Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be annoyed at SIL-to-be?

193 replies

CableCar · 21/06/2024 14:55

My brother and I are your average siblings. We get along, see each other a couple of times a year, chat about the important things, always celebrate birthdays with gifts to one another etc.

My brother is getting married and my SIL-to-be has no interest in involving my family in the wedding. Neither me nor my DC (primary aged children) have been asked to be part of the bridal party, which is a bit of a shame for my DC as they're little and would make cute flower girls / page boy etc, but it's not my wedding, so that's fair enough.

However I just found out that I haven't been invited to her hen party, which is at a spa. Now I personally think that as sister of the groom it is etiquette to invite me... I am a bit offended as I'd have hoped to have come along to her hen party to celebrate - she will be my SIL after all! If this is how their wedding is going I am starting to feel like she doesn't value me, nor care for my brother's family. My mum hasn't been invited either. AIBU? All the hen weekends I have EVER been on have always included the close family on both sides of the wedding party, not just the bride.

It bothers me as it makes me think she doesn't particularly care for me!

YANBU - it's a bit rude to not invite you

YABU - it's her hen do, let her do as she pleases

OP posts:
evencloser · 21/06/2024 17:03

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

theowlwhisperer · 21/06/2024 17:02

who said there was anything WRONG with inviting in-laws?

The point is that the bride-to-be can invite whoever she wants, and can have the kind of hen do she wants. She can include the grand-mothers to a spa day, or she can have a fun week in Ibiza, who cares.

What is WRONG is having expectations and calling her rude for doing her own thing and organising a different kind of party than the one you had.

BeaRF75 · 21/06/2024 17:02

People really care about this trivia? I find it hard to understand. The bro & sister-in-law are not close (which is fine, of course). Just rock up to the wedding, be polite and otherwise concentrate on the important things in life.

BrownTroutBluesAgain · 21/06/2024 17:01

We had a joint hen and stag do and just invited friends. Each to their own
We had requests from parents re ‘ can their dds be flower girls they’d love to dress up’, no I’m afraid not. I just had one witness, dh had his best man, we had a friend play an ice trumpet for my ‘entry’ 😆 and some friends in a band play other music. Dh asked a few friends on the day to tell people where to sit.
Kept it casual, very little fuss. That’s our choice. Just as your SIL and your brother have theirs.

Everyone does things differently.
Try not to take it personally or dwell on it. These things can fester and ruin your opinion of someone who could become a great new addition to the family.

Ozanj · 21/06/2024 17:01

Some people are just inconsiderate. My sil is like yours - any plans I make I need to make them, as she will never prioritise either me or my family if left to her devices. It’s especially worse because DNs love me but are autistic and she lies to them that I don’t want to see them — I often get awful phonecalls from them begging to see me or DS or DSD.

x88mph · 21/06/2024 17:01

I'd be disappointed too OP, especially about your DC not being included in the wedding. Maybe they're not having any bridesmaids/ flowers girls? But if it is one of those big traditional type of weddings, I'd be really disappointed with my DB for not wanting to include his nieces on his big day.

DodoTired · 21/06/2024 17:00

First time I hear it is etiquette to invite your SIL on to the hen do automatically…

mummyuptheriver · 21/06/2024 16:59

YANBU and it’s happened to me, very similar circumstances but I decided that my brother is way too important to me to do anything other than feel a bit quietly sad and get over it. I don’t mean that nastily! It’s okay to feel a bit sad not to be included in any way. But also, try to remember that your sibling and their happiness is the priority.

AthenaBasil · 21/06/2024 16:58

It’s pretty common to invite mum and mil and sils to hen dos where I am. Haven’t been to one without that. Didn’t realise that made us mad and badshit crazy etc. If you’ve just experienced that I can see why you’d think you’d been snubbed but as you can see from others here it’s not common around the country.

IpsyUpsyDaisyDoos · 21/06/2024 16:57

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Leave it alone.

If I or my parents didn't arrange things with my sister, we'd never see her. It's not malicious, she just exists in her own bubble and doesn't think to ask other people to do stuff.

She loves getting together. Just doesn't occur to her to organise.

Maybe OP still wants a relationship with her own brother despite your best efforts to persuade her not to have one.

You made a point. Now leave her be.

ScentOfSawdust · 21/06/2024 16:56

I see a hen party as a farewell from friends, marking the end of single life. My hen was me and my two best friends. It didn’t occur to me to invite my mum and sisters, let alone my MIL and SIL. Equally, I wasn’t invited to the hen parties of my brother’s wife, or my husband’s sister. I’m very close to both of them, but we don’t have the same kind of relationship as we do with our mates.

Hb7x3 · 21/06/2024 16:55

I see hen do's as a day/night out with your closet friends and family. Having people there that you don't really know or like creates a weird vibe.

ihatecoffee · 21/06/2024 16:54

Just wow! Everyone is ploughing into the OP in a really horrible fashion.
I've been married 30+ years and I invited my SIL and my MIL to my hen do.
I'll admit mine was a sedate do with just a meal and drinks and none of the raucous behaviour of brides nowadays.
I also had all my friends and my mum there too
What's wrong with inviting family to be?
My SIL was also one of my bridesmaids!

I only see her once or twice a year but we are pretty close and message a lot!

I'm on your side OP!

evencloser · 21/06/2024 16:50

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Mummy2024 · 21/06/2024 16:49

CableCar · 21/06/2024 14:55

My brother and I are your average siblings. We get along, see each other a couple of times a year, chat about the important things, always celebrate birthdays with gifts to one another etc.

My brother is getting married and my SIL-to-be has no interest in involving my family in the wedding. Neither me nor my DC (primary aged children) have been asked to be part of the bridal party, which is a bit of a shame for my DC as they're little and would make cute flower girls / page boy etc, but it's not my wedding, so that's fair enough.

However I just found out that I haven't been invited to her hen party, which is at a spa. Now I personally think that as sister of the groom it is etiquette to invite me... I am a bit offended as I'd have hoped to have come along to her hen party to celebrate - she will be my SIL after all! If this is how their wedding is going I am starting to feel like she doesn't value me, nor care for my brother's family. My mum hasn't been invited either. AIBU? All the hen weekends I have EVER been on have always included the close family on both sides of the wedding party, not just the bride.

It bothers me as it makes me think she doesn't particularly care for me!

YANBU - it's a bit rude to not invite you

YABU - it's her hen do, let her do as she pleases

It's rude yes... I see trouble ahead OP. so sorry you've been treated like this.

Boomer55 · 21/06/2024 16:49

Her wedding, her choice.

Ayyaa · 21/06/2024 16:48

As you say their wedding is not about you.

I forgive you for initially being offended as weddings and hen dos these days typically have a lot of people being involved in the hen / bridal party and SIL would automatically assume to be involved - so I get why it would seem odd.

I think before the wedding industry took over weddings, hen dos and bridesmaids were those very close to the bride?

So if you’re not super close possibly she’s keeping the wedding quite traditional / basic?

beAsensible1 · 21/06/2024 16:47

Having read your updates, maybe they’re taking a more hands off approach to IL relationships than you.

or might not be that bothered in maintaining the relationship outside of surface level comms on bday and Christmas

i do get your feeling in the hen do, most people I know might not necessarily invite but would ask their brother to check in SIL wanted to be invited or not.

i wouldn’t get bogged down in the politics of it right now as weddings can be very fraught with family emotions.

countcalculia · 21/06/2024 16:46

I won't stop arranging to meet up with my brother and his future-wife

Why go to the expense of travel costs and hotel costs to see people who make zero effort with you?

You'd be better off spending that money on your own family.

Gerwurtztraminer · 21/06/2024 16:46

Your SiL to be will be taking her lead in terms of contact with you from your brother. You said you didn't see him much before they got together so why would you expect it to change? It's not the woman's job to initiate or facilitate his visits with his family. So it's him not extending you the invitation to come and see them, nothing to do with her. If you want a closer relationship with her you need to work on the one with your brother too. Though sounds as if he's happy enough as it is.

I didn't have a hen party (they weren't very common in my social circle) but if I had it wouldn't have occurred to me to invite MiL or the 2 new SiL's. I don't think I've ever been to a full on hen party that worked like that. In fact my mother & siblings only met all my new in-laws the day of the wedding as my family lived 7-9+ hours drive away and there was never any reason they might have met before.

twilightcafe · 21/06/2024 16:44

Wouldn't have invited MIL or SIL to my hen if you paid me.

HiddenBooks · 21/06/2024 16:43

In all honesty it doesn't sound like you have a huge amount to do with your future SIL if you only see each other a couple of times a year.

Yes, it may be customary to invite the groom's family to the hen do (heck, my now SIL actually organised mine!), but if they don't know you particularly well, then I can understand why they wouldn't invite you.

Better to not be invited, than go and either you feel awkward because you don't know anyone, or her to feel awkward because she feels like she has to spend time with you, rather than her friends, because she knows you don't know anyone IYSWIM. It's her wedding and her hen do.

If you had said you were really close and see each other regularly, I'd say YANBU, but on the basis that you're not, I don't think she's done anything wrong.

The same goes for bridal party inclusion of your DC.

CableCar · 21/06/2024 16:43

I am going to leave now as my post is being picked apart in a way I didn't expect...such is the Mumsnet way, that I didn't quite realise that I would have to explicitly justify exactly how/when/where I see my brother to the days/hours etc. I was just interested to know whether IABU to be irked that I'm not invited to the spa with my SIL, when I thought we all got along well, were excited to become family etc. I have established that actually I've probably been a little presumptuous about the closeness of our relationship.
I won't stop arranging to meet up with my brother and his future-wife, God knows what life will be like when our DP are old and we need to collaborate about DPs care! I am a caring and kind person and just disappointed that the family culture wasn't the same as I've experienced at my own and other weddings etc. As I said - in my circle hen parties have always been inclusive - that's just my experience. I get that not everyone's experiences are like that. I can fully empathise that my SIL wants just close friends at her hen party if that's the way she's looking at it. Fair enough. I want her to be happy!

OP posts:
Caffeineneedednow · 21/06/2024 16:42

YABU to be pissed of at SIL-to-be

It sounds like your brother isn't that interested in having a relationship with you for whatever reason so I think it is unreasonable to expect a marriage to magically fix that. Not all sibling are close as adults and it doesn't sound like you are at all. If you care that much try talking to your brother and seeing why.

My SIL isn't coming to my hen and recently had a bit of a hissy fit and decided whe wasn't coming to our wedding. It made me have even less respect for her that she would upset her brother because we aren't close and I am only having close friends at my hen. My own mum isn't even coming.

Chickpea17 · 21/06/2024 16:40

LondonFox · 21/06/2024 15:03

She probably wants to have fun day, not overthinking how her MIL and you will judge how much she drinks, what she laughs about etc.
Imo inviting only your friends to your hen do is amazing.
If you wamt a day at the spa with your mum book one.

This with bells on.