Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AGAIN! Something must be done

493 replies

Singersong · 07/06/2024 12:22

Yes I know, another XL bulky thread. But seriously, this breed is like a mine field, randomly killing owners all over. You never know when/where it will happen next.

I truly can't wrap my head around people like this woman - may she rest in peace - who are all over the internet defending these KILLERS. They all think theirs is different, theirs would never kill, theirs is a big softy.

Is it time to do something more serious? The legislation brought in doesn't seem to have stopped deaths, although at least it does appear to be the owners (who are stupid enough to keep them) who are dying now instead of innocent members of the public.

https://www.lbc.co.uk/news/xl-bully-owner-celebrating-birthday-mauled-death-videos-defending-breed/

XL Bully owner was celebrating birthday when she was mauled to death - as videos emerge of her defending breed

An XL Bully owner killed by her dog had just come home from celebrating her birthday when she was mauled to death.

https://www.lbc.co.uk/news/xl-bully-owner-celebrating-birthday-mauled-death-videos-defending-breed

OP posts:
Thread gallery
21
WitchyWay · 07/06/2024 18:10

DoubIeLeopardy · 07/06/2024 12:40

Not directly perhaps, but it's all part of shit dog ownership, and shit dog ownership is what causes these attacks.

Not always. Saying it's down to ownership totally dismisses the inate danger and violence of this breed.

Whether attacks are an accumulation of aggression or random dog instinct, at the end of the day, they're dangerous dogs and have no place in society.

MonsteraMama · 07/06/2024 18:09

Rickrolypoly · 07/06/2024 17:44

That is really disgusting. She was someone's child too. And yes she may have been misguided to keep a dangerous breed but she didn't deserve to die so horrifically and her parents don't deserve the heart ache they must be going through now.
So while I agree whole heartedly with the sentiment on this thread around the danger of keeping of such breeds, please remember that she was a 23 year old woman with her whole life ahead of her and she was someone's daughter.
She is not even buried yet- have some compassion.

She was viciously supportive of them online, telling people she doesn't give a fuck what they think, doesn't give a fuck if they're scared, doesn't give a fuck if they don't want to live near one. Honestly why should I give a fuck she got hers? The reason she's dead is because she insisted on keeping a banned breed, the reason she doesn't have the whole of her life ahead of her was because she "didn't give a fuck". So please do tell me why I should give a fuck?

Fireflyfly · 07/06/2024 18:08

I fear i might sound silly saying this and not get my point across ..

But i feel like , in the majority , certain types of people own these dogs . For example , I’ve never known an older couple own one ( the type to treat a dog like their child ) , but i see a lot of people that own them are the type that have them , have them as a “trophy” type dog … they look scary , they’re a big scary dog …. Men who would rough play with them , families who would let the children climb all over them and be proud of that fact then wonder why they attack.

Im not saying everyone who owns them is like this - but then not all of them attack.

I feel like they are a breed that are strong , that have an attack nature within them … and if they aren’t treated correctly they’re going to attack. If someone is rough playing with them and getting them to growl and be rough then they’re going to think it’s ok . I mean chihuahuas are aggressive by nature I think and I know someone who has had behaviourists work with them - but the thing is an attack my a chihuahua isn’t going to have the same outcome as an attack by a very powerful dog.

I don’t think they should be put down ( as a breed ) but they need to be in the right place , they have too much strength. I would never have one with a child.

I have a lab , he is so lovely and calm . But he’s still a big dog . I never let my children climb all over him ( i have no doubt he would let them and just lay there ) but if something made him feel threatened what’s to say he wouldn’t bite to defend himself ? Dont risk it .

Mindyourownbusinessmadam · 07/06/2024 18:06

My neighbour has 2 of them. The mother is really aggressive. It is always muzzled when out but I would be terrified of it ran out the door.
I am an absolute dog lover and have owned different breeds but these dogs scare me!

Tempnametoday · 07/06/2024 18:05

DoubIeLeopardy · 07/06/2024 17:31

And that's absolutely the right thing to do for your dog, done in his best interests and to keep him safe and healthy.

Fucknuts who do it for cosmetic/status reasons, are just further demonstrating how little they understand about dogs and how unsuited they are to own one!

I completely agree, I think I just get my back up sometimes as we had so many snide comments and dirty looks after he had it done. Sorry. 🙈

Singersong · 07/06/2024 18:05

wickerlady · 07/06/2024 17:37

Inbred, like their owners.

The thing here is that there are loads of crap dog owners who treat their "fur babies" like a baby or child replacement. Fortunately though, 99% of the time this just translates to them shitting on the carpet or yapping at passers by in the street and being generally annoying. Crap owners of these monstrosities though is a different matter. They are not and are incapable of being, a domesticated pet.

They are akin to a wild animal and should be treated as such, not asleep on your sofa 😑

Totally agree.

So many people willing to spend £££ on expensive dog crap and even designer collar and leads all for Instagram pictures, but their dogs are basically feral. Zero recall and highly aggressive. But don't you dare say a wrong word about their "fur baby".

OP posts:
Getonwitit · 07/06/2024 18:04

PostItInABook · 07/06/2024 12:42

If people are dumb enough to make the choice to own one they accept the risks and possible consequences, including that it might turn on them and kill them or, even worse, someone else.

Totally agree but it is the neighbours that i feel for. Can you imagine the fear you must have every time you open your front door or turn the corner onto your street, or how poor children that can't play in their own back gardens feel because one of these lives next door. The woman that was killed by this pack said she didn't give a fuck what anyone else felt about her dogs. She made her choices.

DysonSphere · 07/06/2024 18:01

Megifer · 07/06/2024 17:17

But that's no reason to price out dog ownership completely for those who probably actually benefit more from owning a dog? Loneliness, mobility issues, lack of purpose, depression....all things that can improve with having a dog (or any pet) and I imagine issues facing 'non MC' owners more?

Of course people should have the means to provide for the animal, but that's not exclusive to the upper classes.

I'd argue that pets are a huge financial strain on the poor actually. And those with mobility issues are more likely to struggle to keep up with the daily exercise requirements. In fact keeping a pet is questioned when applying for certain benefits probably because (unfairly and wrongly) it is assumed you must be a good pet owner so ARE mobile enough to get out and about and not depressed enough not to care about something other than yourself that requires significant time, focus and attention.

I think obviously the blind, those needing one for therapy etc should be able to get a doctors certificate to ascertain the benefits to mental health and well-being. But that's it.

One thing for certain is no large breeds should be allowed in social housing. I'd like to see a ban with an accompanying fine on that tomorrow.

I myself am dirt poor, but I live the consequences of not being able to access green spaces because one of these dogs is running around off-lead on the green, and having to cross over the street in fear or being unable to access the stairway when seeing teens and so called adults walking with these things which they clearly can't control.

Atethehalloweenchocs · 07/06/2024 17:59

I read that up to half of all XL bullies are descended from an American Dog called Killer Kimbo, who has a history of violent offspring.

I read about the breeding line too, but thought it was actually most of them. As far as I can see they are all bred from a line which was chosen for aggression. And needs to be ended. I am usually totally against ending dog breeds because human intervention has fucked them up, preferring to try and undo the damage (like reversing the extreme flat faces of pugs by introducing controlled cross breeding). However, this breed was made for one thing only and needs to be wiped out.

Wrenbird27 · 07/06/2024 17:58

Apparently the neighbours of this woman (who had been in the house for a year) are saying they never saw her walking the dogs. And she had four of them!

We're considering buying one small dog this summer - they are so expensive and time consuming. How on earth could she afford to keep four?! Surely dogs like that would need loads of exercise and walking..

Megifer · 07/06/2024 17:52

Rickrolypoly · 07/06/2024 17:44

That is really disgusting. She was someone's child too. And yes she may have been misguided to keep a dangerous breed but she didn't deserve to die so horrifically and her parents don't deserve the heart ache they must be going through now.
So while I agree whole heartedly with the sentiment on this thread around the danger of keeping of such breeds, please remember that she was a 23 year old woman with her whole life ahead of her and she was someone's daughter.
She is not even buried yet- have some compassion.

Agree.

The tone and sort of language being used to crow about this is exactly the sort of language I'd expect to hear from some of the lesser educated owners of these dogs regarding those who want to see them banned. 2 sides of the same coin.

BlackFriYay · 07/06/2024 17:49

I abhor them.

Round them up and PTS humanely.

Rickrolypoly · 07/06/2024 17:44

MonsteraMama · 07/06/2024 13:49

One less Bully on the streets and one less room temperature IQ idiot to defend the breed. Better her than some random child or passerby who didn't choose to endanger their own lives by owning a dangerous animal.

That is really disgusting. She was someone's child too. And yes she may have been misguided to keep a dangerous breed but she didn't deserve to die so horrifically and her parents don't deserve the heart ache they must be going through now.
So while I agree whole heartedly with the sentiment on this thread around the danger of keeping of such breeds, please remember that she was a 23 year old woman with her whole life ahead of her and she was someone's daughter.
She is not even buried yet- have some compassion.

Alittlefrustrated · 07/06/2024 17:41

HousedInMySoul · 07/06/2024 12:59

I think people don't understand the risks, because there has been so much talk of bad owners causing dogs to be aggressive, but as I understand it, with this particular breed, they are so inbred and have been deliberately selected to be extremely aggressive, the way they are treated doesn't have any bearing on whether they might flip and start killing people. The owners presumably don't realise this, or can't believe it.

I agree. Plus any dog can be in pain, shocked/anxious, ill, become deaf/blind , and act differently to their normal character, as a result. There was a sad thread recently about a much loved Jack Russell, who became suddenly aggressive, due to a brain tumour. The problem is much bigger, when the dog is built like a killing machine. The breed has to go. I posted yesterday regarding a man killed by an XL, last year, on a neighbouring estate. He was walking his own small dog. I'm a dog lover, but sadly the risks are too great.

wickerlady · 07/06/2024 17:37

Inbred, like their owners.

The thing here is that there are loads of crap dog owners who treat their "fur babies" like a baby or child replacement. Fortunately though, 99% of the time this just translates to them shitting on the carpet or yapping at passers by in the street and being generally annoying. Crap owners of these monstrosities though is a different matter. They are not and are incapable of being, a domesticated pet.

They are akin to a wild animal and should be treated as such, not asleep on your sofa 😑

DoubIeLeopardy · 07/06/2024 17:31

Tempnametoday · 07/06/2024 17:23

Maybe I have used amputation and docking as to mean the same thing, apologises if they are not.

Yes it was for medical reasons, “happy tail”, as our boxer had badly damaged his through excessive wagging.

And that's absolutely the right thing to do for your dog, done in his best interests and to keep him safe and healthy.

Fucknuts who do it for cosmetic/status reasons, are just further demonstrating how little they understand about dogs and how unsuited they are to own one!

montysma1 · 07/06/2024 17:28

IncompleteSenten · 07/06/2024 16:55

I don't think animals are good or bad, they're animals. They are what they are.

Pit bulls aren't 'bad' as such. Bad sort of implies human like thinking and decision making.

They're just dogs that have been bred for aggression and they shouldn't be pets. I think the breed should die out tbh. It is so badly damaged by selective breeding, inbreeding and defective genes that there's simply no recovery and the safest and kindest thing to do is let the breed die out.

But they shouldn't be demonised either, like somehow they are little people making reasoned choices to attack because they enjoy being 'evil.' You don't say a lion is bad for ripping the throat out of a zebra for example.

They should never have been bred to be what they are, but they were and now the breed needs to go imo.

Why difference does it matter if we say the breed is "bad"?
Makes fuck all difference to the dogs how we refer to them.
Why is the wording relevant?
THEY ARE KILLING PEOPLE

Tempnametoday · 07/06/2024 17:23

DoubIeLeopardy · 07/06/2024 16:29

Such as? Because in the UK it's illegal unless done under very specific circumstances relating to certain working breeds and has to be done when the dog is less than 5 days old.

Tail amputation, as opposed to docking, can be done for medical reasons at any point though.

Maybe I have used amputation and docking as to mean the same thing, apologises if they are not.

Yes it was for medical reasons, “happy tail”, as our boxer had badly damaged his through excessive wagging.

Megifer · 07/06/2024 17:17

DysonSphere · 07/06/2024 17:09

Yeah but the stereotypes unfortunately are true on this case. Reluctantly I acknowledge it is mostly the poor with these types of dangerous outsized dogs. A big dog is a status symbol inferring instant Kudos and respec' and more understandably, a deterrent against a knife attack.

As said, MC people can be bloody well annoying with the babyfication of their dogs along with zero boundaries in eating spaces (('What? You mean my dog should give way to a human/cyclist/jogger/child on the same foot path? Oh no, poor poodles has right of way' and 'of course my dog has a right to wag it's tail against your foot in the cafe and sit on the seat' What? allergies you say? Well then you should sit somewhere else))

But their dogs (generally) aren't the ones ripping people to shreds on a monthly basis. So there's that.

But that's no reason to price out dog ownership completely for those who probably actually benefit more from owning a dog? Loneliness, mobility issues, lack of purpose, depression....all things that can improve with having a dog (or any pet) and I imagine issues facing 'non MC' owners more?

Of course people should have the means to provide for the animal, but that's not exclusive to the upper classes.

iamreallyabee · 07/06/2024 17:16

lawnseed · 07/06/2024 16:31

Restrict the sizes/breeds/weights of dogs that the public are permitted to keep.

Of course it won't happen, because..... money. So, enjoy the shitshow carnage.

It's quite unfair how cat owners can't keep a puma. If I had one I'd called it Miss Daisy Bloodbath and put a diamante collar on it. It would sleep in my bed and I'd feed it on terriers and the local bird population. It would leave poo the size of rice puddings all over the neighbourhood. You see, cat owners could be as equally thick and perverse as bully owners.

I would call mine Nancy

LakeTiticaca · 07/06/2024 17:12

Boltonb · 07/06/2024 12:46

The fact that this woman posted a video dancing with her dog (with cropped ears) and saying she doesn’t give a f*ck if people think they look aggressive etc just confirms a) aggressive nature of these awful dogs and b) the stupidity of so many of the owners

She probably would give a fuck now but she can't.
She's dead

FrogandTrumpet · 07/06/2024 17:10

I’m sorry she lost her life but she (and many other dog owners) are prime candidates for the Darwin Award. A general culture who don’t listen to any sensible advice, do what they want regardless. That said, it’s her risk, I’m only concerned when that choice either puts innocent members of the public or kids in the household at risk.

DysonSphere · 07/06/2024 17:09

Megifer · 07/06/2024 16:47

"Make it a mostly MC privilege as it used to be in the past to be honest."

No thanks most of the MC people I know (which is just WC with a Michael Kors bag) I wouldn't trust to look after a goldfish. Too busy stuffing coke up their noses and spending far more than they earn to keep up appearances.

Yeah but the stereotypes unfortunately are true on this case. Reluctantly I acknowledge it is mostly the poor with these types of dangerous outsized dogs. A big dog is a status symbol inferring instant Kudos and respec' and more understandably, a deterrent against a knife attack.

As said, MC people can be bloody well annoying with the babyfication of their dogs along with zero boundaries in eating spaces (('What? You mean my dog should give way to a human/cyclist/jogger/child on the same foot path? Oh no, poor poodles has right of way' and 'of course my dog has a right to wag it's tail against your foot in the cafe and sit on the seat' What? allergies you say? Well then you should sit somewhere else))

But their dogs (generally) aren't the ones ripping people to shreds on a monthly basis. So there's that.

lawnseed · 07/06/2024 17:08

Escothesia · 07/06/2024 17:05

I fid theres sometihng around the eyes and exoression of these dogs. They look sad and depressed.

They're malformed with dodgy genes so they're probably in chronic pain and discomfort. Some of them seem to struggle to walk and breathe. It's very sad.

IncompleteSenten · 07/06/2024 17:07

Thudercatsrule · 07/06/2024 17:05

is there anyway to block posts? not interested in seeing this nonsense anymore, i dont read the posts, just dont want is showing on my feed anymore.

Just hide each thread as you come across it.