Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that too many people are in denial that they should not drive?

259 replies

Onomatofear · 29/06/2024 19:19

I hear about countless examples of elderly people or people with health problems getting behind the wheel of a car when they shouldn't be. Why do they do it?

I remember my dh's granddad doing it. Now it's my dad. He's 78 and can barely walk without falling over and he refuses to accept that he shouldn't be on the road. About 6 months ago, he accidentally drove over a pedestrian island thinking it was an actual road. I pointed out to my mum that him being old wouldn't count as a defence. She still gets in the car with him(!)

And before you say why don't I report him, it's easy to say but I've reported someone before for the same sort of thing and he figured out it was me and went mad at me. It's even more difficult to report your own parent.

OP posts:
Irishbabylondon · 30/06/2024 18:30

You have a duty of care to everyone to inform dvla and police so they can arrange an assessment of his driving..

fetchacloth · 30/06/2024 18:11

justasking111 · 29/06/2024 19:25

Our police set up a roadblock/pull in the other week in our small town. Pulled in drivers made them all do a number plate reading test. Three failed and have lost their licenses.

I hope this initiative is rolled out across the country.
There is no excuse for senior people to not have regular eye tests, they are free for the over 60s. During the eye test, the optician looks out for cataracts which are common in the over 60s and cause issues for drivers, especially at night.

ANiceBigCupOfTea · 30/06/2024 18:09

Yes and there's loads of it, not just elderly people. The amount of people who drive really poorly is shocking to me sometimes.
I have Dyspraxia and I'd be shit. I'd endanger myself and others so I don't do it.

Pixiedust88 · 30/06/2024 17:46

YANBU. There are so many people on the roads (not just elderly people) who shouldn’t be driving and how they even passed their test in the first place is beyond me. There’s so many women I’ve seen who sit so close to the steering wheel their chest is about an inch away, people who can’t see over the steering wheel and even people who go so slow on main roads for no reason to name a few. If your dad isn’t safe to be driving you need to do something or you’d never be able to live with yourself if he accidentally killed someone and you could have done something to help prevent it

HappyAsASandboy · 30/06/2024 16:17

For my grandad, it took a local tragedy where an elderly driver ran over and killed someone. As soon as grandad saw it on the news he stopped driving. He said he realised that absolutely could have been him that hit someone and he didn't want that to happen.

Lollygaggle · 30/06/2024 15:20

After dealing with the consequences of relatives who did no preparation for when things would become difficult and refused to make any adjustments or have any help until things were very bad we have started preparing already so our children do not have to go through what we went through

when we moved we moved somewhere with a lot of services and public transport nearby , although we haven’t ruled out another move in a decade if we feel we need more adjustments

we moved somewhere without an attic and as much storage as we had so not as much crud to get rid of

we have already done power of attorney for health and finances

I have had points where I have not been able to drive for a long time and this has reinforced my view that we need to be somewhere where a car is not essential . Unfortunately some of the people of my age are now moving out to the country and more remote locations and I wonder how they will cope if they can’t drive as public transport is almost nonexistent and taxis ditto .

As a society we are not planning enough , for ourselves, for ageing .

YachtMistress · 30/06/2024 15:11

ILs (86 and 89) do tag team driving down M4 (4 hour journey). Absolutely terrifying. In total denial regarding health and age impairments on driving. They. Just. Don't. Care.

fieldsofbutterflies · 30/06/2024 14:52

Well, ideally you move before it becomes a necessity, so that you're not dealing with a house move (and all that entails) when you're already struggling with your health and mobility.

You don't need a bungalow either, lots of older people still live in "normal" houses and install stair lifts etc. to help them maintain their independence.

FIL is approaching eighty and recently widowed - the only reason he still has his independence is because he has a mobility scooter and lives minutes away from everything he needs. If he lived anywhere more rural, it would have been much harder to get him to give up his car.

anyolddinosaur · 30/06/2024 14:43

And when are you supposed to make this move to a location where you can walk to any resource you need? You can be over 80 and still not hitting things when you drive. But apparently you are supposed to give up your license so that young fools dont want to overtake you when it isnt safe to do so.

I wonder how many own fault accidents the OP has had - and how many her parent has had.

When we're older we'll be moving to a property that needs less maintenance. Ever tried finding a bungalow near to every service you might need - hens teeth are easier. There may be a few ground floor flats but not masses of them either.

fieldsofbutterflies · 30/06/2024 14:30

LlynTegid · 30/06/2024 14:14

One person who believes he is more capable than he probably is sits in the White House, as an example, not that he is driving a car.

Well, exactly.

It's really easy to say "well, I'd happily give my license up if I was eighty" when you're only 35 and are otherwise perfectly fit and healthy, and can happily walk everywhere, navigate the train/bus with no issues, etc.

FWIW I do think there are lots of elderly people out there who shouldn't drive, but I don't think it's as easy to get them to stop as people are making it out to be.

LlynTegid · 30/06/2024 14:14

fieldsofbutterflies · 30/06/2024 14:11

But the impact on your life of not having a car is not a justification for driving should your health deteriorate.

Nobody's saying that.

What they're saying is that it's really hard to ask people to give up their freedom and independence, especially when lots of elderly people believe they're far more capable than they are.

Edited

One person who believes he is more capable than he probably is sits in the White House, as an example, not that he is driving a car.

LlynTegid · 30/06/2024 14:13

JohnofWessex · 30/06/2024 12:37

100% agree.

fieldsofbutterflies · 30/06/2024 14:11

But the impact on your life of not having a car is not a justification for driving should your health deteriorate.

Nobody's saying that.

What they're saying is that it's really hard to ask people to give up their freedom and independence, especially when lots of elderly people believe they're far more capable than they are.

justasking111 · 30/06/2024 13:31

marshmallowfinder · 30/06/2024 13:17

A black box is of course not just for speeding. It monitors the way the car is driven, including heavy braking.

Heavy breaking 😂😂 we're mostly 20mph here occasionally reaching the giddy heights of 30 mph for about 300 yards. From my house 2 miles into town. I go from 20 to 40, back to 20, then 30, then 20.

Yep I'm in Wales.

marshmallowfinder · 30/06/2024 13:17

justasking111 · 30/06/2024 12:46

That's for speeding which folks over a certain age don't do

A black box is of course not just for speeding. It monitors the way the car is driven, including heavy braking.

UnpackingBooksFromBoxes · 30/06/2024 13:16

Foxxo · 30/06/2024 12:18

Not having my car would massively impact on my life. I can take myself, my mom, and my kids to all our medical appointments, i can visit my friends all over the uk, i can go anywhere, at any time.

Being disabled and having a wheelchair/walking stick i'm dependent on, not having my car would be a disaster.. when was the last time you tried using a wheelchair on a bus or train? Or getting in/out of a taxi with one?

Just because your DH isn't impacted, doesn't mean it wouldn't seriously impact on other people.. how very narrow minded.

But the impact on your life of not having a car is not a justification for driving should your health deteriorate.
I have a degenerative condition and had to advise the DVLA when diagnosed. Every three years I have to reapply for my licence. Currently my driving is unaffected but I am very aware of the nature of my health condition that I am going to have to stop driving in the future. This will impact my life massively but that won’t stop me surrendering my licence as if I were responsible for someone being injured or worse killed I couldn’t bear it.

justasking111 · 30/06/2024 13:00

DuesToTheDirt · 30/06/2024 11:50

Well my mum, who didn't want to give up driving, sent me out on some errands in her car when I was staying. These included

shopping at Tescos
get a prescription (but not at Tescos because they'd made here wait once, or something)
get cash from cashpoint (a mile from Tescos, because sometimes that one would give you fivers
get stamps
fill her car with petrol
then pick her up from the hairdressers

Her errands would not be possible without a car, she'd have had to reorganise her whole life and forget about past annoyances from Tescos pharmacy lol. I didn't get them all completed in the time ("Well I'd rather have had the stamps than X, I really needed those" Hmm), and didn't get a receipt for the petrol as the machine wasn't working properly. When I mentioned I'd got the petrol at Tescos, she said, "Why did you go there? I always get it from Blah Garage." Confused

😂😂😂 I don't give a monkeys where I get fuel.

But living in Wales, buses are erratic, cancelled on a whim. I'd have to walk three miles to get one. Taxis since COVID have dried up, they won't leave the burbs because of costs. Our taxi firm just can't get drivers, they're all doing evri, DPD.

Son in Leeds at university had an Uber app. Four minutes from ordering to a taxi outside the restaurant. I was open mouthed at the speed.

sleepyscientist · 30/06/2024 12:57

@JohnofWessex do we or do we need to be less afraid of risk?

justasking111 · 30/06/2024 12:52

Onomatofear · 30/06/2024 11:52

Yes it does, My mum was telling me how much it now costs to insurance them both and that it had jumped. So clearly people of this age do have more accidents. It was then that I said dad shouldn't even be driving.

I hit 66 state pension age my insurance jumped £100. I've 45 years no claims. It's a logarithm, nothing personal. It's a bloody cheek though.

justasking111 · 30/06/2024 12:49

Foxxo · 30/06/2024 12:18

Not having my car would massively impact on my life. I can take myself, my mom, and my kids to all our medical appointments, i can visit my friends all over the uk, i can go anywhere, at any time.

Being disabled and having a wheelchair/walking stick i'm dependent on, not having my car would be a disaster.. when was the last time you tried using a wheelchair on a bus or train? Or getting in/out of a taxi with one?

Just because your DH isn't impacted, doesn't mean it wouldn't seriously impact on other people.. how very narrow minded.

One of the mums at school a few years ago was a thalidomide baby. Her specially adapted vehicle meant that she could get her children to a special needs school, get her wheelchair in and out on her owne

justasking111 · 30/06/2024 12:46

Kendodd · 30/06/2024 10:21

One solution would be black boxes for everyone over a certain age.
Does insurance cost leap up with older drivers?

That's for speeding which folks over a certain age don't do

JohnofWessex · 30/06/2024 12:37

Blimpton · 30/06/2024 07:24

This is the issue with setting up a society that requires people to drive. I hate driving. I know I’m not good at it. I only drive certain familiar routes because I’m scared - to school, to work, to a couple of friends and familys houses, that’s it. But I have to drive. Otherwise how am I supposed to get to work and get DC to school?

AKA Motor normativity

https://www.theguardian.com/world/2023/jan/17/motonormativity-britons-more-accepting-driving-related-risk

Thats what we need to challenge

‘Motonormativity’: Britons more accepting of driving-related risk

Allowance made for dangers that would not be accepted in other parts of life, finds study with potentially major policy implications

https://www.theguardian.com/world/2023/jan/17/motonormativity-britons-more-accepting-driving-related-risk

Foxxo · 30/06/2024 12:18

YellowHairband · 30/06/2024 11:42

I think it's odd to equate driving with independence so much.

DH doesn't drive due to a medical condition. He's very much independent. Admittedly he's never been able to so he never gave anything up, but it's ridiculous to suggest you're no longer independent. As if people with medical conditions preventing driving are all just sitting around waiting for others to do things for them.

And even if it is a loss of independence - that's not actually a reason to keep doing it. No one would think my DH was reasonable for getting behind the wheel because he wants independence.

Not having my car would massively impact on my life. I can take myself, my mom, and my kids to all our medical appointments, i can visit my friends all over the uk, i can go anywhere, at any time.

Being disabled and having a wheelchair/walking stick i'm dependent on, not having my car would be a disaster.. when was the last time you tried using a wheelchair on a bus or train? Or getting in/out of a taxi with one?

Just because your DH isn't impacted, doesn't mean it wouldn't seriously impact on other people.. how very narrow minded.

fieldsofbutterflies · 30/06/2024 11:55

YellowHairband · 30/06/2024 11:42

I think it's odd to equate driving with independence so much.

DH doesn't drive due to a medical condition. He's very much independent. Admittedly he's never been able to so he never gave anything up, but it's ridiculous to suggest you're no longer independent. As if people with medical conditions preventing driving are all just sitting around waiting for others to do things for them.

And even if it is a loss of independence - that's not actually a reason to keep doing it. No one would think my DH was reasonable for getting behind the wheel because he wants independence.

I don't think it's remotely odd.

I didn't drive until my late twenties and, without exaggerating, my life improved massively overnight. All of a sudden I could just hop into a car and go wherever I wanted, whenever I wanted. I was no longer reliant on other people, or on waiting around for buses and trains just to get to the shops.

If you've never driven, you don't know what you're missing out on so it's not really a comparable situation, IMO.

I also never said it was a reason to keep doing it Confused I said it was understandable that people didn't want to stop driving and that it's very easy to say "well, I'd happily give up my car" when you're not actually in that situation yourself.

Onomatofear · 30/06/2024 11:52

Kendodd · 30/06/2024 10:21

One solution would be black boxes for everyone over a certain age.
Does insurance cost leap up with older drivers?

Yes it does, My mum was telling me how much it now costs to insurance them both and that it had jumped. So clearly people of this age do have more accidents. It was then that I said dad shouldn't even be driving.

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread