Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How to eat in a calorie deficit and not be bloody starving!!

187 replies

flossie232 · 18/06/2024 22:40

Trying to eat in a calorie deficit of 1600. I have at least 1.5 stone to lose. I'm finding it so hard to keep to 1600, I'm just hungry all the time. I try to make good choices, today for example I had granola, Greek yoghurt and berries for breakfast thinking it would fill me up. By lunch I was starving again and had a hearty soup for about 300 calories which filled me up at the time but by the evening I was hungry again so ended up having a massive pasta dish that will have probably tipped me over my calories. Even with sensible meals it seems really tough to eat 3 satisfying meals a day and incorporate the other little things I like (like a few coffees, maybe a biscuit in the evening etc) without going over.

I know this method will work if I can find a way to eat within a deficit sustainably. Does anyone have any tips or maybe recommendations for low calorie but filling food? It's astonishing how quickly calories add up and how calorific certain things are.

On my working days I used to have a cereal bar and a coffee for breakfast, then a sandwich/crisps at lunch and something from a Gousto box for tea. I genuinely didn't think that was a lot but logging it all on MFP has made me realised how many calories are in things like supermarket sandwiches. It's all just such hard work.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Aquarelles · 20/06/2024 08:35

Sleepydoor · 19/06/2024 13:31

You can always eat upon waking but stop eating early. When I IF, I eat until 2pm and then stop.

I thought about that, but I work in an office from 7.30am till around 5pm and there aren't any cooking facilities bar a kettle and microwave.

I'm absolutely fine with not eating until midday, I just really miss the cup of tea with milk in the mornings.

MerryChristmasToYou · 19/06/2024 23:50

Trouble is that everything you buy thats packaged says adults NEED 2000 cals a day
The packaging states a recommended daily intake. That will be for the average adult, not for e.g. a sedentary 47 yr old 5'2" woman or whatever.

It doesn't say adults NEED it.

We need to be able to understand what food labelling means.
The 5-a-day is far too low too.

WetBandits · 19/06/2024 22:43

Way more protein. You’re choosing quite ‘empty’ foods to fill your calorie allowance, none of which will fill you up.

Tin of tuna has about 25g protein in it. Mix it with 100g Greek yoghurt (excellent substitute for mayo!) and stick it in a sweet potato jacket for lunch, and you’ve got yourself a 35g+ protein meal for about 340 calories which will keep you full until dinner.

suki1964 · 19/06/2024 22:35

Killingoffmyflowersonebyone · 19/06/2024 10:28

I can't believe some people saying 1,600 calories a day isn't enough. 1,600 calories a day is more than enough for the average person. Unless OP is exercising like a demon every day, she doesn't need more than that. Peoples idea of how much 'food' we need makes me weep and tbh goes to show why so many people have serious weight issues. The fact is, losing weight on 1,600 calories IS working for OP - so we should be supportive of that rather than telling her to increase her intake. All OP needs to do is adjust the quality of what she is eating.

OP - I had 1,300 calories yesterday (most days I eat about 2K as I do a lot of exercise, but yesterday I was lazy and adjusted my calories to reflect that). I don't eat snacks on days I don't exercise as I am a picker.

Breakfast was: Greek Yoghurt, home-made granola (basically just nuts and dark chocolate), one apple chopped up, cinnamon, (400 calories)
Lunch: 200G Rump Steak, 150G Broccoli, 300G Beansprouts. (400 calories, including seasoning such as garlic, ginger, coriander, red onion which has basically no calories etc).
Dinner: Chicken breast wrapped in Parma ham stuffed with cream cheese and spinach. Mediterranean vegetables (in the oven, no oil but lots of seasoning) and 200G asparagus. (500 calories).

As with anything, it's about the quality and quantity of what you eat.

For days you're working (assuming you're going into an office) try a homemade yoghurt bowl or homemade breakfast muffins (with egg, chorizo instead of sausage, cheese and red pepper - you just mix it together and pop it in the oven a few days before. They reheat nicely or you can have them cold). For lunch try homemade marinated chicken breast with vegetables or a big salad or a 'fancy salad' (I have a butternut squash, rocket and blackberry one I do). For dinner, something high protein (Chicken, Steak, Salmon) and bulk up with vegetables - don't do carbs like pasta as tbh it's satisfying at the time but not filling and not really nutritionally 'dense'.

Don't forget seasoning. Seasoning really changes a meal. The mistake so many people make is trying to have things like soup or fruit and yoghurt or chicken and rice and veg and they forget about seasoning - any diet or restrictive eating will fail if you don't give yourself variety.

Trouble is that everything you buy thats packaged says adults NEED 2000 cals a day

Seriously Im 60 this year and have only just learned that needed calories are different for everyone. And as I get leaner and fitter the calories I "need" get less and less

Even when someone feels they are making healthy choices, they are looking at the traffic lights on a sandwich, they are picking what they percieve to be the healthiest, they are choosing their sides to be within their 2000 cals a day, not realising thats a pile of crap.

I seriously ate very little (I ate a lot of carbs though ) and got fat. Oh I kept to the 2000 recommended calories - and got fat. Because I believed that was what I should be doing. Its only now , as Ive tackled the weight, that I have learned better

I do walk a tight line, as my weight drops, my maintaining/loss calories drop and to keep them at a level where Im not feeling hunger all day, or reaching for food, I have to up the exercise.

So right now my needed maintenance calories are 1340, not a lot , so I have to gain a few hundred via exercise and that does take a bit of effort ( well actually quite a bit )

BarbaraVineFan · 19/06/2024 20:07

I posted this the other day. I am trying to eat about 1000 calories a day and have started eating a BIG bowl of vegetables (whole bag of spinach/whole head of broccoli type thing) with some soy sauce or miso, when I get home from work at about 6. This keeps me full and I can then have a smaller dinner at about 8 than I would have done.

Hydrangealilac · 19/06/2024 17:55

Hi @flossie232

I’ve been in a calorie deficit for 8 weeks and have lost 2 stone.

I find it easier to do it along with fasting. So I skip breakfast and lunch and eat around 4.30pm

My favourite meal is 1/2 pack of M&S classic breaded chicken fillets in a toasted brioche bun, with M&S pineapple spicy chutney and a teeny bit of grated cheddar. I add cucumber for crunch. This is served with 100g of sweet potato fries; 70g (4-5) onion rings and a garden salad.
Dessert is an M&S chocolate tiffin or a pineapple tart.

Then I don’t eat until the next day.

I also drink about 2 pints of squash with 1 Tbsp apple cider vinegar added to it.

It’s delicious, filling and has worked for me. I’m not saying it’s overall healthy though. Just effective for losing weight.

AlwaysTripsInFlipFlops · 19/06/2024 17:36

AlltheFs · 18/06/2024 22:58

It’s far easier to do 600 calories twice a week and then eat more on the other days. Then you aren’t hungry all the time and by week 4
the fast days are actually fine.

1600 calories daily is just depressing and not sustainable.

It’s still calorie deficit.

For you.

IF does not suit everyone.

Infinity234 · 19/06/2024 17:11

Low carb. Cheese, yoghurt and berries, eggs

mickandrorty · 19/06/2024 16:49

I'm not saying this is the case but i thought it maybe worth a mention, when i was trying to lose weight i was starving all the time it turns out i was type 2 diabetic. I know several people who are type 2 and i refused the medication because the side effects are bloody awful and did the fast 800. It sounds brutal doing 8 weeks on 800 calories a day but it was (as dramatic as it sounds) life changing. My bloods are now normal after a week or so i wasn't starving all the time, my skin was better, i slept better and i had more energy. after 12 weeks i switched to 5:2 the recipes from the books are really nice as well.

BreatheAndFocus · 19/06/2024 16:08

Veg, veg and veg! Seriously, you can ‘spend’ your calories on a massive, stomach-filling meal if you include enough veg. Have green veg plus a green salad with your meals.

Forks Over Knives has some good recipes (you can add low fat animal protein if you want). The Engine 2 diet is also good. If you want to go it alone, plan your meals around non-carby veg then add protein, healthy fats and some brown carbs. You should be able to make filling meals and stay within your calories target.

Ponoka7 · 19/06/2024 15:43

As said, protein. Instead of hearty soup, chicken curry with chick peas, packed with veg and no carbs rice. Poached eggs for breakfast, or omelette. Use no carbs pasta with bolognaise, with lots of veg and red lentils. Snack on cooked chicken, babybel light cheese etc. IF doesn't have to be all or nothing. You can have a morning coffee, then just clear drinks until you eat.

Helloworld56 · 19/06/2024 15:43

Cereal bars are upf and not good for you at all.

Try a mushroom omelette for breakfast porridge with berries or a kipper.

Cut out carbs as much as you can.

Dinner, try a fish recipe, or slices of beef with onion gravy and veg.

Do a spag bol sauce and eat an omelette filled with the sauce.

A mixed salad with salmon.

AllProperTeaIsTheft · 19/06/2024 15:40

You are much better off having a good breakfast and fasting at the end of the day for your health.

Not if it makes it harder to stick to though. For many people (like me), there's not much time in the morning before work and they would not want to forego sitting down for a proper evening meal with their family. Aside from the social aspect, the last thing I'd want to do was give my teenage dc that skipping a main meal was a good idea.

Tattletwat · 19/06/2024 15:37

Fill you plate up with loads of veg, it fills a lot of volume and is low calorie.

violetcuriosity · 19/06/2024 15:36

Yeah I would do intermittent fasting- drink shit loads of water until about midday, you'll find the hunger passes if you're hydrated (I actually do have milk in my tea and coffee so I'm not properly fasting). I've been having fruit and Greek yogurt with honey for lunch then a normal meal for dinner but just make sure I don't eat after about 5:30. My weight has been coming off nicely surprisingly 🤞🏻

AllProperTeaIsTheft · 19/06/2024 15:34

I dont know how people manage with IF or OMAD, I need to be eating every couple of hours

Once I get used to it, it feels perfectly normal (16:8 IF, not OMAD - I couldn't do that!).

Workoutinthepark · 19/06/2024 15:30

henlake7 · 19/06/2024 14:38

I dont know how people manage with IF or OMAD, I need to be eating every couple of hours....plenty of food too!
I just stick with whole plant foods mostly though as its really hard to physically over eat fruit and vegetables! Im kinda eating from 9am to 9pm, pretty sure my calorie deficit is only a couple of hundred calories as well.
But its working for me, managed to lose 100Ibs without ever feeling hungry or deprived. Im aiming for long term sustainability though and being hungry or really restricting myself just wont work for me long term.

This is great, very much a healthy and very effective approach, high fibre, high natural foods, etc. So nice to read!

Workoutinthepark · 19/06/2024 15:28

Can you exercise too OP? A lot of my PT clients struggle badly with diet alone, partly because of hunger. Working out more, means they can eat more too and still lose weight. Also, exercise controls leptin which is a hormone that can make you more hungry. It's generally 4 times more effective to lose bodyfat if you combine diet with exercise, as opposed to diet only.

financialcareerstuff · 19/06/2024 15:21

Lots of great advice.... it's inspiring me - thanks to everyone!

afrikat · 19/06/2024 14:59

henlake7 · 19/06/2024 14:38

I dont know how people manage with IF or OMAD, I need to be eating every couple of hours....plenty of food too!
I just stick with whole plant foods mostly though as its really hard to physically over eat fruit and vegetables! Im kinda eating from 9am to 9pm, pretty sure my calorie deficit is only a couple of hundred calories as well.
But its working for me, managed to lose 100Ibs without ever feeling hungry or deprived. Im aiming for long term sustainability though and being hungry or really restricting myself just wont work for me long term.

100lbs? That's amazing! Well done 👏

xerneas · 19/06/2024 14:43

Less carbs works for me. For breakfast I have 0% fat yogurt with strawberries, for lunch I have a salad - sweet chilli chicken, cucumber, tomato's, 30g cheese and some light mayo with some sweet chilli rice crackers then I have a smaller portion of what I'd normally have for my tea. This usually leaves me with enough calories left to have a small treat after my tea and stops me from being hungry/craving sweet things. I am currently due on though, proper hungry and craving anything and everything sweet!!

henlake7 · 19/06/2024 14:38

I dont know how people manage with IF or OMAD, I need to be eating every couple of hours....plenty of food too!
I just stick with whole plant foods mostly though as its really hard to physically over eat fruit and vegetables! Im kinda eating from 9am to 9pm, pretty sure my calorie deficit is only a couple of hundred calories as well.
But its working for me, managed to lose 100Ibs without ever feeling hungry or deprived. Im aiming for long term sustainability though and being hungry or really restricting myself just wont work for me long term.

Thegreatgiginthesky · 19/06/2024 14:29

You are much better off having a good breakfast and fasting at the end of the day for your health. Dr Satchin Panda has interesting research on the benefits of working with your body's natural circadian rhythm.
https://open.spotify.com/episode/24BjEcfOzEsNTpYVXWDsR6?si=8QX-JbhdQK2WL2AawWQYWQ

Spotify

https://open.spotify.com/episode/24BjEcfOzEsNTpYVXWDsR6?si=8QX-JbhdQK2WL2AawWQYWQ

ErrolTheDragon · 19/06/2024 14:18

I wanted to get onboard with IF, and I did for a couple of weeks, but I really missed my cup of tea in the mornings. I tried taking it black, but it really wasn't the same Sad I only take a splash of milk - no sugar.

I definitely need a couple of mugs of proper tea in the morning. I did the Zoe thing with a CGM, the tea (with a decent amount of skimmed milk) had negligible impact on my blood sugar so I decided to be pragmatic rather than purist.

AllProperTeaIsTheft · 19/06/2024 14:09

I wanted to get onboard with IF, and I did for a couple of weeks, but I really missed my cup of tea in the mornings. I tried taking it black, but it really wasn't the same Sad I only take a splash of milk - no sugar.

I feel the same about a proper cup of tea with milk in the morning, but I decided that making that small sacrifice to enable IF is still preferable to and far easier than having to constantly restrict what I can eat.