Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Schools should close early on a Friday

504 replies

Goolagoo · 19/06/2024 21:30

I know this will be very mixed opinion - especially for working parents .

But , I’m a teacher . Over the years I have seen so much in schools regarding PPA time and really unfair practices . I have seen , and experienced , teachers having PPA taken away due to staffing issues . I once saw a teacher have a day of PPA ( a whole day because she wasn’t having it the week after due to staffing issues so would need to plan 2 weeks work in this PPA session ) taken away - it was a Friday too so she was supposed to be having that day to plan for lessons beginning on the Monday . It was taken away due to staffing issues and she was in tears - she had plans that weekend that she had to cancel so she could plan for the week ahead ( I didn’t work in that school , she’s a teacher friend ). I have also had PPA time taken away from me before and I also have never had a class that didn’t get upset at me not being in class and having a supply or a Ta cover . Usuall work that’s done during the cover whilst class teacher is out on PPA isn’t ‘important’ work - it’s a lot of filler work , or work that doesn’t go in books . A lot of children also get anxiety over their class teacher being out and children with SEN especially suffer with this .

I read about a school that decided to close at 1pm every Friday to allow teachers to all have their PPA time . They said that they made the time back with a slightly later finish time / slightly earlier start time and they found that behaviour improved massively. Fridays are usually the end of a long week and filled with behaviour issues and this reduced along with attendance improving . I know some schools around the area do Finish at 1/2 on a Friday and I wonder if this is the reason why .

It seems like it would really make sense !

Maybe even , as TAs don’t get PPA time as they don’t plan , they could offer a kind of after school club ( until normal pick up time ) where the TAs watched the children who’s parents couldn’t do an earlier pick up time .

OP posts:
dreamerz · 20/06/2024 09:15

@Cluborange666 most teachers I know do very little work in holidays. My sister tidies her class one day and might do some bits towards the start of new term. Like I say, this half term she was on a beach. The whole time. Most teachers I know do the same.

MrsCarson · 20/06/2024 09:13

It does work.
The school district my kids were in when we lived in California switched up the timetable so all the elementary schools finished at 12 on Fridays, so they were home, or after school care for lunchtime and the teachers had meetings and time to plan. It worked really well. The onsite after school care put on extra staff on Fridays only and increased the number of kids they looked after.

Cluborange666 · 20/06/2024 09:12

Meetingofminds · 20/06/2024 08:55

But I bet you miss the extended holiday! 4 weeks versus 13 weeks minimum for doing the same hours the rest of us work without complaint.

You don’t get 13 weeks though as the half terms were spent catching up on marking and being ill (my body used to hold on to the illness until I had a break). Christmas and summer were the only proper holidays. Summer you can take away two weeks, one at each end for tidying, preparing etc. I only get 4 weeks off per year now, earn more money and feel 100% better about my work/life balance than I did as a teacher. That’s the same for most ex teachers.
Comments like yours just help the flood of decent teachers leaving the profession only to be replaced by under qualified people. No one understands the reality of it unless they’ve lived it.

dreamerz · 20/06/2024 09:10

I agree with others. I do a 37.5 hour week in pharma. I regularly work through my lunch and log on of an evening. It's expected in my industry. When times are busy it's even worse. I don't get paid for it. The work just needs to be done I'm afraid and I work with people in different time zones.

I don't get why teachers think they do so much more than others? Most of my friends do unpaid overtime. In lots of private sector businesses it's just the norm.

We also don't get all that holiday to make up for it.

Teachers are not that hard done by. It's getting a bit much to keep hearing it all the time.

I know several teachers and they do not work beyond a couple of days of the summer holiday. My own sister teacher spent half term on a European beach. So you can't even deny the benefit of all those holidays.

I say early Friday finish is a rubbish idea.

Meetingofminds · 20/06/2024 09:10

Missedvocation · 20/06/2024 09:01

Yes 😆 I barely know a job that doesn’t. And nobody else gets 13 weeks leave a year either 😆

Teaching is a hard job, for sure, but so are 85% of jobs that contain educated / qualified workers…

Most professional jobs are ‘hard’ isn’t that the very point of them!! Not everyone and his dog can do them….

Missedvocation · 20/06/2024 09:01

Goolagoo · 20/06/2024 06:31

But do most people in other jobs take their work home with them - after their 5pm finish - to continue working at home / on the weekend ?

Yes 😆 I barely know a job that doesn’t. And nobody else gets 13 weeks leave a year either 😆

Teaching is a hard job, for sure, but so are 85% of jobs that contain educated / qualified workers…

Meetingofminds · 20/06/2024 08:57

HouseofHills · 20/06/2024 08:55

Lol have you ever worked in the public sector? Go and work in the NHS if you think it’s so indulgent. Junior doctors would love a chilled week of only having to work 45-55 hours.

My dh works 80 hours a week. The work ethic is dire on here.

HouseofHills · 20/06/2024 08:55

Meetingofminds · 20/06/2024 08:39

The public sector are incredibly lazy and self indulgent, I doubt they would last a week in the private sector. Always wanting to do less and less, no wonder so many schools are failing if this is the work ethic!

Most of us work 45- 55 hours a week with four weeks holiday per year and are not whinging at all. Jesus wept.

Lol have you ever worked in the public sector? Go and work in the NHS if you think it’s so indulgent. Junior doctors would love a chilled week of only having to work 45-55 hours.

Meetingofminds · 20/06/2024 08:55

Cluborange666 · 20/06/2024 08:53

Haha somebody doesn’t understand the reality of teaching… I did 7.30 - 5.30 for years until I quit. I was a great teacher but the job was underpaid for the level of abuse I got and the permanent level of exhaustion that I felt.

But I bet you miss the extended holiday! 4 weeks versus 13 weeks minimum for doing the same hours the rest of us work without complaint.

Cluborange666 · 20/06/2024 08:53

Itsmyshadow · 19/06/2024 21:44

But you do finish early on a Friday (and every other day).

Haha somebody doesn’t understand the reality of teaching… I did 7.30 - 5.30 for years until I quit. I was a great teacher but the job was underpaid for the level of abuse I got and the permanent level of exhaustion that I felt.

Youdontevengohere · 20/06/2024 08:53

As long as all employers gave their employees Friday afternoons off fully paid so they could pick their kids up from school then yeah, I guess it could work. Otherwise I’d be in trouble letting my 3 primary aged children stay at home alone on a Friday afternoon, because I can’t afford to drop my hours (not that my employer would allow me to, even if I could).

HouseofHills · 20/06/2024 08:48

Hellodarknessmyfriend · 20/06/2024 08:21

@HouseofHills Do you get paid overtime for extra hours worked?

No of course not!

MinervaMcGonagallsCat · 20/06/2024 08:46

@NappyBag @EatTheGnome

Why should children lose 2 hours of education to resolve an underfunding crisis?

This 👏

They don't. The other 4 days are adjusted. Total teaching time is the same.

MinervaMcGonagallsCat · 20/06/2024 08:44

Hellodarknessmyfriend · 20/06/2024 08:21

@HouseofHills Do you get paid overtime for extra hours worked?

It's unusual for salaried roles to be paid overtime.

elliejjtiny · 20/06/2024 08:43

I would be happy with this. My autistic 10 year old gets upset and self harms when his teacher does her PPA time. I would love to just keep him off then but I'm not allowed.

NappyBag · 20/06/2024 08:40

EatTheGnome · 19/06/2024 22:16

Why should children lose 2 hours of education to resolve an underfunding crisis?

This 👏

MinervaMcGonagallsCat · 20/06/2024 08:40

Great for high schools - works very well at our high school. The afternoon is spent in extra curriculars or studying.

Not acceptable for primary schools.

Very simply working parents can't be burdened with the cost of an extra half day of childcare or lost working hours each week.

Meetingofminds · 20/06/2024 08:39

The public sector are incredibly lazy and self indulgent, I doubt they would last a week in the private sector. Always wanting to do less and less, no wonder so many schools are failing if this is the work ethic!

Most of us work 45- 55 hours a week with four weeks holiday per year and are not whinging at all. Jesus wept.

marmarmalade · 20/06/2024 08:38

My kids have always had one day that finishes early in secondary school. Randomly a Tuesday with the first school. Now a Friday with a different school.

tabulahrasa · 20/06/2024 08:36

I live in an area in Scotland where they do that and am a trustee of a children’s and families charity - it’s a huge issue tbh, it’s a real barrier to work in lower income families.

OOSC is expensive and a half day of it on Friday bumps the cost up so much.

Babyboomtastic · 20/06/2024 08:35

HouseofHills · 20/06/2024 08:17

This is going to be a very unpopular opinion but… I think a lot of primary school teachers have an unrealistic expectation about how the world of work actually works. You knew someone who had to work over the weekend because of something coming up on a Friday? That’s a normal part of working life!

I’m a Civil Servant and many times something has happened on Friday which has meant working until late at night and over the weekend.

DH is a surgeon and he goes into work every Saturday without fail to personally check on the patients he operated on on the Friday, but he’s only contracted to work one weekend in eight. When he gets home at 7 or 8pm he looks over his operating list for the next day and does his admin.

I’m not saying it’s right that people have to work much longer than their contracted hours but it is part of modern life if you want to have a career rather than a job.

My friend is primary school teacher and complains of finishing late when she gets home at 6pm! That’s early or at least normal time for most people. Having to do occasional work at the weekend isn’t unusual. I think if she changed careers she’d get a huge shock.

Quite.

The number of times I've cancelled evening plans, weekend plans, taken my laptop on holiday with me (including my honeymoon 😳). I've lost count. Usually for no extra pay (or toil)., and in a variety of jobs. I've known other people who technically get TOIL, but have accrued so much that it's impractical to take it (ie would mean everyone taking 6 months off).

I'm certainly not saying teaching isn't hard work, but that working evenings and weekends is pretty standard in many jobs. Often for no extra pay.

Abitorangelooking · 20/06/2024 08:33

I suppose my issue would be for working parents. There is no breakfast club, after school care is very limited. I do core hours 9-3 then make up time in evenings. Possibly sports on a Friday afternoon would be a good idea?

whyhavetheygotsomany · 20/06/2024 08:31

The kids go at three or half three. Most jobs are till five or six why can't you do it in that time. Parents need to work and they work longer hours than teachers most of them so no you are being massively unreasonable.

TheKeatingFive · 20/06/2024 08:29

The burden of planning, marking and admin does seem to have increased very significantly over the last 15 years or so.

Why is that and is it strictly necessary? In ROI for example, teachers seem to be under a lot less pressure with this stuff, yet outcomes for children are better.

BestZebbie · 20/06/2024 08:25

Hellodarknessmyfriend · 20/06/2024 08:21

@HouseofHills Do you get paid overtime for extra hours worked?

Generally (across many industries) lower responsibility jobs paid by the hour get overtime, but salaried staff are paid "to get the job done" regardless of how long that takes.