldn't care less about your work rotas. Or how your Dave is doing.

But...

I'm much more interested in your views on conversation and turn-taking which you are sharing in this thread. Genuinely. The things you are saying here - your opinions and assumptions on a social situation - are much more what I would want to talk to you about than your "reporting" on some boring shit that's happened at your work.

So unless you've got some scandalous or hilarious story to tell me, I'd rather hear what you think than what you'd done.

Sleepiemum · 02/07/2024 22:40

@Marmiteontoastgirlie I wonder if I’m your friend who has been cut out! I had a friend who fired questions at me as though I was at a job interview but she avoided answering anything, it felt to awkward to keep asking. She cut me out and I never found out why. I think the questioning was a power and trust issue.

magentarain · 02/07/2024 13:34

OnceICaughtACold · 01/07/2024 18:08

Or don't you care?!

How many people have literally told you on this thread that asking questions is not how they show they care.

My close friend’s mum died recently. How do I know? Because she told me. She didn’t wait to be asked. Honestly from my point of view it’s weirdly self-absorbed to think someone else has to drag information out of you for you to share it.

Or another friend, is getting a dog. How am I meant to know to ask her about getting a dog when she’s never mentioned one before?

Telling people stuff they don’t remember is an entirely different thing.

It's very simple. You say "So what's going on with you at the moment? /How have you been? / What are you up to?"

I have a friend who never asks me questions, and they only just found out that my mum died when I was a child. Why? Because it's not the kind of thing I'm going to suddenly announce. But if they had noticed that I never mention my mother, and that I have a stepmother, they could have asked me why. Other more considerate friends have done just that. They've asked very tactfully "And is your mum still around?" and then I've been able to open up.

EverythingYouDoIsaBalloon · 02/07/2024 12:42

Spotsorstripesor · 02/07/2024 12:06

I would say most people can tell if their friends are interested in what they’re saying, regardless of conversational style. What are the ways a person might show interest that another person might miss?

Although i agree with you that facial expressions often demonstrate it, some people have relatively expressionless faces but may be listening closely. And although they may not ask questions, they may then respond in a way that does continue the conversation - by suggesting how a problem could be resolved, for example, or with comments such as 'That sounds hard', 'Sounds like a great birthday,' 'Oh, it's beautiful there, isn't it,' (when a place is mentioned) etc etc.

If no reply whatsoever is made, I agree, it can then feel like hard work. But there's a lot of value being placed specifically on questions as a way of showing interest, on this thread, when there are all sorts of other ways, both verbal and non-verbal, to show interest.

Spotsorstripesor · 02/07/2024 12:06

EverythingYouDoIsaBalloon · 02/07/2024 11:58

I disagree. To me OP's posts aren't displaying much understanding of why some people don't ask questions, even with some possible reasons having been supplied. And I don't agree that you can always tell whether someone is interested in what you are saying. Different people have different communication styles.

I would say most people can tell if their friends are interested in what they’re saying, regardless of conversational style. What are the ways a person might show interest that another person might miss?

EverythingYouDoIsaBalloon · 02/07/2024 11:58

I disagree. To me OP's posts aren't displaying much understanding of why some people don't ask questions, even with some possible reasons having been supplied. And I don't agree that you can always tell whether someone is interested in what you are saying. Different people have different communication styles.

Spotsorstripesor · 02/07/2024 11:32

EverythingYouDoIsaBalloon · 02/07/2024 11:07

There are two separate things being conflated in so many of these posts: people who don't ask others many questions because it's simply not their way (often for reasons of upbringing, as some posts demonstrate), and people who don't ask others many questions because they lack social antennae, are self-absorbed and prefer to talk about themselves. A lot of people seem to be assuming everyone who doesn't ask others many questions falls into the second category. It's quite offensive tbh, all this 'Oh, don't they drive you mad, all they want to do is bang on about themselves.' Just saying.

Yes but irl you can tell if someone is interested in you, regardless of their conversational style. Even if they’re not asking questions, they might look interested or make a relevant comment that builds on what you’ve just said. That’s ok. What the OP is talking about is people who plainly aren’t interested in others and if the conversation isn’t directly about them they have nothing to say.

shearwater2 · 02/07/2024 11:31

I have to kick myself to remember to do it sometimes. When the person I'm talking to is more interesting it comes more naturally to ask them questions.

I felt like after the pandemic I had to work quite hard to get social skills back and found other people such hard work at first (probably as their social skills had also dropped off). It's better now.

Also when I was younger I was more shy of asking other people questions as it felt intrusive and I was more worried about embarrassment or asking the wrong thing. I can well remember those feelings. People often used to say I was quiet or aloof. Perhaps others found me self-absorbed or rude.

I find with people who don't ask questions for 90% of them it is shyness or lack of social conversational skills rather than self-absorption and am kind and patient with people and try to assume the best of them.

IAmTheQuarry · 02/07/2024 11:25

Urgh, I think a few of us on here know the same people or else there are a lot of them around! One particular friend of a friend is an absolute arse for this - not remotely interested in anything I have to say/ doesn't ask about my life at all; however to add another layer of annoyance to this - loves to ask extremely intrusive questions regarding my finances. So not bothered about finding out my interests/ hobbies/ holidays/who I am as a person/ likes/ dislikes, but is fine asking about how much money I have! She took me off guard the first few times but I'm prepared nowadays and shut it down with a glib response. Who does that? When I'm in her company nowadays I don't bother with her at all - I used to try and engage in her conversation and try to build a relationship with her, but nowadays I'm all about ' matching the energy' so she gets nowt from me. If she prefers to sit in an awkward silence and receive 1 word replies to her nosey money focused questions, so be it.