Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is DD babyish? What can your DD9 do?

257 replies

purplerobot · 08/06/2024 13:47

DD turned 9 last week and is having friendship problems.

Everyone seems to think DD is babyish for her age, including friends and other kids parents (they say it nicely). I think some of her friends are too grown up (doing skin care and wearing makeup at 9??!) so I don't know.

My eldest was far more grown up at this age but times have changed. I have babied DC9 a bit more because she's my last baby so it's probably my fault.

What can your DC9 do?

She still would play with toys if I play with her. But none of her friends play at all. She doesn't play by herself but she never really has to be fair.

She cries easily (her teacher said she's very sensitive) and she cries often.

She likes YouTube and TikTok, she likes to make her little videos but they are maybe babyish in content. She goes to brownies and she likes the park etc.

She can make herself a drink of squash and a sandwich but I do it for her usually. She can make her own bed. She can shower herself (I do her hair as it's bum length and mega thick). She can do all the other basic stuff like teeth and getting dressed lol,

She isn't very athletic so not good with scooter or bike etc but she likes to go to the park. When she plays with her friends it tends to be lots of role play, dressing up, she tries to play toys - but over the last school term it's like her friends have grown up and left her behind, they don't want to do those things anymore and now she's left out.

I have realised I do baby her a lot, I've always done everything for her and as a result she is quite young for her age. Her sibling was very different at this age.

What does your DC9 do?

AIBU: she's a child it's fine
YNBU: you baby her and it needs to stop

OP posts:
purplerobot · 08/06/2024 22:05

Thank you so much for all the replies!

With the "too sensitive" thing, she does cry a lot at school. She says it's because her friends are mean, or leave her out. The teacher mentioned it at parents evening and said she felt DD got upset at the fallouts but perhaps they weren't as bad as DD felt.

The other parents say DD should be able to do the things their kids do (eg go to the shop, makeup, Snapchat) and DD is isolated from her friends because she doesn't do that.

For example on a recent play date her best friend and the other girl wanted to do makeup, DD asked "what if I'm not allowed to do makeup what can we do" and the girls just went ahead and did their makeup. They even asked DD if she would buy makeup for them! (She didnt).

Some of the TikTok's these girls post are mature too like "he's not my type" and stuff about "crushes" and "get ready with me" style stuff. DD has no interest in any of this.

DD is year 4, but those girls are September born so they are 6 months older, but still... they're 9!!!!

OP posts:
Magnificentkitteh · 08/06/2024 22:05

I mean, I don't want to be sneery about the skin care thing but it's not an "interest" is it? That's what I find sad, kids being encouraged to drop actually playing in favour of...what?

QualityDog · 08/06/2024 22:01

My dd got a dolls house for her ninth birthday. She was definitely playing with toys.

However, she has made her own bed since she was about three. Not changing the sheets, but making the end in the mornings.

My dc put their own washing away pretty much as soon as they could and helped with their packed lunches from about aged six. They were certainly getting their own drinks at meal times.

Does she want bum length hair that she can't manage on her own?

StSwithinsDay · 08/06/2024 21:48

this girl is very much "skincare" and doing "get ready with me" videos on Snapchat.

I was in SpaceNK last week. I was gobsmacked at the number of primary school girls who were in there.

3DayStockpiler · 08/06/2024 21:46

Play at 9 is perfectly reasonable. One of my kids was playing hide and seek with their friends this week. 19-21 year olds. I'm glad they still play.

What it could be important to understand whether she's reading the other childrens' cues and that she's not trying to make them play how she wants. That might be something to work on.

Withswitch · 08/06/2024 21:45

Well I'd take that as a blessing in disguise.

Get her in some clubs outside as pps have suggested. Brownies, drama clubs etc so not all her friendships hinge on school.

purplerobot · 08/06/2024 21:43

I'm still reading the replies but just wanted to thank you all

When I say babyish I think it's really because of how different she is to her friends. Literally a few months ago her best friend was the same as DD. Now the best friend has dropped her for another girl, and this girl is very much "skincare" and doing "get ready with me" videos on Snapchat. This other girl is very outgoing and vocal (and actually quite mean!)

OP posts:
Sugargliderwombat · 08/06/2024 21:30

Play at 9 is absolutely fine.

mathanxiety · 08/06/2024 21:24

KarmenPQZ · 08/06/2024 20:47

Seriously have I just read you’re encouraging her to have some self respect by learning baking and helping around the house. Are you wanting her to become a 50s housewife FFS?!?!

i’d be removing tik tok and tablet access and encouraging play with toys.

It has been found that nothing improves self respect and self esteem like becoming a useful member of the household, and this is done by means of learning from a patient adult, receiving positive feedback, and having an adult keep you to a consistent schedule.

Chores are incredibly important.

mathanxiety · 08/06/2024 21:21

Gladtobeout · 08/06/2024 14:08

9yos should be playing with toys. They should still enjoy swings/slides etc at the park.

TikTok - god no! It's 13+ and even 13 is too young imo (and pretty much all education professionals)
Make up/skin care - only as a bit of fun or special occasion, not regularly

Maybe work on resilience for the crying, but the playing sounds completely normal.

The children who are exposed to things too early, and I don't mean inappropriate, just not age-appropriate, will find it much harder when older because they haven't built up the soft skills needed to navigate the social aspects of relationships and/or online communication. Those parents allowing their children (or even encouraging their children) to relinquish their childhood too soon are doing them a disservice.

Yes to all of this.

The girls who have turned their backs on her are insecure. They may have seen videos she has put up on TikTok. Stop her making videos.

There are a few things I would do if I were you.
Have her hair cut if she agrees. It will make it possible for her to do all her own bathing. You could help her blow it dry, but she needs privacy in the shower or bath and she needs to have manageable hair.

Exceptionally long hair and sports/ swimming don't mix.

Encourage her to develop her confidence on bikes, scooters, etc.

Find some extra curricular activity outside of school that would boost her confidence - drama, choir, art...
If you can spend time together on little trips to local events, that might be nice. Art exhibits, museums, musical events, etc. If the two of you have the time, maybe volunteer at an animal shelter together, or some other local thing requiring volunteers - a Guides litter-picking-up day, etc..

Encourage her to do more in the kitchen, including cleaning up after herself. Stop getting drinks and making sandwiches for her. Encourage more independence. Cook and bake together. Teach her to use the washing machine and dryer, hang up clothes, deal with dry clothes.

Get her off TikTok - no more videos! and make sure she can't access adult content or 16+ content on YouTube. Nothing good will come of exposure to SM like that at such a young age.

She's not too young to learn to take care of her skin and clothing, to be aware of nutrition, or learn about puberty.
I recommend "The Care and Keeping of You" published by American Girl Press as a gentle introduction to the years and stages that lie ahead for her. There are books in this series about navigating friendships too.

ChickenNuggetDreamland · 08/06/2024 21:20

She sounds absolutely normal. There should be no rush for children to grown up. I'd make the most of it whilst you still can.

turkeymuffin · 08/06/2024 21:11

My 9yo likes her teddies and Barbies. She plays Minecraft & Roblox. She writes and draws and reads a lot.

She can make a cup of tea and a sandwich, does her own packed lunch when asked. She sorts socks and is good at tidying up.

She walks herself to school (with her older brother) but still gets picked up afterwards.

She's spent all afternoon with her friends at a village Fayre, managing her own money etc.

She does sports, drama and cubs. Cubs in particular is great for independence- they run pretty feral at camps.

T1Dmama · 08/06/2024 21:05

For god sake she’s 9!
Let her play! For as long as she wants to!!… they’re only kids once!
But in other areas she does need to be encouraged to be more independent…
My DD played but didn’t tell her friends she did. She found it therapeutic to play. I think kids are forced to grow up too early… on the other hand my DD has always been mature in all other ways, she was making all her own drinks, sandwiches by 9 or 10, and making me hot drinks.
But there’s also no rush to grow up… we spend a loooong time as adults and it’s pretty dull!

StSwithinsDay · 08/06/2024 20:52

@KarmenPQZ
Seriously have I just read you’re encouraging her to have some self respect by learning baking and helping around the house. Are you wanting her to become a 50s housewife FFS?!?!

Helping around the house, baking, taking out the bins, feeding animals, putting away laundry are all important steps in helping young children to develop healthy self-esteem. Maybe read about it before scoffing at the suggestion.
https://www.psychologytoday.com/ie/blog/it-starts-at-home/202308/the-benefits-of-kid-chores

The Benefits of Kid Chores

Personal Perspective: A pediatrician explains why assigning our kids chores boosts their development, confidence, and promotes gender equity.

https://www.psychologytoday.com/ie/blog/it-starts-at-home/202308/the-benefits-of-kid-chores

StMarieforme · 08/06/2024 20:51

Hermittrismegistus · 08/06/2024 14:02

Try to encourage her to have slightly more mature interests

She's 9 years old ffs! It's normal and healthy for 9 year olds to play with toys and enjoy going to the park and brownies.

What is our society becoming? Thinking a 9 year old needs to develop 'more mature interests'. Fucking hell.

Edited

These were my thoughts too! My DGDs didn't really play with toys often, but loved climbing trees and still do at up to 17! They'll play board games and lots of crafts. My DD played with toys till she was at least 12.
What world where a 9 year old is shunned for not being mature 😞

KarmenPQZ · 08/06/2024 20:47

FadedRed · 08/06/2024 13:56

You really aren’t doing your DD any favours by babying her at 9 years old. Please help her to gain some independence and self respect by helping her to learn/ encouraging her do things for herself and for others. Give her some experiences to make her feel good, like baking and helping in the house. You say she’s ‘not athletic’ but can you try her with different skills to find her niche, maybe horse riding, martial arts, climbing or similar?

Seriously have I just read you’re encouraging her to have some self respect by learning baking and helping around the house. Are you wanting her to become a 50s housewife FFS?!?!

i’d be removing tik tok and tablet access and encouraging play with toys.

CrispieCake · 08/06/2024 20:40

The problem is your DD's peers not your DD.

I don't know what to suggest as you seem to be between a rock and a hard place here - either you encourage/force your DD to grow up prematurely and leave her childhood behind before she's ready to do so or you deal with the heartbreak that comes from a child not fitting in with their peer group.

It's a difficult one. I find these things are driven by area/parental demographic, so I'd move personally to somewhere where the parents are more sensible and the children are allowed a longer childhood. But that's probably an extreme solution for your situation so maybe encourage her to make out-of-school friends with children who aren't being exposed to so many harmful influences.

Previousreligion · 08/06/2024 20:38

I think it's sad that a 9 year old is judged for liking toys.

When I was around that age I wasn't in to role play but I remember some girls at school were, and played those kind of games at lunchtime.

I wasn't in to hair, makeup or fashion, but again there was a group of girls who were.

People like what they like. I know adults who like lego and dolls houses. There must be other kids who like those things too who she could be friends with. Certainly sounds more fun to me than TikToc.

PeachPairPlum · 08/06/2024 20:31

She sounds fine for a 9 year old.

My dds definitely still played with toys at 9 and probably until aged about 11.

I would think its a bit sad to be dragging a 9 year old away from childhood.

SaltyGod · 08/06/2024 20:31

My 10yr old plays Minecraft, listens to music, reads lots, would watch YouTube if we let her. She also sleeps with two cuddly toys, lines her others up neatly and tucks them into shoebox beds. She makes up dances with her friends and spends hours practicing cartwheels and gymnastics moves, she builds cardboard houses for the cat and guinea pigs and decorates them. She paints her nails, and then paints Barbie. She would love a trip to the park, as would her friends.

She also independent and responsible in many ways. Independent doesn’t mean she has to be wearing makeup or watching TikTok.

I remember being the sad 9yr old who had friends that weren’t into playing anymore. I pretended to like what they liked but was glum. I then luckily made new friends and I distinctly remember asking for a baby doll that Christmas when I turned 10. I was so relieved that I could be myself again.

I also used to cry lots and was ‘sensitive’ when I was unhappy with my old classmates. When I found new friends the ‘sensitivity’ stopped. I was crying and sensitive as I was unhappy but struggling to express myself.

Let your DD mature in her own time. She sounds lovely

Temushopper · 08/06/2024 20:26

MyQuaintDog · 08/06/2024 17:01

@CristabelSeagrave do you really think there is no issue with OPs DD when multiple adults and the teacher have mentioned concerns, and friends are no longer wanting to play with her?

It depends I suppose what the adults think the issue is. If they think the issue is she plays with toys then I think the adults are being ridiculous. If they think the issue is emotional regulation that’s a concern to work on independent of what activities she likes

Newsenmum · 08/06/2024 20:23

Make up on a nine year old is messed up!

Theres no way she’s the only girl who plays with toys. Is it more how sensitive she is?

Magnificentkitteh · 08/06/2024 20:21

Has she been on a camp with the brownies? These can be a good way to build a bit of independence/confidence and is a good tester for when they go on the longer residential trips with school

Magnificentkitteh · 08/06/2024 20:15

My dd just turned 9 and I think of her as quite grown up but she certainly isn't into skin care etc! She likes playing - role play type games with her friends. She'd enjoy dress up if her younger cousin was here. She likes art, reading, playing on the trampoline and swing, swimming, board games, quizzes. Kid stuff - I didn't think that was unusual. Chores wise she gets herself dressed, teeth brush, stuff ready for the day, enjoys cooking but I supervise, I also comb her hair in the bath. I took a bunch of kids away recently and say she's probably more independent than most of them really so yours sounds fine to me. Are her friends just not very nice?

cadburyegg · 08/06/2024 20:09

Mature interests. Fucking hell.

My 9 year old plays Minecraft and likes watching YouTube but I limit and monitor screen time. I expect kids that don't have other interests don't have limits set but I don't want my children on screens all day. He still loves playmobil, Lego, going to the park and playing on the climbing frame with ds6. I'm enjoying it while it lasts.

He doesn't know what TikTok is. He can shower by himself but I make sure he is washing his hair properly

Swipe left for the next trending thread