Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask do I tell my dd?

38 replies

andallyourevergonnabeismean · 09/06/2024 21:44

So I have two adult dds (both mid twenties)

Growing up the younger (later diagnosed with adhd) was full on. Always demanding attention , very noisy. In comparison dd1 was a dream child, wonderful with her younger sister, easy going, lovely.

As she's got older dd2 has worked hard to manage her adhd and has grown up to be a lovely thoughtful person. She has massively calmed and is a patient person.

Dd1 now carries a lot of resentment from being the easy one in childhood. She has become difficult, often demands things are done her way. Gets angry easily and will snap if you say something that offends her. She is very easily offended.

I find I'm often having to bite my tongue around dd1 and just go along with her because I don't want the fall out. She can often be rude about my parenting, my personality (I have asd so a bit quirky)

But she will often tell me I'm lucky she's the easy one . (She really isn't)

Do I tell her I don't find her easy? Or keep biting my tongue?

OP posts:
imip · 10/06/2024 06:19

I have a similar dynamic with my teen dds. I remind the ‘easier’ one how proud I am that she doesn’t need as much help. That she has her independance. Her sibling was suicidal and we just needed to be there more to keep her safe.

somewhat past the worst of it now (both still teens) and I give the ‘easy’ teens more of my time. I remind them that I am like nanny McPhee and there when they need me but I will back off when I can see they can do things on their own.

I am sure as they get older there will still be resentment. It can be an impossible situation.

Sirzy · 10/06/2024 06:08

I wonder if her “I’m the easy one” is a dig at how she feels about being labeled as that as a child.

i think you need to have a proper conversation with her and start to repair the damage done rather than making the damage worse!

andallyourevergonnabeismean · 10/06/2024 04:03

@DoreenonTill8

Good points

To me it feels she's resentful when she reflects on her childhood rather than actually unhappy at the time. But if that's the case it may be due to realising now it was unfair but not realising at the time. (Because she was a child and it was all she knew)

I wouldn't shut either of them down now if they had an issue. I don't shut dd1 down when she talks about the past.

I just struggle with her anger and rudeness. It's like we all have to think about what we say around her to not set her off.

OP posts:
DoreenonTill8 · 10/06/2024 03:57

But tl answer 'do I tell her?' Will you tell dd2 how difficult and demanding she was as a child?

DoreenonTill8 · 10/06/2024 03:54

andallyourevergonnabeismean · 10/06/2024 03:32

I think she is. It wasn't intentional at the time I never realised she wasn't happy. In fact I think she was happy as a child it's more when she looks back now.

So are you telling her she's wrong in saying she was unhappy as a child?
Did you ever ask her as a child or like pp was she a glass child who just had to get on with it?
Now dd2 is doing well, if she came to you with an issue would you shut her down too or listen and give all your attention again?

andallyourevergonnabeismean · 10/06/2024 03:38

Stompythedinosaur · 09/06/2024 23:06

I think you should maybe consider family therapy and it might be helpful to acknowledge that she got the raw deal as kids.

It's really toxic to have your dc talking so openly about who's the "easy one", where did that come from?

I definitely don't think you should attempt to make her feel bad for having difficulties related to her upbringing. It would be giving a message that your relationship is dependent on her continuing to be the good/perfect child. She's entitled to her feelings!

Thanks

I have apologised in the past for not realising she needed more as a child.

Calling herself the easy one; I think she genuinely sees herself as easy going. Someone who fits in. She still sees her sister as the demanding one .

OP posts:
andallyourevergonnabeismean · 10/06/2024 03:32

Sunnysummer24 · 09/06/2024 21:51

I wonder is she is resentful of recieving less attention and support and feels/felt she needed more from you when she was younger.

I think she is. It wasn't intentional at the time I never realised she wasn't happy. In fact I think she was happy as a child it's more when she looks back now.

OP posts:
Stompythedinosaur · 09/06/2024 23:06

I think you should maybe consider family therapy and it might be helpful to acknowledge that she got the raw deal as kids.

It's really toxic to have your dc talking so openly about who's the "easy one", where did that come from?

I definitely don't think you should attempt to make her feel bad for having difficulties related to her upbringing. It would be giving a message that your relationship is dependent on her continuing to be the good/perfect child. She's entitled to her feelings!

anythinginapinch · 09/06/2024 22:48

I had a "difficult" twin and an "easy" twin now both adults. I am so sorry for how the "easy" one was unseen and unattended to in comparison to her twin, when they were children. He needed more parental input and time, and she gave us the space to do that for him by being "easy". But while it may have been necessary and easier at the time, it absolutely came at a cost to the easier child. I have seen this, as I reflected on my parenting now they are adult, and i apologised to her. I urge you to do the same. One child gets less attention than their sibling because they don't demand it. But they wanted and needed it, and didn't get it. So it affects them in adult life, of course it does.
She's having her turn, if you like, at pushing those barrier and testing your love for her, which she didn't do growing up.

LostTheMarble · 09/06/2024 22:20

She’s allowed to have hurt feelings, she may feel like she was a glass child. Her own difficulties may have been put aside for her ‘louder’ sister’s sake - she may be ND herself and it went unnoticed as there’s evidently a familial link.

bbbsss · 09/06/2024 22:15

I think you are missing the point. I think you need to address her concerns.

Sit her down and tell her that you have recognized that she is really upset and has been very angry and resentful about the fact you prioritized the needs of her younger sibling. Tell her all the things you are going to do to make her feel special and important in the future so she can stop feeling resentful.

It's not too late but she doesn't need to hear that she is more difficult now.

Sunnysummer24 · 09/06/2024 21:51

I wonder is she is resentful of recieving less attention and support and feels/felt she needed more from you when she was younger.

Accbabymom1994 · 09/06/2024 21:48

I think you should sit down with her and explain to her how it hurts your feelings when she says stuff like that to you . Just make sure you are calm and clear. Explain to her she was a wonderful child but now she needs to sort her attitude out .