Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be shocked at the level of obesity of British children?

971 replies

MEM00 · 23/06/2024 12:41

Having recently come back from holiday I found myself really shocked by the size of so many other British kids at the resort we were at. It was mostly a mix of British, French and German families and I found it impossible to not notice the difference in the British kids compared to others. DD is 8 and I would say average sized, by no means skinny. She made friends with another girl the same age by the pool, and i'm not joking when i say the other girl must have been twice the size when they were next to each other.

Am i overthinking this? Because it really makes me worry for the future.

This isn't intended by be 'fat shaming' in any way btw.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
9
User14March · 23/06/2024 20:41

@BrownTroutBluesAgain boarding school food has declined in quality (a lot) & older kids send out for takeout more than parents would like. Across the 3-4 schools I know well. It’s a bone of contention.

soupfiend · 23/06/2024 20:40

LadyKenya · 23/06/2024 20:36

Some people do need their hand held though, and there are many reasons why that may be the case. People can continue to castigate overweight people, which is not having the desired results from the look of it, or seriously look, and do something tangible to help. When Jamie Oliver was doing his ministry of food, I remember watching a woman who had no idea how to cut/ dice an onion. Another woman did not seem to know how to recognize when water was boiling, and had never boiled an egg. These women were mothers, raising children, who, not surprisingly were being fed nothing but real poor quality food. The cycle is likely to continue without some form of intervention, which thankfully Jamie was willing to help with.

They are quite extreme examples. Generally speaking the majority of the population knows that an apple or some nuts is better for you overall than a marsbar

And in terms of castigating, there is an uncomfortable truth that societies where being overweight is looked at badly, have in the past had less of an obesity issue, France and Spain come to mind. We have Spanish family and health professionals dont pussy foot around like they do here about weight.

But as their own societies become more snacky and americanised, they too are tolerating higher levels of weight so the effect of judgement is wearing off.

I would say that the reason we have got bigger and bigger is through acceptance of obesity, normalising of it, normalising of the bigger portions and snack culture. Think of the difference in how smoking or not wearing a seat belt was seen. People think smoking is disgusting and smelly, thats castigation and people dont want to be seen as smokers. Its not cool anymore.

Leah5678 · 23/06/2024 20:40

Strictlymad · 23/06/2024 16:27

The ‘overweight’ child in class used to stand out, now probably half are overweight and it’s no longer shocking, looks ‘normal’ to the parents and so nothing is done. I’ve had parents say I don’t know where the weight comes from it’s just them, they barely eat, while knowing it’s a magnum for breakfast, half a pack of cookies mid morning, 2 bags of crisps after lunch, a share bag of Harribo….. I’m not making this up

Edited

Sorry but I'm calling bullshit on this. No where near half of kids are obese. There's a handful of fat kids at my kids primary school (out of 200 kids) oh and no I do not live in a rich area where everyone pays for expensive exercise clubs.

I don't dispute that there's people out there who give their kids way too much junk food and they shouldn't but the exaggeration on this thread is insane 😂
Oh haven't been to France but I've been to Germany and saw roughly the same amount of chubby German kids as I see chubby English kids in England. Typical Mumsnet thread where the rest of the continent apparently does everything better

Riversideandrelax · 23/06/2024 20:39

Differentstarts · 23/06/2024 19:43

If your going to take what I say so literally I will change it to kids don't walk anywhere much anymore

Apologies for taking it too literally! I'm autistic and don't always realise.

Riversideandrelax · 23/06/2024 20:38

crochetmonkey74 · 23/06/2024 19:44

Really gently, and with great respect, this is the exact issue. There is statistical anysis of this issue. But instead of going " right ok, they've got an obese parent and I know this statistic, so I'll work hard to counteract and I'll attempt to get him to understand this too and let's make sure Our kids escape this" your reaction is " I don't think it will be 50% for my kids " you wouldn't do this with passive smoking, or any other health risk to kids

Because my DC eat much healthier than the average DC. Hence why I'm not happy with junk for lunch at school. Their dad has put on weight due to medication - obviously it doesn't help that he eats unhealthily.

But no it is not my job to get their dad to understand about nutrition. I spent the whole time we were married doing that. It's not on me now. He has to take responsibility for himself. I mitigate the effect on my DC by him literally only having one meal with them. Even with that they eat much healthier than most of their friends.

I said why I didn't think it would be them. Because they don't live with him or eat like him except one meal a week. They eat very healthily. Which has taken huge effort from me.

I wouldn't do what with passive smoking? Or another health risk? Do my utter best to avoid it for my DC you mean? Or do you mean I'd enable an adult and parent not to have to take any responsibility for themselves or their kids?

crochetmonkey74 · 23/06/2024 20:37

Riversideandrelax · 23/06/2024 20:28

'A portion controlled dinner'?! They don't get a portion controlled dinner - they can choose to buy what they want. A waffle in the morning, a couple of doughnuts at break and a couple of cakes at lunch! That's the equivalent of your 5 jam doughnuts! And they can buy as many soft drinks as they like too. It's exactly the same!

Honestly, no wonder the parents are your problem if you think the current fare in school is ok.

Lots of parents are teachers or ex teachers too. Doesn't mean we agree with junk for lunch. We know that what the DC eat affects their learning and so are actually concerned about it!

No none of that is true for my school
Our hot offer is all boxed up in portions. If its a meal , it comes with either a fruit, a bottle of water or a homemade cake.
We don't have vending and we have no packaged snacks. It's still far from perfect, but that doesn't mean the other option of the doughnuts is any more ok.
With utmost respect, you've extrapolated loads I haven't said. Parents are not an issue because we think our food is fine. Parental interaction is a nationwide concern in teaching at the moment also I've said several times, our school food is NOT OK. It's OK ish but like all schools we could do better food wise

BrownTroutBluesAgain · 23/06/2024 20:36

User14March · 23/06/2024 20:08

@BrownTroutBluesAgain they all get takewaways! And the food generally isn’t what it was.

What ! Regularly ?!
but that’s very expensive I thought the problem was cooking from scratch was too expensive so people buy processed pre made ( I’d question if this is cheaper anyway but OK ) ……not takeaways.
So..How are takeaways cheaper than cooking yourself ?
That doesn’t make sense at all

LadyKenya · 23/06/2024 20:36

BrownTroutBluesAgain · 23/06/2024 20:23

I learnt how to cook from books from the library at University. My parents couldn’t teach me as I’d gone veggie at age 14 and they only did meat and two veg. So I taught myself.
Not everyone needs their hand held and tbh taking a little personal responsibility would be a good thing. No one to blame then.

Some people do need their hand held though, and there are many reasons why that may be the case. People can continue to castigate overweight people, which is not having the desired results from the look of it, or seriously look, and do something tangible to help. When Jamie Oliver was doing his ministry of food, I remember watching a woman who had no idea how to cut/ dice an onion. Another woman did not seem to know how to recognize when water was boiling, and had never boiled an egg. These women were mothers, raising children, who, not surprisingly were being fed nothing but real poor quality food. The cycle is likely to continue without some form of intervention, which thankfully Jamie was willing to help with.

GardenGnomeDefender · 23/06/2024 20:31

Pickled21 · 23/06/2024 19:48

I was a fat child. I lost weight in my teens and kept if off until I had kids where I have yo-yoed back and forth. When I did lose weight I began to control my own portion size, prior to that my mum always served up meals. For her if you didn't eat the portion she served she would take it to mean you didn't like it. I actively parent differently.

My dh is slim as are all of my children. I cook from scratch. My mum reckons my kids are skinny and need fattening up, I spoke to my hv and she said that people's views of what is a healthy size is more skewed now as we are used to seeing fat or overweight as becoming the norm. Both my 9 and 6 year old are 99% percentile for height and 50th for weight. So not underweight but slim yes. They are more active as kids than I ever was as a child and we walk lots, they do football, dance and swimming weekly.

Same here, top percentile for height but dead middle for weight. My DS could eat for England but he eats healthily and snacks on fruit so he's under the average for his height. He's perfectly healthy.

Riversideandrelax · 23/06/2024 20:28

crochetmonkey74 · 23/06/2024 18:53

There's a huge difference between having a portion controlled dinner at school, which btw has veg and salad with it and eating 5 jam doughnuts a day and drinking 2 litres of coke every day. As is referenced on this thread, kids are often not the issue, they want to be guided. Our problem now is with parents who are convinced they know how to run a school and spend every night on Facebook telling everyone that

'A portion controlled dinner'?! They don't get a portion controlled dinner - they can choose to buy what they want. A waffle in the morning, a couple of doughnuts at break and a couple of cakes at lunch! That's the equivalent of your 5 jam doughnuts! And they can buy as many soft drinks as they like too. It's exactly the same!

Honestly, no wonder the parents are your problem if you think the current fare in school is ok.

Lots of parents are teachers or ex teachers too. Doesn't mean we agree with junk for lunch. We know that what the DC eat affects their learning and so are actually concerned about it!

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 23/06/2024 20:26

Yes to whoever talked about pizzas in the 80’s.

We used to split a medium pizza between 4, have with a baked potato and a salad. That was fine.

Now people eat an entire massive pizza to themselves.

It was definitely the 80’s when this started! I remeber going out one night and someone wanting to go for a burger after the pub, and l was thinking ‘but I’ve had my tea……’

That was 1982

BrownTroutBluesAgain · 23/06/2024 20:23

LadyKenya · 23/06/2024 19:01

Eating habits are formed in childhood. If a child is raised on cheap, processed food, they are not going to know anything different. They will accept the food, and see nothing wrong with it, or understand that the food is low in nutrition, and even harmful to them. All these things have to be taught. How can a parent pass on, what they do not even know themselves? Too many people have not been taught even basic cooking skills. The factors involved with this obesity epidemic are legion.

I learnt how to cook from books from the library at University. My parents couldn’t teach me as I’d gone veggie at age 14 and they only did meat and two veg. So I taught myself.
Not everyone needs their hand held and tbh taking a little personal responsibility would be a good thing. No one to blame then.

NeelyOHara1 · 23/06/2024 20:22

Once you recognise that for decades we've been primed to follow the USA's lead rather than the European one it explains many decisions and results.

Riversideandrelax · 23/06/2024 20:20

Mrsredlipstick · 23/06/2024 18:44

My sister who I mentioned up thread will not compromise. She inherited packet soups, gravy and such like at her schools. It went in the bin. She declined a directive to use halal meat only and won't serve pizza unless it is in house made and on special days only. We are not the best of friends but she's principled and has a special interest in ND children and encouraging them to have variety in their diets which they often don't. My DD is SEN and at various points she has eaten badly particularly when she was being bullied at school. I have worked overseas and everyone eats together. It's useful in schools where the teachers eat with the students. My daughters food issues were picked up by a dinner lady who told me she wasn't eating. Everyone else was competively under eating (girls school).
I do think we need to demand a balanced nutritional meal is served in our schools otherwise we are not offering a quality service. Maslow said food and shelter are the foundation of life. We've been shit at delivering that for years. Poor housing and poor quality food puts our children at a disadvantage.

I agree so much.

crochetmonkey74 · 23/06/2024 20:19

Riversideandrelax · 23/06/2024 20:17

Tbh, the central dish would probably put my ASD DD off.

But that's easily overcome if you tell the host. We are talking in general averages here, at the moment , whenever there's a problem that's general, a very specific scenario is cited as a strawman reason why it can't work. We keep doing it at work...not sure where it has come from

Hedgeoffressian · 23/06/2024 20:18

Pickled21 · 23/06/2024 19:48

I was a fat child. I lost weight in my teens and kept if off until I had kids where I have yo-yoed back and forth. When I did lose weight I began to control my own portion size, prior to that my mum always served up meals. For her if you didn't eat the portion she served she would take it to mean you didn't like it. I actively parent differently.

My dh is slim as are all of my children. I cook from scratch. My mum reckons my kids are skinny and need fattening up, I spoke to my hv and she said that people's views of what is a healthy size is more skewed now as we are used to seeing fat or overweight as becoming the norm. Both my 9 and 6 year old are 99% percentile for height and 50th for weight. So not underweight but slim yes. They are more active as kids than I ever was as a child and we walk lots, they do football, dance and swimming weekly.

Statistics say that obese children normally end up being obese adults.

twistyizzy · 23/06/2024 20:17

BrownTroutBluesAgain · 23/06/2024 20:06

Most Private schools do so much more sport than state.
Not only 2 full afternoons a week ( if boarding ) but after school sports clubs as well. They are constantly on the go.
But also. Was it a boarding school you were invigilating because there meals are excellent.
If a kids boarding there’s not much in the way of crisps etc. ( except from their own tuck )

Ageee. DD does 2 x double games sessions, 2 x double PE sessions plus 1 x single activity per week. Her stamina and fitness since starting Yr 7 has increased massively, she struggled at the start but now runs 800m as a warm up before the sport they are doing in that session!
She then rides and does watersports outside of school on a weekly basis.

Riversideandrelax · 23/06/2024 20:17

LadyFeatheringt0n · 23/06/2024 19:59

Oh and the food!!

The number of children we've had for tea who eat basically no vegetables at all. I always put out a central dish with 3 or 4 choices to serve yourself from - things like carrot or swede, green beans, peas, broccoli, asparagus, kale etc. Most children barely touch it. The same at lunch - we will always have a plate with tomatoes, cucumber, peppers, carrot, celery, beetroot etc and many children take a single piece of cucumber and nothing else.

Tbh, the central dish would probably put my ASD DD off.

Hedgeoffressian · 23/06/2024 20:16

Itsprobablynotcominhome · 23/06/2024 12:45

Why do you care? Look after your own kid, stop judging everyone else's.

Yes let’s all bury our heads in the sand and pretend there isn’t a problem that needs addressing 🙄

crochetmonkey74 · 23/06/2024 20:16

I agree about parents making exercise a priority. We would walk to thr shop, walk to the park to play on the swings and run about and then walk home. Same with swimming etc

DrCoconut · 23/06/2024 20:16

Some observations about portions that occurred to me. In my student days in the mid 90s when I was out with my then boyfriend and we got takeaway post pub/club, we used to share a pizza that would probably be classed as medium now. Or our portions of chips would fit in a smallish tray. That was for a stodgy meal after a night out too. People have a pizza each plus sides or large chippy meals now. There was no competitive under eating for us and money wasn't an issue as he was working, it was just the way we had grown up. You just wouldn't have bought more than one pizza to serve two people. Going further back my grandma used to buy 1/4 lb of mince to serve two in a cottage pie or similar. Her traditional dinners were seen as pretty generous but by today's standards they were probably small. Could have been a hangover from rationing but no one ever complained of hunger at her house. People (myself included) definitely eat more.

MissyB1 · 23/06/2024 20:15

BrownTroutBluesAgain · 23/06/2024 20:06

Most Private schools do so much more sport than state.
Not only 2 full afternoons a week ( if boarding ) but after school sports clubs as well. They are constantly on the go.
But also. Was it a boarding school you were invigilating because there meals are excellent.
If a kids boarding there’s not much in the way of crisps etc. ( except from their own tuck )

Yes boarding, although lots are day pupils, but obviously everyone eats lunch there. The food is amazing!! I was eating like a queen 😂

Parker231 · 23/06/2024 20:15

twistyizzy · 23/06/2024 20:11

I agree 100% but the sad fact is that many adults do no exercise/activity and this is then passed on to their children

It was part of my childhood going for a long walk at the weekend or mum and I trying to follow exercise videos. DT’s started coming on runs with DH and I from being little and did numerous sports clubs with school.
Why don’t adults exercise - it’s free and doesn’t have to take up a huge amount of time

BrownTroutBluesAgain · 23/06/2024 20:11

Zebedee999 · 23/06/2024 20:06

Yes I totally agree. Health and nutrition should be taught to all from primary school to age 13 imo. To include cooking on a budget etc.
It's a poor show when advocating the provision of budgeting and cooking skills is politicised instead of being encouraged.

I think processed foods, pre made meals, high salt and all sugary products need to be heavily taxed to pay for the cost to the NHS and hopefully to stop people buying them.
Feels quite dictatorial though

twistyizzy · 23/06/2024 20:11

RainbowColouredRainbows · 23/06/2024 20:09

That's 100% on the parents if the kids are doing no exercise outside of school. Parents KNOW they need to be doing it, and actively choose not to prioritise it. When I grew up, yes we all played out on the street, rode our bikes, went off to the woods for a walk without a care etc etc but we also didn't have the same access to clubs that kids have nowadays. Maybe children from lower income families should get coupons to attend sporting activities of their choice. We live in a village but we still have 2 football teams covering all ages and both boys and girls teams, we have numerous types of dance and cheerleading, we have running clubs for children, the gym offers membership for children 8+. In sure the amenities are even better in cities and towns.

I agree 100% but the sad fact is that many adults do no exercise/activity and this is then passed on to their children