Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

6 year child - stranger talking about her penis

434 replies

hermenmumster · 20/06/2024 09:58

Trigger warning : sensitive topic around Gender Identity

I was at a work event (private garden - bring family along deal) and someone there is a transgender woman- she was tall, bearded ,hirsuite and wearing a dress and heels.
My daughter (6) was roaming around with the other kids and i think must have asked the lady why she was wearing a dress.
She explained that she ´was born a man with a willy , and is now a lady ’

Something jarred in me about a grown person talking about gentalia to a 6 year old child.
What does the mumsnet think?
AIBU to be annoyed?

OP posts:
MissScarletInTheBallroom · 21/06/2024 13:06

Allshallbewell2021 · 21/06/2024 12:53

OneTC

Of course no one wants a strange man to say penis to their child - but equally this whole issue can't be reduced to this one thing IMO.

I can't say it should be illegal to say 'penis' to a child - you understand that I am trying to demonstrate neutrality. Kids are watching really horrible porn on their phones. Twitter showed images of Michael Mosley's body on the beach - these are terrible boundaries being breached and we are helpless.

This gender ideology believes that men can be women in reality. I don't believe that but through this social movement we are expected to be kind and understand the glaring contradiction of an ordinary hairy assed bloke in a dress in a garden exposing to a child he has a penis but he is also a 'lady' (whatever that means.. see David Wallisms...)

Given this new reality this man is trying to make sense of his presentation to a child. Clueless and offensive.

Children were always taught - men and boys have penises and women have breasts, vaginas and have the potential to have babies.

This incident encapsulates this new reality. I don't like it much either! But I'm trying to get my head round it. That's all. But context and intention also matters.

The way to get your head round it is to acknowledge that it is harmful nonsense and teach your children that it is harmful nonsense.

Men have penises and women have vaginas. Anyone trying to tell you otherwise is at best misguided and at worst wants to harm you.

There is nothing kind about any of this. Kind has been redefined, just as woman, female and rights have been redefined.

AGlinnerOfHope · 21/06/2024 13:05

“This incident encapsulates this new reality. I don't like it much either! But I'm trying to get my head round it. That's all. But context and intention also matters.”

There is no context where it’s ok for a man to mention his penis to a child he has just met.

None.

There are some hard boundaries.
Not everything is relative.

I understand you are trying to negotiate a world where a significant chunk of the population is trying to renegotiate all the boundaries and you are trying to avoid being judgemental about it.

I would recommend you hold on to the wisdom you’ve acquired over your lifetime and stop pandering to children and young adults telling you you’re sooo old fashioned and just don’t understand.

Keep your head when all around you are losing theirs. Exercise discernment and wisdom. Call a spade a fucking shovel.

This was not just a man in a dress, it was a man pretending to be someone he is not- and we all know they are dangerous. This man is showing us who he is. Why not believe him?

OneTC · 21/06/2024 13:04

You're far more generous in your assessment than I am

Allshallbewell2021 · 21/06/2024 12:53

OneTC

Of course no one wants a strange man to say penis to their child - but equally this whole issue can't be reduced to this one thing IMO.

I can't say it should be illegal to say 'penis' to a child - you understand that I am trying to demonstrate neutrality. Kids are watching really horrible porn on their phones. Twitter showed images of Michael Mosley's body on the beach - these are terrible boundaries being breached and we are helpless.

This gender ideology believes that men can be women in reality. I don't believe that but through this social movement we are expected to be kind and understand the glaring contradiction of an ordinary hairy assed bloke in a dress in a garden exposing to a child he has a penis but he is also a 'lady' (whatever that means.. see David Wallisms...)

Given this new reality this man is trying to make sense of his presentation to a child. Clueless and offensive.

Children were always taught - men and boys have penises and women have breasts, vaginas and have the potential to have babies.

This incident encapsulates this new reality. I don't like it much either! But I'm trying to get my head round it. That's all. But context and intention also matters.

TheKeatingFive · 21/06/2024 12:51

Also @Allshallbewell2021 i still don't understand why you think it's acceptable or even necessary for women/children's rights and needs to be compromised for men who like to wear dresses.

It seems perfectly straightforward to me. We accept men expressing themselves how they like - without confusing the issue with any suggestion that this gives them rights to women's spaces or leeway to talk about their genitalia to children.

Imtheotherguy · 21/06/2024 12:50

OneTC · 21/06/2024 11:18

I certainly don't want to be open-minded at any cost but I also believe it's hard to be in a truly pluralistic society without everyone potentially having to put up with things they find uncomfortable and even wrong

There's being pluralistic and there's being okay with people doing sex things in public. Most societies draw a line there. If you're dressed in your fetish gear, be it rubber, dressed like a little doggy and walking round on all 4s, dressed as a baby, a woman, whatever, and you're not queuing outside a club or other event then you're intentionally involving people automatically and without consent in your sex shit. I'm not cool with that

This bloke aside (because bringing genitalia into a conversation with a child is obviously not right), but a man wearing a dress isn’t necessarily a fetish or sex related. Men are allowed to wear whatever clothes they like, just as women are.

MissScarletInTheBallroom · 21/06/2024 12:49

Allshallbewell2021 · 21/06/2024 12:38

I do believe in biological reality and that woman means biological woman - but I also believe that the cultural space has shifted out of my comfort zone and I am working with that reality.

As a person who was sexually abused as a child by a family friend - believe me - I do not want to destroy child safeguarding! We didn't have that when I was little.

I am not condoning any abuse, exploitation, or even bad behavior.

I am only acknowledging that the people I deal with are individuals and I am trying to work with the mix of people in this complex new cultural world. The innocent and the bad intentioned are all mixed up in this. Just like in life and politics. I don't defend the bad but I can see there are perfectly innocent men in dresses who don't say penis to children.

We need people who believe in biological reality to bring the cultural space back into their comfort zone, not just accept that society believes women can have penises now.

TheKeatingFive · 21/06/2024 12:45

As a person who was sexually abused as a child by a family friend - believe me - I do not want to destroy child safeguarding!

Yet by suggesting that men in a dress be treated in some different way to men not in a dress with regard to public conduct - you are doing that. Whether you realise it or not.

Didimum · 21/06/2024 12:44

OneTC · 21/06/2024 12:42

All shall be well said she'd feel more understanding of a bloke in a dress talking about his dick to a child rather than a bloke in trousers talking about his dick to a child because one's a quirky paradox and one's a deviant sex pest.

Pull the other one

No, in the exact same scenario – a child asked a trousered male-presenting man (or however you wish to phrase it) why a transgender person was wearing a dress and came out with the same answer – I would also have the same opinion.

OneTC · 21/06/2024 12:42

Didimum · 21/06/2024 12:38

Literally no one has said it was OK. No one is standing up for this right.

All shall be well said she'd feel more understanding of a bloke in a dress talking about his dick to a child rather than a bloke in trousers talking about his dick to a child because one's a quirky paradox and one's a deviant sex pest.

Pull the other one

Didimum · 21/06/2024 12:38

TheKeatingFive · 21/06/2024 12:06

I hope all the posters standing up for men's rights to talk about their penis to little girls are proud of themselves.

Literally no one has said it was OK. No one is standing up for this right.

Allshallbewell2021 · 21/06/2024 12:38

I do believe in biological reality and that woman means biological woman - but I also believe that the cultural space has shifted out of my comfort zone and I am working with that reality.

As a person who was sexually abused as a child by a family friend - believe me - I do not want to destroy child safeguarding! We didn't have that when I was little.

I am not condoning any abuse, exploitation, or even bad behavior.

I am only acknowledging that the people I deal with are individuals and I am trying to work with the mix of people in this complex new cultural world. The innocent and the bad intentioned are all mixed up in this. Just like in life and politics. I don't defend the bad but I can see there are perfectly innocent men in dresses who don't say penis to children.

Didimum · 21/06/2024 12:37

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

As long as I'm not aligning myself with someone who uses the word 'pervert' as a blanket statement to cover one characteristic, I'm good thanks.

Didimum · 21/06/2024 12:36

x2boys · 20/06/2024 11:32

Agree.

Yup!

OneTC · 21/06/2024 12:32

I'm really intrigued by pp assertion that inclusivity requires victimising people and hope they expand on that.

TheKeatingFive · 21/06/2024 12:27

IdgieThreadgoodeIsMyHeroine · 21/06/2024 12:21

I cannot believe this is a hill any woman would choose to die on, and yet here we are!

It's ... quite something 😵‍💫

Needanewname42 · 21/06/2024 12:26

minipie · 21/06/2024 09:16

I cannot understand why someone who truly wishes to be a woman and be seen as such, would have a beard?

It does seem that in this person’s case it’s far more likely to be about wearing women’s clothes than actually wanting to be female.

I support breaking down stereotypes and I have no issues with a man wearing a dress (as long as it’s a work-event appropriate one) but in that case his response ought to have been “Because I like wearing dresses” rather than “I used to be a man and now I’m a woman”. But I guess “I like wearing dresses” wouldn’t get the same praise and protection as being trans.

And obviously no need to mention willies either way.

Well said!

IdgieThreadgoodeIsMyHeroine · 21/06/2024 12:21

TheKeatingFive · 21/06/2024 12:06

I hope all the posters standing up for men's rights to talk about their penis to little girls are proud of themselves.

I cannot believe this is a hill any woman would choose to die on, and yet here we are!

TheKeatingFive · 21/06/2024 12:06

I hope all the posters standing up for men's rights to talk about their penis to little girls are proud of themselves.

RoaringtoLangClegintheDark · 21/06/2024 12:05

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Didimum · 21/06/2024 11:57

MessyHouseHappyHouse · 21/06/2024 11:36

She?? It was a bloody bearded man, not a woman. Transwomen who are genuinely trans, do not attend garden parties wearing a full beard.

FFS. Stop making excuses for these perverts.

Shame you're not on my keyboard, I guess? I'll write exactly as I wish to and you will have to deal with it – suck to be you, I guess.

CocoapuffPuff · 21/06/2024 11:53

thequickbrowndog · 21/06/2024 11:16

Because this person was clearly a weirdo

Well yes, but I'm not allowed to say things like that. I get ticked off. I appreciate you filling in the gaps though.

TheKeatingFive · 21/06/2024 11:48

Andrew Gold discusses how he met a woman in Germany who works with men who admit they are attracted to children but don't act on it. So to prove her faith in them she lets them babysit her own children

Jesus. I despair

Nanny0gg · 21/06/2024 11:47

hermenmumster · 20/06/2024 11:56

yes, absolutely. Thank you

Have you spoken to the people whose party it was?

TheKeatingFive · 21/06/2024 11:47

I'm willing to believe that @Allshallbewell2021 has simply been a bit bamboozled by all the 'inclusivity' narratives and has boxed herself into arguments that she hasn't fully thought through. Hopefully she doesn't ultimately believe that the vulnerable in society need to suffer more so that men can push the boundaries of what society accepts.

I hope that's the case anyway.