Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that too many people are in denial that they should not drive?

259 replies

Onomatofear · 29/06/2024 19:19

I hear about countless examples of elderly people or people with health problems getting behind the wheel of a car when they shouldn't be. Why do they do it?

I remember my dh's granddad doing it. Now it's my dad. He's 78 and can barely walk without falling over and he refuses to accept that he shouldn't be on the road. About 6 months ago, he accidentally drove over a pedestrian island thinking it was an actual road. I pointed out to my mum that him being old wouldn't count as a defence. She still gets in the car with him(!)

And before you say why don't I report him, it's easy to say but I've reported someone before for the same sort of thing and he figured out it was me and went mad at me. It's even more difficult to report your own parent.

OP posts:
Leeta · 01/07/2024 01:39

The policy and processes for driving over 70 years of age in the uk are too lax. Ie in Cyprus,at 70 you cannot self declare yourself fit to drive, you HAVE to visit dr who decides whether or not you are fit to drive for next 3 years. If ant dr in Cyprus suspects you are unfit to drive at any time the government offices are contacted and they suspend your license immediately. A friend was declared unfit to drive and 30 mins later received a message to say license suspended !

ShallWeGoToTheFirepit · 01/07/2024 01:24

Washingupdone · 30/06/2024 23:48

I know of a young man,18, the day he past his driving test he was turning right but didn’t see a motor cyclist. He knocked the the cyclist off his bike. Police arrived and was told, you must not let this put you off driving. If it had been an older person they would have been told they were too old to drive. Insurance companies know who cause the most serious accidents and price accordingly. That’s why younger inexperienced drivers pay more.

If the stats were recorded per mile I think old people would come pretty close or beyond young drivers causing the most crashes.

Old people pootle around towns and don't do the distance younger drivers do. So the stats reflect this.

Young drivers have better cognitive behaviours and reaction times.

Washingupdone · 30/06/2024 23:48

I know of a young man,18, the day he past his driving test he was turning right but didn’t see a motor cyclist. He knocked the the cyclist off his bike. Police arrived and was told, you must not let this put you off driving. If it had been an older person they would have been told they were too old to drive. Insurance companies know who cause the most serious accidents and price accordingly. That’s why younger inexperienced drivers pay more.

likethislikethat · 30/06/2024 23:34

Re-test every 5 years to about 70 then every year.

ErinBell01 · 30/06/2024 23:33

We have a friend we don't see very often with a medical condition causing cognitive problems. I hear from a mutual friend that he is very concerned that this chap is still driving as he struggles with even simple things sometimes, and forgets where the controls are in his car. I contacted DVLA but they didn't want to know and suggested that I have a word with him and suggest that perhaps he shouldn't drive. As if!!

Whyhaveibeencutoutofmamsnot · 30/06/2024 22:39

And the 17 and 18 year olds should be more strictly supervised as so many fatalities are in this age group

MereDintofPandiculation · 30/06/2024 22:31

VickyEadieofThigh · 30/06/2024 09:02

Remaining socially engaged won't stop someone getting dementia.

Nothing will guarantee that you don't get dementia, but there are various things that reduce the risk, exercise being one of the most important, but another is lack of social engagement, and is the mechanism by which deafness is associated with dementia.

SuperBlondie28 · 30/06/2024 22:09

I watched a lady pensioner barely able to use her walking frame, not even able to straighten up her body, get in a car and drive off. Yikes! I don't know her. Was in our car in a public car park but it just didn't seem safe that she'd be out on the road seriously.

pollymere · 30/06/2024 21:58

There are far too many people driving whose GPs know they shouldn't be. Or their Optician. I think people in these roles should have the power to tell the DVLA about epileptics having day fits or those who can't really see properly to drive. I have a three year rolling licence due to Diabetes and my GP has to report whether I'm safe to drive. But these don't seem to be actioned properly for anyone - especially the elderly.

justasking111 · 30/06/2024 21:36

Onomatofear · 30/06/2024 21:34

I've come up with a solution. I can volunteer to go to the GP with my dad this week , sit in the appointment with him (because he forgets things) and then bring up driving with the GP. Hopefully the GP will say he shouldn't drive. He will (probably) listen to the GP because he tends to obey authority figures.

Let the GP know in advance so he's primed to ask the questions

Onomatofear · 30/06/2024 21:34

I've come up with a solution. I can volunteer to go to the GP with my dad this week , sit in the appointment with him (because he forgets things) and then bring up driving with the GP. Hopefully the GP will say he shouldn't drive. He will (probably) listen to the GP because he tends to obey authority figures.

OP posts:
DannyLovesFanny · 30/06/2024 21:21

Ilovecleaning · 30/06/2024 18:46

Christ! That would be AWFUL!

Tough. A retest would help to keep drivers sharp and competent and wean out those who should no longer be behind the wheel. There are plenty of drivers on the roads who shouldn't be trusted with a supermarket trolley, never mind a killing machine.

UnpackingBooksFromBoxes · 30/06/2024 21:16

Onomatofear · 30/06/2024 20:03

I'm not going to reply any more to people who keep blaming me - I am not responsible for his driving. I am not responsible for other people's shitty decisions that I would never take myself. My mum is the one who would be the most angry with me for reporting him.

Starting a war with them would be very isolating for me, never mind the money and I have no siblings . I have a complex relationship with them - they are not normal people and it is only in recent years that they've mellowed out a bit. I also have my own disabilities and complex mental health and inability to deal with fall outs.

If you still want to have a go at me then consider whether you would say any of this to someone in real life when you're not hiding behind a keyboard.

It's typical Mumsnet (argumentative and a distinct lack of empathy) for people to make this my fault when countless other posters have also said that they have a similar situation to deal with. Reporting him will probably not get him off the road and will just cause me untold trouble when I have enough to deal with.

I have said on this post already that I have a neurological condition and that I will have to give my licence up. I have also stated that I have seen the consequences of someone not giving up their licence when they should. I worked alongside the serious collision investigation unit in my local police force for over ten years and I can categorically tell you that I have said the things I have typed to people’s faces. I went on a weekend away with 16 other people who have the same condition as me and I had a few very frank conversations with some of the participants about this subject. Ultimately your father is making the decision to drive but you and your mother are enabling him. Just report him if you can’t talk to him and deny all knowledge if questioned. Because you will feel responsible even if you’re not should he injure someone.

DuesToTheDirt · 30/06/2024 20:59

Anyone else remember the "man in hat" drivers? I guess they have died out, since the cohort of men who wore hats all the time has passed on. But years ago, if you were behind someone driving very slowly, it nearly always seemed to be a man in a hat, i.e. an elderly man.

GreenFritillary · 30/06/2024 20:58

sorry, muddled threads.

GreenFritillary · 30/06/2024 20:57

In my late 70s I realised that although I could see all right, I was becoming slower at interpreting what I saw. In daily life it has never made much difference, but on the road it was not safe enough, so I stopped driving. But my husband will drive me anywhere: it is not such an easy decision for those who are on their own.

I8toys · 30/06/2024 20:36

Lollygaggle · 30/06/2024 15:20

After dealing with the consequences of relatives who did no preparation for when things would become difficult and refused to make any adjustments or have any help until things were very bad we have started preparing already so our children do not have to go through what we went through

when we moved we moved somewhere with a lot of services and public transport nearby , although we haven’t ruled out another move in a decade if we feel we need more adjustments

we moved somewhere without an attic and as much storage as we had so not as much crud to get rid of

we have already done power of attorney for health and finances

I have had points where I have not been able to drive for a long time and this has reinforced my view that we need to be somewhere where a car is not essential . Unfortunately some of the people of my age are now moving out to the country and more remote locations and I wonder how they will cope if they can’t drive as public transport is almost nonexistent and taxis ditto .

As a society we are not planning enough , for ourselves, for ageing .

This totally. We've also had to deal with the same with in laws. Its been horrendous and I will not do that to my children. Its okay saying oh don't you dare put me in a home. Its not that simple. Its not your choice if you have dementia for example, the decision rests with those who have POA. And with regards to driving, yes we took the responsibility and took the car away because no one else would for everyone's benefit.

Oh and inheritance is never guaranteed. Your parents may need complex care that eats away at their money.

Blarn · 30/06/2024 20:17

No, but like a PP, you could sow the seed that it might be the opticiacians who reported him. He might never need to know exactly where it came from.

Onomatofear · 30/06/2024 20:03

I'm not going to reply any more to people who keep blaming me - I am not responsible for his driving. I am not responsible for other people's shitty decisions that I would never take myself. My mum is the one who would be the most angry with me for reporting him.

Starting a war with them would be very isolating for me, never mind the money and I have no siblings . I have a complex relationship with them - they are not normal people and it is only in recent years that they've mellowed out a bit. I also have my own disabilities and complex mental health and inability to deal with fall outs.

If you still want to have a go at me then consider whether you would say any of this to someone in real life when you're not hiding behind a keyboard.

It's typical Mumsnet (argumentative and a distinct lack of empathy) for people to make this my fault when countless other posters have also said that they have a similar situation to deal with. Reporting him will probably not get him off the road and will just cause me untold trouble when I have enough to deal with.

OP posts:
CatMummyOf3 · 30/06/2024 19:51

Onomatofear · 29/06/2024 19:48

If your dad found out it was you would he have disinherited you? Because that's what will happen to me. And I'm disabled and have disabled children.

And reporting someone and making them lose their license is not always enough to stop them driving.

Wow.

So your potential inheritance is more important to you than the safety of other road users? He could kill or seriously injure someone, and/or himself.

Unbelievable.

Lollygaggle · 30/06/2024 19:21

Have you children? Would you put them in the car with him, and if you haven’t would you be driven by him?

How bad would all of you feel if anyone, your parents included , got hurt?

Do the right thing.

ettabea · 30/06/2024 19:06

Going through similar at the moment with my Dad. Late 70s, numerous very serious health problems inc. stage 4 cancer. Very weak, frail and unsteady on his feet (can't walk more than a few steps so has a scooter to get out and about).
Just bought a high-end car, which he said he needed as 1. It's an automatic and can't manage gears anymore, 2. It's solid and safe, and 3. Why shouldn't he spend his own money? Its very flashy and prestigious and I suspect he likes the fact he can show-off a bit. Tbh I also think the salesman saw him coming.
Anyway, Mum won't drive it as she's not confident enough, and it's too big and complicated. He himself can't really get his head around all the new technology. I'm so scared he's putting himself, mum and other drivers/pedestrians at risk, but he used to drive for a living and is of the opinion all is well. Mum said it would break his heart if he had to give up his car, but admits that other drivers are often shouting at him or beeping the horn.
Currently mulling over my decision to have a word with his doctor and voice my concerns.

Mere1 · 30/06/2024 19:05

It is.
Young, inexperienced drivers cause accidents too.

Ilovecleaning · 30/06/2024 18:46

DannyLovesFanny · 29/06/2024 19:57

I've long held the opinion that driving licences should only be valid for a maximum of 10 years, after which you need to retake your test. Plus, a mandatory eyesight test every 12 months.

Christ! That would be AWFUL!

user8800 · 30/06/2024 18:41

Onomatofear · 29/06/2024 19:49

The solution would be if it became law that everyone needs to take an assessment at say 75 and every 3 -5 years after to ensure they remain fit to drive

I agree.

Hope the cash makes up for him potentially killing someone 🤬

Swipe left for the next trending thread