Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel uncomfortable in working class pubs as a woman of colour?

181 replies

Dreamsaregood · 05/06/2024 22:23

Just that really. I walked in and immediately got heckled by a (presumably) drunk man. Why did this man think this is ok?

I felt really uncomfortable after that and he continued to stare at me every time I walked past. It ruined my evening, and to be honest I felt a little threatened being the only woman of colour in my group.

AIBU to think very carefully before agreeing to meet up in certain places (local pubs etc)?

OP posts:
AccountCreateUsername · 06/06/2024 20:08

That’s the point though isn’t it @AliceMcK

When I go to a pub I don’t care what the patrons think or believe just as long as it’s hidden away enough that I don’t pick up on it. Racism may be everywhere but some people feel more comfortable expressing it than others. If I’m sharing a public space with strangers then I prefer the polite / civil racists any day

username47985 · 06/06/2024 19:34

I am really sorry you feel this way and experience this.

I feel uncomfortable going in our local 'builders' pub as its full of right knob head men. I can't even begin to understand how it must be for you as a person of colour as well as a woman.

Mirabai · 06/06/2024 19:29

AliceMcK · 06/06/2024 18:51

Who’s being naive, you are right, the op stated her experience in a “working class pub” I stated my experience growing up and working in both working class and middle class pubs. The customers in working class pubs in general are no more or less racist than people who drink in middles class pubs. I at no point insulted the op or belittled her experience. I also dint resort to name calling.

If anyone is gross or a tit it’s the person who referred to the working classes as poor people. And has to finish every comment with name calling.

i clearly stated racism is everywhere and MY experience is middle class pubs have just as much racism they just hide it better.

Why are you trying to make someone else’s thread about you and your life experience?

Piemam · 06/06/2024 19:29

@Dreamsaregood talk to your friends. Yes, it shouldn't be on you to educate them, but your experience can teach them in this case, and hopefully you get some support and solidarity. I dislike that I still notice when I'm the only WOC in pubs, I wish I didn't notice and some times therefore be on alert. Hope you are feeling more steady today.

AliceMcK · 06/06/2024 18:51

WhenTheMoonShines · 06/06/2024 15:41

@AliceMcK she clearly stated “working class pub” and talked about her experience within that pub and whether she’d be unreasonable to avoid other working class pubs. The fact you’re working so hard to keep up the faux naivety is gross.

Who’s being naive, you are right, the op stated her experience in a “working class pub” I stated my experience growing up and working in both working class and middle class pubs. The customers in working class pubs in general are no more or less racist than people who drink in middles class pubs. I at no point insulted the op or belittled her experience. I also dint resort to name calling.

If anyone is gross or a tit it’s the person who referred to the working classes as poor people. And has to finish every comment with name calling.

i clearly stated racism is everywhere and MY experience is middle class pubs have just as much racism they just hide it better.

QuacketyQuack · 06/06/2024 18:22

@Getonwitit considering she was with a group of WOMEN and she was the only POC. Yes it's obvious it was about race🙄.
Maybe keep of this thread if you're going to ask silly questions you're coming across as ignorant

Dreamsaregood · 06/06/2024 16:17

OrlandointheWilderness · 06/06/2024 14:34

Oh bless you @Dreamsaregood it can't be easy. They may surprise you and they are obviously a good group of friends who I suspect love you to bits too and will feel awful they have been so blind. We are human, all fallible, and we shouldn't ever stop trying to be better. I wish you all the best.

Thank you for being kind, this made me cry. This experience has bought all sorts of emotions to the surface for me.

I really appreciate everyone taking the time to share experiences and the supportive comment, I have read them all and it makes me feel less alone.

OP posts:
Dreamsaregood · 06/06/2024 16:13

I am sure there is lots of racism in middle class pubs too. Although I think this is usually indirect/under the surface rather than direct stares/going out of their way to make you feel uncomfortable. I have been to lots of "country pubs/middle class pubs" and have never experienced direct racism so this is my experience of them. I am aware I could have just been lucky to date!

It is not comparable to the threat of someone in this working mans pub who could easily have thrown a pint at me or worse because he took exception to the way I looked. I grew up somewhere very derived and working class, I would say nearly all the pubs in the area have this threat. I would not visit but for my friends who I enjoy catching up with. It almost feels like seeing them in that venue was an act of self harm. Why did I do it to myself?

This country may be becoming more diverse by the day but racism is rife and thriving.

OP posts:
WhenTheMoonShines · 06/06/2024 15:41

@AliceMcK she clearly stated “working class pub” and talked about her experience within that pub and whether she’d be unreasonable to avoid other working class pubs. The fact you’re working so hard to keep up the faux naivety is gross.

LadyKenya · 06/06/2024 15:28

I hear you OP. As a black woman I know about the wounding actions from people, who would never mention the colour of my skin, as a reason for their mistreatment of me. The term Misogynoir is what you experienced.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Misogynoir

Misogynoir - Wikipedia

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Misogynoir

LadyKenya · 06/06/2024 15:23

Ihopeithinkiknow · 06/06/2024 13:29

I'm a white woman and reading your post made me a bit emotional tbh the fact that you have pointed out that it's encouraging really does say something doesn't it? It should be standard human behaviour as we are all human beings and I have this thought that humans would be better off without eyes lol i know it sounds stupid but I think it's an interesting thought lol not very practical I know and I'm not suggesting we all gouge our eyes out haha but I think humans would get along better if we took them away. I'm not explaining myself well here and I'm prepared to be piled on but it's just a thought I had lol

Why should you be piled on? What you say makes perfect sense to me. The film A Patch Of Blue, is exactly about what you are trying to convey here.

OrlandointheWilderness · 06/06/2024 15:01

Pinkfluffypencilcase · 06/06/2024 14:58

It’s fine to find something relatable.

It’s not ok to minimise op experience. She knows it was as a result of her race.

I'm hoping that was where my post was going...! But then its been a long day and my brains are currently resembling scrambled eggs.

Pinkfluffypencilcase · 06/06/2024 14:58

It’s fine to find something relatable.

It’s not ok to minimise op experience. She knows it was as a result of her race.

AliceMcK · 06/06/2024 14:57

WhenTheMoonShines · 06/06/2024 14:20

@AliceMcK The OP isn’t saying every poor person is racist, she’s saying there’s certain venues where that racism is allowed and accepted. All you’ve done is make yourself look like a tit by attempting to chastise the OP, well done.

She has clearly stated “working class”. And who said every working class person is poor??? Maybe you should look in the mirror if you want to know what a tit looks like 🙄

OrlandointheWilderness · 06/06/2024 14:47

The problem is human nature @HelloOhHell - it is an innate trait in us to identify with something someone else has experienced. It is a survival trait, to not be seen as an outsider, and proffering similar experiences can make you seem more appealing and likeable to others, ironically enough! Unfortunately you cannot as a white woman, ever identify with an experience of a WoC as you have no basis for comparison, but it doesn't stop the compulsion. People need to recognise in themselves the impulse they immediately felt (I won't lie, I felt it too, immediately thinking of times when I've felt othered or an outsider, but it isn't relevant here!) and listen and learn. That's all we can ask for really!

Oh edited because of stupid lazy fat fingers and an inability to type today!

HelloOhHell · 06/06/2024 14:37

stayathomer · 06/06/2024 14:24

HelloOhHell
“all women-ing” OP when she clearly said what she said is diabolical
diabolical is a bit strong isn’t it? Commenters were just showing solidarity with op

yes- solidarity in minimising what OP said. diabolical wasn’t even strong enough- look at how the well meaning allies continue to “all women” all over this post.

Pinkfluffypencilcase · 06/06/2024 14:35

Dreamsaregood · 06/06/2024 06:59

Yes I think racism is not as openly expressed but it is 100% still there in a lot of people. Some just keep it to themselves these days, which is definitely better than the outward aggression I had today.

I can't explain just how uncomfortable it made me feel. It was a "you don't belong in here" I went to a school with very little diversity and it was this group of friends I was meeting. They picked the venue and probably doesn't even register with them the issue.

It took me right back to being at school, I cannot remember the last time I felt so uncomfortable, probably not for a decade such is the little bubble I have created!

I’ve had this too.

Walked into a pub in a predominantly white area. Silence. Even the white guy i was with noticed. Lots of staring.

To some extent it’s better than it was but at least racists made themselves known in the past. Now I sort of get reminded. It’s more obtuse but it’s there. You just know.

OrlandointheWilderness · 06/06/2024 14:34

Oh bless you @Dreamsaregood it can't be easy. They may surprise you and they are obviously a good group of friends who I suspect love you to bits too and will feel awful they have been so blind. We are human, all fallible, and we shouldn't ever stop trying to be better. I wish you all the best.

HelloOhHell · 06/06/2024 14:31

Intersectionality… a lot of you need to go and pick up a book, you’re embarrassing yourselves.

facelace · 06/06/2024 14:27

Guavafish1 · 05/06/2024 22:55

I feel uncomfortable in white dominated areas. Even going to Central Europe is intimating as I think if an neo-nazi will attack me as I'm the only person of colour here.

My partner is white, I can sense a similar feeling of intimidation when she goes to events that's are non-white dominant.

Can you not see your own prejudices in this way of thinking though?

BobbyBiscuits · 06/06/2024 14:25

I'd say it would be a double whammy. The act of women going to pubs alone, coupled with lack of local poc. Drunk old school bigoted white working class men. Yeah, I can see that happening in certain places.

I've experienced a lot of that as I used to stop off in pubs to do my admin when visiting some really deprived areas for work. I'm white, so I'd imagine it could be worse for poc. A lot of the punters seemed like they were far right, and very unfriendly seeming.

But surely there must be nicer, more welcoming pubs in the locale. Some really are just cliquey and rough as toast. But others are cool, friendly, fun etc. don't let it put you off going to pubs in general.

Write a bad TripAdvisor about that one though, they sound rubbish.

stayathomer · 06/06/2024 14:24

HelloOhHell
“all women-ing” OP when she clearly said what she said is diabolical
diabolical is a bit strong isn’t it? Commenters were just showing solidarity with op

Dreamsaregood · 06/06/2024 14:21

OrlandointheWilderness · 06/06/2024 13:53

"If you are oblivious to prejudice and microaggressions, as my friends are, you will continue to remain oblivious as the status quo suits you/ the majority so why change it to make life better for "others""

hmm @Dreamsaregood. I can't help wondering why these people are your friends if you think so little of them? Why not try? The worse that happens is they confirm what you already think. People are sometimes oblivious to situations that they have not themselves experienced, that does not mean to say they would remain so if they became aware of it. Yes, in an ideal world you should not HAVE to be in a situation where you need to explain it, however this has never been an ideal world and these people are your friends.

We are all very close friends but I will be honest and say I feel very apprehensive about how this will go down - either way i will raise as I will never go somewhere like thjs ever again. I knew when I pulled up what I would be facing but hoped I would be allowed to just get on with my day, isn't that what all of us want?

I feel really quite emotional and upset about this and find myself wondering whether to distance myself from this group of friends. My experience and life is so very different from theirs but we have all this shared history and I love them all, even though I am very angry about what happened and their lack of awareness around issues like this.

OP posts:
WhenTheMoonShines · 06/06/2024 14:20

@AliceMcK The OP isn’t saying every poor person is racist, she’s saying there’s certain venues where that racism is allowed and accepted. All you’ve done is make yourself look like a tit by attempting to chastise the OP, well done.

worryworrysuperscurry · 06/06/2024 14:18

@Kendodd Exactly! I went to university with men like Johnson and Farage, and have never understood the white working class admiration for a type of person who utterly despises them, to the point of barely thinking them human.