Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Biden Trump debate- they must get rid of Biden now?

533 replies

molotovcupcakes · 28/06/2024 07:10

Biden looked so frail and incoherant at times that this must be the end of his Presidency very soon.
How have the Democrats not faced this sooner and selected someone else, I don't understand why they have let this go on for so long.
He had to be helped off the stage by his wife and it seems like elder abuse.

www.politico.com/video/2024/06/28/jill-biden-escorts-joe-biden-off-stage-after-first-presidential-debate-1346575

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
YankTank · 28/06/2024 10:18

GiveMeSpanakopita · 28/06/2024 09:30

Oh OK. I didn't know that, thank you.

Anyway I think the causes of the decline of US and UK democracies are as follows, just my opinions:

  1. Politicians stopped being deep thinkers who had real jobs and started being careerists with little real world experience who put their careers over representing the voters
  2. Too few working class politicians especially from manufacturing, agrarian and service industries
  3. Media stopped exploring politics in meaningful ways and started focussing on soundbites and gotchas. For a shocking example watch an interview with Wilson or Thatcher and see how they are given the space and time to thoughtfully discuss policies and economics and the interviewer has the knowledge to dive in deep with them. And that was prime time TV. Now compare it with an interview with Sunak and Starmer from the present day. There has been a steep and alarming decline in intellectual 'meat'
  4. Voters are lower information due to point 3 and also to social media.
  5. Social media has caused greater political divides so that many voters no longer see themselves as being part of a country but just as part of a tribe that hates and wishes destruction on the other tribe. Which leads to...
  6. ....death threats and political assassinations (Cox, Amess) meaning that good people are getting too scared to go into politics
  7. Media emphasises superficial things like a candidates looks and mannerism rather than policies and abilities
  8. Poor education. Many people know little about the evolution of democracy and how difficult it has been to protect, and what life is like under other systems. Hence some think communism or facism sound reasonable because they haven't learned what these systems are actually like
  9. We don't pay our politicians enough and require them to work stupid hours meaning that the brightest and most conscientious in our society would rather go into law, banking, tech, start a company, anything than politics...
  10. ...so we get left with grifters and morons.

All of this is in our gift as the public to solve but I think we're too distracted and divided just now.

On #8, there are many Trump supporters at rallies going on the record that they believe a Trump dictatorship will be the best outcome for the country. It’s beggars belief: https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=U4mZJZorCUQ&pp=ygUOSm9yZGFuIGtsZXBwZXI%3D

People are also easily taken in by short catchphrases. Build a wall. Make America great again. Stop the steal. Lock her up. Take back control. Get Brexit done. Stop the boats.

Jordan Klepper Takes On Trump Supporters | The Daily Show

Jordan Klepper returns to the Daily Show, this time taking the streets at a Trump rally discovering hilarious insights on Trump as the King, new American val...

https://m.youtube.com/watch?pp=ygUOSm9yZGFuIGtsZXBwZXI%3D&v=U4mZJZorCUQ

luckylavender · 28/06/2024 10:17

Janehasamane · 28/06/2024 07:51

Watching the video of him talking, it is now reached the stage of turning him into a spectacle. Old age has sadly caught up with him, and he’s not fully in charge of his facilities or his physicality any more. Trump is only 4 years younger but to be fair still as sharp as a pin and physically able. Just he’s a twat.

they need to remove Biden, it can’t go on.

I agree with everything about Biden, it's very difficult to watch. But I don't think Trump is great either. Some of his speeches leave a lot to be desired cognitively. We would be notice this more if it weren't for Biden.

Staplerandstappler · 28/06/2024 10:16

Pocketfullofdogtreats · 28/06/2024 10:13

Trump is already telling Americans that their justice system is out to get them. When you don't trust the justice system you get anarchy.

Trump clearly hero worships leaders like Putin and Kim Jong Un, who do what they like, unchallenged and unbothered by (fair) elections and legal scrutiny. He’s a clear and present danger to the world.

Channellingsophistication · 28/06/2024 10:16

Just can’t fathom why the Democrats can’t find someone else to run. If Biden had been 20 years younger or even 10 years younger, it would’ve been fine, but he is just simply too old. Its ridiculous. They’re just handing it to Trump. It’s really scary.

We did see on American TV several months ago a report of Michelle Obama running but sadly this hasnt happened. I would’ve loved to see her as the President.

very worrying times

MrsSkylerWhite · 28/06/2024 10:16

DanielGault · Today 07:47
theresnolimits · Today 07:35
Kamala Harris is not popular. If there was a strong VP things might be different.
Why is she so unpopular that they prefer Biden? I have nothing against him but he looked out of it in that debate. If you can't pull off a debate, how can you run a country?

The President doesn’t run the country. An army of officials behind the scenes does. He’s a figurehead. Trump spent much of his time in bed eating burgers and tweeting.

eggplant16 · 28/06/2024 10:14

The Obamas were such a class act. Its like a bygone age. I remember his first inaugeration, his younger daughter with her camera.

freshbluesnow · 28/06/2024 10:14

BloodyHellKenAgain · 28/06/2024 10:10

Being a decent man with experience and good understanding of policy will only take you so far if you look like you aren't physically or mentally up to the job.

Well, it's a big head start on a man who is not morally up to the job, and who suggested injecting disinfectant might be a good solution for covid.

Pocketfullofdogtreats · 28/06/2024 10:13

Keepingongoing · 28/06/2024 07:23

I think I heard that there isn’t an obvious mechanism; Biden needs to consent to standing aside.

It’s incredibly worrying, not just for Americans but for us all. My father believes that Trump would be a full- on Fascist in a heartbeat if he thought he could get away with it,

Trump is already telling Americans that their justice system is out to get them. When you don't trust the justice system you get anarchy.

AInightingale · 28/06/2024 10:13

Just reminds me of my late father in his last couple of years, after he had suffered a series of small strokes - jumbled words, losing the thread of his sentences.

It's absolutely appalling and so much worse in an era of mass media, I believe that Ramsay MacDonald was quietly replaced by Baldwin in the 1930s because his speeches became increasingly rambling and it was obvious that he had dementia, but politicians did not have the scrutiny that they do now.

Staplerandstappler · 28/06/2024 10:13

Truly cringeworthy viewing. Dreadful.

Trump lying away, completely unchallenged by the moderators or Biden (in any effective way).

Biden - I just don’t know what to say. Shambolic, incoherent, inaudible, confused. And that’s how he is today, how’s he going to be in four years if he wins?

I’d still vote Biden over Trump (I’d never vote Trump, not that I have a vote) but I cannot believe he isn’t stepping aside. Someone needs to have a word.

DanielGault · 28/06/2024 10:13

1dayatatime · 28/06/2024 10:11

@DanielGault

"But surely they must have been looking for a while at least? Surely"

Nope - doesn't look like they did. Bit of a monumental error that gifts the election to Trump.

So it seems. The party must be in a dreadful state.

freshbluesnow · 28/06/2024 10:12

Biden doesn't have a cold!

Looked like he has a cold, sounded like he has a cold. But you know better.

luckylavender · 28/06/2024 10:12

AgnesX · 28/06/2024 07:19

It's heartbreaking. The Republicans are likely to win as a default.

I'm so sorry for America (especially as Trump is being influenced by the obnoxious Farage and all that he stands for).

Or the other way round. Or they're both Steve Bannon's puppets.

1dayatatime · 28/06/2024 10:11

@DanielGault

"But surely they must have been looking for a while at least? Surely"

Nope - doesn't look like they did. Bit of a monumental error that gifts the election to Trump.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 28/06/2024 10:10

Tracker1234 · 28/06/2024 10:00

I think Harris doesnt do well because she isnt very good - not because she is black and I dont think we should try and explain it away like that.

Michelle Obma would be great and popular but she isnt running so that is that

I've often wondered just how much pressure's been put on Michelle to run - I imagine it's a lot - but she's refused and at least for now that appears to be that

Fortunately "they only dislike Harris because she's black" is easy to ignore, not least because it's trotted out so often and usually with little justification

BloodyHellKenAgain · 28/06/2024 10:10

freshbluesnow · 28/06/2024 09:30

Biden was dealing with a cold, as am I. I couldn't do a coherent debate in my pjyamas currently.

In his favour, is a lengthy career in politics and as a diplomat. He may not be quick on his feet or silver of tongue, but he is a decent man with serious understanding of policies.

While Trump is a convicted felon.

Being a decent man with experience and good understanding of policy will only take you so far if you look like you aren't physically or mentally up to the job.

bananaphon · 28/06/2024 10:09

Keepingongoing · 28/06/2024 10:06

Because it’s almost too late to start the process of finding a new president candidate now?

This isn't a sudden decline, there was plenty of time to find someone else before this embarrassment.

DanielGault · 28/06/2024 10:08

1dayatatime · 28/06/2024 10:07

Because at this late stage there is no one else with even the slightest chance of beating Trump.

But surely they must have been looking for a while at least? Surely?

1dayatatime · 28/06/2024 10:07

bananaphon · 28/06/2024 10:03

He looks one foot in the grave. Why are they continuing with this?

Because at this late stage there is no one else with even the slightest chance of beating Trump.

Keepingongoing · 28/06/2024 10:06

bananaphon · 28/06/2024 10:03

He looks one foot in the grave. Why are they continuing with this?

Because it’s almost too late to start the process of finding a new president candidate now?

1dayatatime · 28/06/2024 10:05

@Tracker1234

"Michelle Obma would be great and popular but she isnt running so that is that"

Michelle Obama offers the best chance of beating Trump but she still polls 3% lower than Trump. But as you say she doesn't want to run so it's irrelevant.

molotovcupcakes · 28/06/2024 10:05

freshbluesnow · 28/06/2024 09:30

Biden was dealing with a cold, as am I. I couldn't do a coherent debate in my pjyamas currently.

In his favour, is a lengthy career in politics and as a diplomat. He may not be quick on his feet or silver of tongue, but he is a decent man with serious understanding of policies.

While Trump is a convicted felon.

Biden doesn't have a cold! that's just an excuse by the party trying to spin it, he is very frail and has is failing fast, he possibly has early dementia.

His wife had to help him off the stage when everyone else had left the room practically, this was filmed on someone's phone, that wouldn't happen if he had a cold, it is impossible to ignore the facts anymore.

www.politico.com/news/2024/06/27/biden-democrats-replacement-00165672

OP posts:
bananaphon · 28/06/2024 10:03

He looks one foot in the grave. Why are they continuing with this?

Goldenbear · 28/06/2024 10:03

GiveMeSpanakopita · 28/06/2024 09:30

Oh OK. I didn't know that, thank you.

Anyway I think the causes of the decline of US and UK democracies are as follows, just my opinions:

  1. Politicians stopped being deep thinkers who had real jobs and started being careerists with little real world experience who put their careers over representing the voters
  2. Too few working class politicians especially from manufacturing, agrarian and service industries
  3. Media stopped exploring politics in meaningful ways and started focussing on soundbites and gotchas. For a shocking example watch an interview with Wilson or Thatcher and see how they are given the space and time to thoughtfully discuss policies and economics and the interviewer has the knowledge to dive in deep with them. And that was prime time TV. Now compare it with an interview with Sunak and Starmer from the present day. There has been a steep and alarming decline in intellectual 'meat'
  4. Voters are lower information due to point 3 and also to social media.
  5. Social media has caused greater political divides so that many voters no longer see themselves as being part of a country but just as part of a tribe that hates and wishes destruction on the other tribe. Which leads to...
  6. ....death threats and political assassinations (Cox, Amess) meaning that good people are getting too scared to go into politics
  7. Media emphasises superficial things like a candidates looks and mannerism rather than policies and abilities
  8. Poor education. Many people know little about the evolution of democracy and how difficult it has been to protect, and what life is like under other systems. Hence some think communism or facism sound reasonable because they haven't learned what these systems are actually like
  9. We don't pay our politicians enough and require them to work stupid hours meaning that the brightest and most conscientious in our society would rather go into law, banking, tech, start a company, anything than politics...
  10. ...so we get left with grifters and morons.

All of this is in our gift as the public to solve but I think we're too distracted and divided just now.

Yes, your list is spot on and much more comprehensive than my vague statements that were a bit tongue and cheek.

I also think that many young people only read stuff on their screens now which maybe high quality if a book or magazine but can be one person just indoctrinating them on YouTube.. This is not a sweeping generalisation about young people as I have a DS who is late teens and does read books and does get it but he is studying Politics and History so he has an advantage there. IMO some of the problem is the push to wholly study STEM subjects which means we are loosing that understanding of how a liberal democracy is established and governed, what has led to the mistakes of the past and when some billionaire declares we now have the technology to do certain things, we seem to have a dwindling number of people who ask, ‘but should we do certain things?’, this seemingly is because ethics/philosophy appear to be a subject that is no longer chosen at university. The loss of Arts/Humanities subjects at university level results in fewer graduates able to uphold the tenets of ‘liberal democracy’. I can see why it is happening as university education is so expensive now so young people naturally want to study a subject that is more transferable when it comes to work but it is actually a very worrying trend.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 28/06/2024 10:02

... there was this shocked hush in the studio even from the Democrat commentators - an almost universal horror at what had just happened

Understandable; after all what were they supposed to say?

You're right of course that it would be better for Biden's loved ones to protect him from himself, which would be the compassionate thing to do, but either they're not prepared to or he won't listen - who can say?