Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Ageism.

118 replies

WhatsUpNowThen · 18/06/2024 02:55

It's awful, on Mumsnet. Do these posters think they will never be 60?

I have to admit that I'm not too pleased about it. But turning 60 does not change my views on anything at all. I think the same things as I did when I was 30 Why do the younger generation hate us so much?

I'm on their side.

OP posts:
WINGINGitToday · 18/06/2024 14:14

Sunshineandpinkclouds · 18/06/2024 14:10

Some are but less so compared to the other way round.

I wonder if it is jealousy, some older people jealous of youth, some younger people jealous of the older generation having houses, and alot more money than they ever will, due to the world we now live in.

https://www.dailymail.co.uk/femail/article-10669425/No-wonder-young-despise-lazy-selfish-generation-writes-JENNI-MURRAY.html

No wonder the young despise my lazy, selfish generation!

In 2015, over-60s accounted for 33 percent of greenhouse gas emissions. Jenni Murray says it's time to get radical and follow the lead of the youth. Under-30s cut their emissions by 3.7 tonnes

https://www.dailymail.co.uk/femail/article-10669425/No-wonder-young-despise-lazy-selfish-generation-writes-JENNI-MURRAY.html

Sunshineandpinkclouds · 18/06/2024 14:10

WINGINGitToday · 18/06/2024 14:06

Older women are anti younger women equally wouldn't you say?

Some are but less so compared to the other way round.

jessicalovejoy · 18/06/2024 14:08

What was your attitude towards people in their sixties and older when you were in your 20s/30s?

WINGINGitToday · 18/06/2024 14:06

Sunshineandpinkclouds · 18/06/2024 14:01

Young women are anti-older women on here and I don't know why - they should be trying to bring down the patriarchy not support it. You don't see forum after forum of young men making ageist comments about older men - they have better things to do.

Older women are anti younger women equally wouldn't you say?

Skin96 · 18/06/2024 14:03

I personally don't dislike the 'elder generation' I just don't like the entitlement from some of the 'elder generation ' I'm 27 so consider myself fairly young, I have 3 young children and I teach them all to respect your elders which they do however doesn't stop some of them looking at me like I'm a piece of shit.
I don't think its all about age personality is a huge factor.
If your a dickhead your just a dickhead in my eyes.
Regardless of age.

Sunshineandpinkclouds · 18/06/2024 14:01

Young women are anti-older women on here and I don't know why - they should be trying to bring down the patriarchy not support it. You don't see forum after forum of young men making ageist comments about older men - they have better things to do.

Shakeoffyourchains · 18/06/2024 13:55

Startingagainandagain · 18/06/2024 10:58

@Shakeoffyourchains

'I've noticed that older people seem to find it very hard to distinguish between broad generalisations and personal attacks on them as individuals.I've noticed that older people seem to find it very hard to distinguish between broad generalisations and personal attacks on them as individuals. E.g., stating that older people are more likely to have voted for the tories or brexit isn't a suggestion that you personally did but is factually true of the generation. I've also noticed that ageism is only ageism if directed at older people, contempt and disrespect of younger people and their views is just stating home truths apparently. Someone up thread stated stated that the young are learning their contemptuous attitude from somewhere and I'd suggest looking in a mirror.'

The irony...

Your post is full of generalisations, not 'facts' as you call them, and blanket contempt for older people.

That is not the way to have a constructive discussion or to make your argument stand out.

There's no irony in my post, it was quite deliberate and was just mirroring the tone and content of the poster I had quoted.

But I see you're quite happy to ignore the ageist generalisations directed at young people, including the one in post I quoted, so thanks for proving my point so quickly.

And the only fact I referred to is that older people were more likely to vote for tories and brexit, which is entirely accurate and backed up by data.

PurpleBugz · 18/06/2024 12:22

I see agism going both ways on here.

I also see a nasty attitude to disability or SEN but this isn't just on here it's fucking everywhere all the time.

People seem to be in competition to have it the worst, to suffer the worse abuse or insult or the 'ism' that would be relevant to them. While at the same time having no respect and being derogatory towards another group of people who are different to them.

We all need to do better. We will all be old one day and most of us have family members who are young. Anyone of us could have a child with SEN or anyone could become disabled. Most of us are women. Many of us are minority ethnicity or religion. Unless you are a white healthy middle class man you will tick at least one box on things you are discriminated on. Its just sad how things are really. We have always known these groups of people suffer, we have been aware for years we should not be horrible with our words and actions to these people. But so many of us still are.

VestibuleVirgin · 18/06/2024 11:30

If you say so, @WINGINGitToday

WINGINGitToday · 18/06/2024 11:17

VestibuleVirgin · 18/06/2024 11:05

This was a tongue-in-cheek response. The OP ended with a plaintive 'why do they hate us?'. I doubt she meant that in a serious way. My responses were the generalisations and comments heard/seen both here and IRL. But do you seriously think I would write in the way I did as a serious post? If you did, you need to reappraise how you interpret things, because someday such misinterpretation will be an issue.
Indeed, you are proving the 'people get offended at everything' trope

For christ's sake, of course it works both ways, but the OP was pointing out the ageism and asked why old people are hated here

Sometimes, this place is such hard work

Quite honestly, you sound very angry. I don't know you, therefore I have absolutely no idea what you do, and don't mean. You didn't make any reference to what you say as being in jest, and your detailed list of blanket statements certainly do not sound light hearted, quite honestly.
Again, I do not know you, and it isn't unreasonable to read the comments you made, as being your opinion on young people as a collective.

It is also ironic that you say people get offended at everything, when clearly, you yourself are offended. This very thread is about different generations getting offended. 😂

Kinshipug · 18/06/2024 11:10

In my opinion there is rampant ageism in both directions. My theory is that it stems from a lack of intergenerational relationships.

MariaVT65 · 18/06/2024 11:08

VestibuleVirgin · 18/06/2024 11:05

This was a tongue-in-cheek response. The OP ended with a plaintive 'why do they hate us?'. I doubt she meant that in a serious way. My responses were the generalisations and comments heard/seen both here and IRL. But do you seriously think I would write in the way I did as a serious post? If you did, you need to reappraise how you interpret things, because someday such misinterpretation will be an issue.
Indeed, you are proving the 'people get offended at everything' trope

For christ's sake, of course it works both ways, but the OP was pointing out the ageism and asked why old people are hated here

Sometimes, this place is such hard work

Look, everyone is hated on MN lol. Not just older people. People of every other age group too. Just in the same way that you’re hated if you’re a SAHM or if you to to work and send your kid to nursery before the age of 3.

MariaVT65 · 18/06/2024 11:06

WINGINGitToday · 18/06/2024 10:50

I actually have encountered alot of ageism the other way. I'm in my late 30's now, it isn't as bad as it once was. Comments like "supermarkets in nightwear" show how it goes the other way too. The comments made here demonstrate the contempt from the poster, who is clearly stereotyping all young people. I hope when I am older I would have the decency, and wisdom, not to make sweeping generalisations.

I have had older people talk to me disrespectfully, treat me like I'm stupid, and in a way they would never do to older people. I am a Mother, educated and respectful, nice to people. I have found it depends on the person. There are some lovely, and absolutely amazing older people, but when I was in my 20s, working in retail while at uni, some have reduced me to tears.

Life is difficult, no matter how hard young people work, they can't get onto the housing ladder. In the 90s my dad supported a family of 4 on one lower than average wage, bought a house, car etc, and we had a decent lifestyle. Now this is impossible, even with two wages much of the time. There has always been hardships in life such as poll tax etc, but not getting mortgages no matter how hard people work, is horrendous. I was lucky that I got on the housing ladder a few years ago, in the nick of time.

Give young people a break, the world is tough!

Edited

Your second paragraph is EXACTLY my experience as well.

VestibuleVirgin · 18/06/2024 11:05

WINGINGitToday · 18/06/2024 10:50

I actually have encountered alot of ageism the other way. I'm in my late 30's now, it isn't as bad as it once was. Comments like "supermarkets in nightwear" show how it goes the other way too. The comments made here demonstrate the contempt from the poster, who is clearly stereotyping all young people. I hope when I am older I would have the decency, and wisdom, not to make sweeping generalisations.

I have had older people talk to me disrespectfully, treat me like I'm stupid, and in a way they would never do to older people. I am a Mother, educated and respectful, nice to people. I have found it depends on the person. There are some lovely, and absolutely amazing older people, but when I was in my 20s, working in retail while at uni, some have reduced me to tears.

Life is difficult, no matter how hard young people work, they can't get onto the housing ladder. In the 90s my dad supported a family of 4 on one lower than average wage, bought a house, car etc, and we had a decent lifestyle. Now this is impossible, even with two wages much of the time. There has always been hardships in life such as poll tax etc, but not getting mortgages no matter how hard people work, is horrendous. I was lucky that I got on the housing ladder a few years ago, in the nick of time.

Give young people a break, the world is tough!

Edited

This was a tongue-in-cheek response. The OP ended with a plaintive 'why do they hate us?'. I doubt she meant that in a serious way. My responses were the generalisations and comments heard/seen both here and IRL. But do you seriously think I would write in the way I did as a serious post? If you did, you need to reappraise how you interpret things, because someday such misinterpretation will be an issue.
Indeed, you are proving the 'people get offended at everything' trope

For christ's sake, of course it works both ways, but the OP was pointing out the ageism and asked why old people are hated here

Sometimes, this place is such hard work

MariaVT65 · 18/06/2024 11:04

Startingagainandagain · 18/06/2024 10:58

@Shakeoffyourchains

'I've noticed that older people seem to find it very hard to distinguish between broad generalisations and personal attacks on them as individuals.I've noticed that older people seem to find it very hard to distinguish between broad generalisations and personal attacks on them as individuals. E.g., stating that older people are more likely to have voted for the tories or brexit isn't a suggestion that you personally did but is factually true of the generation. I've also noticed that ageism is only ageism if directed at older people, contempt and disrespect of younger people and their views is just stating home truths apparently. Someone up thread stated stated that the young are learning their contemptuous attitude from somewhere and I'd suggest looking in a mirror.'

The irony...

Your post is full of generalisations, not 'facts' as you call them, and blanket contempt for older people.

That is not the way to have a constructive discussion or to make your argument stand out.

No sorry, i agree with the PP. When i was young and starting out in work, i definitely still remember cases of older superiors speaking to me and other younger colleagues in a disgusting way that they wouldn’t have done and didn’t to my colleagues in their 40s for example. The ageism and poor behaviour most definitely goes both ways.

MariaVT65 · 18/06/2024 11:00

RampantIvy · 18/06/2024 10:41

But as I said, I know this is an issue with my mum’s individual personailty and not reflective of everyone the same age.

I'm glad you said this because I don't recognise any of those traits in me or any of my friends, many of whom are older than me (65).

That’s great. I do think PP has a point though that older people take some points really personally even if it doesn’t apply to them. An example being that my observation in my absolute personal, individual experiences of driving, is that i’ve had the most near misses due elderly drivers. However, many people would count me stating that as being ageist.

Startingagainandagain · 18/06/2024 10:58

@Shakeoffyourchains

'I've noticed that older people seem to find it very hard to distinguish between broad generalisations and personal attacks on them as individuals.I've noticed that older people seem to find it very hard to distinguish between broad generalisations and personal attacks on them as individuals. E.g., stating that older people are more likely to have voted for the tories or brexit isn't a suggestion that you personally did but is factually true of the generation. I've also noticed that ageism is only ageism if directed at older people, contempt and disrespect of younger people and their views is just stating home truths apparently. Someone up thread stated stated that the young are learning their contemptuous attitude from somewhere and I'd suggest looking in a mirror.'

The irony...

Your post is full of generalisations, not 'facts' as you call them, and blanket contempt for older people.

That is not the way to have a constructive discussion or to make your argument stand out.

WINGINGitToday · 18/06/2024 10:50

VestibuleVirgin · 18/06/2024 03:15

Ps. They hate us because apparently;

  • We all live in 7-bedroomed houses and won't give them up, therefore contibuting to the housing crisis
  • We all read the Faily Dail. And believe everything we read
  • We all voted for Brexit
  • We don't go to the supermarket in our nightwear
  • We didn't validate tantrum-throwing toddler's feelings while in the middle of the supermarket, we told them to just shut up. Which is very traumatising. Apparently
  • We take too long at a checkout/bank teller window. God forbid we exchange pleasantries with the person we interact with rather than just continuing the conversation we are having on our mobile telephones and ignoring them
  • We don't wallk down the road reading our phones or sharing our conversations with the entire street. Ditto for public transport. I mean, what is wrong with us??
  • We don't abuse emergency services or hospital staff. We are grateful
  • We can add and subtract in our heads and do long division on paper

Read through any thread and you'll find any number of other reasons they hate us!
But theyare daft enough to think that they won't be like every other old person when they are old!

I actually have encountered alot of ageism the other way. I'm in my late 30's now, it isn't as bad as it once was. Comments like "supermarkets in nightwear" show how it goes the other way too. The comments made here demonstrate the contempt from the poster, who is clearly stereotyping all young people. I hope when I am older I would have the decency, and wisdom, not to make sweeping generalisations.

I have had older people talk to me disrespectfully, treat me like I'm stupid, and in a way they would never do to older people. I am a Mother, educated and respectful, nice to people. I have found it depends on the person. There are some lovely, and absolutely amazing older people, but when I was in my 20s, working in retail while at uni, some have reduced me to tears.

Life is difficult, no matter how hard young people work, they can't get onto the housing ladder. In the 90s my dad supported a family of 4 on one lower than average wage, bought a house, car etc, and we had a decent lifestyle. Now this is impossible, even with two wages much of the time. There has always been hardships in life such as poll tax etc, but not getting mortgages no matter how hard people work, is horrendous. I was lucky that I got on the housing ladder a few years ago, in the nick of time.

Give young people a break, the world is tough!

RampantIvy · 18/06/2024 10:41

But as I said, I know this is an issue with my mum’s individual personailty and not reflective of everyone the same age.

I'm glad you said this because I don't recognise any of those traits in me or any of my friends, many of whom are older than me (65).

Shakeoffyourchains · 18/06/2024 10:24

Tortiemiaw · 18/06/2024 07:51

Dearie me, Vestibule made a very funny observation, which, as a clearly almost dead and probably demented 60 year old living in a mansion and block voting tory whilst clogging up shops at the weekends made me laugh a lot.

I have noticed that younger people find it hard to laugh at themselves. Probably too busy taking selfies and having their eyebrows done*
*sarcasm for the youngsters

I've noticed that older people seem to find it very hard to distinguish between broad generalisations and personal attacks on them as individuals. E.g., stating that older people are more likely to have voted for the tories or brexit isn't a suggestion that you personally did but is factually true of the generation.

I've also noticed that ageism is only ageism if directed at older people, contempt and disrespect of younger people and their views is just stating home truths apparently.

Someone up thread stated stated that the young are learning their contemptuous attitude from somewhere and I'd suggest looking in a mirror.

Flopsythebunny · 18/06/2024 10:00

Goldenbear · 18/06/2024 07:29

’perfectly Normal’, all my family on Mum and Dad side are from working class backgrounds, I don’t know anybody who experienced that.

It was perfectly normal when I grew up in the north in the 60's and 70's

MariaVT65 · 18/06/2024 09:31

KimberleyClark · 18/06/2024 08:02

As a fully competent 63 year old zI would like to know what it is you have to guide her on?

A few examples:

She was gloating that a celebrity on X was DMing her, so I had to make her aware it was a scam account.

She asks for guidance every time she comes to visit as to what she should wear eg should she bring a jacket, instead of checking the weather forecast. I live a couple of hours further south.

She’s had a few rants on social media about kids not giving up her seat for her on buses because she sees herself as ‘elderly’ (at 64) and they should show respect. I had to remind her that she doesn’t look elderly (very young for her age) so no one is going to offer a seat to someone who doesn’t look vulnerable. Kids don’t need to give up seats for healthy adults.

She criticised me for having kids and then going back to work, because she didn’t work when I was little. So I had to explain to her how much a mortgage is nowadays and how silly it was to want me to suddenly fuck my job security after her emphasis on me getting qualifications.

Also get a lot of ‘in my day we wouldn’t have done that or my mum wouldn’t do this’ so I have to explain that times change and previous ways were not always the right way.

But as I said, I know this is an issue with my mum’s individual personailty and not reflective of everyone the same age.

Pocketfullofdogtreats · 18/06/2024 09:25

VestibuleVirgin · 18/06/2024 03:15

Ps. They hate us because apparently;

  • We all live in 7-bedroomed houses and won't give them up, therefore contibuting to the housing crisis
  • We all read the Faily Dail. And believe everything we read
  • We all voted for Brexit
  • We don't go to the supermarket in our nightwear
  • We didn't validate tantrum-throwing toddler's feelings while in the middle of the supermarket, we told them to just shut up. Which is very traumatising. Apparently
  • We take too long at a checkout/bank teller window. God forbid we exchange pleasantries with the person we interact with rather than just continuing the conversation we are having on our mobile telephones and ignoring them
  • We don't wallk down the road reading our phones or sharing our conversations with the entire street. Ditto for public transport. I mean, what is wrong with us??
  • We don't abuse emergency services or hospital staff. We are grateful
  • We can add and subtract in our heads and do long division on paper

Read through any thread and you'll find any number of other reasons they hate us!
But theyare daft enough to think that they won't be like every other old person when they are old!

All true! Except the last bit. They won't be doing maths in their heads when they're 60 because they've never done it. And they'll probably still want to be looking at their phones while they walk but tripping over on dodgy pavements will teach them not to!

VestibuleVirgin · 18/06/2024 09:20

anunlikelyseahorse · 18/06/2024 08:29

Errr what's ageist about vestal's post? She's pointing out how the younger generation think about us oldies.....although I'm still a young'un in my dreams!

I dislike the posts where children are convinced their parent is demented, when in fact it's very clear their parent has capacity, and it's obvious that the adult child(ren) just want to control finances....occasionally there have been genuine concerns, but most of the time it's pretty unpalatable, but I don't think it's ageist in the true sense just more abusive.
I also dislike it when age is used as a negative descriptor, if someone is being a dick it's not because they're old, it's because they're a dick! Tbf you often see teenagers getting a hard time on here, again it's not their ages that make them dicks, it's because they are dicks! The young'uns I work with are awesome!

What's that saying 'every generation thinks the one before or after is wrong'? 😁

Thank you! I was begining to think I was going potty. Altho' there are times when I am (house keys in dishwasher, anyone?!)
You are so right about each generation thinking every other is/was wrong. C'est la vie!
I

BrigadierEtienneGerard · 18/06/2024 09:14

If you think MN is ageist, try reading the Guardian. I'm amazed Polly Toynbee still has a job.

Swipe left for the next trending thread