Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Guy revealed this on phone.

170 replies

newdater32 · 22/06/2024 00:45

So I've been talking to a guy I met through an online dating app. We've been on one date and due to meet again next weekend. We've been talking everyday and have had a 2 hour phone conversation tonight. He's ticked all my boxes and seems great.

Tonight he's revealed that he has had a one on one with a guy to experiment to see if he liked it. He said he wasn't satisfied and that he's not gay, but wouldn't be against it if he was in a group situation and the other guy was bi.

This has completely turned me off him. It was like a switch turned off completely in me. I'm not homophobic, but just was not expecting this.

Am I being unreasonable here? Is there something wrong with me? Am I wrong?

OP posts:
MateyMusings · 22/06/2024 17:54

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Didimum · 22/06/2024 17:54

Moneysitu · 22/06/2024 17:26

Didimum

Imagine finding out a sole piece of information, like your DH had used prostitutes in the past. You might leave him for that sole piece of information, if men buying women's bodies didn't align with your moral compass.

But I would say, that it's a behaviour rooted in Punterphobia, if that sole piece of information has reversed your feelings. No one likes to be told they are Punterphobic, or thinks of themselves as such, but sometimes we just have to accept our prejudices and move on.

EYE ROLL.

Newsflash - a woman is allowed to reject a man FOR. ANY. REASON. SHE. LIKES. And him sticking his cock into other men, might be one of them.

So you’re equating men being attracted to men or men sleeping with men to men paying vulnerable trafficked women to have sex with them and also with it being on the wrong side of a moral compass. Right, got it.

Couldn’t have conjured up a better homophobic answer if I’d tried – so that’s very enlightening.

I didn’t say she couldn’t do what she wanted. It doesn’t mean it’s not rooted in homophobia.

oakleaffy · 22/06/2024 17:51

twentysevendresses · 22/06/2024 14:43

Many years ago I was dating a guy who disclosed this to me MID sex! He said he'd experimented in the past and although didn't think he was bi/gay was still open to experimenting, and when having sex with a woman, often fantasised that there was also another man in bed - pleasuring HIM not me, just for clarity. He went on to tell me that he'd like to be giving a man a blow job whilst I was giving him one...and actually mimed that as he told me, mimed him giving a man a blow job!

He was very definitely sussing me out for 'future endeavours' but I was instantly turned off. Nowhere and at no time had I given him any indication that group sex/threesomes was my jam!

Also...despite him protesting, he was clearly bi 🤦‍♀️ Instant ick for me I'm afraid...actually made me feel quite uncomfortable if I'm honest, especially his miming!!

How does one mime a BJ?

Like a game of Charades.

Urgh..I googled! Now I see..{I won't put up a screenshot} 🤔

oakleaffy · 22/06/2024 17:41

@newdater32 No, you are not wrong to be put off.

My guess is that he told you this to see if you would be 'open' to it.[?]

You are not.

It's not homophobia not to want to date a Bi man or woman if you are straight.. There are probably Gay men and women who wouldn't want to date a Bi woman/man either.

Moneysitu · 22/06/2024 17:38

And we seem to be seeing this more and more - people being that told they are phobic or a bigot, if they don't want to date certain people. Why? It just screams, ME ME ME.

I'm 54 and a little over weight. If I was rejected on a dating site for either of those things, I would say Fair Enough. I certainly wouldn't demand that someone dated me, and then scream "Ageist" or "Fatphobe" and start throwing around insults like judgemental, prejudice etc. Not everyone is going to be in everyone's dating pool. And that's fine.

Moneysitu · 22/06/2024 17:26

Didimum · 22/06/2024 17:03

I agree with @OhNoNotAnotherNameChange

You are completely free to do what you want to regarding your dating life and relationships, OP – move on if you wish. But I do believe it’s a behaviour/feeling rooted in homophobia if this sole piece of information has reversed your feelings.

No one like to be told they are homophobic or think of themselves as such – I get it. But sometimes we just have to accept our prejudices and move on.

Didimum

Imagine finding out a sole piece of information, like your DH had used prostitutes in the past. You might leave him for that sole piece of information, if men buying women's bodies didn't align with your moral compass.

But I would say, that it's a behaviour rooted in Punterphobia, if that sole piece of information has reversed your feelings. No one likes to be told they are Punterphobic, or thinks of themselves as such, but sometimes we just have to accept our prejudices and move on.

EYE ROLL.

Newsflash - a woman is allowed to reject a man FOR. ANY. REASON. SHE. LIKES. And him sticking his cock into other men, might be one of them.

DoreenonTill8 · 22/06/2024 17:19

Didimum · 22/06/2024 17:03

I agree with @OhNoNotAnotherNameChange

You are completely free to do what you want to regarding your dating life and relationships, OP – move on if you wish. But I do believe it’s a behaviour/feeling rooted in homophobia if this sole piece of information has reversed your feelings.

No one like to be told they are homophobic or think of themselves as such – I get it. But sometimes we just have to accept our prejudices and move on.

@Didimum is that meant to be as condescendingly, judgemental and admonishing as it comes across?

"You'd be a MUCH better person and less 'prejudiced if you ignored your own boundaries and wants".

Moneysitu · 22/06/2024 17:18

OhNoNotAnotherNameChange · 22/06/2024 16:48

Hi Op

"This has completely turned me off him. It was like a switch turned off completely in me. I'm not homophobic, but just was not expecting this."

Isn't this pretty much text book homophobia? You were attracted to him but as soon as you found out he may be/is bisexual/bi curious, you're no longer interested.

I don't think you are being unreasonable as you can't help the way you feel. But at least have the guts to own your prejudice.

I would do him a favour and ditch him, there will be other people out there for him who won't be so judgemental and appreciate his honesty. Speaking as someone who considers themselves bisexual, we really don't need people like you in our life.

It is NOT homophobic for a straight woman, not to want to be with a Bi sexual man.

Look at it this way - you are bi sexual. You don't say whether your prefer men or women, but let's say you were dating a nice guy, but over the years he put on 400lb and became morbidly obese, with a huge beer belly. If that put you off him sexually, would that make you a Fatphobe? Would that make you judgmental? Would it be fair if someone said to you "that you don't deserve to be in his life, because he really doesn't need judgmental people like you, you Fatphobe!" Would you own your own prejudice then, and walk away with your tail between your legs?

Thought not.

LightSpeeds · 22/06/2024 17:16

"... but wouldn't be against it if he was in a group situation and the other guy was bi."

What did he mean by a 'group situation'?? This alone would have me running for the hills 😬

Vroomfondleswaistcoat · 22/06/2024 17:06

I'm not in the least homophobic (one gay child and was married to a bisexual man) but the casual dropping in of not being averse to trying again in a group situation would put me RIGHT off. I'd constantly be wondering when he would raise the 'oh, I've got this friend...' once he felt comfortable in the relationship.

Not wanting to date a bisexual man and not wanting to date a man who indicates he would be up for group sex are two very different things in my opinion.

Blondiney · 22/06/2024 17:06

I’ve got the ick by proxy.

YANBU.

Didimum · 22/06/2024 17:05

Bumblebeeinatree · 22/06/2024 16:55

But he would like group sex with men and women, which is a turn off in it's own right if you like a monogamous relationship of whatever flavour.

He didn’t say that. He said the only reason he would consider it again would be in a group scenario, not that he wanted one.

Sexually adventurous people are capable of loyalty and monogamy.

TheBottomsOfMyTrousersAreRolled · 22/06/2024 17:05

nameohnameohname · 22/06/2024 09:08

It wouldn’t be the one-time experimentation that put me off, but the fact he’d be ‘open to it in a group session with a bi-man’.
WTF. Very specific.

This. This tells you a lot about his turn ons. He isnt going to be satisfied with a monogamous committed relationship. He enjoys group sex with men and women. He has told you early so you knew what you were getting into. And all this is fine if you want the same.

I don't know whether it was full sex or just playing. Why does this matter to you?

Didimum · 22/06/2024 17:03

I agree with @OhNoNotAnotherNameChange

You are completely free to do what you want to regarding your dating life and relationships, OP – move on if you wish. But I do believe it’s a behaviour/feeling rooted in homophobia if this sole piece of information has reversed your feelings.

No one like to be told they are homophobic or think of themselves as such – I get it. But sometimes we just have to accept our prejudices and move on.

loropianalover · 22/06/2024 17:01

YouWearItWell · 22/06/2024 16:55

But surely it's better he's told her now than further down the line when they could be more committed to each other?

Well yeah obviously? It’s still a turn off.

YouWearItWell · 22/06/2024 16:55

loropianalover · 22/06/2024 01:05

The fact that he’s done it wouldn’t bother me, but the way he’s spilling this after only meeting once is the major ick for me… to me it just screams that he wants to set up group sex further down the line. That’s the turn off for me, not that he’s slept with a guy.

But surely it's better he's told her now than further down the line when they could be more committed to each other?

Bumblebeeinatree · 22/06/2024 16:55

Barleysugar86 · 22/06/2024 02:24

Nah. I experimented one night with a woman in my younger years and didn't like it and this confirmed very definitely in my mind that although I can find women mesmerising, and indeed sexy, I don't actually want to be sexually involved with them at all. It very definitely confirmed my hetrosexuality to me and that's fine. I certainly don't identify as bisexual and I'm sure this man doesn't - he didn't like it.
I have several gay friends who tried dating the 'expected' sex in our youth before coming out and they aren't bi and would be quite offended if you tried to label them as such now- besides you don't get to choose others sexuality label for them anyway.
You are however allowed to get the ick for whatever reason you get it, reasonable or not. If this is that for you then that's ok.

But he would like group sex with men and women, which is a turn off in it's own right if you like a monogamous relationship of whatever flavour.

ReversedFerret · 22/06/2024 16:54

I don't think "reasonableness" applies here. There's no objective standard or expectation of equal treatment or impartiality that applies to personal relationships, the way there would be for, say, a business transaction or provision of public services; if the situation between the two of you is not right for you (or for him), it's not right. The only question to ask yourself, I think, is are you ending something otherwise good for a reason that may seem trivial to you later on, that perhaps now seems like more than it is because of the newness and the surprise/shock around it and will you likely regret ending it later? Only you can know that.

He said he wasn't satisfied and that he's not gay, but wouldn't be against it if he was in a group situation and the other guy was bi stuck out to me in your post. Irrelevant if the two of you were discussing having a threesome and that's a topic you're genuinely interested in and open to, but if he said this out of the blue it would be a red flag for me. Is he discussing introducing another person into your sexual interactions when you aren't even sexually involved yet? Are you comfortable with group situations as a typical part of your sex life (not shaming if you are, but many people are not and if he's going to pressure you about that, it can get pretty tedious).

Also, unless there's explanatory context I'd worry a little that his remarks around this might indicate he's self-centered. If he "experimented" with another guy who knew his feelings and also wanted to experiment then fine, but if he "experimented" with someone who thought he was bi or gay, that's pretty ick. And why would this hypothetical bi male partner he's envisioning in a "group situation" want to have a threesome with a woman and a straight man?

MsLuxLisbon · 22/06/2024 16:49

YANBU. That would not be for me, either.

OhNoNotAnotherNameChange · 22/06/2024 16:48

Hi Op

"This has completely turned me off him. It was like a switch turned off completely in me. I'm not homophobic, but just was not expecting this."

Isn't this pretty much text book homophobia? You were attracted to him but as soon as you found out he may be/is bisexual/bi curious, you're no longer interested.

I don't think you are being unreasonable as you can't help the way you feel. But at least have the guts to own your prejudice.

I would do him a favour and ditch him, there will be other people out there for him who won't be so judgemental and appreciate his honesty. Speaking as someone who considers themselves bisexual, we really don't need people like you in our life.

PetulantPenguin · 22/06/2024 16:37

DH had experimented with a man and told me when we got together. It didnt bother me at all, but I have also had a same sex relationship so that may hr why. I genuinely don't see why that would put anyone off but the rest of wuat he said would have put me off as it sounds like future plans.

twentysevendresses · 22/06/2024 16:30

@Skyrainlight it was pretty grim to be fair! Instant turn off...just thinking about the expression on his face whilst he was miming the blow job makes me clamp up 😬

Fair enough if this is your 'thing' and it's been discussed properly, but to introduce the concept whilst we were were being intimate was really off-putting 😯

Skyrainlight · 22/06/2024 16:02

twentysevendresses · 22/06/2024 14:43

Many years ago I was dating a guy who disclosed this to me MID sex! He said he'd experimented in the past and although didn't think he was bi/gay was still open to experimenting, and when having sex with a woman, often fantasised that there was also another man in bed - pleasuring HIM not me, just for clarity. He went on to tell me that he'd like to be giving a man a blow job whilst I was giving him one...and actually mimed that as he told me, mimed him giving a man a blow job!

He was very definitely sussing me out for 'future endeavours' but I was instantly turned off. Nowhere and at no time had I given him any indication that group sex/threesomes was my jam!

Also...despite him protesting, he was clearly bi 🤦‍♀️ Instant ick for me I'm afraid...actually made me feel quite uncomfortable if I'm honest, especially his miming!!

Mid sex, that is insane! There was literally no escape.

EvangelicalAboutButteredToast · 22/06/2024 15:57

I’d feel the same. The reason would be because it opens up the potential of cheating to the whole population instead of half of it. Men are also far less discerning if they want sex. Two minutes on Grindr would find you a sex partner. I just couldn’t be bothered with the concern over it. Would cause me stress.

AliceCallous · 22/06/2024 15:55

Moneysitu · 22/06/2024 14:42

A lot of women wouldn't object to a MFF threesome

Most women would object to a threesome. MFF is just yuck. In no way would I want to compete with the other female, but also, seeing tits and vagina would be an instant ick for me. MMF doesn't feel very safe, tbh.

You'd be surprised. Your disgust for the female body isn't a universal thing.

Swipe left for the next trending thread