Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To resent that my future depends on whether a man deems me good enough

562 replies

Iwilldrawjapan · 23/06/2024 10:18

The main source of my mental health problems has been men.
I'm 33 years old and except for my very first boyfriend aged 18, who I left when I was 20, no guy has ever fallen madly in love with me.

I'm fully aware I don't need a man in my life to be happy but I'm only human and it's natural to want a connection with somebody. Not that it's attractive to admit that, mind. You're supposed to not be looking at all and absolutely love being single until someone unexpectedly falls into your lap, otherwise you're 'desperate'.

I'd be ok with it if more people chose to be single, however I hardly know anyone who's single, every bloody person I know is with someone, especially at this age, this is the worst age for me.

Men like me and find me attractive, they just don't want to date me seriously/don't want to marry me/just don't fall in love.

Everyone seems to have some guy become absolutely obsessed with them and just really want to marry them.
Guys mainly use me for an ego boost but I'm just not the one for them.

People sprout mindless fucking clichés at me all the time 'Oh it'll happen when you least expect it!' well here's the thing, I'm not 'expecting' it at all, and guess what, nobody's fallen into my lap.

'Just go online!' like it's that easy, it really isn't.
I'm attractive physically, I have stuff going for me, I travel, I am financially independent, I own property, I have hobbies, good family relationship, I have friends. In other areas of my life all is great.

I'm really not desperate, I'm sure someone will be along to tell me I'm coming across as desperate but I have turned down men too, I would not date just anyone.
My standards are not too high, either. If anything I'm very likely considered out of these men's leagues. They're just very ordinary, average men, but I liked them.

People I've dated have either not wanted a relationship after 2 months, or not wanted a bigger commitment after a few years.

Life isn't fair I guess, people will tell me to 'love myself first ' and all the usual crap. Having 10,000 hobbies is no replacement for a happy relationship. I'm sick of seeing the happy couple photos on Facebook, posing with their husband and holding the baby.

Maybe I will meet someone, but for 13 years I've had bad luck. I've never been anyone's 'one'.

I can't have a child alone, I don't have local family, I can't afford to be a single parent financially or otherwise, period.

Honestly, my mental health has been shot to pieces. Life still has meaning, but it's unfair that I'm deprived of what seems to come so easily to other people.

OP posts:
Iwilldrawjapan · 23/06/2024 11:46

Majority of men in their 30s already seem to be married/in a LTR.

Haven't heard of tall poppy syndrome but will look it up now.

OP posts:
Startingagainandagain · 23/06/2024 11:46

Some really unpleasant responses on this thread...

I think many women your age are in the same situation: attractive, financially independent with a full life with hobbies and friends, yet can't find a decent partner who can commit.

I think this has a lot to do with:

-online dating: it seems to have made men less willing to commit and obsessed about always looking for someone else
-the fact that many men are still not able to handle successful women.

OP, I think the advice if you are online dating is to not waste too much time on men who are just playing the game and have not intention to commit.

Get rid if there is no progress after a few dates and avoid having sex with them too early. Make your expectations clear from the start: you are looking for someone who can commit and have a family with. Don't settle for the 'let's see where it gets us' or 'let's take things slowly' brigade. Helps filter out the time wasters.

Personally I completely gave up on online dating and I think dating apps/websites do affect people's self-esteem and mental well-being.

It is always better to try to meet people in real life through shared interests/hobby/work/friends.

Sillystrumpet · 23/06/2024 11:45

MsLuxLisbon · 23/06/2024 11:44

I understand what OP means, though. Women are told from a young age that our beauty is the most valuable thing about us, and that is also definitely reflected in dating patterns and choice of partner. I think where OP is going wrong is actually in dating men who are less attractive and successful than she is. Those men probably have tall poppy syndrome and as OP says, use her for an ego boost before going on to someone whom they feel they can be mediocre around.

The op isn’t targeting only these men, she’s dating anyone basically with minor amount of rejections

weirdinstagram · 23/06/2024 11:45

Why are you only going for men in their 20s? that age are very unlikely to want to commit so early - its a time for testing the waters and dating lots of people to figure out which kind of partner is best for you.

Men in their 20s dont want to think about settling down and kids- thats something most people do when they get to 30 and above. Obviously not all, but generally speaking, most of my male friends didnt settle down long term until into their 30s and were quite immature in their 20s.

You say you cant meet anyone who wants a commitment but that could easily be why- why not broaden your age range (I am NOT saying much older men btw, just someone in their 30s). You also say it wont be different but you dont know that if you haven't tried it.

Tattletwat · 23/06/2024 11:45

You seem to be blaming everyone else for your problems, is it really men who have shattered your mental health or is it your choices and seeming desperation that are ruining your mental health.

Everything seems others fault take control and responsibility for your life and stop hanging it on getting a man.

keeptryinggirl · 23/06/2024 11:44

if you hadn’t clarified that you’re a woman

i’d honestly think that this was a scary man angry that no woman wants to be with him

MsLuxLisbon · 23/06/2024 11:44

Demonhunter · 23/06/2024 11:39

You appear very focused on the fact you're attractive and have material goods and "out of the mens league" but all of that only goes so far. Being physically attracted to someone is what will initially be the attraction, but there needs to be more to build that attraction into genuine feelings and love. Maybe your anger and bitterness and want of obessive love is coming across in ways you don't realise?

I understand what OP means, though. Women are told from a young age that our beauty is the most valuable thing about us, and that is also definitely reflected in dating patterns and choice of partner. I think where OP is going wrong is actually in dating men who are less attractive and successful than she is. Those men probably have tall poppy syndrome and as OP says, use her for an ego boost before going on to someone whom they feel they can be mediocre around.

JLou08 · 23/06/2024 11:44

Cotonsugar · 23/06/2024 10:58

I’m older so don’t understand the going official bit. If you continued the relationship without talking about that then maybe it would continue. I don’t think a lot of men (and women) like to be pushed into or made to feel that they are in something official until they’re ready. Maybe labelling it is the problem?

Could be something in this, I'm not much older that OP, I'm married and had 2 other serious relationships. I don't recall any conversations about being official, it just naturally progressed and there was an unspoken understanding that we don't see other people.

Leah5678 · 23/06/2024 11:43

Some harsh replies on here considering op is hurting and some of y'all decide to overanalyze her mentioning married men to imply she sleeps with them?
Op I was in your situation for years but eventually found someone it can happen unexpectedly but I completely get it feels like shit before you meet them and you think you'll be alone forever. Just keep going you will get there eventually

Iwilldrawjapan · 23/06/2024 11:43

To the posters who asked, I think I'm good to spend time with too. I get told I'm really nice, fun, interesting, intelligent and that they really liked talking to me.

Also, I think I have stuff to offer but nobody has everything, and they cannot expect me to tick every single box when they aren't bringing the same thing themselves.

OP posts:
Iwilldrawjapan · 23/06/2024 11:42

I just feel like I'm not cut out for dating.
I don't feel that I have it in me to be ruthless, to do the whole 'why men love bitches' thing, to make them chase, and so on. I don't have it in me. Some of them have ridiculously high standards.

OP posts:
MsLavender · 23/06/2024 11:42

I'm attractive physically, I have stuff going for me, I travel, I am financially independent, I own property, I have hobbies, good family relationship, I have friends. In other areas of my life all is great.

All of this is great but what are you like as a person? What are you like to spend time with? Are you outgoing, upbeat, fun, spontaneous? Dramatic, depressive, emotionally unavailable, stand offish?

BettyBardMacDonald · 23/06/2024 11:40

That should have said "why NOT date men 35-45?"

BettyBardMacDonald · 23/06/2024 11:40

Looking for long term commitment from younger guys in their 20s seems sort of self-defeating. Why bother date men 35-45?

maybe1 · 23/06/2024 11:40

OP
You are getting some good advice here.

I NC for this and honestly, I didn't feel like posting, but then I was known as a dating Guru/ wise counsel by/to friends a result of a combination of being younger and watching and learning from my married friends who were incredibly open about their marriages; career focussed so had to learn Dating101 in my 30s after moving countries and luck of connecting with all sorts so got a quick dating2.0 from friends who had spent more years dating than me. Seeking advice (as you are doing) and listening to ALL feedback although I chose what to follow and when.

Pointers-

1.Look at your title. Reframe your mindset and attitude and stop the 'resentment'
2.Also stop 'believing' men hold key to your destiny. Even your DH will never. You are the master of your own destiny.
3.Good you are waiting on therapy. Please engage with this or go private if you can afford.
4.Nothing wrong with being direct- I too am direct. However, you need to work on being feminine. If a man wanted to be with another man, they would. There are certain things men like about women they marry, and being feminine is one of them. Look, I do all sports and can beat some men at some sports. Was brought up between city and farm- so I am not talking about being girly. As you can see, I can kick ass and be feminine at teh same time. My Dh loves that.
Yes, a divorced DR with 2 PHDs asked me how she can be more feminine as she too was struggling in that department. She said she was thinking of wearing more long skirts- she loved trousers. I said she also needed to be more flirty and not always serious. I can flirt like my life depended on it- if teh situation allows ( I have a job that requires seriousness at all times so hard to meet partner). Even when I know nothing can come out of it. People (men and women) like to be made to feel desirable and wanted. So be kind and generous in your words with all you meet. Don't be husband shopping. Make friends, and who knows.
5.I sense you are very laid back (I have no idea if you become desperate at 2 months mark). But when meeting these men, strike a balance between showing an interest and not being desperate. I can be as cool as a cucumber; so I had to try to meet them half way, so they don't misinterpret my relaxed attitude as being uninterested.
6.I would hold off being intimate soon.
7.I would mix up strategies and feedback and see what happens.
8.One thing you need to be grateful for is that you meet men and even start dating them. At my peak, I wasn't even meeting men (working long hours); and the ones I met, I wouldn't even agree to have coffee with let alone a 2 month relationship with.
9.However, I was the one deciding at 2 or 3 months that it was not for me. Yes, dating is ruthless.
10.You sound like you have options as you have financial independence and hobbies, so why don't you choose men who are likely to want to date you? Not you be unkind, maybe you are the one fishing in wrong pool- this takes a few years until you realise you need to meet men half way. Choose the most important things you want from a man: family, ambition- then focus. If it is someone outgoing, focus on that. I was very clear about what I wanted and what I didn't want. Other things were always negotiable.
A. Are you in London? London dating can be ruthless and can be a draw of luck.
B.I now live between London and the countryside, now I am married, otherwise I would offer to meet for a coffee or two, after you have had meaningful therapy.
good luck. Yes, dating or looking to date is very lonely so you need to not let it take over your life. Have fun with things you enjoy, a long teh way. I travelled; sailed; shopped all designer gears I wanted, bought several properties; climbed mountains and went on safaris; volunteered at a charity, visited family abroad for months (I was self-employed) etc etc. I even got a 2nd masters degree and my career progressed at fastest space imaginable. It is not all bad.

GingerPirate · 23/06/2024 11:40

Sorry you feel this way, OP.
Not to speak for you, obviously, but this stuff
IS hugely overrated.

GRex · 23/06/2024 11:39

It's a very tricky age to be single, and no platitudes will help. I well remember the feeling of wondering just how it was that nobody worked out for a plethora of spurious reasons. I can't really tell you why I had a decade of crappy relationships (though work travel didn't help) and then one worked out, it really is just luck when you find someone who is not perfect in ways that fit your not being perfect either. Keep on looking, you are still young and have plenty of time.

MsLuxLisbon · 23/06/2024 11:39

Findwen · 23/06/2024 10:59

Before you ask for exclusivity, have you made them feel special ? That is - do you tend to be passive in the relationship and let them do all the chasing, organising and paying for everything ?

Am not advocating any kind of grandiose, expensive gestures - just trying to uncover perhaps a root cause that is not just bad luck !

If a man doesn't do the pursuing, he isn't worth having. I'm like the OP in my expectations: I am a prize to be treasured, beautiful, intelligent, successful. There would be no room in my life for some 5/10 man who thought he was doing me a favour by just being around. I have been married for a long time.

OP, I truly feel for you. I hate to sound complacent, but I got truly lucky and met my person when I was 23. If I hadn't, though, I could have written your post because I felt the way you did from the ages of 19 to 23. I also wasn't going to entertain married or partnered men, nor was I willing to put up with bullshit from time wasters. I think that maybe where you are going wrong is actually setting your expectations too low. I find that average, mediocre men often have tall poppy syndrome and prefer to date women whom they perceive to be 'in their league'. They will mess around with the high achieving beauties, but they will then go back to their safe zone. You deserve someone so much better than that.

Sillystrumpet · 23/06/2024 11:39

Iwilldrawjapan · 23/06/2024 11:35

Can I ask why I 'sound like hard work?
They were happy to sleep with me so did fancy me, just didn't get deeper feelings

Someone happy to have sex op is irrelevant. Some men will have sex whenever it is offered. Any chance they can. Relationships are about much more.

Demonhunter · 23/06/2024 11:39

You appear very focused on the fact you're attractive and have material goods and "out of the mens league" but all of that only goes so far. Being physically attracted to someone is what will initially be the attraction, but there needs to be more to build that attraction into genuine feelings and love. Maybe your anger and bitterness and want of obessive love is coming across in ways you don't realise?

Iwilldrawjapan · 23/06/2024 11:38

kitteninabasket · 23/06/2024 11:37

I'm also mid 30s. I've been single for several years by choice because I realised men have caused me nothing but pain. I don't have any family so am literally nobody's priority, which can feel difficult at times. I solved the coming home to an empty flat issue by getting a cat. Best thing I ever did. I no longer have the energy for men's bullshit.

I'm sorry to hear that, men have caused me nothing but pain either.
I am definitely going to look at getting a cat as I loved them, I'm glad it made you feel happier.

OP posts:
Tagyoureit · 23/06/2024 11:38

Fostering? You say you have mental health problems, scrambling around for a relationship but you want to foster a child!!

I'm seriously calling absolute bullshit on this thread!!

Iwilldrawjapan · 23/06/2024 11:37

Tagyoureit · 23/06/2024 11:36

Then calm down with the dating. There is nothing wrong with being single. Jesus, have a read of some of the other threads where partners and husbands are being massive dicks and you'll soon realise that you probably aren't missing out.

You don't want the clichés but they are said for a reason because they're true. I gave up on dating and was a single mother for years then the right guy came along.

No, there isn't anything wrong with being single.
So why is it that 99% of people aren't?
Im tired of constant rejection, there's nothing wrong with not wanting to be single for years though.

OP posts:
kitteninabasket · 23/06/2024 11:37

I'm also mid 30s. I've been single for several years by choice because I realised men have caused me nothing but pain. I don't have any family so am literally nobody's priority, which can feel difficult at times. I solved the coming home to an empty flat issue by getting a cat. Best thing I ever did. I no longer have the energy for men's bullshit.

Sillystrumpet · 23/06/2024 11:37

Op. The only thing I can see is you want to go to official with men who are slow fading.

this tells me you cannot read a relationship , at no stage should you be wishing to go official with someone who isn’t interested. You have to question them as you don’t know. This is a huge red flag.

this could indicate you’re more focused on getting a relationship than being remotely interested in them as a person. Going through the motions to get to the status you wish.

thats a huge red flag. Even on here you clearly still can’t see why they didn’t wish to. Figuring if it had been a couple of months then they should wish to call you their girlfriend.

so something is very wrong there. Does that make sense. A relationship develops. Two people talking, sharing their feelings to one another. So there is no confusion. No unknowns.

The list of reasons they are giving you are not honest, it’s just bullshit to save your feelings.

Swipe left for the next trending thread